Barrymore Blu-ray Review
Score: 65
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
A meticulously crafted and vividly performed translation of Barrymore's theatrical brilliance to the screen, highlighted by Christopher Plummer's captivating portrayal.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
Barrymore's 1080p, AVC-encoded Blu-ray presentation offers stunning clarity, well-pitched contrast, and remarkable shadow detail, capturing Christopher Plummer's performance with deep blacks and rich, soft colors free of noise or artifacts. Close-ups showcase fantastic levels of fine detail.
Audio: 68
Barrymore's DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack impressively utilizes stereo separation to enhance the off-stage voice and stage dynamics, delivering clear, well-modulated audio that captures Plummer's vocal nuances. Limited surround activity and subtle score integration maintain a live theater atmosphere.
Extra: 40
A thoughtful and extensive 59-minute documentary, 'Backstage with Barrymore', offers an in-depth exploration of the play and film's history, Christopher Plummer's artistic biography, and behind-the-scenes insights, featuring interviews with key creatives and notable actresses, despite minor video flaws.
Movie: 72
Christopher Plummer's portrayal of John Barrymore in this Blu-ray release is masterful and poignant, although the film's visual presentation can drag and may feel less captivating than a live performance. Canuel's direction adds compelling cinematic flourishes but leaves room for more imaginative moments, making this a mixed yet worthwhile homage.
Video: 73
The Blu-ray video presentation of “Barrymore” excels in delivering a first-rate 1080p, AVC-encoded transfer that captures every nuance of Christopher Plummer's outstanding performance. Shot in high-definition by cinematographer Bernard Couture, the image boasts deep and solid black levels, with precisely delineated shadow details. This meticulous rendering ensures that viewers can appreciate the artful use of shadows crucial to the narrative. Additionally, the video maintains an impressive clarity in both long shots and close-ups, allowing intricate details, such as costumes and stage props, to stand out with remarkable precision.
The color palette is soft yet rich, maintaining a vibrant and true hue throughout, even though "Barrymore" is not particularly colorful. Black-and-white sequences, achieved in post-production, have an antiquated texture suitable for the theatrical experience. The crisp image remains free from any specks or scratches, and no noise disrupts the seamless presentation. Background elements are clearly discernible, and shadow delineation is maintained aptly due to expert lighting design. Furthermore, close-ups reveal exceptional levels of detail, highlighting every crease and wrinkle on Plummer’s face with striking definition.
Notably, digital enhancements such as noise reduction or edge sharpening are absent, allowing the natural quality of the high-definition footage to shine. This careful approach avoids common digital artifacts like banding or compression issues. Viewers experience a front-row vantage point, fully immersing them in the theatrical environment and enhancing the immediacy and impact of Plummer’s portrayal. Overall, this Blu-ray transfer is a flawless example of how high-definition video can elevate the viewing experience of a theatrical production.
Audio: 68
The audio presentation of "Barrymore" on Blu-ray, provided in lossless DTS-HD MA 5.1, showcases a surprisingly dynamic soundstage for a predominantly dialogue-driven film. The stereo separation is meticulously handled, with Frank’s lines distinctly issuing from either the left or right, depending on the scene perspective, while Barrymore's voice remains centered. Notably, the live audience sounds and the occasional massive house lights switching on and off create impressive environmental effects. The audio track’s range is further tested by Christopher Plummer’s wide vocal execution, spanning gentle murmurs to powerful outbursts, reflecting his character’s emotional depth.
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track maintains clarity and modulation comprehensively, ensuring every syllable from Plummer is clear, from subtle throwaway lines to impassioned orations. Off-stage voices and applause are well-placed within the surround channels, enhancing the theatrical ambiance. Although the subwoofer remains mostly silent, it effectively punctuates the abrupt switching off of stage lights. The discreet score by Michel Corriveau subtly interweaves with the dialogue, rarely intruding but supporting the narrative quietly in the background.
In summary, while not designed to compete with more action-oriented soundtracks, "Barrymore’s" audio presentation excels in delivering precision and clarity. The nuanced production enhances the intimate nature of this theatrical performance and ensures the audio quality remains consistent throughout, catering well to its material.
Extras: 40
The Blu-ray extras for "Barrymore" are notable for their substance and depth, particularly through the documentary "Backstage with Barrymore". This nearly hour-long feature offers a comprehensive examination of both the production history of the play and film "Barrymore" and an artistic biography of Christopher Plummer. Featuring interviews with Plummer, director Erik Canuel, stage director Gene Saks, playwright William Luce, and renowned actresses Helen Mirren, Julie Andrews, and Zoe Caldwell, the documentary delves into Plummer's process in taking on and reviving the role for film. It explores the technical challenges of adapting the play for the screen, as well as providing an insightful look at rehearsals and backstage dynamics. Notably, a technical flaw originating from a camera issue appears during the last 15 minutes but should not be mistaken for a malfunction in viewers' devices.
Extras included in this disc:
- Backstage with Barrymore: Insightful documentary about the play's history, Christopher Plummer's role, and behind-the-scenes footage.
Movie: 72
"Barrymore" on Blu-ray presents a captivating examination of John Barrymore’s turbulent life and career, brought to life by Christopher Plummer’s exceptional performance. Plummer, who has been professionally and personally fascinated with Barrymore for decades, reprises his acclaimed Broadway role in this film adaptation. Director Erik Canuel artfully blends theatrical and cinematic elements, occasionally utilizing sepia tones and flashbacks to immerse viewers in Barrymore’s memories and inner world. Despite these touches, some critics feel more visual dynamics could have enhanced the engagement, asserting that the film sometimes feels confined to the stage.
