Poor Things Blu-ray Review
Score: 79
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Poor Things offers a visually stunning experience and a standout performance by Emma Stone, though its divisive, surreal narrative may not appeal to all.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 95
Presented with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer at 1.66:1, 'Poor Things' excels in both its black and white and remarkably vibrant color sequences—intentionally rich with Ektachrome's saturated hues. Despite some post-production tweaks, detail remains consistent and impressive, though a 4K release is sorely missed.
Audio: 89
Poor Things' DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix delivers a consistently immersive soundscape with rich, clear dialogue and a wide soundstage that complements its surreal visuals. Fendrix's haunting score and ambient effects enhance its psychedelic aura, while optional subtitles in multiple languages support a global audience.
Extra: 43
"Possessing Beauty" offers a concise yet insightful behind-the-scenes look at the making of "Poor Things," exploring film production facets from casting to design; complemented by three brief deleted scenes, the extras are engaging but leave room for a more comprehensive future release.
Movie: 63
"Poor Things" is a visually stunning, audacious film by Yorgos Lanthimos that blends Frankenstein-esque themes with phantasmagoric aesthetics, delivering a bizarre yet compelling narrative. Emma Stone shines as Bella, a child-brained woman navigating a surreal world, in a film that captivates with its production design and unconventional storytelling.
Video: 95
"Poor Things," presented on Blu-ray by 20th Century Studios’ Searchlight division and Disney/Buena Vista, showcases a 1080p AVC encoded transfer in the 1.66:1 aspect ratio. The imagery benefits from the unique use of 35mm Ektachrome film and demonstrates a captivatingly organic appearance, despite noticeable post-production tweaks. Robbie Ryan's exceptional cinematography comes through with engaging visual distinctions, such as sharp fisheye lens effects alongside bold quasi-iris distortions. The color grading is notable, featuring vibrant cotton candy hues and deep yellows that provide a thematic richness, especially in scenes described to echo the charm of the series "The Prisoner."
The Blu-ray release provides a striking testament to the visual prowess achievable without a UHD offering. It highlights both colorful and monochrome sequences with remarkable clarity and depth. The film's beginning segments in black and white present an extraordinary level of detail, drawing attention to fabric textures and precise character makeup that showcase Willem Dafoe’s features in sharp focus. Flesh tones are slightly washed out yet reveal every intricate facet important for the audience's immersion.
Utilizing Super 35 cameras, the film receives a 4K digital intermediate treatment, aptly demonstrating Blu-ray's capabilities through saturated colors and heightened contrasts—an effect of the Ektachrome reversal stock. The imagery achieves a dreamlike quality, with backgrounds and foregrounds maintaining crisp detail. Color reproduction is effectively executed, mixing natural and surrealistic tones seamlessly. The aesthetic choice of boat sequences, noted for their indescribably beautiful sky imagery, underscores the pristine representation of color within this medium. Overall, "Poor Things" remains a visually compelling piece despite not being offered in a 4K UHD format, delivering clean visuals free from noise and artifacts.
Audio: 89
The audio presentation of "Poor Things" on Blu-ray features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that excels in delivering an immersive auditory experience. The mix utilizes active surrounds and a wide front soundstage, which complements the film's surreal visuals. The sound design emphasizes ambient environmental effects, enhancing the viewer's sense of immersion. Notably, the musical score by Jerskin Fendrix is a highlight, utilizing intricate and peculiar instrumentation that bends and swoops to create a hallucinatory auditory experience. Meanwhile, the film's dialogue remains crystal clear and well-articulated, even during scenes with additional background noise or multilingual exchanges.
In terms of dynamics, the 5.1 mix is rich and full-bodied, with a balance that strategically positions music and ambiance in surround channels while maintaining a dialogue-forward approach. LFE is utilized to add low-end enhancement, most notably in musical sections where unusual instruments contribute an engaging bass response that fills the room. Surround sound presentation effectively captures indoor and outdoor environments, providing a consistent and immersive surround activity.
Overall, while the audio track on the Blu-ray might not be groundbreaking, it aligns well with the director’s stylistic choices by refraining from overwhelming sound effects or overly vibrant soundscapes. Instead, it offers a solid, nuanced effort characterized by clarity and purposeful surround deployment. Additionally, with available language options and subtitles in several languages, "Poor Things" ensures accessibility for a wide audience.
