Mother and Child Blu-ray Review
Score: 60
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
'Mother and Child' is a powerful, emotionally complex drama, featuring stellar performances and superb Blu-ray video and audio quality—highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
'Mother and Child' shines on Blu-ray with a 1080p transfer that faithfully captures its digital origins. The MPEG-4 AVC encoding ensures vivid detail, realistic skin tones, and deep black levels, though the muted color palette lacks vibrancy. Coupled with a clear DTS-HD MA track, this transfer stands out despite minor banding.
Audio: 55
Mother and Child's DTS-HD MA 5.1 track excels in clarity and precision, focusing primarily on dialogue and piano, with nuanced atmospherics enhancing the experience; it’s a clean, well-mixed presentation suitable for the film's understated nature.
Extra: 40
The Blu-ray extras for 'Mother and Child' offer insightful, albeit brief, behind-the-scenes pieces on character dynamics and production challenges, a few inconsequential deleted scenes, and standard trailers—an adequate but not essential enhancement to the main feature.
Movie: 73
"Mother and Child" is a beautifully balanced, character-driven film about the complexities of motherhood, featuring a superb cast and seamless direction by Rodrigo García, but may have struggled to connect with a wider audience due to marketing missteps and its understated nature.
Video: 73
The Blu-ray presentation of "Mother and Child" delivers a solid 1080p transfer encoded in MPEG-4 AVC and maintains an aspect ratio of 2.35:1. The digitally-shot film boasts a remarkably clean and virtually blemish-free image, providing a faithful representation of its source material. Skin tones appear natural, black levels are deep, and while the film's overall color scheme may be muted, certain scenes—such as those featuring sugary confectionery colors—display a significant pop. Exceptional detail and strong textures are evident throughout, highlighting every wrinkle and fabric nuance, making the film’s visual experience both immersive and engaging. The slight banding observed does not detract significantly from the overall picture quality, maintaining a nearly flawless digital transfer without dirt, grain, or debris interference.
The visual fidelity of this transfer brings a crisp, almost film-like quality to the screen, notable for both its simplicity and beauty. Although the contrast may occasionally seem bumped up and the color palette lacks vividness, the transfer holds up well, surpassing many other digital features. Sony's Blu-ray transfer captures an incredibly detailed image that is both steady and accurate. While it might not be at the top of the Blu-ray heap in terms of flashy colors or dynamic contrast, it stands out for its faithful and undisturbed presentation, making it a stable high-definition video transfer. This understated yet stunning portrayal ensures that "Mother and Child" remains visually appealing while offering a dramatic essence true to its roots.
Audio: 55
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for "Mother and Child" delivers a quietly effective and nuanced auditory experience, befitting the film's dialogue-driven and understated nature. The soundtrack composition leans heavily on dialogue, light music, and subtle atmospheric sounds, predominantly utilizing the front three speakers. Dialogue is consistently clear and centered. The piano score, centrally instrumental in setting the film’s mood, spreads smoothly across the left and right channels. Surround activity remains minimal, focused primarily on atmospheric details that enhance scene-specific ambiance without demanding attention.
Although the surround channels are generally reserved for the understated score by Ed Shearmur or subtle sound effects, these elements are flawlessly integrated into the overall mix. Noteworthy is the precision with which ancillary sounds, such as a ticking clock, are executed; they seamlessly enrich the scene’s atmosphere. The limited LFE presence aligns appropriately with the film’s dramatic tone. The audio mix steers clear of extravagance, instead providing a clean, workmanlike output that is clear, crisp, and always well-prioritized. While it may not offer groundbreaking dynamic range or surround sound prowess, it excels in delivering a consummate and non-intrusive auditory backdrop to the narrative.
Overall, the lossless DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack reflects ‘Mother and Child’s sound design ethos: routine but executed with remarkable clarity and precision. This mix epitomizes a drama-focused presentation, prioritizing intelligible dialogue and a mood-setting score over aggressive surround sound dynamics. For a film of this genre, the soundtrack’s quality lies in its simplicity and unobtrusiveness, achieving the desired emotional resonance without extraneous embellishment.
