Black Panther 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 7 reviewers
Review Date:
Black Panther shines as a unique marvel, but its 4K release needs better audio.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 86
Black Panther's 4K Blu-ray excels with vibrant colors, deep blacks, and detailed imagery, offering a superior visual experience enhanced by HDR and Dolby Vision.
Audio: 72
Black Panther's Ultra HD release impresses with detailed Atmos audio, but is marred by Disney's low mixing, lacking the cinematic bass punch.
Extra: 66
Black Panther 4K Blu-ray excels in visuals but lacks extras on disc; contents like director's commentary and featurettes enrich the Blu-ray version, offering a deep dive into the film's making and legacy.
Movie: 87
Black Panther revitalizes superhero narratives with its vibrant Wakandan setting and rich themes, offering a groundbreaking cultural milestone with a blend of political depth, stunning visuals, and a fresh take on familiar plots.
Video: 86
Black Panther's 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation is a marvel of modern home cinema technology, offering an unfalteringly crisp and vibrant viewing experience. Rendered from a 3.4K source and finished on a 4K digital intermediate, the movie takes full advantage of the HEVC (H.265) codec, boasting 10-bit video depth, a wider color gamut (WCG), HDR10, and Dolby Vision. This technical foundation translates to an extraordinary degree of detail and a nuanced, deep color palette that elevates every scene. Particularly impressive are the nighttime sequences and the lush landscapes of Wakanda, which display an enhanced richness in colors and a striking contrast that breathes life into each frame. The film's meticulous costume and production design benefit immensely from this, with textures and fabrics visible in a way that was previously unattainable.
However, while Black Panther's video quality sets a high bar in many respects, it's not without its quirks. Some viewers have noted occasional shadow crush, where the darkest scenes can obscure finer details, although this is a minor complaint in an otherwise stellar transfer. The HDR grading accentuates the film's dynamic range, presenting deeper blacks and more vibrant highlights. The Dolby Vision implementation, in particular, enriches the visual experience with its superior contrast and brightness, making scenes like T'Challa's visit to the ancestral plane or the South Korea street chase unforgettable. Despite these high points, it's worth mentioning that certain scenes exhibit fluctuating brightness levels and slight black level crushing, though these issues don't significantly detract from the overall experience.
In terms of color reproduction, Black Panther's 4K presentation is nothing short of sensational. The use of WCG and HDR technology allows for a more vivid and varied palette, where the reds of the Dora Milaje's uniforms are fiery and intense, the blues of Wakandan technology pulse with energy, and the purples of the mystical realm dazzle. The natural world of Wakanda is rendered with breathtaking clarity, from the verdant greens of its forests to the rich earth tones of its landscapes. This release showcases what is possible with current home video technology when applied to a visually ambitious film. The Blu-ray format is pushed to its limits, offering enthusiasts and casual viewers alike a reference-quality showcase of color and clarity that stands as a testament to Black Panther's visual artistry.
Audio: 72
"Black Panther" ascends into the home theater realm with a Dolby Atmos track that, while based on a robust Dolby TrueHD 7.1 core, has been met with a mixed reception chiefly because of Disney's persistent issue of low mixing levels. This has been a recurring critique not only limited to "Black Panther" but also observed in other UHD releases, suggesting a pattern rather than an isolated incident. The resultant effect is a soundtrack that demands elevation beyond conventional listening levels to truly unfold its potential. Despite this hurdle, when amplified, the audio reveals a rich tapestry of soundscapes, from the intricate dynamics of Wakandan tech to the vivid clash of vibranium-laden combat.
Amidst the contentious mixing lies an audio presentation that shines in its delivery of atmospheric and directional cues, showcasing the immersive potential of the Atmos format. Viewers are treated to a layering of sounds that extend beyond the screen, with overhead channels being effectively utilized to enhance the sense of immersion, particularly during action sequences and the portrayal of Wakanda's lush environments. However, this ambitious audio design seems constrained by the subdued low-frequency effects (LFE), which lack the visceral impact expected from such a visually and thematically powerful film. This underwhelming bass response, especially in scenes demanding significant auditory heft like the South Korea car chase, leaves a palpable void in what could have been a more enveloping experience.