Extras: 43
The "Poor Things" Blu-ray extras deliver insightful, albeit concise, content for fans and film enthusiasts looking to delve deeper into the making of this unique film. "Possessing Beauty: The Making of Poor Things" offers an engaging 21-minute feature that stands out with interviews, behind-the-scenes looks at costumes, makeup, and prosthetics, including detailed applications on Willem Dafoe. It explores the creative journey from book adaptation to casting decisions and technical aspects like film stock and lens choices, providing a comprehensive overview. Also included are Deleted Things, featuring three brief deleted scenes — Brothel Doctor, Alfie’s Chapter, and Bella’s Notebook — which run a combined duration of slightly over three minutes. Though limited in quantity, these extras provide valuable insights into the creative process behind "Poor Things," paired with a digital copy and slipcover packaging that enhance the overall offering.
Extras included in this disc:
- Possessing Beauty: The Making of Poor Things: Explores the creative process, with interviews and behind-the-scenes content.
- Deleted Things: Three deleted scenes: Brothel Doctor, Alfie’s Chapter, Bella’s Notebook.
Movie: 63
Yorgos Lanthimos's "Poor Things" is an intricate and visually stunning exploration of twisted narratives and bizarre yet compelling character arcs. Emma Stone delivers a riveting performance as Bella Baxter, a woman reborn through the eccentric genius of Dr. Godwin Baxter, played hauntingly by Willem Dafoe. The film thrusts viewers into a fantastical world that taps into both Frankenstein-esque motifs and a steampunk-adjacent Victorian setting, echoed in its Oscar-winning production and costume design. The narrative unfolds with Bella's brain transplanted from her own unborn child, leading to a unique adult-infant dynamic that Stone captures with precision.
The film weaves a peculiar yet captivating tale, marked by stylistic audacity and a distinctive narrative voice reminiscent of Lanthimos's previous works such as "The Lobster" and "The Killing of a Sacred Deer." Mark Ruffalo brings a complex dimension to the character of Duncan Wedderburn, whose unpredictable journey with Bella underscores her quest for identity and autonomy. Lanthimos’s characteristic visual flair shines through in the seamless transition between dazzling color and contrasting black-and-white sequences, further enriching the film's engaging storytelling. Romantic nuances intertwine an odd array of humorous yet unsettling scenes, emphasizing Bella's liberation and self-discovery amidst societal constraints.
Despite its eclectic narrative, "Poor Things" captivates with its thematic depth and surreal imagery, lingering well past its runtime. The film challenges conventions through its excellent cast performances and daring exploration of freedom, equality, and feminine awakening. It is an unpredictable cinematic gem that intrigues audiences, rewarding those who appreciate Lanthimos's unorthodox storytelling with a uniquely immersive experience. However, this avant-garde exercise may divide viewers, necessitating a readiness to embrace its peculiarities—a testament to Lanthimos’s ability to craft enduring and thought-provoking art.
Total: 79
"Poor Things" is a vivid exploration of unconventional storytelling, seamlessly embodying the signature idiosyncrasies of director Yorgos Lanthimos. The film's audacious presentation and quirky narrative are accentuated by Emma Stone's Oscar-winning performance, which serves as the film's cornerstone. While the narrative ambitiously tackles themes of female empowerment and sexual liberation, it occasionally veers towards the surreal, challenging its coherence and universality. Despite the absence of a 4K UHD release, the Blu-ray edition offers impeccable image quality and engaging supplementary content that enriches the viewing experience, meriting a recommendation despite the divisive reception.
The film's polarizing nature arises from its juxtaposition of oddity and poignancy, appealing to viewers who appreciate avant-garde cinema. Although it may not resonate with everyone, its distinctiveness amid a homogenized Hollywood landscape is commendable. "Poor Things" invites audiences to dive into a world that alternates between humor, discomfort, and reflection. This highly stylized piece remains memorable for its bold visual storytelling and unique perspective, yet it may not warrant repeated viewings for all.
In conclusion, "Poor Things" transcends conventional standards, offering both grand entertainment and artistic introspection. Its allure lies in its challenging narrative and outstanding performances, though its strangeness might deter some viewers. Nevertheless, for those willing to embrace its eccentricity, "Poor Things" represents a significant cinematic endeavor that asserts Lanthimos' prowess and Stone's versatility in her craft. The Blu-ray release further enhances this experience, making it a respectable addition to the collection of cinephiles who appreciate innovation and depth in contemporary film.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 100
The main making of supplement included on this disc has some interesting information about "special order" 35mm Ektachrome film that was utilized for this shoot, and the entirety of this presentation offers...
Audio: 100
Once Bella gets out into the world, there are a number of scenes where background clamor is noticeable, though the entire sound design seems intentionally "artificial" in, again, the same way the visuals...
