Eight Below Blu-ray Review
Score: 51
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Eight Below offers a heartwarming, family-friendly adventure with stunning visuals and decent sound, but its high price and lack of extras make it best as a rental.
Disc Release Date
Video: 57
Eight Below's Blu-ray presentation, framed at 2.40:1 and delivered in 1080p/MPEG-4, offers an above-average, film-like transfer with vibrant colors and excellent detailing, especially on snow textures and winter clothing. However, occasional wavering colors and softness in mid to long shots prevent it from being exceptional.
Audio: 57
Disney's uncompressed PCM 5.1 track for 'Eight Below' provides strong, immersive sound with crisp dialogue, dynamic range, and pronounced environmental effects, despite not being a 24-bit mix. The cold winds, shifting ice, and Mark Isham's score are particularly well-highlighted, enhancing the overall viewer experience.
Extra: 21
Eight Below on Blu-ray disappoints with minimal extras, featuring mainly an informative yet occasionally overly technical commentary by the director, cinematographer, and actor Paul Walker, complemented by a short film and demo scenes; notably missing are the rich supplements of the DVD version.
Movie: 66
"Eight Below," a Disney live-action film, defies typical animal movie cliches through its technically proficient direction and emotionally compelling storytelling. Notable for its beautiful yet dangerous depiction of the Antarctic, the film intertwines the gripping survival story of sled dogs with their trainer's relentless quest, creating a family-friendly adventure that remains genuine and uplifting amidst trials.
Video: 57
Eight Below's Blu-ray presentation offers a commendable 1080p video transfer framed at 2.40:1. Despite being an early Disney release, it delivers a solid image that is rich in detail and maintains a film-like texture. The Antarctic landscape, composed predominantly of white and gray tones, is brought to life with sporadically vibrant colors, particularly noticeable in the brightly-colored jackets against the snow-covered terrain. The transfer excels in visual realism, with texturing on snow-covered landscapes appearing exceptional. Only during specific scenes, such as the blizzard in chapter five, does the snow appear more uniform and undefined, which is expected given the conditions.
The cinematography by Don Burgess benefits greatly from this transfer. Close-up shots are remarkably sharp, showcasing intricate details in winter clothing and human faces—from Paul Walker’s facial hair to Bruce Greenwood’s wrinkles. However, some inconsistencies do emerge, with medium and long shots occasionally lacking the same depth and sharpness. While the contrast is excellent and whites do not bloom, there are moments where colors waver slightly on solid backgrounds like skies and sunsets. Shadow detail and black levels are consistently strong throughout, maintaining a natural skin tone influenced by the film's frigid environment. The source material is generally free from major blemishes or excessive grain, with only minimal speckles and a light grain coating visible.
In summary, "Eight Below" on Blu-ray offers an engaging visual experience that highlights the beauty of its harsh, icy landscapes with clarity and vividness. While some minor inconsistencies in sharpness and color stability exist, the overall transfer is excellent, making it a worthy addition to high-definition collections.
Audio: 57
The audio presentation of "Eight Below" on Blu-ray is delivered through a high-quality PCM 5.1 uncompressed soundtrack that stands out for its active and lively sound design. Despite lacking a full 24-bit mix, the 48 kHz/16-bit track offers a robust dynamic range with noticeably expanded mid-range and cleaner highs compared to the standard DVD release. The soundtrack effectively uses the entire soundstage, providing a crisp and full presence to Mark Isham's score and various atmospheric effects. The music, whether subtle or action-oriented, is presented with remarkable clarity that enhances the overall viewing experience.
Atmospheric effects, particularly wintery ambiance such as cold winds and cracking ice, are expertly incorporated, filling the soundstage and adding a palpable chill to the listening area. These effects are especially pronounced in scenes requiring environmental immersion, bringing additional depth to the audio experience with potent bass elements that punctuate moments of tension. Dialogue reproduction is consistently clear and natural throughout, even during busier outdoor scenes, ensuring that viewer engagement is maintained without distraction. Although this track may not be the most aggressive or a demo-quality example, it perfectly complements the film, providing a well-realized and immersive audio experience aptly suited to "Eight Below."
Extras: 21
The Blu-ray release of "Eight Below" offers a sparse selection of extras. The standout feature is the audio commentary with Director Frank Marshall, Cinematographer Don Burgess, and Actor Paul Walker. This commentary delivers informative content, with discussions on the intricacies of filming in cold climates, the efforts involving animal actors, and insights on Mark Isham's score. The participants share a good dynamic, making it an engaging listen. However, fans might be disappointed with the limited extras and the absence of background on the true story that inspired the film. Additional video features like "Blu-Scape - Ice" by Louie Schwartzberg and "Movie Showcase" serve as brief visual treats but do not substantially enhance the supplementary offering.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director, Cinematographer, and Actor discuss the film's production.
- Blu-Scape - Ice: A short film by Louie Schwartzberg.
- Movie Showcase: Selected scenes highlighting Blu-ray quality.
Movie: 66
Disney’s Eight Below stands out as a top-tier family adventure movie that meshes danger, raw emotion, and traditional values in an uplifting tale. The story centers on Jerry Shepard (Paul Walker), a sled dog team leader at the National Science Foundation's Antarctica base. Shepard is tasked with transporting UCLA professor Davis McClaren (Bruce Greenwood) to a remote site to gather a rare rock sample. Despite achieving their mission, the team faces peril on the return journey, with McClaren suffering severe injuries and Shepard battling frostbite. Forced to evacuate, they leave the dogs to survive alone in the harsh Antarctic winter. The film skillfully intertwines the dogs' survival story with Jerry's relentless efforts to rescue them, portraying the unwavering spirit of love and friendship. Though containing mature themes and bits of violence, the movie maintains a family-friendly focus, ensuring audiences of all ages grasp the unbreakable bonds and resilience required in dire situations.
