Child 44 Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Child 44's Blu-ray impresses with strong video and audio, yet the film's narrative flaws and sparse extras make it recommended primarily for die-hard fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
Child 44's Blu-ray presentation, encoded in AVC/MPEG-4 at 1080p with a 2.40:1 aspect ratio, offers a clean and crisp image despite an intentionally desaturated and muted color palette reflective of mid-century Soviet Russia. Although resolution and black level fidelity occasionally suffer, exterior scenes reveal more detail, with no issues in compression artifacts.
Audio: 74
Child 44's lossless DTS-HD MA 5.1 provides fantastic bombast and immersion with excellent fidelity and ambient environmental sounds. Dialogue clarity is maintained despite the dynamic range of action sequences. The mix also includes Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 and English Descriptive Audio, with subtitles in English, Spanish, and English SDH.
Extra: 13
Child 44's Blu-ray extras include a concise yet insightful making-of featurette, 'Reflections of History,' offering cast and crew interviews focused on production design and historical accuracy, alongside a theatrical trailer and Digital HD UltraViolet Copy. However, the limited content detracts from the overall value.
Movie: 50
An engaging but ultimately flawed adaptation, 'Child 44' excels with its oppressive Soviet atmosphere and strong performances, particularly from Tom Hardy, but suffers from a convoluted plot and fragmented narrative that fail to fully develop either the political intrigue or the serial killer mystery.
Video: 74
The Blu-ray presentation of "Child 44", encoded in AVC MPEG-4 with a 1080p resolution and a 2.40:1 aspect ratio, offers a detailed yet intentionally subdued visual experience that aligns well with the film's mid-century Soviet Russia setting. The film was shot on film using various Arricams, and its desaturated color palette effectively conveys the grim and oppressive atmosphere. The muted tones are particularly evocative, heightening the emotional impact of the narrative. Notably, the video suffers from some challenges like slightly soft perceived resolution and black levels that occasionally lack depth, which results in some loss of shadow detail. However, the transfer remains free from image instability and compression artifacts.
Despite the film's overall dark and moody aesthetics, there are instances where the exterior sequences brighten up, showcasing good depth of field and above-average detail, especially in close-ups. These scenes provide a stark contrast to the otherwise dull palette, accentuating key moments without disrupting the overall tone. The color grading is consistent yet features some aggressive hues in isolated scenes, such as an early encounter at the opera with notable yellow tints. While CGI scenes used for establishing shots of locations like Moscow appear somewhat minimalistic and soft, they do not detract significantly from the overall quality.
In terms of technical fidelity, this Blu-ray holds up well with high clarity and clean visuals. The muted color scheme occasionally gives way to more vibrant, pastel-like appearances, which are compelling but infrequent. Flesh tones are accurately represented to reflect the cold Russian environment, lending a pasty complexion to characters. Black levels generally perform admirably without compression or crush issues, although shadows could have benefitted from more detail. Overall, while "Child 44" does not deliver a spectacular HD video presentation, it offers a strong and immersive visual experience that complements its thematic elements effectively.
Audio: 74
"Child 44" arrives on Blu-ray featuring an impressive English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix that stands out despite its primarily dialogue-driven narrative. The soundtrack navigates a balance between immersive action sequences and quieter, dialogue-heavy moments, effortlessly transitioning from bombastic battle scenes to nuanced exchanges. Ambient environmental sounds—such as the clattering in train stations or gentle breezes across fields—are finely detailed, enriching the atmospheric surroundings. Jon Ekstrand's melancholic score is well-distributed throughout the surrounds, enhancing the film's somber mood. The fidelity is excellent and the dynamic range notably wide, ensuring a problem-free audio track.
The audio design is multifaceted, mirroring the film’s blend of thriller, war, and drama elements. Action sequences and fight scenes see the sound mix rising to a new level; gunfire is particularly crisp and dynamic, with bullets and explosions offering palpable heft through effective LFE utilization. While not overwhelmingly aggressive, the surround panning provides believable outdoor soundscapes complete with insects and bird calls, alongside well-placed interior sound effects like ringing phones. Dialogue reproduction remains crystal clear throughout, unperturbed by the thick accents of the cast. The track, while not reference-grade demo material, delivers an engaging and satisfyingly immersive audio experience.
