Duck, You Sucker! Blu-ray Review

The Kino Lorber Blu-ray release of "Duck, You Sucker!" (also known as "A Fistful of Dynamite") is presented in a 1080p resolution with an aspect ratio of 2.35:1. The transfer leverages an older restoration and reconstruction from the English language version prepared by MGM, which results in a few inherent limitations. Notably, some of the darker scenes struggle to maintain proper grain structure, at times appearing borderline noisy, while certain daylight scenes exhibit similar issues, albeit less frequently. Colors are reasonably well-rendered but could benefit from improvement. Stability is largely consistent, even during transitions merging footage from different sources, although minor white specks are occasionally observable.

Grain structure remains intact across the film, maintaining an attractive, film-like quality. The detail is particularly strong in close-ups but tends to soften in medium shots and becomes notably unfocused during the Irish flashback sequences. The dynamic range is effectively showcased, with colors ranging from lush landscapes to the deep blacks of character Juan's hair. Black levels hold up well, especially in interior scenes. However, dirt and speck occurrences alongside occasional image banding detract from the overall experience. Intercut segments using different source materials appear hazy, shaky, and lack necessary focus and color depth.

Overall, while the transfer is generally satisfactory and offers a captivating viewing experience marked by solid colors and image stability, it fails to achieve perfection due to inherited limitations and a lack of new scanning efforts. Akin to "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly" 50th Anniversary Edition, a more thorough restoration could have significantly enhanced this edition, elevating it from good to great.

The Blu-ray release of "Duck, You Sucker!" comes equipped with English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 and DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks, accompanied by optional English subtitles that appear within the image frame. The 2.0 track remains stable, clean, and dynamically intense for a Mono track, offering a satisfactory audio experience. Although a Stereo track might have been a welcomed addition—especially given its availability in Italian—the current presentation maintains an authenticity that purists will appreciate.

Conversely, the 5.1 track introduces sparse surround elements derived primarily from the original 2.0 mix. However, this configuration doesn't significantly elevate the viewing experience and the dialogue remains clear, anchored mostly to the front and center channels without overwhelming them. The film’s battle scenes can push these channels, so keeping the volume at a medium level is advisable to avoid the audio becoming overly tinny and distorted. Notably, some sync issues appear more frequently than desirable, which could detract from immersion.

Ennio Morricone’s score is another point of interest; while it is essential to the film, it lacks the enduring impact of his other collaborations with Sergio Leone. Nonetheless, it adds a unique atmospheric element to the production, complementing the narrative's tone and pacing effectively. Altogether, this Blu-ray delivers a sound presentation that, with few exceptions, stays true to the original experience.

The extras included in the Blu-ray release of "Duck, You Sucker!" are a well-curated collection ported primarily from previous MGM DVD and Blu-ray editions, offering a comprehensive dive into the film's production, history, and legacy. Highlighted by insightful commentary tracks from film historian Sir Christopher Frayling and filmmaker Alex Cox, the extras deliver both academic analysis and passionate fandom perspectives. The featurettes explore various facets—including the myth-busting themes of revolution, detailed recollections by screenwriter Sergio Donati, and the meticulous restoration process led by John Kirk. Further enriching the disc are location comparisons, image galleries with Morricone's iconic score, and engaging visual essays.

Extras included in this disc:

• The Myth of Revolution: Christopher Frayling discusses the film’s themes and production.
• Restoration Italian Style: John Kirk on the film’s restoration and production history.
• Sergio Donati Remembers: Screenwriter Donati reflects on his work with Leone.
• Sorting Out the Versions: Details the various edits and the film’s reconstruction.
• Once Upon a Time in Italy: Focus on Leone’s cinematic legacy.
• Location Comparisons: Visual comparisons of filming locations.
• Trailers From Hell: Brian Trenchard-Smith reviews the film.
• Audio Commentaries: By Alex Cox and Sir Christopher Frayling.
• Animated Image Galleries: B&W and color photos with music.
• Radio Spots: Six vintage spots.
• Trailer: Original theatrical trailer.
• Additional Trailers: Films from Kino Lorber’s catalog.

Sergio Leone’s A Fistful of Dynamite, also known as Duck, You Sucker, is a monumental entry in the spaghetti western genre. As his final foray into westerns, Leone infuses this film with profound political and social commentary, distinguished by a sense of melancholy often absent in his earlier works. Starring James Coburn as Irish revolutionary John Mallory and Rod Steiger as Mexican bandit Juan Miranda, the narrative intertwines themes of revolution, betrayal, and the human condition against the backdrop of the Mexican Revolution of 1913. Leone's direction crafts a narrative rich in subtext, elaborating on the futility and cyclical nature of revolutionary fervor.

The restored long version included on this Blu-ray reintegrates the extended finale footage, adding crucial context to Coburn’s character arc. The flashback sequences, essential for understanding John’s motivations and internal conflict, while cathartic, occasionally disrupt the film’s pacing but are integral to its thematic depth. Ennio Morricone's score elevates the film further, bringing an emotional resonance that complements Leone's powerful storytelling.

Visually, Leone's approach is grandiose yet intimate, employing wide shots and visceral cinematic techniques that captivate audiences familiar with his oeuvre. The film’s aesthetic grandeur is coupled with intense gunfights and gritty character portrayals, encapsulating the chaotic spirit of revolution. Despite occasional missteps in character accents—Coburn's inconsistent Irish dialect and Steiger's exaggerated Mexican portrayal—the performances add a unique texture to the film. This edition respects the complexity of Leone's vision, inviting viewers to reengage with a classic work that remains startlingly relevant.

For enthusiasts of spaghetti westerns desiring substance over stylistic fluff, A Fistful of Dynamite serves as a compelling piece that bridges Leone’s Dollars Trilogy with his later Once Upon a Time series. This restoration not only preserves but enhances the critical subtexts that solidify its place as a formidable entry in both Leone’s career and cinematic history.

Sergio Leone's "Duck, You Sucker!" also known as "A Fistful of Dynamite," remains an intriguing entry in the spaghetti western genre. Despite not achieving the legendary status of Leone’s earlier Dollars Trilogy, this film’s complex narrative and socio-political depth stand out. The visual style is robust and captivating, notably with the long zoom shot featuring the approaching train— a scene that could serve as a central piece in many period films. Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release utilizes an older restoration of the English language version from MGM. While not new, this restoration maintains a respectable level of visual and audio fidelity, presenting the film in a manner that highlights its understated brilliance.

The film's thematic ambition is unmistakable. It boldly deconstructs socio-political myths, offering a narrative rich in irony and complexity. Some may find it muddy or confusing at points, but these imperfections do not overshadow its overarching message and cinematic artistry. The Kino Lorber Blu-ray offers a solid A/V presentation that faithfully captures the essence of Leone’s vision. Furthermore, the disc is laden with extensive bonus features, adding significant value for collectors and enthusiasts eager to delve deeper into the film’s production and context.

In conclusion, "A Fistful of Dynamite" encapsulates the ultimate spaghetti western experience with its sophisticated narrative and exceptional visual style. While it may lack the immediate charisma of Leone’s previous works, its depth and ambition make it a compelling watch. Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release, sourced from an older MGM restoration, offers a commendable presentation with enriching special features that are sure to delight fans. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.