Extras: 40
The Blu-Ray extras for "Mother and Child" provide an insightful look behind the scenes of this drama, enriching its viewing experience. Creating the Family Tree delves into the creative process, including casting, character dynamics, and financial challenges, with commentary from Director Rodrigo Garc�a. Universally Connected focuses on the film's themes and technical aspects, detailing a significant tracking shot and providing behind-the-scenes insights, such as Jimmy Smits' fat suit. The Deleted Scenes feature three excerpts that, while interesting, add little to the overall narrative. Additionally, there are multiple trailers for other films, though they are more cursory. This comprehensive look at both creative and practical filmmaking aspects makes the extras a worthwhile addition to any fan's collection.
Extras included in this disc:
- Creating the Family Tree: In-depth discussion on film production.
- Universally Connected: Exploration of character dynamics and technical aspects.
- Deleted Scenes: Includes "She Wanted to Look For Her," "How Did You Get Pregnant?," and "Tell Me What to Remember."
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional trailer for "Mother and Child."
- Previews: Trailers for various other films.
- BD Live enabled
- movieIQ
Movie: 73
Rodrigo Garcia's "Mother and Child," bolstered by executive producer Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu, is an evocative exploration of the multifaceted relationships between three women whose lives are intricately woven by the theme of adoption. Karen (Annette Bening) grapples with the haunting aftermath of putting her daughter up for adoption at 14, while her estranged daughter Elizabeth (Naomi Watts) lives a loner's life as a lawyer until an affair with her boss (Samuel L. Jackson) changes her trajectory. Concurrently, Lucy (Kerry Washington) and her spouse navigate the fraught journey of adopting a child. This narrative, first showcased at the 2010 Sundance Film Festival, is lauded for its poignant portrayal of contemporary motherhood, grounded in realism and emotional depth.
"Mother and Child" thrives on its authentic storytelling and stellar ensemble cast. Bening’s profound portrayal alongside Watts’s and Washington’s compelling performances contribute to a seamless realism that elevates the film. This sense of genuineness is further enhanced by Garcia's unobtrusive direction, which emphasizes character-driven narratives over visual embellishments. The interplay of these domains crafts a tender, albeit sometimes challenging, viewing experience that doesn't shy away from the harsh realities of life while also capturing fleeting moments of hope. Despite its thematic heaviness, Garcia maintains a balance that prevents the film from descending into melodrama, making it an engaging yet sobering piece.
The film's title might be subtly misleading and its release perhaps ill-timed against mainstream blockbusters, yet "Mother and Child" remains a commendable drama that dissects the joys and pains of motherhood with unflinching honesty. Supported by uniformly excellent performances from its high-caliber cast, and underscored by Garcia’s technical finesse, it carves out an intimate space that reflects the nuanced struggles and small victories inherent in human connections.
Total: 60
"Mother and Child" stands as a highly compelling and emotionally complex drama, showcasing the talents of an exceptional cast led by Annette Bening, Naomi Watts, and Kerry Washington. Director Rodrigo Garcia deftly tackles a challenging narrative, rooted in realism and poignantly exploring the intertwined lives of several women grappling with issues of motherhood, loss, and identity. The inclusion of Kerry Washington's storyline was a critical addition that transformed the narrative, providing a rich and necessary dimension to the film.
Technically, Sony's Blu-ray release excels with stunning video quality and a high-fidelity lossless soundtrack, enhancing the viewing experience considerably. Although the special features, including interviews and behind-the-scenes footage, are not overwhelming, they do offer valuable insights into Garcia's decade-long journey to bring this story to the screen. The steady and unobtrusive direction combined with the seamless performances ensure that audiences are deeply immersed in the drama from start to finish.
