For No Good Reason Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
For No Good Reason offers a mesmerizing glimpse into Ralph Steadman's artistic genius with solid video, strong audio, and captivating extras, though it leaves viewers yearning for more of his perspective.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 61
For No Good Reason's 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer delivers crisp, detailed visuals emphasizing fine facial features, clothing textures, and Steadman's vivid artwork. The film excels in color and contrast, providing strong blacks and balanced whites, albeit with minor issues like occasional wavy edges on glasses.
Audio: 66
For No Good Reason's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix offers a surprisingly active and immersive experience for an art documentary, balancing clear dialogue with well-integrated sound effects and ambient noises, providing deep bass, spontaneous surround sound, and effective use of rear and front channels.
Extra: 56
For No Good Reason’s Blu-ray extras offer a rich collection including articulate commentary from Charlie and Lucy Paul, extended interviews, a TIFF Q&A, and animated readings of Steadman’s work, providing an immersive and informative viewing experience.
Movie: 61
‘For No Good Reason’ offers a detailed, intimate portrait of Ralph Steadman's career, highlighting his chaotic artistic genius and profound impact on the art world, yet sometimes focuses too much on his collaboration with Hunter S. Thompson rather than Steadman’s own multifaceted life and works.
Video: 61
"For No Good Reason" delivers a visually engaging experience with its 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 encoded transfer. The clarity and crispness are immediately evident from start to finish, with a high level of fine detail visible in facial features, hair, and clothing textures. The transfer skillfully showcases the intricate details of Ralph Steadman's studio and artwork, ensuring viewers can appreciate the deep textures of canvases, photographs, and painted surfaces. The film's overall presentation benefits from clean edges that maintain the pristine quality of the subjects and Steadman's creations.
Color reproduction is exceptional, with eye-catching and even hues, particularly evident in the animated sequences styled after Steadman's distinctive art. The transfer handles color contrasts adeptly, offering strong, inky blacks without evident banding or crush, and a well-balanced white tone that enhances visual clarity without appearing overblown. While the image retains a somewhat flat HD video appearance, it still breathes life into paint and canvas details, making the visual experience both engaging and satisfying.
Despite these strengths, minor imperfections remain. Some soft focus instances and slight issues with artifacts around Steadman's glasses create occasional visual disruptions. However, these are minor quibbles in an otherwise solid presentation. Overall, the Blu-ray provides a largely satisfying and visually rich experience that aligns well with the film’s artistic essence.
Audio: 66
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray for "For No Good Reason" is highlighted by a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix that unexpectedly delivers engaging soundscapes for an art documentary and biography. The track opens with impressively deep bass and airy, evenly spaced notes that set a high standard. Throughout, the sound mix is punctuated by detailed sound effects that enhance several key scenes remarkably well. Notably, a rumbling airplane sequence during Steadman’s journey to New York and the background ambiance of the Kentucky Derby are particularly effective. The Nixon/Vietnam era montage exhibits robust power with sounds of helicopters and bombing runs, adding intense realism to the sequence.
Dialogue remains clear and clean, emerging firmly from the center channel, ensuring that Steadman’s conversations—whether with Depp or his monologues—are easily intelligible. Ambient noises subtly enhance the rear channels to provide an immersive listening experience, while the front channels manage more dynamic elements and LFE with finesse. Although the film is heavily dialogue-driven, there are animated sequences that exploit the full capabilities of the surround sound system, offering a more enveloping auditory experience. On the whole, this mix may be basic in structure but excels in delivering a balanced and immersive audio presentation befitting the film’s content.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "For No Good Reason" provide a comprehensive and insightful look into the creative mind of Ralph Steadman and the film's production process. The Audio Commentary with Director Charlie Paul and Producer Lucy Paul delves deeply into the film's structure, storytelling techniques, shooting styles, and their personal history with Steadman. The Toronto International Film Festival Q&A session offers a further in-depth conversation with Steadman and Paul, moderated by John Northcott. An animated short film, Cherrywood Cannon, brings Steadman's book to life, while Extended Interviews with Bruce Robinson, Richard E. Grant, and Terry Gilliam enriches the viewing experience. The Deleted Scenes provide additional context and insight into the film's narrative, complemented by the For No Good Reason Theatrical Trailer and previews of other Sony titles.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insights from Director Charlie Paul and Producer Lucy Paul.
- Toronto International Film Festival Q&A: Discussion with Ralph Steadman and Charlie Paul.
- Cherrywood Cannon: Animated reading of Steadman’s book.
- Extended Interviews: With Bruce Robinson, Richard E. Grant, and Terry Gilliam.
- Deleted Scenes: Additional scenes providing further context.
- Theatrical Trailer: "For No Good Reason" trailer.
- Previews: Additional Sony titles.
Movie: 61
"For No Good Reason" is an incisive documentary that vividly chronicles the life and career of Ralph Steadman, the esteemed artist known for his long-standing association with Hunter S. Thompson. Directed by Charlie Paul, the film intricately weaves Steadman's deviant yet masterful creations with his philosophical musings and desire to influence societal change. The documentary effectively captures the sheer transformative process of Steadman's art, showcasing moments where he translates raw splashes of ink into profound and often grotesque works of genius. These segments provide a compelling insight into Steadman's artistic methodology, from his inspirations—such as Rembrandt, Da Vinci, and Picasso—to his creative ventures beyond traditional canvases, including Polaroid manipulation.
