Brian Banks Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Brian Banks thrives on Aldis Hodge's standout performance, complemented by solid video quality on Blu-ray, but falters with a low-volume soundtrack and minimal extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 81
Brian Banks Blu-ray delivers a vibrant 1080p AVC-encoded transfer with detailed visuals, despite occasional source noise and flat blacks. The lush green fields and well-handled contrast in dark scenes underline Universal's capable high-definition presentation.
Audio: 71
Brian Banks' DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack, though initially quiet, delivers clear dialogue and nuanced musical clarity, utilizing surrounds for atmospheric effects and occasional LFE enhancements for hip-hop tracks. Predominantly front-channel focused, it ensures a basic yet immersive listening experience.
Extra: 11
The Blu-ray extras for 'Brian Banks' are minimal, featuring a brief 1:42 behind-the-scenes segment titled 'The Story Behind Brian Banks' in 1080p, mostly consisting of interviews and film clips, alongside a Movies Anywhere digital copy code.
Movie: 66
Aldis Hodge's compelling portrayal of Brian Banks elevates this true story of wrongful imprisonment, capturing the man's resilience and fight against a system stacked against him; with Greg Kinnear adding depth as the dedicated attorney, the film steers clear of melodrama to deliver an inspiring tale of redemption.
Video: 81
The Blu-ray presentation of Brian Banks exhibits a highly commendable 1080p AVC-encoded transfer from Universal. The digital source does introduce some inherent noise, particularly in low and moderate light scenarios, but overall, the visual integrity remains intact without any significant encoding issues. Blacks can appear flat and somewhat washed out in some scenes; nonetheless, the color palette is largely effective—ranging from the crispness of white dress shirts to the vibrant green football fields and various attire throughout the film. Skin tones are well-rendered and appear natural, providing a balanced and visually satisfying experience.
Fine detail in the film is adequately captured, with facial close-ups revealing pores, facial hair stubble, and other nuanced details that enhance complexity and realism. Clothing textures are sharp, and environmental details are generally crisp, though some scenes can appear slightly soft and blurry around the edges. Notably, the prison scenes stand out with their dark yet purposeful lighting, using contrast artfully to reflect thematic elements of inspiration and resilience. While not groundbreaking, this Blu-ray transfer proficiently delivers a high-definition visual experience that serves the film well.
Audio: 71
The Blu Ray of "Brian Banks" features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack that offers a commendable yet imperfect audio experience. The track is encoded at a lower volume, necessitating an upward adjustment to achieve optimal clarity and presence. Once the volume is adjusted, the soundtrack provides a notably clear and well-prioritized dialogue, which is crucial for this dialogue-driven film. The front channel implementation is predominant, delivering good musical clarity and acceptable front side stretch. Surround integration is subtle, effectively used to extend John Debney's score and enhance atmospherics in specific scenes such as the bustling courthouse backdrop.
In terms of technical execution, the soundtrack occasionally showcases discrete effects, like people walking in a stairwell or crowd noise during a football game. These elements are proficiently rendered to create an immersive atmosphere when required. Furthermore, the occasional hip-hop tracks benefit from the LFE channel's low-end enhancement, adding depth and resonance where applicable. Despite its excellent dialogue management and well-executed surround elements, the track's restrained volume and minor surround integration may leave some listeners wishing for a more dynamic range and immersive experience.
Extras: 11
The Blu-ray of "Brian Banks" features limited but insightful extras that enhance the viewing experience. The primary supplement, "The Story Behind 'Brian Banks,'" offers a concise yet informative behind-the-scenes look at the making of the film through interviews and film clips. Despite its brief runtime, this feature provides valuable context and a deeper understanding of the narrative and production. Additionally, the disc includes a digital copy code redeemable on Movies Anywhere, ensuring flexible viewing options. The packaging includes a non-embossed slipcover, maintaining a professional and sleek appearance.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Story Behind 'Brian Banks': A brief behind-the-scenes trailer with interviews and film clips.
- Digital Copy: An insert with a code for Movies Anywhere.
Movie: 66
In "Brian Banks," Director Tom Shadyac masterfully captures the harrowing journey of Brian Banks (Aldis Hodge), who is wrongfully accused and imprisoned for a crime he did not commit. The film's narrative focuses on Banks' relentless pursuit to reclaim his life and clear his name, shedding light on the largely unyielding American judicial system. Aldis Hodge delivers a deeply compelling performance, portraying Banks with emotional depth and authenticity, revealing the clash between hope and despair. Supported by a solid screenplay from Doug Atchison, the storyline demonstrates how Brian's perseverance, shaped by his football discipline, drives him towards seeking justice through the California Innocence Project led by Justin Brooks (Greg Kinnear).
Key scenes, such as Brian's flashbacks to his time in prison and a soul-crushing 60-day stint in solitary confinement, are pivotal. His resilience and the profound advice from a prison teacher, played by an uncredited Morgan Freeman, serve as critical turning points in his struggle for redemption. These moments poignantly depict Brian's internal battles and his unyielding resolve to move forward despite overwhelming odds. The legal maneuvers to overturn his conviction, while fraught with challenges, underscore the systemic issues within the justice system, making for a thought-provoking viewing experience.