Additional offerings include Spanish 5.1 Dolby Digital and English Descriptive Audio, along with subtitle options in English, Spanish, and English SDH. This ensures accessibility for a broader audience without compromising the quality of audio delivery across different formats. Overall, "Child 44" offers a strong auditory presentation aligned with its thematic complexity, reflecting its diverse genre inspirations while maintaining crystal-clear dialog and dynamic action sequences.
Extra: 13
The Blu-ray extras for "Child 44" offer a limited yet insightful peek into the film's production process. Although succinct, the content provides a valuable understanding of the challenges faced in re-creating a heavily censored historical period. "Reflections of History" stands out with its engaging interviews with cast and crew, and behind-the-scenes footage focusing on the intricacies of production design, costumes, and props. Theatrical Trailer is also included, but the extras lack depth and length, with only a modestly brief featurette and trailer available. The Digital HD UltraViolet Copy adds a convenient viewing option but does not contribute to the behind-the-scenes knowledge.
Extras included in this disc:
- Reflections of History: Recreating the World of Child 44: In-depth look at production design with interviews and behind-the-scenes footage.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original movie trailer.
- Digital HD UltraViolet Copy: Digital copy for alternative viewing options.
Movie: 50
Set in the paranoid, oppressive atmosphere of 1953 Soviet Russia, "Child 44" vividly depicts a society where the government denies the very existence of murder. This decree, driven by Stalin's vision that only capitalist societies experience such deviance, sets the stage for a tension-filled narrative. Our protagonist, Leo Demidov (Tom Hardy), a decorated hero of the state and Ministry of State Security (MGB) officer, faces a moral quagmire when his godson is found dead under suspicious circumstances. The thriller delves into Leo's struggle against a regime that refuses to acknowledge the serial killings of young boys, leading to his professional and personal downfall.
Leo’s journey begins with internal conflict as he is forced to silence his grieving friend Alexei about his son's murder. This is compounded by his assignment to investigate his own wife Raisa (Noomi Rapace) on charges of treason. The narrative escalates when Leo and Raisa are exiled to a remote town, stripping them of their status and security. Persisting in his quest for truth, Leo uncovers patterns that suggest a serial killer is at large, pushing him to act against a system designed to hide the truth. Hardy delivers an intense performance against a backdrop of an increasingly convoluted storyline marked by various plot twists.
While "Child 44" boasts a gripping premise and showcases strong performances, particularly from Hardy, the film’s narrative suffers from overstuffed subplots which detract from its primary focus on the serial killer mystery. The transition between Leo’s fall from grace and the murder investigation feels jarring and fragmented, leaving significant plot points underdeveloped. Despite its atmospheric tension and visceral fight scenes, the film's pacing issues and lack of coherent focus between its political thriller and crime drama elements ultimately undermine its potential, resulting in a disjointed viewing experience.
Total: 59
"Child 44" showcases a fascinating premise with gripping performances that unfortunately do not fully cohere into a dramatically satisfying whole. The film's stifling and oppressive atmosphere, while initially compelling, becomes increasingly suffocating as the narrative progresses. Daniel Espinosa's direction, while talented, struggles with the material, leading to numerous narrative sidebars that detract from the main storyline. Despite these flaws, the atmospheric tension and excellent acting make "Child 44" worth pursuing for those who appreciate immersive settings and character-driven performances.
The Blu-ray release of "Child 44" delivers impeccable technical quality, boasting strong video encoding and an impressive 5.1 surround sound experience. These elements enhance the film's already palpable ambiance, drawing viewers into the stark and haunting world depicted on screen. However, the minimal special features associated with this release may disappoint those hoping for additional content or behind-the-scenes insights. This scant offering of extras underscores the need to temper expectations regarding this Blu-ray edition.
