The Pearl Button Blu-ray Review
Score: 65
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"The Pearl Button" delivers stunning cinematography and a deeply troubling exploration of human atrocities, combined with Kino Lorber's excellent A/V presentation and revealing bonus content. Recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 67
The 1.78:1 AVC-encoded 1080p transfer for 'The Pearl Button' excels with its crisp, vibrant details in both nature shots and interview footage. Colors are bold, and black levels exhibit strong shadow separation without crush. Minor banding is present but does not detract from the overall stunning image quality.
Audio: 72
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA and Spanish DTS-5.1 surround mixes deliver a remarkably immersive experience for 'The Pearl Button,' blending atmospheric natural scenes with clear, front/center-channel dialogue, enveloping the listener with weather patterns, flowing water, and low-end highlights such as ice shelf rumbling and airplane fly-bys.
Extra: 46
The 14-page booklet offers a thoughtful essay by Eric Hynes analyzing the film's poetic themes, while 'Encounters' (35:05, SD) enriches ecological and political discussions with deleted interviews, and the theatrical trailer (1:46, HD) rounds out the extras, all of which enhance the viewing experience significantly.
Movie: 76
"The Pearl Button" is an ambitious and lyrically beautiful documentary by Patricio Guzmán that intertwines Chile’s natural beauty with its horrific history under Pinochet, though at times it can feel unfocused. The Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber showcases stellar aquatic footage and includes an essay by Eric Hynes.
Video: 67
The AVC encoded image with a 1.78:1 aspect ratio presentation on Blu-ray for "The Pearl Button" captures its HD-shot production crisply and clearly. Detail remains superb across various sequences, including location visits and interview footage, even in sections captured in SD. Particulars of aging and natural textures are highlighted effectively in close-ups, providing a textured appreciation of both subjects and environments. The colors are tastefully managed throughout, supplying appropriate hues that enhance geological and conversational contexts, maintaining accurate delineation with only minor instances of banding.
This Blu-ray release, with its 1.78:1 1080p digital photography presentation, makes the most of its format. The detail is both strong and vibrant, showcased wonderfully in stunning nature shots as well as interview sequences. Facial features appear robust, and the natural textures of the outdoor scenery are strongly defined. Colors are consistently bold, with primary hues particularly effective during nature sequences while maintaining natural flesh tones during interviews. Black levels are impressively managed, offering substantial shadow separation and strong depth without any issues of crush. Minor banding is present but does not detract significantly from the overall visual quality of this impressive transfer.
Audio: 72
The 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix for "The Pearl Button" offers a commendable auditory experience that effectively preserves the film's sense of expansiveness. Nature sequences, featuring both aerial and outer space shots, utilize surround channels to immerse the listener in rich atmospheric details like weather patterns and flowing water. This creates a magnificent sense of space and pulls viewers deeper into the narrative.
The audio track excels particularly in its handling of interview segments and narration, where clarity is paramount. Dialogue is predominantly centered in the front channels, ensuring it remains easily discernible amidst the surrounding soundscape. Low-end frequencies are articulated in key moments, such as the rumbling of ice shelves and the roar of airplane fly-bys, adding depth to the viewing experience without overpowering the more subdued elements of the audio mix.
Though sound effects are used sparingly given the film’s quiet and contemplative nature, they are nonetheless impactful. The representation of environmental sounds significantly enhances viewer immersion, making this DTS-5.1 surround mix far more engaging than typical documentary soundtracks. With its balanced approach to both dialogue and ambient sound, this audio presentation elevates "The Pearl Button" beyond standard documentary auditory experiences.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras for "The Pearl Button" provide a compelling and informative addition to this evocative documentary. The booklet contains an insightful essay by Eric Hynes, offering a deep analysis of the film’s poetic themes and complementing the viewing experience. The Encounters feature is a must-watch, showcasing 35 minutes of deleted and extended interviews with scholars and witnesses, providing rich additional context on the film's ecological and political discussions. The collection of extras is rounded out by the theatrical trailer, which serves as an effective enticement for new viewers and a concise encapsulation of the film’s essence.
Extras included in this disc:
- Booklet: Contains an essay by Eric Hynes with thoughtful analysis.
- Encounters: Deleted interviews with scholars and witnesses, totaling 35 minutes.
- Theatrical Trailer: A 1 minute 46 second promotional piece.
Movie: 76
"The Pearl Button," directed by Patricio Guzmán, is a compelling exploration of Chile's deeply intertwined relationship with water. Renowned for his examination of Chile's history and complexities, Guzmán extends his focus to the nation's vast aquatic landscapes, weaving a richly thematic tapestry that spans from indigenous displacement by missionaries and settlers to the atrocities committed during Pinochet's brutal dictatorship. Guzmán combines breathtaking footage of the Chilean coastline with poignant interviews, creating an immersive experience that traverses history, geography, and politics.