In conclusion, "Mother and Child" is an arresting drama that may not appeal to everyone due to its intensely emotional subject matter, yet it is undoubtedly one of the finest dramas of 2009. The film's heart-wrenching authenticity, complemented by unparalleled acting and high-quality production values, makes it a must-watch for fans of mature, emotionally gripping cinema. Whether seeking a breakthrough performance by Kerry Washington or simply desiring a profound cinematic experience, this Blu-ray is highly recommended for discerning viewers.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Sony's image is a bit flat and glossy by nature, but it's also crisp and incredibly detailed, capturing every wrinkly line on older characters' faces wile picking up every small texture in clothing and...
Audio: 80
Music and dialogue both are perfectly clear and accurate, with the former spreading out a bit to the sides while the latter remains centered, both infinitely pleasant and supporting the movie about as...
Extras: 30
Creating the Family Tree (1080p, 13:39): Director Rodrigo Garc�a and other cast and crew discuss the history of the project, the challenges of acquiring the necessary finances, the casting process, the...
Movie: 90
Whether big name actors and actresses or relative newcomers who might otherwise be dwarfed by names like Jackson, Benning, Watts, and Smits, the cast is uniformly superb with each and every primary character...
Total: 80
Touching, honest, and real, Director Rodrigo Garc�a's film doesn't shy away from the tough issues while also celebrating the joys of life that, no matter the pains, doubt, and fears, always seem to, eventually...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
It looks like film, has a lushness and life to it, but also carries with it all the hallmarks of a top tier digital film – noticeably its virtually perfect picture quality and attention to detail....
Audio: 60
The surround channels are mostly used for the twinkly, understated score, although there are occasionally bursts of activity, mostly due to an important sound effect, which do jar you into noticing the...
Extras: 60
There is also a collection of "previews" on the disc, which also plays before the menu, so there's really no need to go into depth on what is essentially a collection of studio-packaged commercials....
Movie: 60
The performances, the filmmaking, and the attempt to address an issue as complicated as motherhood and fertility in a way that is even remotely uplifting and relevant, should be commended....
Total: 60
With wonderful audio and video and a watchable, if not overwhelming, collection of extras, 'Mother and Child' is easily recommendable....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 82
However, there is a dull look to the film, contrast seems bumped up at times and the over-all color scheme has no real pop....
Audio: 78
However, there is a dull look to the film, contrast seems bumped up at times and the over-all color scheme has no real pop....
Extras: 40
(HD) Creating the Family Tree (HD) Universally Connected (HD) Deleted Scenes with Introductions by Director Rodrigo Garcia (HD) Trailers: You will meet a tall dark stranger, Tamara Drewe ,Inside Job, I...
Movie: 80
Inarritu ("Babel") comes the moving story of three women and the power of the unbreakable bond between mother and child....
Total: 70
If you want to see a break through performance by Kerry Washington and do enjoy adult drama's with no action elements, I think you will enjoy giving this a spin....
Director: Rodrigo García
Actors: Naomi Watts, Annette Bening, Kerry Washington
PlotKaren, a middle-aged physical therapist, struggles with the lifelong regret of having given up her daughter for adoption when she was just a teenager. Her emotional distance and bitterness impact her relationship with people around her, including her aging mother and her colleague, Paco, who shows romantic interest in her. Karen's lost daughter, Elizabeth, is now a successful lawyer and a fiercely independent, emotionally guarded woman. Elizabeth's complex personality, shaped by her unresolved feelings about her adoption, leads her to navigate relationships in her own detached manner, including a significant liaison with her married boss.
Meanwhile, Lucy, a married woman desperate to become a mother, embarks on a challenging journey to adopt a child. With her husband’s reluctant support, she connects with a young, pregnant teenager who is considering giving her baby up for adoption. The film intertwines the lives of these three women, exploring themes of loss, reconciliation, and the deep, often painful, connections between mothers and their children. Through a tapestry of interconnected stories, it delves into the complexities of forgiveness, the impact of past decisions, and the yearning for familial bonds.
Writers: Rodrigo García
Release Date: 02 Jul 2010
Runtime: 125 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Spain
Language: English