The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Extended Edition
Score: 90
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Fellowship of the Ring 4K edition shines with exceptional quality, satisfying Tolkien fans.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 82
The 4K release of The Fellowship of the Ring eradicates the green tint, enhancing colors, details, and contrast for an unparalleled viewing experience, despite minor digital flaws.
Audio: 92
The new Dolby Atmos mix delivers a dazzling, immersive audio experience for 'Fellowship,' with superb clarity, depth, and dynamic range, rivaling recent 4K releases.
Extra: 96
The 4K UHD edition of The Lord of the Rings Trilogy is a movie-only release, excluding all bonus features previously available on the 2012 Extended Blu-ray Edition.
Movie: 96
Peter Jackson's LOTR trilogy, an ambitious project costing $300M and taking over 8 years, is now on 4K, enhancing its epic fantasy world with outstanding visuals and sound, captivating audiences anew.
Video: 82
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" represents a significant improvement over previous releases, particularly addressing the infamous green tint of the Blu-ray edition. This iteration offers a fresh 4K scan of the original camera negative and VFX filmouts, resulting in a presentation that allows the vivid palette of Middle Earth to shine with unparalleled naturalism and clarity. The HDR10 enhancement tastefully elevates the visual experience without exaggeration, from the lush landscapes of the Shire to the fiery depths of Mount Doom. This enhancement not only elevates color fidelity but also significantly improves contrast levels, deep blacks, and brilliant whites, enhancing both intimate interior scenes and expansive landscapes with remarkable detail and realism.
The resolution and fine detail throughout the film are nothing short of astounding in this 4K release. Every frame, from close-ups of characters to sprawling vistas, reveals an extraordinary level of texture and clarity. The intricate details of costumes, the rugged landscapes of New Zealand, and even subtle expressions on characters' faces are presented with an unprecedented depth and sharpness. This meticulous attention to detail extends to the film's iconic props and enchanted environments, immersing viewers in Tolkien's world as never before. Despite minor drawbacks such as faint noise reduction effects and slight inconsistencies in visual effects detailing, these do not detract significantly from the overall quality of the presentation.
What stands out in this 4K edition are the marked improvements in black levels, shadow detail, and color correctness, delivering a more authentic and immersive viewing experience. Scenes that benefit notably include those set within the dark confines of the Mines of Moria and the brilliant flames surrounding Durin's Bane, showcasing exceptional clarity and vibrancy. However, this edition falls short of dramatically expanding the overall color spectrum compared to its HD counterparts. While enhancements are evident – notably in scenes set in Hobbiton and Rivendell where colors feel more lively and accurate – the palette shift isn't as pronounced as one might expect from 4K HDR technology. Nonetheless, this release undoubtedly sets a new standard for home video presentations of "The Fellowship of the Ring," significantly elevating the visual experience for fans and newcomers alike.
Audio: 92
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray audio presentation of "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" showcases a Dolby Atmos soundtrack that is both a feast for the ears and a monumental upgrade from its predecessors. From the onset, viewers are engulfed in Howard Shore's iconic score, which permeates the room with precision, warmth, and an expansive mid-range that captures the essence of Middle-earth with remarkable clarity. This auditory experience is further amplified by a plethora of acoustical details, ensuring an immersive soundscape throughout. The mix excels in delivering clean separation and distinction, particularly in the screeches of Orcs and Nazgûl, while the resonance of clashing metal in battle scenes envelops the audience, creating a convincingly tangible environment.
Coupled with the magnificent orchestration are the meticulously crafted ambient sounds that employ all channels effectively, including the Atmos' height channel, enhancing sequences such as Moria’s chaotic battle. This results in a dynamic and omnipresent sound field that effortlessly moves around and above the viewer, with echoes and movements rendered in stunning clarity and precision. Every scream, cheer, and atmospheric nuance contributes to a 360° sound environment that is as immersive as it is expansive. From the subtle rustle of leaves to the overwhelming roar of the Balrog, each element is presented with an astonishing level of detail, ensuring an enveloping experience.
Additionally, the robust and commanding low-end adds another layer of immersion to the action sequences, with palpable, wall-rattling impact during key moments like the confrontation with Sauron and the Balrog encounter. Throughout all this, dialogue remains crystal clear and well-prioritized, ensuring that even amidst the most sonically chaotic scenes, every word is discernible. Optional dubs and subtitles enhance accessibility without compromising on quality, maintaining the integrity of this auditory masterpiece.
Extra: 96
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray edition of "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" is a dedicated release that offers viewers an unparalleled visual and auditory experience, focusing solely on the movie itself without the inclusion of supplementary features. This choice to not include any bonus content allows for an undistracted appreciation of the film’s remastered resolution and audio, ensuring that fans and new viewers alike can immerse themselves fully in the rich detail and expansive world that Peter Jackson has created. However, for those seeking behind-the-scenes content, commentary, or documentaries that have been part of previous versions, it's important to note that this release diverges by offering the movie exclusively.
Extras included in this disc: No bonus features are included in this edition.
Movie: 96
Peter Jackson's adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" marked a groundbreaking moment in cinema, notably for its ambitious approach of shooting all three films of the trilogy back-to-back. This daring venture, which spanned over eight years and nearly $300 million in production costs, proved to be a monumental success, both critically and commercially. The film serves as the trilogy's introduction, masterfully establishing the tone and immersing viewers in the fantastical world of Middle-Earth, populated with its diverse, courageous inhabitants. Its success is a testament to Jackson's innovative vision, transforming New Zealand's landscapes into the vividly realized realms of Middle-Earth, complemented by a cast's performances that breathe life into their characters' epic quests.
