To Catch a Thief Blu-ray Review

The video presentation of the Paramount Presents Blu-ray release of "To Catch a Thief" showcases noteworthy elements and some disappointing factors regarding its 4K master. The transfer, derived from a 6K 16-bit scan of the original VistaVision negative, demonstrates remarkable color saturation and a vibrant appearance, particularly in outdoor scenes and at the costume ball, highlighting the lush color palette. VistaVision's inherent capability for high resolution is evident in detailed shots of the French Riviera, emphasizing intricate elements such as fabric patterns and landscape features. The black levels are notably deep, contributing to the visual allure in various sequences. However, the Blu-ray appears in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio, deviating from the traditional VistaVision framing of 1.85:1.

Despite these enhancements, the heavy application of Digital Noise Reduction (DNR) remains a significant criticism, affecting image authenticity by stripping away film grain and over-smoothing textures. This alteration leads to a less natural and sometimes waxy appearance of details, particularly impacting facial features and background clarity. The alteration of Hitchcock’s original color intent for nighttime scenes from green to blue raises additional concern. This results in a sequence of visual fidelity discrepancies when compared to previous releases or Hitchcock's intended aesthetic. While the new master offers a vibrant, contemporary look, it potentially compromises the original film's authentic texture and classic charm.

Paramount's attempt to minimize DNR does not entirely succeed, as evidenced by discussions among reviewers regarding excessive smoothing and detail loss. While the new edition tries to present a polished version of this Hitchcock classic, purists may find it lacks the tactile authenticity provided by its predecessors. Although the presentation is far from disastrous and offers certain visual merits, it does not universally surpass the 2012 Blu-ray edition in honoring the cinematic legacy of "To Catch a Thief."

The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack for "To Catch a Thief" is both a technical achievement and a point of contention among purists. Paramount has opted for a 5.1 remix that, while immersive, bypasses the original mono track, which might disappoint those seeking an authentic experience. This new mix offers clarity, especially in dialogue, with Cary Grant's and Grace Kelly's voices coming through distinctly. However, certain high frequencies appear slightly stressed, characteristic of the era’s recordings. Surround effects are utilized sparingly, contributing primarily during vibrant scenes such as the bustling flower markets and the cinematic presentation of Lyn Murray's iconic score.

The audio track focuses predominantly on the front soundstage, with subtle touches of ambient sound filling the rear channels in select sequences. The lack of intense low-frequency effects might not fully exploit your sound system but creates a clean and balanced auditory experience nonetheless. While scenes do provide some spatial depth and dimension, as seen in scenic on-location shots, these are relatively restrained—consistent with the film's original production limitations. The dynamic range is robust, providing a satisfying blend of music, dialogue, and occasional ambient effects that enhance the viewing experience.

In conclusion, despite the absence of the original mono or stereo tracks, the 5.1 Dolby TrueHD mix is executed with precision, delivering crisp dialogue and an engaging ambiance fitting for this classic Hitchcock thriller. For audiophiles and collectors who value historical fidelity, this absence might be viewed as a shortcoming. Nevertheless, those willing to embrace the remix will appreciate its expanded soundscape and clarity.

The Blu-ray release of "To Catch a Thief" includes a mix of both new and previously available special features, though it misses some from earlier editions. The highlight is Dr. Drew Casper's audio commentary, which provides an insightful yet debatable formalist analysis, occasionally delving into technical aspects such as Eisenstein's editing theories. The disc introduces a new feature, "Filmmaker Focus," where Leonard Maltin delivers an engaging, albeit brief, overview of Hitchcock’s career and the film’s lush cinematography. The archival featurette “Behind the Gates” explores the chemistry between Cary Grant and Grace Kelly through comments from industry experts. The original theatrical trailer is also included but retains some visual artifacts. The lack of certain expected extras may disappoint completists, although what is presented is both informative and entertaining.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary by Drew Casper: Insightful and detailed exploration by a Hitchcock historian.
• Filmmaker Focus: Leonard Maltin on To Catch a Thief: Brief but engaging discussion on Hitchcock's career highlights.
• Behind the Gates: Cary Grant and Grace Kelly: Analysis of the on-screen chemistry between the lead actors.
• Theatrical Trailer: Original 1955 trailer with some color inconsistencies.

Alfred Hitchcock's "To Catch a Thief" is a visual and narrative delight that trades the director’s darker thriller motifs for a lighter caper mystery intertwined with romance. The film, set in the breathtaking French Riviera, pivots around retired jewel thief John Robie, played with suave sophistication by Cary Grant. He soon finds himself embroiled in a web of suspicion when jewel heists occur, mirroring his old style. Opposite him, Grace Kelly enhances the film's charm as Francie, an affluent American tourist whose allure and wit match Robie’s suave demeanor. Their chemistry is vibrant, accentuating the romantic undertones amid the mystery.

Technically, the film stands out for its use of VistaVision, capturing the French coast’s vibrant colors and scenic beauty. The cinematography by Robert Burks bathes each frame in luscious detail, almost eclipsing the narrative with its aesthetic appeal. Hitchcock's deliberate choice to film on location, diverging from his usual studio confines, enriches the texture and authenticity of the setting. The dynamic interplay between Grant and Kelly—charged with playful banter and clever dialogue—entrances audiences, rendering their romance as captivating as the unfolding mystery.

"To Catch a Thief" operates with a sly sense of humor and wit—a hallmark of Hitchcock’s style—despite adopting a less intense pace compared to his other works. The plot's allure is less about unraveling the identity of the cat burglar and more about savoring the elegant repartee and charismatic performances. Amidst the luxurious backdrops and glamorous costumes, Hitchcock crafts a lighthearted yet sophisticated caper that balances intrigue with amusement. This film achieves a timeless allure through its masterful blend of suspense, romance, and humor, securing its place as a beloved classic that continues to engage audiences with its exquisite storytelling and visual splendor.

The recent Blu-ray release of Alfred Hitchcock's "To Catch a Thief" as part of the Paramount Presents line is a mixed bag. Renowned for its captivating pairing of Cary Grant and Grace Kelly against the charming backdrop of the French Riviera, this release attempts to celebrate the film with a new transfer and audio mix. Unfortunately, the visual treatment involves apparent use of Digital Noise Reduction (DNR) and modified color timing, which detracts from the film's original aesthetic charm. Although the Dolby TrueHD 5.1 audio mix is modernized, it feels unnecessary without retaining the original Perspecta Sound. This development is disheartening for enthusiasts of the movie's classical presentation.

Paramount has included only one new feature—a short Leonard Maltin interview—while neglecting previously available content, a decision that feels insufficient for a collector's edition. The omission of comprehensive commentary tracks and multiple featurettes that accentuated earlier releases further diminishes the value of this edition. For those who own the 2012 Blu-ray, there is little incentive to upgrade due to these shortcomings in content and questionable remastering choices that prioritize vibrancy over authenticity, sacrificing the lush cinematography for manipulated hues.

In conclusion, while "To Catch a Thief" remains an undeniable Hitchcock classic with its tantalizing mix of suspense, romance, and humor, this particular Blu-ray iteration falls short of expectations for true connoisseurs of his work. Paramount's approach to modernizing this iconic film compromises the delicate balance of visual splendor and archival richness that fans enjoyed in previous versions. For those who cherish adherence to original cinematic quality, skipping this release in favor of older editions might be a wiser choice. The heritage and magic of Hitchcock’s original production deserve more respectful preservation.