The Sign of the Cross Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
A commendable classic with superb direction and performances; the Blu-ray offers strong video-audio quality and valuable extras, making it highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
The Sign of the Cross arrives on Blu-ray with a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC transfer in its original 1.37:1 aspect ratio, boasting a naturally filmic quality, superior contrast, and rich detail that honor Karl Struss's cinematography, despite minor imperfections like occasional nicks, soft blacks, and slight image softness.
Audio: 79
The DTS-HD Master Audio mono soundtrack delivers a clear and well-modulated audio experience, with strong dialogue and minimal issues like crackling or hissing, making it a significant improvement over previous releases.
Extra: 60
The Blu-Ray extras for 'The Sign of the Cross' present in-depth audio commentaries by film experts Mark A. Vieira and David Del Valle, covering production history, artistic insights, and intriguing anecdotes, complemented by a selection of promotional trailers for other Kino Lorber releases.
Movie: 80
A masterpiece of pre-Code Hollywood, 'The Sign of the Cross' is a visually stunning epic from Cecil B. DeMille, notable for its bold depictions of Roman debauchery and persecution, groundbreaking camera work, lush production design, impressive score, and standout performances, particularly by Claudette Colbert and Charles Laughton.
Video: 72
The Blu-ray release of "The Sign of the Cross" by Kino Lorber presents a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded high definition transfer, maintaining the original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.37:1. Hailing from a print preserved by the UCLA Film and Television Archive, this version includes all previously omitted scenes restored in the 1990s. The result is a naturally filmic presentation, capturing the gorgeous cinematography by Karl Struss, which earned the movie an Oscar nomination. The grain structure is pleasing, reinforcing the celluloid feel without compromising clarity despite predominant soft focus techniques. Superior contrast and grayscale add depth to the visuals, while intricate details on costumes and sets remain discernible.
Rich blacks anchor the image, and bright whites like those in Poppaea’s milk bath are rendered vibrantly. Although occasional nicks and scratches are present, they are not intrusive and do not detract from the overall visual experience. The shadow delineation generally avoids crush, keeping silhouettes well-defined. Despite slight imperfections—such as window-boxed opening credits, moderate softness in some scenes, and minor signs of print wear—the presentation remains impressive, delivering a crisp viewing experience that brings out the historical grandeur of this early sound period film.
Overall, this Blu-ray presentation stands as likely the best home video rendering of "The Sign of the Cross" to date, improving significantly over previous DVD incarnations. With faithful film grain representation and minimal detractors like scratches or dirt, it brings the dazzling elements of DeMille's classic to life with fidelity and elegance.
Audio: 79
The Blu-ray release of "The Sign of the Cross" offers an impressive DTS-HD Master Audio mono soundtrack. Dialogue is notably crisp and clear, ensuring ease of understanding throughout the film. No significant issues such as crackle, hiss, warps, pops, or clicks mar the audio presentation, providing a smooth and pleasant listening experience. The quality of this lossless audio presentation aligns seamlessly with the high-quality filmic scan, creating a cohesive audiovisual experience. Optional English subtitles are provided for additional clarity.
Furthermore, the DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track effectively revitalizes the original 88-year-old audio. Although it necessitates a higher-than-average volume setting for optimal listening, the sound remains clear and well-modulated. Despite the film’s limited musical score, the moments that do feature music exhibit a rich tone that effortlessly fills the room. The essential sound elements, including dialogue, animal growls, and gladiator grunts during the intense Colosseum scenes, are distinct and immersive.
Incorporating a meticulous cleaning of age-related artifacts such as hiss, pops, and crackle, this soundtrack showcases an early talkie era film in its best auditory form. The uncredited Rudolph Kopp's modest but effective score gains solid strength and fidelity in this remaster. This release undeniably represents the pinnacle of how the movie can be experienced on home video, marking a significant upgrade over previous DVD releases.