However, the film's reliance on Johnny Depp as a bridging figure sometimes distracts from its core focus. While Depp's presence adds a layer of relatability and draws a connection with mainstream audiences familiar with "Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas," it occasionally diverts attention from the richly layered tapestry of Steadman's solitary journey and achievements. Despite this minor misstep, Paul's direction manages to paint a vivid picture of Steadman's tumultuous yet inspiring partnership with Thompson, marked by their collective zeal for Gonzo journalism and their drug-fueled escapades.
The documentary does risk overemphasis on Steadman's past collaborative ventures at the expense of exploring his individual accomplishments and more recent works. This narrative choice may tilt the film toward appealing more to fans of Thompson rather than aficionados of Steadman’s art alone. Despite these shortcomings, "For No Good Reason" provides a fascinating lens into Steadman’s world, offering a rich character study filled with both chaotic brilliance and raw artistic prowess. The documentary captures Steadman's essence as an unrefined yet profoundly impactful creator yearning to change the world through his beautifully grotesque art.
Total: 62
For No Good Reason delivers an intricate and engaging portrait of Ralph Steadman, one of the most unconventional artists of the 20th century. The documentary thoroughly explores Steadman's friendship with the infamous writer Hunter S. Thompson, intertwining it with the artist's unique creative journey. The film goes beyond mere biographical details to showcase Steadman's mental, emotional, and physical process in crafting his art, beautifully brought to life on screen. The Blu-ray release from Sony enhances this experience with robust video quality and compelling visual fidelity, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate details of Steadman's artwork.
However, the film leaves the viewer yearning for a deeper dive into Steadman’s individual perspective, suggesting that a more focused examination devoid of another prominent personality might have unveiled even richer insights about the artist himself. Nonetheless, this air of mystery adds to Steadman's enigmatic appeal. The audio quality on the Blu-ray is equally commendable, delivering a crisp and immersive auditory experience that complements the visual storytelling. Additionally, the array of extra content provided offers valuable insights and further context for those eager to delve deeper into Steadman’s world.
For No Good Reason paints a satisfying portrait of one of the most bizarre artists of the 20th century. A man whose creativity yields art that is simultaneously beautiful and hideous and a man who shared countless adventures with Writer Hunter S. Thompson, a biographical Documentary seemed all but inevitable. For No Good Reason delivers. Satisfying in every way and particularly fascinating in its depiction of Steadman's mental, emotional, and physical artistic process that are realized on-screen in the production of several works of art, the film will capture the imagination of anyone who appreciates fine art and a fascinating life story. Sony's Blu-ray release of For No Good Reason delivers solid video, strong audio, and a healthy assortment of extra content. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
It's mostly rather flat in that HD video sort of way, but there's at least a good bit of life to paint and canvas....
Audio: 80
Some Kentucky derby background din proves pleasing to the ears, and the turmoil of the Nixon/Vietnam era montage enjoys good power, particularly in the sounds of helicopters and bombing runs over Vietnam....
Extras: 60
Toronto International Film Festival Q&A with Ralph Steadman and Charlie Paul (1080i, 28:20): Moderator John Northcott hosts the star and director at TIFF....
Movie: 90
There's a fascinating sequence in which he guides Depp -- and his audience -- through his processes as a painter, focusing a little more on the physical side of the process rather than the mental, but...
Total: 80
Satisfying in every way and particularly fascinating in its depiction of Steadman's mental, emotional, and physical artistic process that are realized on-screen in the production of several works of art,...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Although it is not terribly dynamic, and outside of a few instances of soft focus, there is very little wrong with this transfer....
Audio: 80
As with the image, there are a few animated sequences that offer up something more to listen to, and these moments deliver more of an immersive experience....
Extras: 60
Toronto International Film Festival Q & A with Ralph Steadman and Charlie Paul (HD, 28 min.)...
Movie: 40
Depp's presence is sometimes necessary, as it seems he gives Steadman a voice to play off of, and Paul certainly seems interested in framing certain scenes by having his camera act as a fly on the wall,...
Total: 60
Still, one can't help but wonder what a lessened focus on Hunter S. Thompson might have forced the filmmaker to reveal about his subject, instead of making another person the topic by proxy....
Director: Charlie Paul
Actors: Ralph Steadman, Johnny Depp, Hunter S. Thompson
PlotThe film explores the life and career of British artist Ralph Steadman, known for his distinctive, chaotic style and his collaborations with American writer Hunter S. Thompson. Johnny Depp visits Steadman's studio, acting as a narrator and guide, to delve into Steadman's world. The documentary presents Steadman's artistic process, illustrating how he produces his provocative illustrations that often critique society and politics. Through interviews, animations, and archival footage, the film portrays Steadman's influences and his passionate engagement with the counterculture movement of the 1960s and 70s.
The narrative weaves through various phases of Steadman's career, highlighting his relationship with Thompson and their creation of Gonzo journalism. It reveals the interplay between their personalities and artistic visions, shedding light on the tumultuous yet productive nature of their partnership. As the film progresses, it captures Steadman’s reflections on his work, providing insights into his motivations and the impact of his art. The documentary culminates in a deeper understanding of Steadman’s legacy, emphasizing his role in shaping modern illustration and his unwavering commitment to challenging the status quo through art.
Writers: N/A
Release Date: 08 Mar 2014
Runtime: 89 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English