Justice League: War Blu-ray Review
DC Universe Animated Original Movie #19
Score: 68
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Justice League: War is an entertaining, visually engaging introduction to the 'New 52' Justice League, boasting superb DTS-HD audio, but its video quality and bonus features fall short.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 62
The 1080p/AVC-encoded video of 'Justice League: War' reveals banding, occasional aliasing, and intermittent softness, but boasts smooth character lines, vivid contrast, inky black levels, and solid overall detail—delivering a clean and visually satisfying experience typical of 2D animated features.
Audio: 72
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for 'Justice League: War' excels in delivering a dynamic and immersive experience, with crisp dialogue, robust LFE moments, and a soundfield that captures every explosion and battle. Though slightly lacking in background ambiance, it remains one of the best audio tracks for a DC animated release.
Extra: 71
Justice League: War's Blu-ray extras offer a rich array of content, from insightful featurettes like 'Deconstructing JL: War' with detailed commentary on adaptation nuances by Jay Oliva and Jim Lee, to an in-depth biography of Jim Lee, production insights, a 'Son of Batman' sneak peek, and episodes from classic DC animated series.
Movie: 67
Justice League: War dynamically chronicles the formation of a new JLA amidst nonstop, action-packed sequences, yet its condensed runtime limits character development, emphasizing Cyborg's origin and featuring drastic personality shifts that may alienate die-hard fans, while appealing more to casual viewers.
Video: 62
The 1080p/AVC-encoded video presentation of “Justice League: War” offers a largely commendable experience, though not without a handful of technical complications. Banding remains the most prominent issue, particularly notable in scenes involving gradient lighting or sky backgrounds, a trait consistently observed in many of DC Universe's animated releases. Occasional aliasing and intermittent softness also arise, often due to artificial enlargements and zooms intrinsic to the animation itself rather than flaws in the encoding. Minor incidences of macroblocking and pixilation may be noticed upon close inspection but do not heavily detract from the overall viewing experience.
On the positive end, the film's color palette is both subdued and satisfying, with primary colors exhibiting a striking pop and black levels achieving an impressive inky depth. Details are solid throughout, and the animation's inherent smoothness and clarity are successfully preserved. The lines around characters remain smooth, avoiding the jagged edges sometimes seen in animation of this nature. However, certain shots may present a hazy quality, occasionally blurring the action to impart a more cinematic feel, though this sometimes diminishes visual appeal. Overall, seasoned viewers of DC's animated titles will find “Justice League: War” consistent with prior releases, showcasing polished animation with few significant detriments.
Audio: 72
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track for "Justice League: War" offers an exhilarating experience, particularly if you're drawn to high-octane action. The audio is laden with explosive sequences that resonate through the LFE channel, capturing every heat-vision-induced explosion, earth-shattering punch, and collapsing building. Dialogue remains clear and intelligible throughout, ensuring that even amidst the chaos, every line is comprehensible. Directionality and dynamic range are impressive, allowing for a well-balanced and immersive soundstage.
Despite minor drawbacks such as occasional imprecise directionality and a slightly low mix for spoken words, the overall audio performance is robust and engaging. The DTS-HD track is active and glitch-free, devoid of dropouts, cracking, or hissing, ensuring a seamless listening experience. Additional Dolby 5.1 tracks in Spanish and French are available, along with subtitles in English SDH and French, providing accessibility options that enhance the viewing experience.
In summary, while the 5.1 DTS-HD MA track might not rival a theatrical superhero outing like "Man of Steel," it certainly excels within its domain. Loud, clear, and packed with action, this audio presentation captures the high-energy essence of "Justice League: War," making it one of the standout tracks among DC animated releases. This is a must-crank track that promises to deliver a powerful and rock-solid auditory experience.