In conclusion, "Child 44” is a visually stunning and professionally crafted film that suffers from narrative missteps but shines in individual scenes, especially action sequences. The Blu-ray edition excels in audio and visual presentation but lacks substantial special features. While it is recommended for fans and those intrigued by its premise, others might find more value in giving it a rental first. Despite its imperfections, the potent atmosphere and strong performances make it a worthy, if flawed, addition to one’s collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
A lot of the film is quite dark (as can easily be seen in many of the screencaptures accompanying this review), a choice which deprives many scenes of much in the way of shadow detail and even general...
Audio: 80
Child 44's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 has moments of fantastic bombast and immersion, including the battle scene which begins the film, but then retreats to a somewhat more staid and center focused...
Extras: 20
Reflections of History: Recreating the World of Child 44 (1080p; 8:18) is a decent EPK with several interviews and an emphasis on production design....
Movie: 60
The film probably has too many competing elements to ever fully develop any of them, something that becomes more than obvious when the whole "mystery" revolving around who is killing the kids is revealed...
Total: 60
Certainly a case of the parts being greater than the whole, Child 44 has an intriguing premise which is at least partially wasted by too many sidebars that only add to Demidov's struggles....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
It works well to set the mood and tone, but perceived resolution and black level fidelity suffer for these choices....
Audio: 80
Atmospherics are also very strong -- insects, bird calls, and other nature sounds build believable outdoor soundscape while well-placed ringing phones pepper interior-office environments....
Extras: 20
Recreating the World of 'Child 44' (HD) This short featurette includes cast and crew interviews as well as behind the scenes footage about what went into researching and recreating the costumes, props....
Movie: 60
These disparate elements certainly serve one another (the paranoid MGB makes Leo's investigation more difficult), but I wonder if this project should have focused more on the murder and less on Leo's world,...
Total: 60
That said, the movie generally works from scene-to-scene, especially action sequences, so perhaps it'll be more your cup of tea....
Why So Blu? review by Gerard IribeRead review here
Video: 100
The color palette is very muted but does poke through every once in a while giving the image a pastel looking appearance – in parts....
Audio: 100
Audio Format(s): English DTS-HD MA 5.1, Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1, English Descriptive AudioSubtitles: English, English SDH, SpanishDynamics: The film is a mixed batch of different sounds, because it’s...
Extras: 10
There’s a very short making-of featurette, trailer, and Digital UltraViolet Copy included....
Movie: 40
It’s obvious to everyone around that it is no accident but common sense and the very basic act of speaking up against authority is met with a bullet to the head almost instantly and where one stands....
Total: 50
Child 44 is a great looking film and more than competent but it’s severely misguided and that is very unfortunate....
Director: Daniel Espinosa
Actors: Tom Hardy, Gary Oldman, Noomi Rapace
PlotIn 1950s Soviet Russia, former war hero Leo Demidov works as a high-ranking officer in the state security administration. His life is upended when his loyalty is tested after he refuses to denounce his wife, Raisa, as a traitor. Relocated to a remote outpost, Leo begins investigating a series of gruesome child murders that the state refuses to acknowledge. The totalitarian regime's official stance is that murders do not happen in their utopia, creating an insurmountable barrier for justice. Determined to uncover the truth, Leo's pursuit puts him in direct conflict with his own government.
As Leo delves deeper into the case, he teams up with General Nesterov, who initially distrusts him. Despite the oppressive environment and constant surveillance from political adversaries, the two men discover that the murders are connected, suggesting the presence of a serial killer preying on vulnerable children. Their investigation uncovers dark truths about the very foundations of the Soviet state, challenging their beliefs and forcing them to confront moral dilemmas and personal betrayals. Amidst the paranoia and brutal crackdowns on dissenters, Leo's quest for justice becomes a dangerous struggle for survival against a backdrop of widespread suspicion and impending danger.
Writers: Richard Price, Tom Rob Smith
Release Date: 17 Apr 2015
Runtime: 137 min
Rating: R
Country: Czech Republic, United Kingdom, United States, Russia, Romania
Language: English, Russian