The 4K UHD edition release of "The Fellowship of the Ring" elevates the home viewing experience to spectacular new heights, courtesy of Warner Bros. Home Video. This version retains the integrity of the original special effects while presenting the film in an eye-popping 2160p transfer coupled with a breathtaking Dolby Atmos audio mix. Such enhancements deliver an immersive experience that rivals the awe of initial theatrical viewings. Notably, this edition includes both the theatrical and extended cuts of the film, with the latter being widely regarded by fans as the definitive viewing experience. The extended version enriches the narrative, allowing for a deeper exploration of Middle-Earth and its characters' journeys.
Released as part of The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy package, this 4K UHD edition offers fans both digital and physical formats, the latter comprising nine UHD100 discs housed in a specially designed keepcase with iconic music accompanying the menu screen. For enthusiasts seeking to relive the enchantment of "The Fellowship of the Ring" or to introduce it anew, this edition ensures an unparalleled viewing experience, capturing the magic and grandeur of Jackson’s vision with unmatched clarity and audio depth.
Total: 90
Warner Bros.' 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "The Fellowship of the Ring" Extended Edition is an undeniable treat for fans of Tolkien's masterpiece and aficionados of high-quality home cinema alike. This edition stands out with its impeccable 2160p video transfer, breathing new life into Middle-earth with outstanding clarity, vibrant colors, and refined detail that surpass previous releases. The visual grandeur is complemented by a stunning Dolby Atmos soundtrack, which envelops the viewers in the film's epic soundscape, from the tranquil Shire to the ominous Mines of Moria. While this release comes as part of The Motion Picture Trilogy 4K set without additional extras, the sheer quality of this presentation alone makes it a must-have for collectors and enthusiasts.
Upon its original release, "The Fellowship of the Ring" set high standards for fantasy cinema, and two decades later, it remains an unparalleled achievement. This 4K Ultra HD edition not only honors Peter Jackson's vision but elevates it, showcasing the unparalleled beauty of the New Zealand landscapes and the intricate details of setting and costume design that made the world of Middle-earth so believable. Unfortunately, the absence of bonus features in this package may leave some die-hard fans yearning for more content. However, the significant enhancements in picture and sound quality offer a compelling reason to revisit the beginning of this epic journey.
In conclusion, the 4K UHD Blu-ray edition of "The Fellowship of the Ring" Extended Edition represents a substantial upgrade over earlier releases, making it a highly recommended addition to any film library. Its exceptional video and audio presentation revitalizes an already timeless film, ensuring that both longtime fans and newcomers will find themselves immersed in the enchanting world of Middle-earth as never before. Despite the lack of extra content, this edition stands as a testament to the enduring appeal and cinematic triumph of "The Fellowship of the Ring.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
The second bit of good news is that its HDR10 enhancement does an excellent job of tastefully boosting certain hues into very appealing territory without going overboard, from the lush greens of the Shire...
Audio: 0
This is a tastefully remixed but extremely powerful track that shares a lot in common with other recent 4K discs like 300 and even V for Vendetta, showcasing countless demo-worthy sequences that are filled...
Extras: 100
...
Movie: 100
As of this writing, this title is only available as part of The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy 4K. Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings trilogy broke new ground in the fantasy genre by...
Total: 0
It's currently only available as part of The Motion Picture Trilogy 4K set which contains no extras but, even if that changes in the future, this is still an outstanding presentation of an extremely durable...
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 90
The same is true of the earthy browns and tans in other sequences or the dreamy quality of Rivendell where everything may appear more colorful after removing the greenish-blue tint of the previous HD version,...
Audio: 100
While maintaining remarkable acoustical details from start to finish, even during the loudest, most boisterous action sequences, imaging continuously feels wide and expansive as background activity fluidly...
Extras: 0
2012 Extended Blu-ray Edition: 4K Ultra HD Disc: This UHD edition of The Lord of the Rings Trilogy is a standalone release without any of the previous bonus features ported over....
Movie: 100
The point being, when The Fellowship finally released during the 2001 holiday season, my level of confidence for Jackson's live-action adaptation was not initially high, and I remember walking into the...
Total: 90
Journeying across the lands of 4K Ultra HD, the first entry in the trilogy arrives with an exceptional Dolby Vision HDR presentation and a demo-worthy Dolby Atmos soundtrack, providing a notable improvement...
Director: Peter Jackson
Actors: Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen, Orlando Bloom
PlotIn the peaceful Shire of Middle-earth, young hobbit Frodo Baggins inherits a seemingly innocuous ring from his elderly cousin Bilbo Baggins. However, the wizard Gandalf reveals that this is no ordinary ring—it is the One Ring, an instrument of unimaginable power forged by the Dark Lord Sauron to bend all of Middle-earth to his will. When it becomes evident that Sauron's forces are mobilizing to search for the ring, with the intent to restore Sauron to his full might, Frodo accepts the perilous task of taking the ring to the fires of Mount Doom, where it can be destroyed. He is joined by his loyal friends, fellow hobbits Sam, Merry, and Pippin, who decide to share in Frodo’s dangerous quest.
Setting out from the Shire, the quartet quickly encounters danger, leading them to the elven haven of Rivendell. Here, representatives of Middle-earth's various peoples—the humans Aragorn and Boromir, the elf Legolas, the dwarf Gimli, and Gandalf—come together and form the Fellowship of the Ring. This unlikely alliance pledges to protect Frodo on his journey to Mordor, the land where Mount Doom lies. As the Fellowship commences their trek across diverse and treacherous landscapes, they must contend with external threats from Sauron's minions and internal strife sparked by the ring's corrupting influence, which tests the bonds of their alliance and the resolve of their mission.
Writers: J.R.R. Tolkien, Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens
Release Date: 19 Dec 2001
Runtime: 178 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: New Zealand, United States
Language: English, Sindarin