Eugenie Blu-ray Review
De Sade 70
Score: 61
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Eugenie, an atmospheric film from Jess Franco's prime era, boasts a wonderful Bruno Nicolai soundtrack and a beautiful 4K restoration, though with limited audio quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 62
Eugenie's 1080p Blu-ray presentation, restored in 4K and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, boasts bold colors and strong black levels, though intentional blurring and inconsistent depth do impact clarity. Overall, an impressive transfer with good stability and no significant debris issues.
Audio: 62
The Blu-ray of 'Eugenie' features a faithful DTS-HD MA 2.0 audio track with clear, clean dialogue and balanced levels, although occasional distortion and post-production dubbing are noticeable. The sound is impressively free of background noise, and Bruno Nicolai's well-balanced score enhances the viewing experience.
Extra: 61
Extras of the Blu-ray for 'Eugenie' offer a diverse range of insightful content including a restored 1080p trailer, an extensive poster and still gallery curated by Gregory Chick, in-depth analyses by Stephen Thrower, and a featurette with archival interviews, rounded off with Bruno Nicolai's soundtrack CD and a detailed booklet.
Movie: 56
"Eugenie" on Blu-ray, featuring a beautifully surreal adaptation of de Sade's "Philosophy in the Boudoir," showcases outstanding performances and a trippy Nicolai soundtrack, yet suffers from repetitive storytelling and uneven execution despite its technically solid presentation by Blue Underground.
Video: 62
Blue Underground’s Blu-ray release of Jess Franco's "Eugenie" presents the film with a 2.35:1 aspect ratio and a 4K-restored, MPEG-4 AVC-encoded 1080p transfer. The restoration proves effective, yielding improved balance and clarity in daylight footage, which greatly enhances the viewing experience. However, there are minor denoising corrections that slightly affect depth in certain scenes. Despite these minor drawbacks, the overall image quality remains quite satisfying, with stable and nicely saturated colors. The image stability is consistent, with only occasional specks and no significant debris or frame damage disrupting the presentation. This Region-Free release ensures compatibility regardless of geographic location.
The transfer retains film grain, maintaining strong detail levels and presenting colors that are bold and vivid, featuring prominent reds, deep blues, and earthy greens. Some sequences, particularly dream and more provocative scenes, utilize a heavy red color grading which affects clarity and detail. Black levels maintain depth without issues of crush, and contrast remains well controlled without unintentional softness or blooming. Purposeful use of blurred focus appears frequently, often to navigate around censorship constraints similar to Franco's "Marquis de Sade's Justine." This intentional blurring and occasional lack of focus pulling during camera pans are attributable to the original filming techniques rather than the transfer quality. Overall, the video presentation is nearly flawless, providing an engaging visual experience for viewers.
Audio: 62
The Blu-ray release of "Eugenie" features a singular English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, supplemented with optional yellow English SDH, French, and Spanish subtitles. The audio quality is commendable, showcasing clarity, sharpness, and depth, despite occasional unevenness typical of Jess Franco's works. Impressively, the audio has been meticulously cleaned, eliminating background hiss and previous release imperfections. The music, which holds significant importance in the film, is well-balanced with dynamic intensity, ensuring a sonically engaging experience.
The DTS-HD MA 1.0 mono track is faithful to the original presentation of "Eugenie," effectively handling the heavy post-production dubbing inherent to the film. While it does not offer extensive dynamic range or imaging effects, the dialogue remains clear and clean without any problematic volume inconsistencies. However, there are moments when speech distortion occurs, drawing attention to the post-production dubbing. Despite canned sound effects, these maintain a robust presence, with Bruno Nicolai's playful score consistently well-leveled. Although the audio track aligns closely with the film’s low-budget origins and might not astound audiences, it capably replicates the original auditory experience.
Overall, despite some minor imperfections related to dubbing and distortion, the audio presentation on this Blu-ray release of "Eugenie" delivers a clean and balanced soundscape that honors the film’s original subtleties and highlights its musical elements effectively.
Extras: 61
The Blu Ray extras for "Eugenie" offer a comprehensive and insightful look into the film's production history and its cultural impact. The "Stephen Thrower on Eugenie" interview provides an in-depth analysis of Jess Franco's work, the film's atmosphere, and Maria Rohm’s portrayal, complemented by context on Franco's collaboration with producer Harry Alan Towers. "Perversion Stories" delves into firsthand accounts from key figures like Jess Franco and Christopher Lee, offering a valuable behind-the-scenes perspective. The trailer captures the essence of the original marketing campaign, while the "Poster & Still Gallery" compiles an impressive array of international promotional materials. Additionally, Bruno Nicolai’s evocative soundtrack is available on a separate CD. This wealth of content is rounded out by an 18-page booklet featuring detailed essays and a reversible cover.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: Restored original trailer for Eugenie.
- Poster & Still Gallery: Extensive collection of promotional materials.
- Stephen Thrower on Eugenie: Comprehensive interview with Stephen Thrower.
