Raw Wind in Eden Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Raw Wind in Eden offers stunning Tuscan visuals and a fresh 2K master, but lacks chemistry and depth, recommended mainly for fans of the leads.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 80
Kino Lorber’s Blu-ray release of 'Raw Wind in Eden' showcases the 2.35:1 CinemaScope visuals with a new 2K master. The 1080p transfer offers striking Mediterranean landscapes and bold costume colors, though minor registration issues and inconsistent color grading require attention. Despite these flaws, the natural film grain and vibrant hues make it an appealing debut for home video enthusiasts.
Audio: 76
The Blu-ray's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track delivers clear dialogue and solid atmospheric details, though some upper register imperfections and light hiss are evident. Despite these minor setbacks, the dynamic scale and fidelity elevate Hans J. Salter's score, lending it a lush, full tone.
Extra: 43
The Blu-ray extras for 'Raw Wind in Eden' include an insightful audio commentary by David Del Valle and Daniel Kremer, praising the film's lush photography and detailing its debut on video. They describe it as a 'guilty pleasure' from the 1950s, noting its notable cast changes and production anecdotes.
Movie: 50
Raw Wind in Eden (1958) visually captivates with its breathtaking Rochette landscapes and features spirited performances by Esther Williams and Jeff Chandler. However, despite exotic settings and promising talent, the film falters with its cliched storyline and underdeveloped characters, resulting in a predictable, passion-lacking melodrama. The Blu-ray presentation preserves the original 2.35:1 aspect ratio and offers clear DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono sound quality.
Video: 80
The Blu-ray release of "Raw Wind in Eden," presented by Kino Lorber, showcases a 1080p transfer with an MPEG-4 AVC encoding, sourced from an exclusive new 2K master. Retaining its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio, the film offers an engaging visual experience despite several technical imperfections. A natural grain structure supports a filmic texture, though transitions display minor registration issues affecting color stability and delineation. Surface imperfections, such as nicks, are notable but infrequent, sparing viewers from significant distractions like cut or warped frames. Notably, the grading occasionally falters, with shaky blue hues replacing more desirable tones, which detracts slightly from visual cohesion.
Director of photography Enzo Serafin's use of 35 mm film in the CinemaScope process results in captivating views of the Mediterranean's vibrant scenery, accentuated by Williams' standout costumes and the film's travelogue appeal. Her attire—particularly a striking red jumpsuit—contrasts dramatically against lush island landscapes, offering visual vibrancy and depth. Many scenes exhibit pristine clarity and commendable contrast, allowing the Mediterranean blues and greens to shine. The vivid color palette highlights rich blacks, bright whites, and natural flesh tones, enhancing cinematic appeal.
Despite a few unfavorably fuzzy transitions, the master showcases mostly stunning visuals, marked by crystal-clear scenes and sharp close-ups that celebrate Williams' glamor and Chandler's rugged features. While some issues with saturation and color balance persist, the overall result remains largely impressive for a film debuting on home video. This Blu-ray release provides a visually enriching experience geared towards fans of CinemaScope films and admirers of its star-studded cast, promising enjoyment through stunning Italian locations and impeccable costume presentation.
Audio: 76
The Blu-ray release of "Raw Wind in Eden" features a singular audio option: English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono. Complementary English SDH subtitles are available, appearing within the picture frame when activated. This audio track primarily delivers a solid listening experience with clear dialogue, ensuring that viewers remain engaged with the film’s narrative. Notably, the voiceover for Argentinian actor Carlos Thompson by Paul Frees is executed seamlessly to maintain articulation and clarity throughout.
While the overall sonic performance is commendable, certain areas could benefit from further refinement. The dialog tracks may require an elevated volume to fully appreciate intricacies, exposing minor background hiss and intermittencies in tonal balance. Despite these subtleties, the soundtrack maintains integrity, and potential restoration work could result in further enhancement.