Frank Marshall’s direction brings both visual splendor and dramatic heft to Eight Below. Drawing from his experience with the similarly-themed Alive, Marshall transforms the Antarctic landscape into an awe-inspiring yet treacherous character within the story. Notably, the cinematography by Don Burgess captures the stark, chilling beauty of the frigid environment, enhancing the narrative's suspense and emotional weight. While the human performances are commendable—Walker’s portrayal of a determined yet sensitive lead shines—it's the dogs that steal the show. Their physical and emotional communication is groundbreaking for an animal-centered film, conveying fear, support, and camaraderie without uttering a single word. These animal actors contribute significantly to the film’s thematic richness, reinforcing the narrative of survival and kinship against overwhelming odds.
While Eight Below do have moments where the human narrative feels less compelling than its canine counterpart, the movie overall remains captivating and sincere. The seamless transition between the two parallel stories ensures that the film resonates strongly with its audience. Whether depicting human perseverance or canine bravery, Eight Below expertly demonstrates that love and persistence can triumph even in the direst circumstances.
Total: 51
"Eight Below" is a stirring family adventure that intertwines themes of friendship, bravery, and survival against the harsh backdrop of Antarctica. The storyline celebrates the unbreakable bonds between humans and animals, presenting a cinematic journey that is simultaneously thrilling and heartwarming. The film balances intense moments of danger with touching scenes that highlight the depth of commitment and love driving the characters through their trials. Despite dealing with some themes that might be challenging for younger viewers, the movie's overall warmth, excellent cinematography, and well-developed characters ensure it captivates audiences of all ages.
In terms of technical specifications, Disney's "Eight Below" Blu-ray release delivers a commendable viewing experience. The picture quality showcases the stunning landscapes with remarkable clarity and detail, truly bringing the icy wilderness to life. Additionally, the soundtrack is robust, effectively enhancing the film's emotional and adventurous tones. However, this Blu-ray edition does fall short in the extras department, offering a rather limited selection of bonus features that will likely disappoint those looking for a more comprehensive behind-the-scenes look at the film's production.
Conclusion
"Eight Below" is a heartwarming tale of friendship, courage, and survival, celebrating the essence of love and life's precious bonds. With its breathtaking photography and emotionally resonant story, it is a classic Disney family film suitable for all ages. While the Blu-ray release excels in technical quality, the high price tag and sparse extras suggest it is best enjoyed as a rental or considered for purchase once it becomes more affordable.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
The picture is often saturated in shades of white and gray; however, colors can be vibrant at times, particularly as brightly-colored jackets contrast against the many white snow-covered landscapes and...
Audio: 80
Whether more subtle notes or amped-up action-oriented pieces, such as that heard in chapter 10, the track presents each segment of the score with a clarity that brings the film to life and draws the listener...
Extras: 30
It's easy, informative, but not too heavy, touching on the challenges of making the film, the work of the animals and the difficulties of riding with the sled dogs, shooting in the frigid locales, the...
Movie: 80
Although the movie seems destined for a storybook happy ending, it heads in that direction with an appreciable honesty; there are consequences, fears, and trials that try and threaten to break the spirit...
Total: 60
A family Adventure in the classic Disney spirit, Eight Below is a film suitable for the whole family, even if it does delve into some slightly complex themes that the youngest of viewers may find difficult...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Not that any of the first Disney titles are bad, per se, but 'Eight Below' at least delivers the kind of transfer that reminds you why you invested so much money in a high-def home theater....
Audio: 80
The film's sound design is quite active and lively, so even with a lack of action-movie bombast there is a solid level of envelopment throughout....
Extras: 20
Though Marshall and Burgess sometimes lapse into areas that are too technical, especially when it comes to discussing the rigors of location shooting, there is some good talk about the dogs and their various...
Movie: 60
I also like that Marshall was able to convey such a range of emotion through the dogs' movements and behaviors, as of course they cannot speak....
Total: 60
'Eight Below' is one of those movies you go in expecting to be embarrassed to watch, and come out surprised at how much you enjoyed it....
Director: Frank Marshall
Actors: Paul Walker, Jason Biggs, Bruce Greenwood
PlotIn the harsh landscapes of Antarctica, a scientific expedition led by Jerry Shepard sets out on a mission to find rare meteorites. Accompanied by his trusted team of sled dogs, Jerry navigates the challenges of the freezing wilderness. Unexpectedly, a severe storm rolls in, forcing the team to abandon their efforts and evacuate. In the chaos and urgency, the sled dogs are left behind, tied to a makeshift post. Confronted with the brutal environment and dwindling supplies, the dogs must rely on their instincts and teamwork to survive the relentless cold and isolation until they can be rescued.
As the days turn into weeks, the film shifts focus to the harrowing journey of the abandoned dogs, showcasing their struggle for survival against natural predators and extreme weather conditions. Meanwhile, Jerry wrestles with guilt and determination to return and rescue his loyal companions. The passage of time builds suspense and poignancy, underscoring themes of loyalty, courage, and the enduring bond between humans and animals. With each passing day, the hope for a rescue becomes more tenuous, testing both the resilience of the sled dogs and the persistence of those who care about them deeply.
Writers: David DiGilio, Toshirô Ishidô, Koreyoshi Kurahara
Release Date: 17 Feb 2006
Runtime: 120 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English