Extras: 71
The extras on the "Justice League: War" Blu-ray disc offer a robust and insightful exploration of the film's creation and related DC Universe content. Director Jay Oliva and artist Jim Lee lead the commentary on pivotal scenes, offering detailed analysis of the differences between the original comic series and its animated adaptation. Fans of Jim Lee will appreciate an in-depth documentary showcasing his career and influential artwork. Additionally, viewers can gain insights from the animation process with storyboard-to-pencil test featurettes and enjoy a sneak peek of the subsequent DC animated film, "Son of Batman." The disc also includes various episodes from notable DC Comics animated series and a selection of promotional trailers, providing comprehensive entertainment for DC enthusiasts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deconstructing JL: War: Director Jay Oliva and artist Jim Lee discuss key scenes and differences between the comic arc and animation.
- Creating Heroes: The Art and Life of Jim Lee: A documentary featuring interviews and insights into Jim Lee's career.
- Act D: From Animatic to Pencil Test: Jay Oliva discusses storyboarding and animation stages.
- Sneak Peek: Son of Batman: Preview of the upcoming DC animated film.
- From the DC Comics Vault: Episodes from Justice League Unlimited, Batman: The Brave and the Bold, and Young Justice: Invasion.
- Trailers: Various promotional trailers for related content.
Movie: 67
"Justice League: War" is a bold and action-packed reimagining of the Justice League's origins, drawing directly from Geoff Johns and Jim Lee’s 'Justice League: Origin' arc from the New 52 reboot. This film offers a fresh start for DC's iconic characters, making it an accessible jumping-on point for new viewers. The narrative kicks off when Green Lantern teams up with Batman to investigate alien Parademons, leading to a broader battle against the formidable Darkseid. The Justice League members are reintroduced with significantly altered personalities—Superman exudes arrogance, Green Lantern provides comedic relief, and Wonder Woman takes cues from Thor, all while Batman remains the most consistent in character.
The movie excels in its relentless action sequences that span its swift 79-minute runtime, with a standout being the climactic showdown against Darkseid. However, this focus on action means that character development is sometimes sacrificed for spectacle. While Cyborg receives a well-crafted origin story, other heroes like Flash and Shazam remain underdeveloped. The film's pacing is one of its main strengths and weaknesses; it moves quickly, often feeling like a relentless, extended action sequence, but this leaves little room for deeper storytelling or emotional resonance.
Despite its flaws, "Justice League: War" manages to be an entertaining ride filled with comedy and dynamic interactions between the heroes. The voice cast, particularly Justin Kirk as Green Lantern and Jason O'Mara as Batman, bring strong performances that bolster the film's appeal. Ultimately, while purists might find the changes jarring, casual viewers and new fans are likely to appreciate the fresh take and thrilling pace of this animated feature. This movie provides a glimpse into the potential for future Justice League projects on the big screen.
Total: 68
"Justice League: War" offers an engaging adaptation of the New 52 origin story for the Justice League. Character development dominates the first half of the film, successfully setting the stage with strong, reimagined versions of familiar heroes. However, the latter half pivots heavily towards action, which may feel overly extended to some viewers. This structure, though somewhat uneven, still provides a substantial introduction to the new continuity that DC Entertainment is cultivating in its animated universe.
The Blu-ray release of "Justice League: War" stands out with a notable audio-visual presentation. The DTS-HD Master Audio track delivers an impressive auditory experience, capturing the film’s dynamic range and action sequences effectively. Conversely, the video quality is slightly less consistent, with some scenes appearing less refined than others. The supplemental features are plentiful but not deep enough to provide lasting engagement beyond a few hours – a minor drawback for dedicated collectors and fans.
Where does "Justice League: War" fall on the spectrum of DCU animated original movies? Every comic and DCU animation fan will walk away with a different answer. And debate will continue to rage as long as DC Entertainment sticks with The New 52. Being introduced to new incarnations of familiar characters can be exhilarating, particularly when creators are given the freedom to play. It can also be a frustrating experience, fraught with pitfalls and wrong turns. As a launch pad for the DCU's newly announced plans to develop a shared continuity among its animated movies, "War" plants plenty of intriguing seeds and serves as a decent origin tale. Its flaws are pretty glaring, though, and it's more divisive than most. Warner's Blu-ray release isn't exactly reliable either. Its DTS-HD Master Audio track is excellent, but its video presentation is a bit too problematic and its supplemental package can be exhausted too quickly. Still, it's an entertaining flick and a solid disc. Rent it if you need to be sure. Otherwise, take advantage of the low price point and enjoy the latest DCU animated original movie, flaws and all.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 70
Like The Flashpoint Paradox and others before it, banding is the biggest flaw to be found in Justice League: War, followed by almost negligible aliasing and intermittent softness....