The DTS-HD Master Audio track excels in rendering atmospheric elements such as island breezes and crashing surf, enriching the viewing experience with vivid natural sounds. Sonic elements like gunshots, thunderclaps, and physical altercations are articulated crisply and precisely, enhancing key cinematic moments. Hans J. Salter’s rich musical score benefits from high fidelity and wide dynamic range, offering a lush, full-bodied soundscape that supports the onscreen action. Significantly, age-related noises such as pops or crackling have been notably absent, suggesting attentiveness to maintaining pristine sound quality. Despite its relatively minor shortcomings, this audio presentation provides an effective and engaging auditory backdrop to the visual narrative.
Extras: 43
The Blu Ray release of "Raw Wind in Eden" enriches its offering with insightful extras that serve to both entertain and inform enthusiasts of classic cinema. The exclusive audio commentary by critics David Del Valle and Daniel Kremer is a notable highlight. It is a treasure trove of anecdotes, sharp wit, and deep dives into the film's production and legacy. Del Valle and Kremer delve into the film’s lush visuals, historical context, and casting choices, with a particular focus on the technical prowess behind its creation. Their dynamic commentary vividly paints the cinematic landscape of the 1950s, highlighting the challenges and nuances of film productions from that era. The vintage theatrical trailer complements the commentary, offering viewers a nostalgic glimpse into the film's original appeal. Overall, these extras significantly enhance the viewing experience and are essential for dedicated fans and scholars alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Engaging insights from film historian David Del Valle and filmmaker Daniel Kremer.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original preview emphasizing the film's dramatic elements.
Movie: 50
Kino Lorber’s Blu-ray release of Richard Wilson's "Raw Wind in Eden" (1958) provides a visually captivating yet narratively challenged film experience. Filmed on location in Tuscany and back at the Universal lots in California, the picture offers a glimpse into the era's penchant for exotic locales and adult romance that was prevalent in 1950s cinema. The film stars Esther Williams and Jeff Chandler, both of whom endeavor to inject life into their underdeveloped characters. Despite the picturesque backdrop of Rochette providing a rich visual tableau, the story is marred by cliched scenarios and predictable conclusions. The narrative attempts to meld romance, intrigue, and action but falters, failing to utilize fully the chemistry between its leads or the potential of its scenic setting.
The film centers on Laura, played by Esther Williams, a fashion model seeking respite from a mundane romantic entanglement. She is whisked away by playboy Wally Drucker (Carlos Thompson) on a journey that soon leaves them stranded on a mysterious Mediterranean island, inhabited only by Mark Moore (Chandler) and the humble duo Pintón and his daughter, Costanza. The ensemble cast struggles to lift the film above its lackluster script that leans heavily on contrived conflicts and misguided melodrama. Esther Williams, known primarily for her dazzling aquatic performances, transitions into more dramatic roles, showcasing her charm and presence despite the script's limitations. However, her performance and the breathtaking visuals compete for attention rather than complement each other.
While "Raw Wind in Eden" doesn’t deliver on its evocative title, it remains an eye-catching curiosity from Hollywood's vault of romantic-adventure films. Fans of classic cinema might find joy in its nostalgic aesthetic and the allure of its leads. However, newcomers seeking depth in storytelling may view it as a missed opportunity overshadowed by its scenic majesty. This Blu-ray edition offers clean visual restoration in 1080p with DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 and no frills, rendering it primarily as a visual spectacle for collectors and aficionados of the era.
Total: 68
"Raw Wind in Eden" is a modest production that attempted to capture the evolving tastes of 1950s Hollywood audiences, transitioning from formulaic romantic narratives to something more engaging. The film stars Esther Williams and Jeff Chandler, whose real-life chemistry sadly fails to translate onto the screen. The narrative unfolds on a picturesque island off the coast of Italy, contributing significantly more to the film’s appeal than the actual storyline. The beautiful Italian landscapes, captured vividly in color photography, serve as a highlight amidst an otherwise underwhelming drama centered around a group of individuals marooned in an emotional impasse.
Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release of "Raw Wind in Eden" serves up a fresh perspective via its new 2K master, which revitalizes the visual elements. The transfer does justice to the vibrant cinematography, enhancing the limited allure of this cinematic artifact. Accompanying the upgraded visuals is a commendable audio track that supports the film’s soundscape without overshadowing it. The release also includes an insightful commentary track, adding depth and context for audiences interested in the film’s background and production nuances.