Nonetheless, the audio mix does manage to excel in clarity and positional audio, ensuring dialogue remains intelligible amidst the bustling soundscape. The use of ambient sounds and discrete effects across the surround channels crafts a convincing aural environment that complements the visual storytelling. Despite its flaws, particularly in its bass execution and overall volume consistency, "Black Panther's" 4K UHD audio track still manages to captivate with its detailed sound design and expansive use of the Atmos soundscape. The effort to bring Wakanda to life through sound is evident, though it falls short of its full potential due to decisions in its audio mastering process.
Extras: 66
The Black Panther 4K UHD Blu-ray release serves as a testament to Disney's commitment to quality, albeit with a noteworthy reservation. Primarily, the extras, which are notably absent on the 4K disc itself, necessitate a switch to the included standard Blu-ray disc to access a rich array of supplemental content. This package is impressively headlined by an introduction and a full audio commentary from Director Ryan Coogler, offering profound insights into the making and thematic underpinnings of this Marvel Cinematic Universe milestone. Furthermore, the disc features an array of featurettes, including insightful explorations of Wakanda's lore, technology, and the pivotal role of its female warriors, alongside a roundtable discussion that delves deeper into the film's cultural and historical significance. Also included are a selection of deleted scenes, a gag reel, and a teaser for "Ant-Man and The Wasp," enriching the viewing experience with behind-the-scenes glimpses and extended narrative content.
Extras included in this disc:
- Director’s Introduction: Ryan Coogler provides insights into his vision for the movie.
- Audio Commentary: A detailed discussion by Director Ryan Coogler and production designer Hannah Beachler.
- From Page to Screen: A Roundtable Discussion: A deep dive into the making of the film with creators and filmmakers.
- Crowning of a New King: Explores Black Panther’s origins and significance.
- The Warriors Within: Highlights the film's portrayal of Wakanda’s female protectors.
- The Hidden Kingdom Revealed: Insights into the diverse populace and culture of Wakanda.
- Wakanda Revealed: Exploring the Technology: Examination of Wakanda's advanced technology.
- Deleted Scenes: Including “U.N. Meet and Greet,” “Okoye And W’Kabi Discuss the Future of Wakanda,” “T’Challa Remembers His Father,” and “Voices from the Past.”
- Gag Reel: Light-hearted outtakes from filming.
- Exclusive Sneak Peek at “Ant-Man and The Wasp”
- Marvel Studios the First Ten Years: Connecting the Universe: A retrospective look at the Marvel Cinematic Universe leading up to Infinity Wars.
- Digital Exclusives: Wakanda tourism ads for an immersive experience.
Movie: 87
"Black Panther," presented in the stunning clarity and vibrance of 4K UHD Blu-ray, transcends the typical origin story mold of superhero films, enriching the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) with its vivid portrayal of Wakanda—an Afro-futuristic realm brimming with magical herbs and cutting-edge technology. Director Ryan Coogler skillfully juxtaposes the film's culturally significant backdrop—a kingdom untouched by colonialism and capitalist greed—with a tale of internal conflict and ideological battle, foregrounding the cultural, political, and personal stakes at play. The narrative centers around T'Challa (Chadwick Boseman), who, upon his father's death, returns to Wakanda to ascend the throne. His sovereignty is challenged by Killmonger (Michael B. Jordan), whose motives stem from a deep-seated vendetta against the historical injustices inflicted upon their people. This confrontation is not merely physical but philosophically profound, posing critical questions about identity, leadership, and the global diaspora's plight.
Despite criticisms concerning its conventional plot structure and occasional reliance on CGI, "Black Panther" stands unparalleled in its cultural impact and socio-political commentary. The film deftly weaves together themes of racial prejudice, nationalism, and the ethics of power, thereby resonating on a global scale and significantly advancing discussions around representation and diversity in Hollywood. Moreover, the stellar performances, especially by Jordan, whose portrayal of Killmonger offers a nuanced look at villainy rooted in righteous anger, elevates the narrative, making it compelling and relatable. The vibrant costumes, innovative production design, and a unique score that blends hip-hop with traditional African music further immerse viewers in the richly constructed world of Wakanda.
Coogler's vision for "Black Panther" not only redefines the superhero genre but also sets a new standard for storytelling within the MCU by integrating action-packed sequences with cultural authenticity and substantive discourse on pertinent global issues. As a standalone movie within the Marvel franchise, it achieves a rare feat—delivering an exhilarating cinematic experience that is both entertaining and enlightening without necessitating prior knowledge of the interconnected universe. In doing so, "Black Panther" solidifies itself as a milestone in cinema, celebrating African heritage while boldly addressing the enduring legacies of discrimination and inequality.