Extras: 60
The extras for the Blu-ray release of "The Sign of the Cross" are incredibly robust, providing significant enhancements to the overall viewing experience. The inclusion of two newly recorded audio commentaries stands out, offering comprehensive, expert insights into Cecil B. DeMille's creative process and the production nuances of this classic film. Mark A. Vieira delivers an engaging historical perspective, delving into DeMille's artistic style, influences, and the film's journey through censorship and restoration. In contrast, David Del Valle's commentary offers an enthusiastic and slightly more casual exploration, enriched with personal anecdotes and gossipy details. Both commentaries are informative and compelling, catering to different preferences for scholarly analysis versus conversational discussion. Complementing these are the original theatrical trailer and a selection of enticing trailers from other Kino Lorber releases, which round out a thoroughly satisfying extras package.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Mark A. Vieira: Comprehensive background on production, artistic style, and film history.
- Audio Commentary by David Del Valle: Enthusiastic discussion with personal anecdotes and additional insights.
- The Sign of the Cross Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer offering a glimpse into the film's promotional strategy.
- Bonus KLSC Trailers: Previews of other Kino Lorber releases including "Bluebeard’s Eighth Wife," "Since You Went Away," and more.
Movie: 80
The Sign of the Cross remains a paramount example of pre-Code Hollywood filmmaking, offering an extensive, richly woven narrative that combines the splendid opulence of Ancient Rome with the salacious and brutal elements often sanitized by later production codes. Directed by Cecil B. DeMille, the film plunges viewers into the turbulent reign of Emperor Nero (Charles Laughton), who masks his manipulative schemes behind a façade of regal indifference, as highlighted in unforgettable sequences such as Rome set ablaze. Supporting the gripping narrative is a stellar cast with Fredric March as Marcus Superbus, whose complex portrayal of a love-torn prefect adds a level of emotional depth amid glaring debauchery. Claudette Colbert as the seductive Empress Poppaea and Elissa Landi as the devout Christian, Mercia, both enrich the storyline with their compelling performances.
The technical achievements in The Sign of the Cross are exceptional, particularly in its production design and orchestration. Mitchell Leisen's art direction and costume design add striking visual authenticity to the lavish sets and grandeur attire, enhancing the movie's atmosphere significantly. The cinematography by Karl Struss, an Oscar-nominated effort for this film, captures strikingly fluid visuals through pioneering use of camera cranes, lending an unprecedented dynamism to the scenes. Anne Bauchens' adept editing maintains narrative clarity and pace, a testament to her frequent collaboration with DeMille. The evocative musical score, composed by Jay Chernis, Rudolph G. Kopp, Paul Marquardt, and Milan Roder, complements the grandeur on screen with sweeping themes that elevate key moments of drama and romance.
DeMille's direction shines through in his ability to balance intense character interactions against the backdrop of Rome’s gaudy excesses—alluding to more than just spectacle. The film persists in depicting early Christian perseverance against tyrannical oppression with graphic honesty uncommon for its era—most memorably during Claudette Colbert's notorious milk bath scene or in gut-wrenching sequences within the gladiatorial arena. At once provocative and reverent, The Sign of the Cross delivers both visual splendor and weighty storytelling, solidifying its status as a quintessential cinematic epic that brilliantly withstands the test of time.
Total: 73
"The Sign of the Cross" Blu-ray release is a masterclass in preserving cinematic history. The film, directed by Cecil B. DeMille, emerges as a provocative and artistically impressive epic. Set during Nero’s reign in first-century Rome, the movie delves deeply into Christian persecution with notable performances by Fredric March, Elissa Landi, Claudette Colbert, and Charles Laughton. Its notorious pre-Code content, including scandalous scenes and shocking violence, sparked considerable controversy but also garnered immense audience appeal, rejuvenating DeMille’s career.
Kino’s Blu-ray edition honors this historical classic with a stellar HD transfer that flaunts Karl Struss's Oscar-nominated cinematography. The video presentation is crisp and visually captivating, thereby ensuring that the grandiose pageantry and meticulous production details are vividly preserved. The audio quality is commendable, balancing dialogue and the musical score seamlessly. Notably, the release includes two enriching commentary tracks that offer valuable insights into the film's production and historical context.