In conclusion, "Raw Wind in Eden" remains a B-film that evokes mixed impressions. For fans of Williams and Chandler or enthusiasts of classic Hollywood explorations into adult relationships, it offers enough to warrant a viewing. However, beyond the visual splendor and the technical polish provided by this Blu-ray release, the film’s dramatic engagement leaves much to be desired. This release is recommended primarily for those already inclined toward its lead stars or those with a specific interest in period dramas marking Hollywood's transitional era.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
However, to look as it should Raw Wind in Eden needs to be fully restored because there are several transitions with small registration issues that impact delineation and color stability....
Audio: 80
For example, some very light background hiss makes its presence felt, plus some unevenness can be noticed as well....
Extras: 40
Commentary - this exclusive new audio commentary was recorded by critics David Del Valle and Daniel Kremer....
Movie: 60
Unfortunately, and somewhat surprisingly, the production has too many critical limitations that appear to have predetermined the type of film Wilson could deliver....
Total: 70
But, sadly, it is not, and all Raw Wind in Eden has to offer are a few breathtaking visuals from Rochette, a picturesque village in Tuscany....
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 95
Kino Lorber’s Blu-ray release offers breathtaking views of the Mediterranean, its blue-green waters, Williams’ bold costumes, and the island itself, all of which are exquisite....
Audio: 85
The sound of the surf splashing on the rocks suggests danger as Laura swims in the strong current....
Extras: 80
In their audio commentary, film historian David Del Valle and filmmaker Daniel Kremer spend a good deal of time discussing the film’s lush photography, saying it’s “stunning to look at.”...
Movie: 60
She plans to spend the weekend with her married millionaire boyfriend but on returning to her apartment, she encounters Wally Drucker (Carlos Thompson, Valley of the Kings), who explains that her boyfriend...
Total: 80
The studios knew how to light the embers of male-female relations but were still unable to create real fire....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The schizophrenic source material alternates between pristine splendor and a scratchy mess, with many scenes featuring crystal clarity and pitch-perfect contrast, while fuzzy softness plagues others....
Audio: 80
A wide dynamic scale and excellent fidelity lend the lush music score by six-time Oscar nominee Hans J. Salter a lovely fullness of tone and all the dialogue is clear and comprehendible....
Extras: 20
He also shares some gossipy details about its production and stars, most notably that Williams and Chandler had an affair during shooting, discusses Williams' talent as a straight dramatic actress, and...
Movie: 40
Her chemistry with the always reliable but not particularly magnetic Chandler fuels the film (the two reportedly had an affair during shooting), but despite their best efforts, neither can compete with...
Total: 60
Raw Wind in Eden provides an exotic location, but there's not much passion in this tepid drama about a handful of disparate people who must coexist on a remote Italian island....
Director: Richard Wilson
Actors: Esther Williams, Jeff Chandler, Rossana Podestà
PlotLaura, a glamorous model, and her friends are on a private flight over the Mediterranean when their plane encounters trouble and crashes near a desolate island. The survivors, while relieved to be alive, soon realize their challenges are far from over. As they survey their surroundings, they are warmly welcomed by Mark, a charming yet enigmatic recluse who resides on the island with his sister, Costanza. Mark offers them shelter and provisions, presenting himself as a gracious host, though his hospitality comes with an air of suspicion. As the group settles in, they observe the peculiar dynamics between Mark and the other island inhabitants. Intrigued and captivated by his mysterious charisma, Laura finds herself drawn to Mark, even as she senses an underlying tension that suggests things on the island might not be as idyllic as they seem.
As the days go by, Laura and her friends navigate their complex relationships and try to understand the true nature of their host. The island's isolation exacerbates personal tensions among the group, leading them to question their perceptions and loyalties. While exploring their temporary home, they uncover unsettling clues pointing to hidden dangers and past secrets that threaten their safety. Desperate for answers, Laura takes it upon herself to unravel the mysteries surrounding Mark and the island's past, striving to ensure her group's survival and a potential escape. In doing so, she must grapple with her feelings for Mark and decide whom she can truly trust in an environment where every revelation alters their understanding of this unexpected paradise.
Writers: Dan Lundberg, Elizabeth Wilson, Richard Wilson
Release Date: 27 Nov 1958
Runtime: 93 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English