Amistad Blu-ray Review
Score: 60
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Spielberg's 'Amistad' is a technically brilliant and gripping film with superb picture and audio quality, despite minor historical inaccuracies and limited supplements.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
Amistad's Blu-ray presentation impresses with its 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer, showcasing vivid colors, steady black levels, and finely detailed textures, maintaining an authentic filmic quality with light grain throughout and no digital artifacts, ensuring a respectful and impressive high-definition rendering.
Audio: 66
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix of 'Amistad' delivers a refined, immersive experience with clear dialogue, effective atmospheric soundscapes, and a stirring John Williams score, although deep bass effects are notably muted.
Extra: 20
Extras for "Amistad" offer a 26-minute making-of featurette in standard definition with detailed insights from cast and crew, exploring characters, production design, and Spielberg's direction, alongside a high-definition theatrical trailer with Dolby Digital 5.1 sound.
Movie: 80
Amistad's Blu-ray sustains Spielberg's powerful storytelling, vividly depicting the brutal realities of slavery through balanced direction, compelling performances, and poignant historical reflections, while highlighting technical excellence in visual and sound quality, despite moments of sentimentality.
Video: 72
The Blu-ray presentation of "Amistad" offers a visually impressive and authentic transfer that preserves the original film's intended aesthetic. The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encoding in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio faithfully captures the film’s vivid palette with clean rendering and subtle tonal variations. The color reproduction is precise, highlighting both the earth tones of the interior settings and the dynamic colors of outdoor scenes. Despite occasional minor fluctuations in sharpness and detail, likely attributable to the original cinematography, the level of detail is remarkably complementary, showcasing an array of detailed textures—from complex facial features to ornate period costumes and elaborate set designs. Natural grain is maintained throughout, lending the image a cinematic feel that enhances its historical ambiance.
Contrast levels are consistently stable, promoting excellent visibility in both light and dark segments of the film. Black levels are robust, avoiding issues of crush or over-brightness, and facilitating a clear distinction in shadow details. The image boasts notable clarity and depth, with close-ups particularly striking, as seen in the sweat beads on Cinque's face that amplify his emotional struggle. The film's slightly diffused visual style in several scenes seems deliberate and is evocative of the period, adding to the overall narrative impact. Outdoor scenes offer the most vibrant colors, such as blue waters sparkling under the sunlight and lively red military uniforms that stand out dramatically.
No signs of age or wear were detected in the source print, ensuring a pristine viewing experience free from digital processing artifacts. The natural texturing throughout positions this transfer as one of exceptional quality, demanding large screen viewing for full appreciation. This high-definition rendering brings "Amistad" to Blu-ray with meticulous attention to detail, offering an engaging and immersive visual experience that honors the film's original craftsmanship.
Audio: 66
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix for "Amistad" effectively captures the film's diverse auditory elements with natural precision. Dialogue, which dominates much of the film, is consistently clear and full-bodied, supported by the high-resolution, lossless sound. During the numerous segments devoid of dialogue, the soundtrack leverages the clean reproduction of sound effects and John Williams' evocative score, free from strident highs or edgy midrange anomalies. The front soundstage, although occasionally narrow, expands beautifully during key scenes, creating an immersive atmosphere. While the rear channels and low-frequency effects are subtly utilized, they provide just enough ambient support to enrich the overall presentation.
The sound design is particularly notable in the film's opening mutiny scene, where crashing waves, creaking wood, distant thunder, and primal screams craft a palpable sense of chaos. These elements transform the viewer's space into that of the ship's tempestuous deck. Mid-film, the mix transitions to a more subdued state with delicate atmospherics like trotting horses and rolling carriages, maintaining a firm grip on the listener's attention. Additionally, action sequences such as later gunfire and explosions benefit from sturdy heft and presence, though bass activity remains somewhat muted.
Overall, the mix demonstrates thoughtful sound design that supports Spielberg's visual storytelling seamlessly. The audio enhances the film's emotive triumphs and tragedies, underpinned by Williams' music with high fidelity and dynamic range. Though some aspects of the recording may sound dated, there is a refined clarity throughout, creating a living and spacious soundstage that engages from start to finish.
Extras: 20
The Blu-ray of "Amistad" includes a pair of informative extras that offer significant insight into the film's production and promotional approach. The 26-minute "The Making of Amistad" featurette is a standard-definition documentary that combines voiceover narration with behind-the-scenes footage, cast, and crew interviews. It provides a comprehensive look at the film's development, covering topics such as the casting of Djimon Hounsou, the characters played by Morgan Freeman, Matthew McConaughey, and Anthony Hopkins, the Amistad Africans, and aspects like cinematography, music, costuming, and set design. Spielberg's direction is prominently featured. Additionally, the disc includes the film's theatrical trailer in high-definition with Dolby Digital 5.1 sound. While more special features would have enhanced the package, the provided extras offer appreciable depth and context.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of Amistad: Documentary with narration, interviews, and behind-the-scenes footage.
- Theatrical Trailer: HD promotional trailer with Dolby Digital 5.1 sound.
Movie: 80
Steven Spielberg's "Amistad" eloquently dramatizes the harrowing journey of a group of enslaved Africans who revolt aboard the slave ship Amistad, only to face a complex legal battle upon their arrival in the United States. The film, while not Spielberg's most celebrated work, stands out for its intricate depiction of historical events and deep emotional resonance. Djimon Hounsou delivers a powerful performance as Cinqué, capturing both the physical toll of enslavement and the indomitable spirit driving the quest for freedom. Matthew McConaughey, Morgan Freeman, and Anthony Hopkins further elevate the film with their compelling portrayals of the individuals fighting for justice alongside Cinqué.
