Seven Years in Tibet Blu-ray Review
Score: 50
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Both view 'Seven Years in Tibet' highly for its story & visuals, with top recommendations for its upgrade in quality.
Disc Release Date
Video: 68
Sony's Blu-ray release of 'Seven Years in Tibet' impresses with vivid, detailed visuals, though some inconsistencies and a modest upgrade from the Superbit DVD are noted.
Audio: 53
Seven Years in Tibet's Blu-ray PCM track impresses with balance and dynamics but is critiqued for underwhelming, less effective sound design and issues in soundfield accuracy, despite John Williams' outstanding score.
Extra: 0
Disappointment abounds with the Blu-ray release of 'Seven Years in Tibet' by Sony, mirroring past editions by offering no extras - not even a trailer. A missed opportunity for added value.
Movie: 76
'Seven Years in Tibet' showcases Brad Pitt in a transformative role, capturing the heart of a historical conflict with a mix of cinematic grace and political tension, amidst controversy and mixed critiques.
Video: 68
Sony's AVC-encoded Blu-ray presentation of "Seven Years in Tibet" is a visual treat that demonstrates the significant capabilities of high-definition media to enhance cinematic landscapes. The video quality is exceptionally lucid, benefitting from solid black levels and an outstanding balance of colors that bring the Himalayan scenery to life with an almost tactile vibrancy. Notably, the transfer maintains a faithful rendition of the film's natural hues, from the stark whites of snow-capped mountains to the myriad tones of the rugged terrain. This clarity extends to the fine details as well, with close-ups revealing the minutiae of skin textures and fabric weaves, alongside the expansive long shots that showcase mountain vistas with compelling depth and filmic authenticity. A light grain texture ensures that the movie retains its original, theatrical quality, enhancing rather than detracting from the viewing experience.
However, the presentation is not devoid of flaws. Some scenes exhibit a variability in sharpness, particularly in background elements where inconsistency occasionally mars the overall crispness. This slight inconsistency, along with a marginal dullness in exterior color vibrancy compared to interior shots, and variation in shadow density in darker scenes, indicates a small step down from absolute perfection. Moreover, while this Blu-ray edition surpasses its DVD predecessors, including the highly-regarded Superbit release, the upgrade is not as monumental as one might expect for owners of the Superbit DVD. The improvements are noticeable and appreciated, yet they might not justify an upgrade for those already satisfied with their Superbit edition. Despite these minor criticisms, Sony’s presentation remains an impressive achievement in home cinema, offering a visually rich and meticulously detailed viewing experience that admirably showcases the breathtaking beauty and drama of "Seven Years in Tibet".
Audio: 53
The audio presentation of "Seven Years in Tibet" on Blu-Ray showcases an intriguing blend of quality and nuance, particularly through its uncompressed PCM 5.1 surround sound track (48 kHz / 16-Bit / 4.6 Mbps), which stands in stark contrast to its standard Dolby Digital 5.1 counterpart (640 kbps). The PCM track embodies a superior auditory experience, delivering distinctly fuller dialogue without compromising the sharpness of each uttered word. Furthermore, environmental sounds, such as breezes through the foliage, are rendered with a delightful realism that the Dolby mix struggles to match. Despite the relatively few moments that exploit the full capabilities of the surround sound setup, those that do offer a rich dynamic range complemented by deep bass tones, thus highlighting the PCM track’s edge in creating a more immersive audio environment.
However, this auditory prowess is somewhat dimmed by an underwhelming sound design that fails to fully seize the high-definition opportunity. Chaotic scenes, expected to be vibrantly cacophonic, are surprisingly subdued, lacking the impactful prioritization of sound that would lend these moments a more compelling presence. Further detracting from the experience is an occasional inconsistency in soundfield accuracy, most notably during sequences of heightened activity such as the Chinese raids. These scenes sometimes suffer from an erratic channel movement, with sounds abruptly shifting in the stereo field without a smooth transition, detracting from an otherwise meticulous mix.
Despite these imperfections, the overall audio experience provided by "Seven Years in Tibet" remains commendable for its balanced and subtle dynamics that enhance both the dialogue and John Williams’ enchanting score. The PCM track in particular stands out for its ability to convey a naturalistic atmosphere and detailed soundscapes, although it's marred by occasional lapses in soundfield precision and a generally conservative approach to utilizing the full spatial potential of the home theater setup. This mix is a testament to the importance of advanced audio formats like uncompressed PCM in elevating the Blu-Ray viewing experience, even if it doesn't always reach its full explosive potential.
Extras:
The Blu-ray edition of "Seven Years in Tibet" maintains the same minimalist approach seen in prior releases, offering viewers an untouched, extras-free experience that harks back to previous DVD and Superbit versions. Despite the high-definition upgrade that the main feature undoubtedly benefits from, Sony's consistent omission of additional content – not even a basic trailer or behind-the-scenes documentary to enrich the viewing experience – is a missed opportunity to add value for cinephiles and fans of the film alike. This release could have been a chance to delve deeper into the movie's production, its historical context, or the stunning locations used, but instead, it remains a purely cinematic offering with no supplementary materials to speak of.
Extras included in this disc:
- NONE: No additional content provided.
Movie: 76
'Seven Years in Tibet,' a cinematic journey led by Brad Pitt as Heinrich Harrer, is a profound narrative that, despite its historical liberties and Brad Pitt's much-criticized Austrian accent, stands as an awe-inspiring portrayal of emotional evolution set against the backdrop of Tibet's breathtaking landscapes and its political turmoil. Released in 1997 and directed by Jean-Jacques Annaud, this film navigates through the intertwining paths of personal redemption and cultural immersion, encapsulating the essence of an overlooked gem within Hollywood's archives. Harrer's transformation, from a self-centered mountaineer to a compassionate tutor of the young Dalai Lama, unfolds within the vast expanse of the Himalayas, with Pitt delivering a performance that, despite initial skepticism towards his accent, reveals a depth of character compelling enough to anchor the film's emotional and ethical quandaries.