In conclusion, "The Sign of the Cross" is a sweeping epic that has withstood the test of time as a true Hollywood classic. The sheer scope and spectacle of the filmmaking are downright fantastic; such magnificent work was done behind the scenes to make the film an essential gem of cinema. The performances are fantastic, the direction is superb, and the Blu-ray release features a strong video-audio presentation with some extras to round out the package. Cinephiles would do well to pick up this classic for their collections. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 80
A absorbing presentation which is naturally filmic, The Sign of the Cross has likely never looked better than it does on this new Blu-ray edition of the film....
Audio: 80
There were no egregious issues to report with regards to crackle, hiss, warps, pops, and clicks....
Extras: 80
The release also includes a selection of trailers promoting other releases available from distributor Kino Lorber: Bluebeard's Eighth Wife (SD, 3:08), Since You Went Away (HD, 1:40), Death Takes a Holiday...
Movie: 90
One of the elements contributing a great deal to the scope of the spectacle is the stunning costumes and art direction by Mitchell Leisen (Remember the Night, Death Takes a Holiday)....
Total: 90
The sheer scope and spectacle of the filmmaking is downright fantastic: such magnificent work was done behind-the-scenes to make the film such a commendable and essential gem of cinema....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Superior contrast and grayscale enhance depth (which is a critical component of this movie's beauty), the fine details on the lavish costumes and opulent sets are easy to discern, and all the close-ups...
Audio: 80
All the dialogue is easy to comprehend, as are the growls of the wild animals and grunts of the gladiators during the shocking Colosseum scenes, and any age-related hiss, pops, and crackle have been meticulously...
Extras: 40
Viera shares numerous anecdotes and bits of trivia, points out the material that was cut by the censors for the film's various reissues, cites the differences between the stage play and movie, notes how...
Movie: 80
While it's true DeMille is more of a showman than a craftsman most of the time, he goes the extra mile with The Sign of the Cross, expertly balancing eye-filling spectacle with striking shot compositions,...
Total: 80
Kino honors all the pre-Code debauchery with a beautiful transfer that celebrates Karl Struss's arresting, Oscar-nominated cinematography, solid audio, and a couple of interesting commentary tracks....
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 80
Overall, this is likely the best the movie will ever look on home video and an improvement over previous DVD releases of the movie, including The Cecil B. DeMille Collection DVD boxset....
Audio: 100
In short, this is likely the best the movie will ever sound on home video and another improvement over previous DVD releases....
Extras: 70
Commentary by author Mark A. Vieira – Recorded for this release, the co-author of a book on Cecil B. DeMille shares some of the background information on the production and restoration and some of the...
Movie: 80
And it all flourishes under the DeMille’s direction, whose earnestness about the material helps to gloss over some of the slower spots in the plot and pacing; equally worthy of praise here are the contributions...
Total: 80
Despite courting controversy with its ribald depiction of Ancient Rome, The Sign of the Cross was a hit with audiences and ushered Cecil B. DeMille back into relevance and another fruitful period....
Director: Cecil B. DeMille
Actors: Fredric March, Claudette Colbert, Elissa Landi
PlotIn ancient Rome, during the reign of Emperor Nero, the persecution of Christians intensifies, casting a shadow of fear and uncertainty across the empire. The story begins with Roman Prefect Marcus Superbus caught in a moral quandary as he falls in love with Mercia, a devout and compassionate Christian woman. Attracted to her kindness and unwavering faith, Marcus finds himself emotionally torn between his duties as an enforcer of Nero's brutal edicts and his growing affection for Mercia. His internal struggle deepens as he witnesses the suffering inflicted upon Christians, leading him to question his loyalties and the value of the imperial power he serves.
As Nero’s excesses spiral and his grip on the empire weakens, the conflict between personal conviction and state-imposed cruelty comes to a head. Pulled between adhering to the emperor's wishes and protecting Mercia, Marcus faces increasingly perilous decisions. Amid gladiatorial games, public spectacles, and instances of profound humanity, the empire's depravity is starkly contrasted with the potency of Christian faith, tested by relentless trials. As tensions escalate, irreversible choices are made that will determine not only Marcus's fate but also that of those who dare to defy Rome in pursuit of a higher cause.
Writers: Waldemar Young, Sidney Buchman, Wilson Barrett
Release Date: 10 Feb 1933
Runtime: 125 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English