The play, set in an empty theater where Barrymore attempts to rehearse Shakespeare’s Richard III, is interwoven with reminiscences, regrets, and self-doubt. Plummer’s portrayal is both powerful and poignant, reflecting his own vulnerability with age while maintaining Barrymore’s complex mix of charm and despair. The offstage presence of Frank, whom we see only in the shadows, adds a subtle layer of interaction and tension. Plummer's on-screen command effortlessly blurs the lines between actor and historical figure, despite debates about whether his performance perfectly encapsulates Barrymore himself.
While the film provides a compelling glimpse into Barrymore’s fractured psyche and tarnished legacy, it occasionally lacks depth in biographical details. Some viewers might find the play's structure fragmented, paralleling the scattered thoughts of an actor in decline. Plummer’s advanced age compared to Barrymore’s might pose a believability challenge, but his prowess and the film’s lyrical moments ultimately transcend these concerns. For those interested in a beautifully acted narrative with touches of cinematic flair, "Barrymore" is a noteworthy piece, though it may not fully satisfy those seeking an exhaustive exploration of John Barrymore’s storied life.
Total: 65
The Blu-ray release of "Barrymore" stands out as a meticulous cinematic adaptation of a singular theatrical performance, displaying rare dedication to preserving its dramatic impact. The production transcends the usual conventions of recording live stage performances by thoughtfully redesigning makeup, sets, and costumes, ensuring the drama's translation to screen retains its emotive power. Christopher Plummer's embodiment of John Barrymore is nothing short of captivating, offering a multifaceted portrayal that balances ego, devilish charm, optimism, and despair. This careful adaptation becomes even more critical given the improbability of another actor reprising this role with Plummer's unique combination of experience and charisma.
Technically, "Barrymore" boasts strong video and audio transfers that bring the theatrical setting to life with vivid clarity and immersive sound. While some viewers may desire more in-depth exploration of Barrymore’s biography, the film's focused narrative allows Plummer’s virtuoso performance to take center stage, making it a must-watch for those keen on witnessing great acting. The included documentary, "Backstage With Barrymore," although not visually groundbreaking, offers an intimate look at Plummer's process, adding value to the disc.
In conclusion, "Barrymore" is a highly recommended Blu-ray that skillfully captures an exceptional theatrical performance for posterity. While it may not encompass every aspect of Barrymore’s history, it delivers a compelling showcase of Christopher Plummer's talents, making it essential viewing for theatre enthusiasts and admirers of masterful acting alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
When the image occasionally fades to black-and-white, the effect has been achieved in post-production); the shades of grey don't have quite the depth of old-fashioned Hollywood cinema, but the contrast...
Audio: 80
The live audience that Barrymore imagines in the theater when he first enters laughs gently at his opening jokes (and, of course, there really was an audience there for this portion), and later the massive...
Extras: 60
The first is the history of the play and film Barrymore, from its initial Broadway production through its Toronto revival and filming....
Movie: 80
Watching Plummer rant, joke and stagger around the stage, stopping occasionally to assemble his faculties and deliver a passage of Shakespeare with the full authority that so enchanted audiences back in...
Total: 80
The usual method of setting up multiple cameras to record a live performance is better than nothing, but seldom does one experience such care in redesigning the makeup, sets, costumes and even the performances...
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 90
The score, of which there is very little, creeps in and out of the proceedings without ever stepping on them....
Extras: 50
Movie: 85
It’s just a shame that when the play is moved over into a new medium, it isn’t as exciting as one would hope....
Total: 80
It may not be all that visually interesting, but it’s an admirable attempt to capture a virtuoso performance on film....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Every crease and wrinkle on Plummer's weathered face and every fiber of his mustache and eyebrows are strikingly defined, lending further immediacy and impact to the portrayal....
Audio: 80
Because this is largely a one-man theatrical performance, surround activity is quite limited, but some stereo separation up front allows the off-stage voice of the stage manager the proper directional...
Extras: 20
The technical aspects of shooting are also addressed, director Erik Canuel talks about his interpretation of the piece and relationship with Plummer, and plenty of rehearsal and backstage footage provides...
Movie: 60
Set on a sparsely dressed stage, the premise is a mock audition, and with only the disembodied voice of a stage manager to work off of, Barrymore, the self-anointed "clown prince" of theater's royal family,...
Total: 60
If you know a lot about Barrymore, you might be disappointed by the lack of specifics concerning his life and career, but if you're more interested in simply seeing a great performer tackle a colorful...
Director: Erik Canuel
Actors: Christopher Plummer, John Plumpis
PlotSet in 1942, the story revolves around the iconic performer John Barrymore, who is rehearsing for a potential revival of his Broadway triumph, "Richard III." Within the confines of a grand theater, now empty and echoing with memories, Barrymore grapples with his fading career and turbulent personal life. As he practices his lines, he reminisces about his illustrious past and the challenges that come with aging and obscurity. Accompanied by a prompter, Frank, who tries to keep him focused, Barrymore's struggle between his former glory and his current reality intensifies.
Through his soliloquies and candid reflections, Barrymore reveals the depths of his despair, humor, and enduring passion for the stage. The rehearsal becomes a metaphor for his life, where every forgotten line and missed cue brings forth a torrent of emotions and memories. The intimate setting underscores the deeply personal nature of Barrymore's journey, as he confronts the ghosts of his past while clinging to the remnants of his artistry. Juxtaposed against his fading vigor, his indomitable spirit and charisma shine through, offering a poignant reflection on fame, loss, and the relentless passage of time.
Writers: Erik Canuel, William Luce
Release Date: 25 Aug 2012
Runtime: 83 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Canada
Language: English