Technically, 'Seven Years in Tibet' is a marvel of cinematography and daring filmmaking. The filmmakers' commitment to authenticity led them to secretive shoots in Lhasa, affording audiences a rare glimpse into the city amidst China's contentious governance over Tibet. These visuals, reminiscent of David Lean's epics, juxtapose humanity against nature's grandeur, highlighting the film's underlying themes of insignificance and introspection. Moreover, the inclusion of actual historical tensions surrounding Tibet's struggle with Chinese invasion enriches the narrative, offering viewers not only a story of personal growth but also a lens into the complex political landscape that continues to define the region.
The relationships depicted, notably between Harrer and the Dalai Lama, are crafted with nuance and sensitivity, transcending mere political commentary to explore deeper, universal themes of friendship, enlightenment, and cultural exchange. While some critics have pointed out historical inaccuracies and the film's condensed timeline as detriments, these elements do little to detract from the overarching narrative that makes 'Seven Years in Tibet' such a compelling watch. The performances, especially by the young actors portraying the Dalai Lama at different ages alongside David Thewlis as Peter Aufschnaiter, add layers of authenticity and emotional resonance. Ultimately, this film does more than recount an extraordinary tale; it serves as a poignant educational tool and a visual spectacle, inviting reflection on the enduring impact of cultural connections forged in the face of adversity.
Total: 50
"Seven Years in Tibet" on Blu-ray offers an immersive experience that combines an absorbing tale with superior technical presentation. This adaptation of Heinrich Harrer's remarkable journey through Tibet and his relationship with the young Dalai Lama is brought to life with compelling visuals and a keen eye for detail. The video quality is standout, offering a significant upgrade over previous DVD releases, including the Superbit DVD with its already noteworthy transfer. The 1080p visual presentation shines, capturing the breathtaking landscapes of Tibet and the intricate details of the period accurately, making it a visual feast for the viewer.
However, while the film itself portrays a unique and fascinating story filled with rich character studies, the Blu-ray edition presents some drawbacks in terms of audio and additional content. The audio quality is described as acceptable, lacking the impact one might hope for in such a visually stunning film. Similarly, the absence of special features may leave some viewers wanting more insight into the film's production and the historical context of Harrer's story. Despite these limitations, the audiovisual experience remains top-notch, ensuring that the film's portrayal of this extraordinary adventure is both beautiful and involving.
In conclusion, "Seven Years in Tibet" on Blu-ray is highly recommended for its exceptional video quality and engaging storytelling. Although it falls short in audio dynamism and extra material, the Blu-ray edition represents the definitive visual experience for this cinematic journey. Fans of historical epics and visually driven narratives will find immense value in this release, affirming its status as a must-have for collectors and cinephiles alike who seek to immerse themselves in the vividly rendered landscapes and deeper understanding of this significant period in history.
Blu-ray.com review by Ben WilliamsRead review here
Video: 100
There is some light, intended grain in Seven Years in Tibet that adds to the theatrical aspect of this presentation....
Audio: 90
While not a show-stopping or action-packed track, the 5.1 uncompressed PCM track on Seven Years in Tibet still amazes with its perfect balance and subtle dynamics....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 80
Once in Tibet, Harrer finds himself tutoring the young Dalai Lama and coming to terms with his own troubled mentality....
Total: 90
I found the background on the Dalai Lama to be extremely interesting and entertaining and Harrer, himself, is quite a character study....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Finally, there are a handful of darker scenes where shadowy corners aren't as black as others (most likely a problem with the print since this flaw is found on the DVD as well)....
Audio: 60
To be fair, the center channel is usually being used for something important in these instances, but accomplished sound designers normally tuck panned effects beneath the dialogue....
Extras: 0
Like the previous DVD and Superbit releases of 'Seven Years in Tibet,' this Blu-ray edition doesn't offer any supplements....
Movie: 80
Years disappear in a matter of moments in order to provide room for the relationship between Heinrich and the Dalai Lama -- I personally would've preferred a three hour film that spent more time with Heinrich...
Total: 60
While the audio package on this Blu-ray edition is merely acceptable and there isn't a special feature to be found, thankfully the video quality is very good and provides an impressive visual upgrade to...
Director: Jean-Jacques Annaud
Actors: Brad Pitt, David Thewlis, BD Wong
PlotIn the late 1930s, an Austrian mountaineer and skilled skier embarks on an expedition to conquer one of the highest peaks in the Himalayas. However, his journey takes an unexpected turn when World War II breaks out, leading to his capture by British forces in India. After a daring escape, he traverses the treacherous landscapes of the Himalayas alone, enduring harsh conditions and reflecting on his life’s choices and the arrogance that led him to this point.
Making his way into the forbidden city of Lhasa, Tibet, the protagonist undergoes a profound transformation influenced by the serene beauty of the land and its people. He befriends the young Dalai Lama, becoming his tutor in Western science and geography. Through this unique friendship, he learns the value of patience, humility, and compassion, challenging his previously held beliefs and ambitions. The peaceful and spiritual way of life in Tibet offers him a stark contrast to his prior existence, guiding him on a path towards inner growth and enlightenment.
Writers: Heinrich Harrer, Becky Johnston
Release Date: 10 Oct 1997
Runtime: 136 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, United Kingdom
Language: English, German, Mandarin, Tibetan, Hindi