Murder by Decree Blu-ray Review

"Murder by Decree" has been presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 with a 1080p transfer, utilizing the MPEG-4 AVC codec. However, the technical fidelity of this Blu-ray release leaves much to be desired. The source material appears to be an outdated master that introduces a range of limitations, resulting in fluctuating noise levels and an overall lack of sharpness. This is particularly evident in dark scenes where delineation is subpar, making some wide shots appear almost upscaled. While the cinematography's unique, intentionally hazy and dreamlike style hides some flaws, the overall flatness in well-lit scenes remains a detractor. Color consistency is generally acceptable, though notably desaturated at times. The transfer also features occasional vertical ribbons and scratches which disrupt the viewing experience.

Despite these drawbacks, certain scenes do manage to stand out with commendable quality. For instance, some daylight outdoor sequences and specific indoor moments deliver impressive visual fidelity with stable grain and defined details. Nonetheless, these instances are overshadowed by pervasive issues such as gloppy grain structure, uneven sharpness in soft focus areas, and fluctuating image stability—qualities notably detrimental during Donald Sutherland's flashback sequences. Compared to previous formats, including DVD and LaserDisc, this Blu-ray release doesn't offer a significant upgrade, merely achieving baseline acceptability rather than excellence. Consequently, while the transfer captures the film’s hazy aesthetic, it is apparent that a more rigorous restoration could have vastly improved this presentation. In summary, this Blu-ray edition is adequate but marred by significant limitations that could have been alleviated with more recent and meticulous restoration efforts.

The audio presentation of "Murder by Decree" on this Blu-ray release features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track accompanied by optional English SDH subtitles. While the track demonstrates a superb balance, allowing for clean and clear dialog, there are moments, particularly during early scenes like the opera sequence, where Christopher Plummer's lines seem a bit muddy. However, this issue is an isolated case, and overall, dialogues remain discernible even amid busy crowd scenes and intense action sequences.

Scoring by Carl Zittrer and Paul Zaza integrates well with the film’s suspenseful narrative, supporting the drama effectively. The mix remains consistent throughout, providing an authentic atmospheric feel, especially during scenes set in foggy streets. Although the DTS-HD MA 2.0 mix is characteristic of its time, it would benefit from a remaster to enhance dynamic effects and deliver punchier fidelity, essential during more dramatic sequences. Channel movement is minimal due to the conversational-focused nature of the film, yet specific sequences such as chases and the finale offer a degree of excitement.

Typically, the mix maintains an even level, negating the need for volume adjustments. Despite minor limitations in dynamic range and imaging, the sound effects and musical score are well resolved, contributing to an immersive viewing experience. The audio track, although not revolutionary, successfully supports the film's atmospheric and narrative demands, making it suitable for this classic's presentation.

The Blu-ray release of "Murder by Decree" boasts a rich array of bonus features that will surely delight both longtime fans and newcomers alike. The standout elements are the two detailed audio commentaries. The first, an archival commentary by director Bob Clark, provides insightful anecdotes on the film’s conception and production, despite some occasional digressions. The second, a new commentary with film historians Howard S. Berger and Steve Mitchell, offers an engaging and enthusiastic analysis of the film’s stylistic facets and cultural impact. Together, these commentaries create a comprehensive understanding of the film’s place within the Sherlock Holmes canon and wider genre influences. The disc also includes a vintage theatrical trailer and additional trailers from Kino Lorber's catalog, enriching the supplemental content.

Extras included in this disc:

• Trailer: A vintage trailer for "Murder by Decree".
• Audio Commentary One: Archival commentary by director Bob Clark.
• Audio Commentary Two: New commentary by film critics Howard S. Berger and Steve Mitchell.
• Additional Trailers: Trailers for "The Silent Partner", "Ordeal by Innocence", "The Great Train Robbery", and "The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes".

Bob Clark's Murder by Decree (1979) stands out as an exceptional interpretation of the Sherlock Holmes legacy, exemplified by Christopher Plummer and James Mason's performances. Plummer’s portrayal presents a fastidious and energetically engaged Holmes, while Mason offers an intelligent and adept Dr. Watson, deviating from the traditional bumbling sidekick archetype. Together, they navigate the fog-shrouded streets of Victorian London with a synergy seldom seen in similar adaptations. Emphasizing the atmospheric elements, Clark and cinematographer Reginald H. Morris capture a haunting and eerie London, enhancing the film’s immersive quality. The meticulously designed sets blend seamlessly with historical locales, producing a visually rich tableau that serves as the perfect backdrop for this dark mystery.

The plot intricately interweaves Arthur Conan Doyle's fictional detective with the real-life Jack the Ripper case, developing a narrative that is as engaging as it is coherent. The screenplay, while dour and complex, effectively uses the grim real-world events of 1888 Whitechapel to fuel Holmes' investigation, revealing layers of deceit tied to high society and the monarchy. Notably, Donald Sutherland’s portrayal of psychic Robert Lees provides a masterful blend of eccentricity and authenticity, adding another layer to the atmospheric tension. The historical conjectures explored, although sometimes wild, remain plausible within Clark’s deft storytelling.

The film’s ambiance is bolstered by Clark's direction, which masterfully utilizes Steadicam to navigate Whitechapel’s labyrinthine streets, enhancing the sense of danger and mystery. The juxtaposition of cultured daylight scenes with the perilous nocturnal alleys enriches the narrative’s visual texture. Despite some minor pacing issues in its over two-hour runtime, Murder by Decree delivers a compelling exploration of one of history's most infamous murder mysteries through the lens of cinema’s greatest detective, offering viewers both historical insight and classic detective thrills.

Kino Lorber Studio Classics' Blu-ray release of "Murder by Decree" invites viewers to revisit Bob Clark's compelling blend of historical and fictional narratives set in Victorian England. Christopher Plummer shines as the determined Holmes, with James Mason delivering a charmingly capable Watson. This historical "what if?" adventure holds a special place among Sherlock Holmes adaptations, captivating audiences with its unique storytelling and strong performances.

However, the technical aspects of this Blu-ray leave much to be desired. Contrary to initial information that suggested a recent remaster, the video quality is sourced from an older master, limiting its visual appeal. While it surpasses the decade-old DVD release from Lionsgate Films, the transfer fails to provide the film with a solid, organic high-definition appearance. Audio quality fares better, delivering a decent experience that complements the engrossing score and dialogue.

The bonus features include two intriguing commentary tracks that enrich the viewing experience, offering insights into the film's production and context. Though it doesn't deliver a stellar high-definition presentation, "Murder by Decree" on Blu-ray remains a recommended pick for fans of the genre, the stars, or Sherlock Holmes. Ideally, collectors should aim to acquire this release when available at a discount.