The film's inherent beauty lies in its visual poetry, capturing the mesmerizing allure of Chile's environment juxtaposed with harrowing accounts of political oppression. Through vivid nature photography, viewers witness the stunning landscapes of islands and inlets rising from the water, contrasted starkly with the chilling revelation that these same waters hide the remains of countless political dissidents executed under Pinochet's regime. This duality imbues "The Pearl Button" with a profound emotional impact, emphasizing the brutal reality that beauty often coexists with horror.
However, while Guzmán's narrative ambition and passion are palpable, the film's focus sometimes wavers. His storytelling approach can be likened to that of Terrence Malick, where the method of storytelling occasionally overshadows the message. Nonetheless, despite moments of perceived artistic excess, "The Pearl Button" remains an engrossing piece. It does not shy away from tough historical material but presents it contextually rather than dogmatically. The integration of Jemmy Button's tragic 19th-century story adds a vital historical perspective, enriching Guzmán's narrative with depth and poignancy. Overall, "The Pearl Button" succeeds in educating its audience through a balanced mix of beauty and distress, providing a deeply reflective documentary experience.
Total: 65
Kino Lorber’s Blu-ray release of 'The Pearl Button' delivers a striking and contemplative documentary that juxtaposes the serene beauty of nature with the brutalities of human history. The film's exploration of Chile's complex past, especially focusing on the atrocities under Pinochet's regime, is both fascinating and deeply troubling. The haunting narrative examines how the dictator executed countless individuals by weighing their bodies down with railroad tracks and drowning them in the ocean, creating a poignant connection between life, death, land, and water.
The audiovisual presentation on this Blu-ray is commendable, showcasing impressive cinematography that captures the awe-inspiring Chilean landscape while resonating with emotional and cultural depth. The imagery does an excellent job of highlighting the palpable contrasts within the narrative, making the viewer both ponder the past and reflect on future implications. Additionally, the Blu-ray extras include compelling deleted scenes that serve to deepen one's understanding of the film’s themes and context.
'The Pearl Button' may struggle to find a seamless balance between its narrative threads, but its individual components are undeniably compelling. The documentary beautifully intertwines natural beauty with human history, providing an engaged audience with a fully formed cultural viewpoint. This release is highly recommended for those interested in both the aesthetic appeal and the profound historical insights it offers.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
Weaving through location visits and interview footage (some captured in SD), detail is superb, delivering the particulars of aging during close-ups, providing a textured appreciation for the subjects and...
Audio: 90
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix is generally quite good about preserving expanse, finding visits to nature and space pushing out into the surrounds, enveloping the listener with atmospheric details, including...
Extras: 60
"Encounters" (35:05, SD) is a companion piece to "The Pearl Button," collecting deleted interviews with scholars and witnesses, filling out ecological and political discussions....
Movie: 80
Guzman arrives prepared, armed with stellar footage of Chile's aquatic resources and surroundings, and interviewees share powerful memories of Pinochet's cruelty and the very transformation of the country,...
Total: 80
"The Pearl Button" doesn't ever find true balance between the stories, but the disparate sides are fascinating on their own, offering an education with emphasis on awe, making a very specific connection...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Black levels are strong with plenty of shadow separation creating a strong sense of depth to the image without any crush issues....
Audio: 80
Sound effects are relatively sparse considering the nature of the film, but are readily audible during the nature shots and can make the viewer feel immersed in the scene....
Extras: 40
This essay by Eric Hynes is a wonderful companion piece to the film and provides a very thoughtful analysis of the film and its poetic themes....
Movie: 80
The Pearl Button' is a film that feels more like a celebration of beauty and ugly, good and evil that one can't live without the other, but the good and beautiful is the side to strive for....
Total: 80
It's a fascinating and challenging documentary that proves to be incredibly informative about the past while being contemplative about what the future can bring....
Director: Patricio Guzmán
Actors: Martín Calderón, Cristina, Patricio Guzmán
PlotIn the distant landscapes of Chile, the ocean's mystique intertwines with the country's turbulent history. Water becomes a central narrative conduit, revealing stories of both indigenous cultures and the vast cosmos. The film begins by tracing the spiritual and practical significance of water to the region’s earliest inhabitants, the Kawésqar people, who navigated their lives on the southern waterways. Their lineage and presence are meticulously explored, reflecting an intimate connection with nature that has been largely disrupted by colonization and progress. This poetic journey is not only visually captivating but also deeply introspective, inviting viewers to contemplate the broader human relationship with the natural world.
As the narrative progresses, it shifts focus to more contemporary historical events, plunging into the dark period of Chile's political past. Memories of Pinochet's dictatorship mark a contrast to the serene natural beauty, with water again serving as a symbolic medium. Testimonies and archival footages recount tales of oppression, disappearance, and resistance. Central themes of memory, loss, and resilience are interwoven through personal narratives and historical accounts. With these dual narratives of indigenous heritage and political turmoil, the movie constructs a thoughtful exploration of identity, heritage, and collective memory in Chilean society.
Writers: Patricio Guzmán
Release Date: 15 Oct 2015
Runtime: 82 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: France, Spain, Chile, Switzerland
Language: Spanish