Shadyac's direction, combined with Hodge's vivid portrayal of Brian's turmoil and Kinnear's supportive role as Brooks, elevates "Brian Banks" from standard biographical drama to an emotionally charged narrative of redemption and justice. The film's power lies in its straightforward yet compelling depiction of one man's fight for truth, highlighting the high stakes and monumental challenges faced by those wrongfully convicted. It's a story not just of personal triumph but also a critique of the judicial system's rigidity against exonerating the innocent.
Total: 62
Brian Banks is a film that effectively portrays an emotionally compelling story anchored by standout performances, notably from Aldis Hodge in the titular role. Hodge's sincere and multidimensional portrayal of Brian Banks adds immense credibility to the narrative, transforming what could have been a standard melodrama into a deeply engaging drama. Complementing Hodge, Sherri Shepherd delivers a heartfelt performance as Banks' mother, an embodiment of the emotional core that guides the audience through the protagonist's tumultuous journey. The screenplay is tight and focused, adeptly balancing accessibility in its legal intricacies with a straightforward, yet impactful storytelling approach.
Universal's Blu-ray presentation of Brian Banks is notable for its visual quality, which is consistently clear and sharp, effectively capturing the film's emotional tones and subtleties. However, the audio execution does leave something to be desired, with some reviewers noting a low-volume soundtrack that may detract slightly from the immersive experience. Additionally, while the Blu-ray release maintains a high standard in video quality, it disappointingly falls short in terms of special features, offering minimal supplementary content that could have enhanced the viewer's understanding and appreciation of the film.
In conclusion, Brian Banks succeeds on the back of a concise script and a few strong performances. Perhaps underused is Sherri Shepherd as Brian's mother, who is a surrogate for the audience, the outlet for the core raw emotions that define the story. The film is fortunate to have Aldis Hodge in the lead, who brings a sincerity and definable depth to the part; he's believable as a good man whose life has been changed by circumstance but who finds the same ferocious fight in his own defense as he showed on the football field. While the movie lacks dramatic ingenuity, the straightforward tale is well versed in its characters and makes the legalities accessible. The end result is predictable, but it's still a story worthy of one's movie-watching time. Universal's Blu-ray is unfortunately hindered by a low volume soundtrack and a dearth of extras, but the video quality is by and large fine. Worth a look.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Blacks often appear flat and washed out, but colors are largely acceptable, whether crisp white dress shirts, green grasses on city football fields, or various examples of attire seen throughout the film,...
Audio: 70
Listeners will note light surround integration but the track is predominantly a product of the front channels....
Extras: 10
The Story Behind 'Brian Banks' (1080p, 1:42) recaps the story via interviews and clips from the film....
Movie: 70
The system makes it nearly impossible for a ruling to be overturned, and with time running out before Brian will have to report as a sex offender for the rest of his life, there's little hope for saving...
Total: 60
Perhaps underused is Sherri Shepherd as Brian's mother, who is a surrogate for the audience, the outlet for the core raw emotions that define the story....
Home Theater Forum review by Todd ErwinRead review here
Video: 100
The prison scenes are darkly lit but use light as a form of inspiration to Banks, and is an excellent example of how well contrast is handled on this release....
Audio: 90
Surrounds are used to extend John Debney’s score as well as atmospherics, plus some nice discrete effects where needed, such as people walking in the stairwell above or crowd noise during a football game....
Extras: 20
The Story Behind “Brian Banks” (1080p; 1:42): This is a very brief Behind the Scenes-style trailer and nothing more that really does not have a great deal of content....
Movie: 70
After agreeing to the pleading “no contest” to the judge, Brian is sentenced to six years in prison, followed by five years of probation, and must register as a sex offender for the rest of his life....
Total: 80
Brian Banks could have been nothing more than a standard TV-Movie melodrama, but it is the performances of its two stars that help it rise above the material....
Director: Tom Shadyac
Actors: Aldis Hodge, Greg Kinnear, Sherri Shepherd
PlotBrian is a promising high school football player with dreams of playing in the NFL. His life takes a dramatic turn when he is falsely accused of a crime he didn't commit, leading to his wrongful conviction and imprisonment. Faced with a shattered future and the loss of his freedom, he navigates the brutal reality of incarceration. Amidst this turmoil, Brian finds solace and determination, driven by a fervent desire to clear his name and reclaim his life.
After spending years behind bars, Brian is released on parole, but his criminal record continues to overshadow his attempts at rebuilding his life. Struggling to find work and resume his football career, he seeks help from the California Innocence Project. With the support of the organization and his relentless pursuit of justice, Brian embarks on an arduous journey to prove his innocence. The compelling narrative highlights the resilience of the human spirit and the fight for redemption while shedding light on the flaws in the justice system.
Writers: Doug Atchison
Release Date: 09 Aug 2019
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English