Accident Blu-ray Review
Score: 41
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A technically competent Blu-ray marred by ham-fisted execution, spotty video quality, and poor characterization, ultimately failing as an engaging thriller.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 60
The Blu-ray of 'Accident' features an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.39:1, displaying solid saturation and robust detail in bright daylight scenes. However, dark scenes suffer from minimal shadow and fine detail, occasional noise, and digital grading issues, though overall, it delivers better-than-average picture quality.
Audio: 50
Accident's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track provides immersive moments with discrete effects and clean dialogue but disappoints in critical scenes, delivering a baseline background noise. The audio mix lacks balance, with tinny dialogue and unexpected sonic choices, though the included 2.0 Dolby Digital and subtitles offer additional options.
Extra: 2
"The Blu-ray for 'Accident' includes a high-definition trailer for the film, followed by three additional Well Go USA trailers that auto-play at startup but can be skipped. No other extras are provided, and the disc is Region A."
Movie: 21
Despite outstanding production values and a photogenic cast, 'Accident' devolves into an inane thriller, hampered by a ridiculous script and baffling plot twists, making it hard to maintain interest as it lurches through a thin premise with tedious sequences and illogical developments.
Video: 60
The Blu-ray release of "Accident," presented by Well Go USA, offers an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. The film, assumed to be based on a 2K Digital Intermediate of a digitally shot production, exhibits generally impressive visual fidelity, especially in daylight scenes. These sequences benefit from robust detail levels and strong saturation, contributing to a visually pleasing experience during flashbacks and opening scenes. The movie's production values, particularly for an independent South African film, are commendably showcased in these moments.
However, the darker scenes, predominantly set in a ravine post-collision, present notable challenges. Shadow detail is minimal, and fine details can become almost nonexistent in these dimly lit environments. Instances of noise are observable in these sequences, with sporadic banding further diminishing the visual quality. Issues with digital grading manifest as lapses in contrast and occasional blown-out colors, which could have been addressed with better post-production processing. Despite stable black levels, the overall consistency of detail and contrast could use improvement.
On balance, Well Go USA's 2.39:1 presentation of "Accident" achieves a moderately high level of picture quality. The bright daylight scenes display considerable depth and definition, particularly the darker shades of green in the crash location. While there are intermittent inconsistencies, the video transfer remains above average for most of the runtime, making it a competent yet imperfect visual experience.
Audio: 50
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track of the Blu-ray presentation of "Accident" offers select moments of immersive sound and distinct channel separation, particularly during sequences featuring torrential downpours and live electric lines. However, the overall surround activity often defaults to a mere baseline background noise. A curious choice in the sound design is apparent during the film’s primary accident scene where the sonic elements are dialed back, resulting in a subdued effect that contrasts with what audiophiles might typically expect in such impactful sequences. On the brighter side, the dialogue is consistently clear, and when the film transitions into heavily action-packed sequences involving helicopters and automatic weapons, the audio design sees a noticeable improvement in engagement.
Despite these positive elements, the audio design isn't without its flaws. The DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix sometimes lacks balance, particularly during pivotal moments where it falls short of fully leveraging discrete sound effects. Additionally, there are instances where the dialogue feels tinny and oddly distant from the rest of the audio landscape. While the mix incorporates decent amounts of LFE when needed, it doesn’t always deliver a cohesive listening experience. For those seeking an alternative, a secondary 2.0 Dolby Digital track is provided. The Blu-ray also includes optional English SDH subtitles in a white font that remain within the scope of the presentation at all times.
Extras: 2
The Blu Ray of "Accident" offers a concise selection of extras, predominantly comprising trailers. Upon startup, trailers for other Well Go USA releases are triggered, which can be skipped or viewed later through the menu. The disc's focus remains minimalistic in additional content, lacking a slipcover or comprehensive features, and catering specifically to Region A. Below is a detailed list of included extras.
Extras included in this disc:
- Accident Trailer: Standard high-definition trailer for the film.
- Well GO USA Trailers: A selection of three promotional trailers for other Well Go USA releases, accessible from the main menu.
Movie: 21
"Accident," helmed by writer and director Dan Tandowski, relies on an unwarrantedly complex series of plot contrivances that stretch believability beyond its limits. The film centers around Jess (Stephanie Schildknecht) and Caroline (Roxane Hayward), who, after a failed ride to an outdoor music festival, resort to hitchhiking in what is supposed to be California but is clearly South Africa. Their ride comes in the form of two mysterious men, Fred (Tyrone Keogh) and Thomas (Keenan Arrison), who soon plunge everyone into an implausible series of calamities starting with a devastating car accident. This accident, intended to serve as a gripping inflection point, instead sets the stage for seventy minutes of tedium as characters spend most of the film trapped in a wrecked car, marooned in a conveniently isolated location where cell phone reception is non-existent.