Audio: 90
When fistfights and battles with alien invaders aren't being waged, the front speakers do the majority of the lifting, but only insofar as the sound design dictates....
Extras: 50
Act D: From Animatic to Pencil Test (HD, 24 minutes): War's third featurette affords Oliva the opportunity to provide insight into the creation process, production and the various stages of storyboarding...
Movie: 70
The back- and-forth between Hal Jordan and Bruce Wayne keeps things light, every hero is given a crucial role to play, and there are only a few hints of reckless implausibility....
Total: 70
Being introduced to new incarnations of familiar characters can be exhilarating, particularly when creators are given the freedom to play....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
To be fair, the issues seem to be related to the way the animators are creating these releases, as opposed to something that's not there in the source and only showing up in the 1080p transfer....
Audio: 80
There's some entertaining LFE moments as well, thanks to the many explosions that occur in the movie....
Extras: 0
(HD, ½ min.); and a game trailer for 'Lego Legends of Chima: Laval's Journey' (HD, 1 min.)....
Movie: 60
While there's plenty of action in this opening sequence, the real purpose is the development of a love/hate relationship between Batman and Green Lantern, which is pretty fun to see develop onscreen....
Total: 60
Still, there's more than enough here to like and this is a decent introduction to the 'New 52' version of the Justice League....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
War has a very clean image as you’d come to expect from a 2 dimensionally animated feature....
Audio: 90
This movie is purely action based and things are constantly exploding, crashing and being pounded and this track manages to capture all that impact....
Extras: 100
Creating Heroes: The Life And Art Of Jim Lee (HD, 37:19) – A nice piece chronicling the life and career of famed comic book artist, Jim Lee.Justice League War Act D – From Animatic To Pencil Test (HD,...
Movie: 80
When I was watching War, and knowing the plans the studio has currently, I couldn’t help but feel like this felt like a sketch for the Justice League movie that Warner Bros is ultimately trying to hurry...
Total: 90
This one has the extra enjoyment of feeling like you’re looking in to some of what they may be conjuring up for the eventual Justice League film....
Director: Jay Oliva
Actors: Sean Astin, Zach Callison, Christopher Gorham, Justin Kirk
PlotParademons have been kidnapping and experimenting on humans in Gotham City, prompting Batman to investigate. He encounters Green Lantern while both are tracking the mysterious alien creatures. The two heroes discover a mother box, a powerful alien computer, which leads them to believe an invasion is imminent. Superman joins them after an altercation, and with the help of investigative reporter Lois Lane and STAR Labs scientist Silas Stone, they uncover that more mother boxes are appearing around the world. Meanwhile, young football star Victor Stone gets caught in an explosion caused by one of these devices, leading his father, Silas, to use the alien technology to save him, transforming Victor into Cyborg.
Simultaneously, Wonder Woman is visiting Washington D.C. for diplomatic purposes but is soon embroiled in the conflict when a mother box activates nearby. The alien invasion begins in earnest, with legions of parademons attacking major cities. Flash and Shazam join the hastily formed team of heroes to combat the threat posed by Darkseid, a powerful tyrant who seeks to conquer Earth. As they face off against Darkseid’s forces, the heroes must learn to work together despite their differing methodologies and personalities to protect humanity from certain doom. The newly formed team’s synergy and determination become the Earth's best hope against the extraterrestrial threat.
Writers: Heath Corson, Geoff Johns (comic book: "Justice League: Origin"), Jim Lee (comic book: "Justice League: Origin"), Jerry Siegel (character created by: Superman), Joe Shuster (character created by: Superman), Bob Kane (character created by: Batman), William Moulton Marston (character created by: Wonder Woman), Marv Wolfman (character created by: Cyborg), George Pérez (character created by: Cyborg), Jack Kirby (characters created by: Darkseid, Desaad & Parademons)
Release Date: 04 Feb 2014
Runtime: 79 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: USA
Language: English