Total: 77
Marvel's foray into the rich, vibrant world of Wakanda with "Black Panther" has undeniably set a new benchmark within the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the superhero genre at large. Lauded for its groundbreaking representation and cultural significance, the film has been transformed into a cinematic phenomenon, capturing audiences' imaginations worldwide. On the 4K UHD Blu-ray front, "Black Panther" makes a grand entrance with an Ultra HD video presentation that is both exquisite and visually captivating, thanks to its Dolby Vision HDR enhancement that dazzles with its color spectrum and depth. However, while the video quality gets high marks for its clarity and detail, the audio aspect, particularly the Dolby Atmos soundtrack, falls slightly short of expectations. It delivers a solid performance but lacks the bass impact that made the theatrical experience so memorable. This minor shortcoming notwithstanding, the overall auditory experience remains compelling, complementing the film's stunning visuals and dynamic action sequences.
The physical package itself adds value to the collector’s edition, with striking SteelBook artwork that is both aesthetically pleasing and fingerprint-resistant. Although the inner artwork could be more imaginative, it does not detract from the overall allure of the package. Supplementary materials provided are comprehensive enough to enhance the viewing experience, offering a deeper dive into the making of this iconic film. Notable is the roundtable featurette, which provides fascinating insights and is certainly a must-watch for fans. However, some may find the extras lacking in depth compared to previous Marvel releases.
In conclusion, "Black Panther" on 4K UHD Blu-ray is an essential addition to any Marvel enthusiast's collection, presenting a meticulously crafted visual feast that nearly matches its theatrical glory. While the audio mix might not reach the zenith of what was hoped for, it does not significantly diminish the overall enjoyment of this landmark film. Coupled with valuable behind-the-scenes content and striking physical packaging, it's a compelling purchase for fans wishing to revisit Wakanda in the highest fidelity. Although there’s room for improvement in audio dynamics, this release solidifies "Black Panther's" legacy as a pivotal moment in cinematic history and a beacon of superhero storytelling.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 90
Black Panther already looks reference in 1080p Blu-ray, so the supporting tools of the 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray format are the key elements in raising the bar, refining the colour palette and taking the more...
Audio: 70
The reality, though, is that this is much closer to Last Jedi's release, in that it just appears to have been mixed low, rather than mixed badly (though there's some understandable debate as to whether...
Extras: 70
There's also a great little extended piece with the crew, From Page to Screen: A Roundtable Discussion; a selection of Deleted and Extended Scenes, a Gag Reel and a preview of the upcoming Ant Man sequel,...
Movie: 80
Thankfully, beyond the political statement that this film can't help but embody, there's actually a very good origin movie beneath, one which fits in very nicely in the run-up to the game-changing Infinity...
Total: 80
Marvel accomplished the impossible with Avengers: Infinity War, but plenty of the chapters along their way were important events, arguably none moreso than Black Panther, which not only took one of the...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
...
Audio: 90
...
Extras: 80
The rear side features the character in profile, a head-and-shoulders depiction that revels the mask and telltale necklace in some detail....
Movie: 80
The film received several store exclusive releases as well, including this Best Buy exclusive UHD SteelBook (also available in standard Blu-ray), which is very simplistically attractive....
Total: 70
The inner artwork is a little more straightforward and borderline boring but works well enough (the "floating heads" are a bit much but the Wakandan skyline vista is a treat)....
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 90
Contrast is very good, though while the brightest areas of the frame have nice gleam and pop, they’re not quite as bright as the highlights on other recent Marvel films released in 4K. On the other hand,...
Audio: 80
Then it’s smooth and more expansive, creating a very natural soundscape, though still not a particularly aggressive one....
Extras: 85
But the audio commentary and the roundtable discussion in particular are outstanding and well worth your time....
Movie: 90
Then a child, N’Jobu’s son, N’Jadaka (Michael B. Jordan), was abandoned by the former King to live a life of poverty and violence in the outside world, eventually becoming an American black ops soldier...
Total: 86
Black Panther is not quite a perfect superhero film, for it ultimately devolves into a giant melee of digitally-rendered carnage, like so many other examples of this genre....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 100
High contrast images burst from the screen, and some black crush is hardly a show stopper....
Audio: 60
When the closing battle erupts, a charging rhino and a number of explosions finally activate the subwoofer to a suitable degree – this assuming the volume is boosted....