Extras: 30
Possessing Beauty - The Making of Poor Things (HD; 21:12) has a number of really good interviews and some brief looks at things like the prosthetics being applied to Willem Dafoe's face....
Movie: 70
Wedderburn is understandably intrigued by what kind of woman would require a contract keeping her more or less a prisoner (Baxter doesn't want her leaving his estate), with the result being that Wedderburn...
Total: 70
Now, don't get me wrong, I unabashedly enjoyed watching Poor Things, but it never struck me as being as hilarious as it seemed to want to be, and its allegorical ambitions vis a vis female empowerment...
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 90
However with this one, there are some splashes of color that put his other films to shame....
Audio: 80
Vocals are pure and rich, surrounds are used sparingly yet effectively and the front stage handles the burden of the mix....
Extras: 30
Take a tour with Willem Dafoe and see how Godwin and Bella’s home mirrors and accommodates them both....
Movie: 0
And having seen a few of Lanthimos’s other films, I thought I had an idea as what to expect....
Total: 80
If you’re a fan of the films of Yorgos Lanthimos then this is yet another feather in his cap....
Home Theater Forum review by Todd ErwinRead review here
Video: 100
Where this disc truly shines is in the color sequences, which are intentionally rich in saturated color and heightened contrast (a byproduct of the Ektachrome reversal stock)....
Audio: 90
The track features active surrounds and a wide front soundstage that match the surreal imagery on the screen....
Extras: 40
Possessing Beauty: The Making od “Poor Things” (1080p; 21:12): An above average piece on the making of the film, from locating the book to casting and film stock and lens options....
Movie: 50
Max soon asks for Bella’s hand in marriage, to which she and the doctor accept, but Bella is seeking her identity, and quickly escapes her imprisonment by Dr. Baxter with Duncan Wedderburn (Mark Ruffalo),...
Total: 70
...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 96
Audio: 86
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Extras: 60
Take a tour with Willem Dafoe and see how Godwin and Bella’s home mirrors and accommodates them both....
Movie: 80
Hungry for the worldliness she is lacking, Bella runs off with Duncan Wedderburn (Mark Ruffalo), a slick and debauched lawyer, on a whirlwind adventure across the continents....
Total: 81
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
The looks of everything in the film are natural and wonderful, with background and foreground information looking nice and sharp even in an HD resolution....
Audio: 100
5.1 Dolby Digital, German Dolby Digital 5.1, Italian Dolby Digital 5.1Subtitles: English, French, Spanish, Spanish Castilian, German, Italian, Japanese, Dutch, Danish, Finnish, Norsk, SwedishDynamics:...
Extras: 60
Possessing Beauty: The Making Of Poor Things (HD, 21:12): A short but informative mini-doc about the making of this movie that is quoted within as being a movie that should not have been made....
Movie: 60
It’s of course funny, and definitely bizarre, but Bella becomes more human and more alive as she sleeps with Wedderburn, and he shows her the world in a different way that seems to refresh her and help...
Total: 60
But, for it’s style, a sensational performance from Emma Stone and for being so different in a time where films are very much made for mainstream consumption, there’s a reason Poor Things stands out....
Director: Yorgos Lanthimos
Actors: Emma Stone, Mark Ruffalo, Willem Dafoe
PlotIn a reimagined Victorian era, a young woman named Bella Baxter is resurrected by an eccentric scientist after a mysterious accident. The scientist, Dr. Godwin Baxter, takes Bella under his wing, nurturing her into a strong-willed and curious spirit. As Bella navigates this new life, she discovers the complexities of human emotions and social constructs with childlike wonder. Driven by an insatiable thirst for knowledge and experience, she soon questions the boundaries set by those around her. In search of autonomy, Bella yearns to explore life beyond the confines of Dr. Baxter's world.
Bella's journey leads her to encounter a charming but opportunistic lawyer, Duncan Wedderburn. Together, they embark on a sweeping adventure across continents. As Bella immerses herself in diverse cultures and experiences new facets of love and pleasure, she grapples with her identity and what it means to be truly free. Her voyage is as much internal as external, leading to profound personal revelations and transformations. Meanwhile, lurking tensions back home threaten to upend her newfound aspirations. As challenges mount and old secrets suffocate the present, Bella must decide what she values most in her reconstructed life, ultimately forging a path all her own.
Writers: Tony McNamara, Alasdair Gray
Release Date: 27 Feb 2024
Runtime: 141 min
Rating: R
Country: Ireland, United Kingdom, United States, Hungary
Language: English, French, Portuguese