Spielberg's direction is masterfully balanced between intense courtroom drama and visceral flashbacks that do not shy away from the brutality of slavery. The infamous mutiny and subsequent trials are expertly interwoven, maintaining a gripping pace throughout the 155-minute runtime. The courtroom battles unfold with a palpable urgency, reflecting the era's political tensions and the competing interests that threaten to overshadow the human tragedy at the story's core. Equally commendable is Spielberg’s ability to infuse moments of levity and hope amid the relentless depiction of suffering, aided by Chiwetel Ejiofor's role as the interpreter who bridges the chasm of communication between cultures.
Technically, "Amistad" is a testament to Spielberg's skill in crafting historical narratives with visual and emotional depth. The film's meticulous composition, dynamic movement, and thoughtful editing contribute to its storytelling efficacy. Despite Spielberg’s occasional tendency toward sentimentalism, which can sometimes feel overly calculated, the film largely succeeds in presenting an affecting narrative that underscores themes of justice, human rights, and resilience against oppression. Overall, "Amistad" stands as a stirring exploration of one of history's darkest chapters, rendered with both raw honesty and cinematic finesse.
Total: 60
Steven Spielberg's 'Amistad' is an exceptional representation of his filmmaking prowess, focusing on the profound themes of freedom and injustice. Through its courtroom drama structure, the film communicates a weighty narrative with a meticulous attention to detail, balancing entertainment with the gravity of its subject matter. Although the film is sometimes seen as overly sentimental and calculated, it remains a compelling and raw depiction of Cinque's harrowing journey. Spielberg's direction ensures that each dramatic arc is engaging and dynamically paced, making 'Amistad' both a stirring and intellectually stimulating work.
The Blu-ray release of 'Amistad' from Paramount offers a visually impressive experience, with the video transfer delivering an authentic and film-like image devoid of any bothersome digital artifacts. The audio mix complements this with strong, immersive sound quality that enhances the overall viewing experience. However, the disc is scant on supplementary materials, featuring only a single worthwhile making-of documentary. Despite this limited selection, the film’s technical presentation alone makes this Blu-ray release highly commendable.
In conclusion, while 'Amistad' might not be Spielberg's masterpiece, it stands out as a notable and gripping piece of cinema. Its powerful storytelling, strong performances, and outstanding technical aspects on Blu-ray create an emotional and thought-provoking experience. This release is highly recommended for both its cinematic merits and its superior audio-visual quality.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Amistad's 1080p transfer may not be a traditional showstopper with bright, cheery colors and perfectly defined lifelike textures in every scene, but the Blu-ray presents the film's somewhat dark and filmic...
Audio: 80
The track settles down considerably and, for much of the rest of the film, becomes a rather simple dialogue-driven listen with only the occasional light atmospherics in the form of trotting horses and...
Extras: 20
Specifically, it examines Djimon Hounsou's life and career; Morgan Freeman's, Matthew McConaughey's, and Anthony Hopkins' characters; the people who played the Amistad Africans; the film's cinematography,...
Movie: 90
The film refuses to draw its strength from sentimentality, however, and constructs its narrative, on one hand, in a straightforward pursuit of justice seen through the eyes of men brought together by a...
Total: 70
Steven Spielberg's picture tackles a weighty subject through standard Courtroom Drama proceedings but does so with special attention to detail for flow and narrative significance while maintaining an entertainment...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Though the film's style does have a comparatively soft quality in several shots (helping to evoke the bygone era), detail remains very impressive, showing off the elaborate period appropriate costumes...
Audio: 80
Immersive and artfully designed, the mix complements Spielberg's visual storytelling well, enhancing the characters' triumphs and tragedies through effects and music while transporting the audience into...
Extras: 20
The participants discuss casting Djimon Hounsou, the movie' characters, the script's treatment of history, and the film's production design, costumes, locations, and visuals....
Movie: 80
This maddening back and forth becomes the source of most of the film's drama, subjugating the African's freedom to the whims of several competing manipulators who wish to use the case as a means to further...
Total: 60
This isn't among Spielberg's very best work, but the movie is a gripping piece of filmmaking that is both disturbing and inspiring....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
The range of colors is not particularly extensive but the earth tones which are its primary source look great....
Audio: 82
There isn’t much in the way of active surround sound or deep low frequency effects but the application of supportive rear channel ambience and upper level bass adds an enriching element that enhances the...
Extras: 30
...
Movie: 80
The movie chronicles the incredible journey of a group of enslaved Africans who overtake their captor’s ship and attempt to return to their beloved homeland....
Total: 71
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SV Sound PB-13...
Director: Steven Spielberg
Actors: Djimon Hounsou, Matthew McConaughey, Anthony Hopkins
PlotIn 1839, off the coast of Cuba, a group of Mende tribesmen led by Cinqué rebel aboard the Spanish slave ship La Amistad. They forcibly take control, hoping to navigate back to Africa but are eventually deceived and captured by the U.S. Navy. The ship and its occupants are taken to America, where the Africans are imprisoned, marking the start of a complex legal battle over their fate. Various parties, including the Spanish government and the ship's original owners, claim ownership of the Africans and demand their return.
When the case reaches trial in a New England court, it becomes a symbol of the divisive issue of slavery in America. A passionate young lawyer, Roger Baldwin, takes up the case for the defense, arguing for the freedom of the Mende on the grounds that they were illegally enslaved. As public interest grows, former President John Quincy Adams lends his support, contending that the trial transcends mere property disputes and touches on fundamental human rights. The courtroom drama propels the nation into a heated debate over justice, morality, and human dignity.
Writers: David Franzoni
Release Date: 25 Dec 1997
Runtime: 155 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Mende, Spanish, Portuguese