Extras: 60
Director Ryan Coogler joins production designer Hannah Beachler for a commentary, the best of the extras....
Movie: 80
Wakanda, where Black Panther primarily takes place, is the essence of beauty, free from exploitation or racial judgment – a haven where culture survives, free of discrimination....
Total: 75
Filled with beautiful imagery, imaginative fights, and a social conscious, Black Panther is a unique addition to the Marvel bloodline....
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 100
Faithful to Rachel Morrison's marvelously-stylized photography, the picture displays precise, spot-on contrast, delivering some breathtaking scenic photos of Wakanda while allowing for the whites in the...
Audio: 80
Once there, the welcoming soundscape is layered with various effects discretely and flawlessly moving from left to right of the screen and vice versa, some of which occasionally bleed into the top heights,...
Extras: 30
Featurettes (HD, 25 min): A collection of four separate pieces looking at different aspects of the production, from T'Challa/Black Panther and the female characters to the production design and the Wakandan...
Movie: 100
Making it the best, unrivaled and significant installment of the entire series, Ryan Coogler's film is, quite frankly, a work of genius, redressing the gross misrepresentation of minorities in the superhero...
Total: 80
In tackling important issues about globalization, colonization, the unfortunate lasting legacy of America's history with slavery and, most notably, black identity in the 21st Century, the 18th installment...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 95
Black Panther is a fantasy/action-based film that is boldly colorful, relying on stylized visuals that employ stark contrast, vivid chromatic elements and lots of CGI....
Audio: 92
This is done to good effect when implemented and creates an enriching level of immersion that coincides with the onscreen events nicely....
Extras: 60
Disc 1: Black Panther Ultra HD Blu-ray Disc 2: Black Panther Blu-ray Blu-ray: • Director’s Intro • From Page to Screen: A Roundtable Discussion - Delve into the film’s making • Crowning of a New King –...
Movie: 90
In the acclaimed film, T’Challa returns home to the hidden high-tech African nation of Wakanda to succeed to the throne and take his rightful place as king, following the death of his father....
Total: 84
It comes to Blu-ray in this Cinematic Universe Edition from Disney featuring top notch Ultra HD video, solid lossless surround sound, including a complimentary Dolby Atmos immersive listening experience...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
Texture and detail is comparable to the standard Blu-ray version, but it does show improvement, especially in the medium and longer shots....
Audio: 80
Vocals are clear and crisp, always feeling a perfect part of the environment and always clearly audible....
Extras: 80
It begins with the history of the comic, the character’s influence and reflection on pop/political culture of the 1960s, how he fits in today, getting the film’s production right and placing importance...
Movie: 90
Like I said, this is an Avengers remix, and it plays just as well and if not better than it at times due to its sense of style and cool that keeps the movies feeling like it has more of a personal touch...
Total: 80
What’s going to hold this one up, as it typical of Marvel, is all the fun character scenes that populate the movie....
Director: Ryan Coogler
Actors: Chadwick Boseman, Michael B. Jordan, Lupita Nyong'o
PlotAfter the death of his father, the King of Wakanda, Prince T'Challa returns to his technologically advanced African nation to claim his rightful place as king. Wakanda, a secretive country, possesses vast reserves of the exclusive and powerful metal vibranium and has developed advanced technology unbeknownst to the rest of the world. During the sacred ceremony where T'Challa is to be crowned, he is challenged by rivals from within his own nation but ultimately secures his position as both king and the protector of Wakanda, the Black Panther. His mettle as ruler is tested early on by the emergence of external and internal threats that seek to undermine the peace and prosperity of Wakanda.
T'Challa's reign faces an unprecedented challenge when he encounters Erik Killmonger, an African-American mercenary with deep ties to Wakanda. Killmonger's hidden history and his radical viewpoints on how Wakanda should use its technology and resources to influence the wider world bring him into direct conflict with T'Challa's ideals. As tensions rise, T'Challa must navigate the complex politics of his nation and the burdens of his predecessors to keep Wakanda safe. In the face of brewing conflict, he draws upon the strength of his allies, including his sister Shuri, a genius inventor, and Nakia, a fearless spy, to maintain the secrecy of Wakanda and protect its people from those who wish to exploit its riches.
Writers: Ryan Coogler, Joe Robert Cole, Stan Lee
Release Date: 16 Feb 2018
Runtime: 134 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, Swahili, Nama, Xhosa, Korean