While the actors bring physical appeal and a valiant effort to the screen, their performances are undercut by an incoherent script and poorly developed characters. The film's pacing suffers significantly due to incessant flashbacks and incongruent backstories designed to add depth but ultimately add confusion. At times, it feels as though Tandowski is uncertain whether to focus on building tension or developing character motivations. This results in uneven narrative progressions that disrupt engagement, coupled with surprising lapses of logic that challenge even the most forgiving audience’s suspension of disbelief.
Despite its narrative flaws, "Accident" boasts high production values that belie its modest budget. The cinematography captures the desolated setting with a certain gritty aesthetic, and the visual effects are impressively executed for an independent feature. However, strong technical execution cannot salvage a fundamentally flawed script. The film’s reliance on increasingly absurd plot twists diminishes its potential as an effective thriller, leaving viewers with an experience that is credible only for its unintentional comedic moments.
Total: 41
Review Summary: The Blu-ray release of "Accident" offers a mixed bag of experience. The film is a collaborative production between South Africa and France, an odd pairing that gives it a unique cultural edge. The story's basic premise holds promise, yet the execution falters severely. Character development is essentially nonexistent, and the narrative quickly devolves from merely implausible to utterly absurd. Despite its shortcomings in plotting and performance, the movie sometimes compensates with decent visual effects and competent audio.
The visual presentation of "Accident" can be hit or miss. Dark scenes dominate the film, and the Blu-ray occasionally struggles to maintain image clarity during these sequences, leading to spotty video quality. Bright, outdoor scenes fare much better, showing off some impressive cinematography. The audio, on the other hand, is consistently solid, providing clear dialogue and an immersive soundtrack that enhance the viewing experience.
In conclusion, "Accident" is an underwhelming thriller with glaring flaws in characterization and plot development. However, its decent audio performance and occasional visual highlights might make it a worthwhile watch for some audiences. Proceed with tempered expectations if you decide to add it to your collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
Unfortunately, a lot of the film takes place in the dark, rainy confines of the ravine where the car ends up after a collision, and many of these scenes suffer from pretty minimal shadow detail and virtually...
Audio: 80
Weirdly the main accident moment, one that might have employed some pretty significant effects work (and, presumably, bombastic LFE) is played out in slow motion with tamped down sonics, which stylistically...
Extras: 10
As is the case with most Well Go USA Blu-ray releases, the disc has been authored so that trailers for other Well Go USA releases play automatically after the trailer for this film....
Movie: 30
Things only go from bad to worse when it turns out that the really cool car is the "McGuffin" of the film, and that there is a gaggle of paramilitary types intent on retrieving it (they may not be fully...
Total: 30
Video is a little spotty at times due to the prevalence of dark settings, but audio is fine, for those considering a purchase....
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 60
The picture quality is better than average much of the time, showcasing darker shades of green in the crash location....
Audio: 40
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA audio offers some immersion and a decent array of discrete cues, but strangely lacking in critical moments....
Extras: 2
For an additional 19 Accident screenshots, early access to all screens (plus the 20,000+ already in our library), 75+ exclusive 4K UHD reviews, and more, support us on Patreon....
Movie: 20
This is an easily avoidable thriller that gets more and more ridiculous after you realize they are going to stick in the same crash setting for a long time....
Total: 31
A lame, brain-dead “thriller” that looks nice, but is poor on characterization and everything else that matters in a thriller....
Director: Dan Tondowski
Actors: Roxane Hayward, Karl Thaning, Tyrone Keogh
PlotA group of teenagers, including Caroline and Jess, decide to steal a car for a joyride. Their plan quickly takes a dark turn when they find themselves pursued by the police. The thrill of the chase escalates into terror as they are forced off the road, causing them to crash into an abandoned quarry. Realizing their precarious situation, the teens scramble to figure out how to escape the flipped vehicle while grappling with their injuries and rising panic. Tensions flare as they blame one another for their predicament and struggle to maintain composure.
As the hours pass, their sense of desperation intensifies. The confined space and oppressive heat test their survival instincts. They attempt various methods to free themselves, all while keeping an eye out for help that never seems to come. Unseen dangers threaten their every move, and their hope dwindles with each failed attempt. Stranded and vulnerable, the group must confront their past choices and each other in a tense atmosphere that leaves them questioning who will make it out alive.
Writers: Dan Tondowski
Release Date: 01 Dec 2017
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: N/A
Country: South Africa, France
Language: English