- Perversion Stories: Archival interviews with director and cast.
- Soundtrack: Bruno Nicolai's soundtrack on CD.
- Booklet: 18-page illustrated booklet.
- Cover: Reversible cover.
Movie: 56
Jess Franco's "Eugenie a.k.a. De Sade 70" (1970) manifests Franco's intent to deliver a serious adaptation of Marquis de Sade's "Philosophy in the Boudoir." While it lacks some of the more controversial elements of Franco’s other works, the film still exudes a polished finish bolstered by stellar performances from its lead actors. The narrative follows young Eugenie (Marie Liljedahl) who is lured into a world of debauchery by Madame Saint Ange (Maria Rohm) and her stepbrother, Mirvel (Jack Taylor). As Eugenie’s innocent curiosity gives way to fear amidst narcotic-fueled seductions, the movie plunges into an atmospheric, surreal experience, only accentuated by unexpected twists featuring Christopher Lee as the ominous Dolmance.
While the atmospheric build-up may not deliver a conventional storyline structure, it constructs a dreamy, evolving backdrop that emphasizes tone over precise narrative development. Lee’s presence, alongside Taylor and Rohm, provides a sophistication often missing from similarly themed films. However, some technical inconsistencies, such as awkward zooms and uneven transitions, reflect Franco's rushed production schedule. Despite these flaws, the elegance of the main cast and Bruno Nicolai’s haunting soundtrack ensure the film maintains an engrossing aesthetic.
The challenge with “Eugenie” lies in its lack of a compelling continuous plot; the narrative becomes repetitive, struggling to maintain audience engagement until Lee’s later appearance. While not an outright failure, it caters primarily to niche audiences familiar with de Sade’s work or Franco’s directorial style. Performances by Rohm and Taylor oscillate between menace and camp, failing to fully achieve either dramatic or bawdy potential. Despite the meticulous set-pieces and beautiful cinematography, "Eugenie" ultimately falls short in delivering a satisfying, cohesive cinematic experience. Nonetheless, it remains a visually striking film supported by noteworthy acting and a powerful closing sequence.
Total: 61
"Eugenie" stands as one of Jess Franco's standout films from his prolific period in the late 1960s and early 1970s. The film's atmosphere, bolstered by an excellent cast and Bruno Nicolai's mesmerizing soundtrack, contributes significantly to its appeal. Blue Underground’s 4K restoration brings much of its visual splendor to the fore - although it doesn't reach the technical heights of "Marquis de Sade's Justine", it still markedly enhances the film's presentation. The image quality is impressive and the overall production retains a certain allure that merits attention.
From a cinematic perspective, "Eugenie" presents itself as both a testament to Franco's directorial style and a reflection of the challenges inherent in adapting Marquis de Sade’s controversial works. The adaptation navigates the constraints of its time quite capably, even if it occasionally stumbles due to censorship and an overly faithful adherence to the source material. The Blu-ray release by Blue Underground is commendable not only for its new 4K transfer but also for the inclusion of a DVD and a CD featuring Nicolai's score, offering an enriched viewing experience.
In conclusion, Eugenie represents a fascinating snapshot of Jess Franco’s oeuvre and the broader European exploitation cinema of its era. While it may not be his most universally acclaimed work, the Blu-ray release undoubtedly does it justice with its meticulous restoration. Whether you are a die-hard Franco enthusiast or newcomer, “Eugenie” offers enough to warrant your interest – though newcomers might consider renting before buying. Overall, this release comes recommended for its atmospheric depth and historical significance.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 70
The end result is still quite pleasing, but it isn't difficult to see where the dynamic range should be much better (you can see the flatness that emerges in screencaptures #3, 12, and 13)....
Audio: 90
Generally speaking, clarity, sharpness and depth are good, but as it is the case with a lot of Jess Franco films some unevenness is occasionally felt....
Extras: 90
Stephen Thrower on Eugenie - in this new video interview, Stephen Thrower, author of Murderous Passions: The Delirious Cinema of Jesus Franco, discusses the placement of Eugenie in Jess Franco's body of...
Movie: 80
There are a few segments where Jess Franco unleashes his imagination in a familiar fashion, but Eugenie does not enter that risky territory that some of the director's more controversial films visit....
Total: 70
I still think that the release is worth picking up, but the truth is that Eugenie could have looked every bit as magnificent as Marquis de Sade's Justine....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
For the dream sequences and some of the more salacious moments, the image color was graded to be completely red....
Audio: 60
If there is an issue to be had with the clarity of this audio track it is that it draws more attention to the moments in the film where more post-production dubbing was added....
Extras: 40
Jess Franco, Harry Alan Towers, and stars Marie Liljedahl and Christopher Lee provide insights into the production, their thoughts on the film and what it was like making a film based on the work of Marques...
Movie: 40
While de Sade is an important literary figure, his works aren't ones that you would normally see adorning a movie house marquee and not expect a certain amount of skepticism towards the film's content...
Total: 60
As an adaptation of Marques de Sade, it's a bit hit or miss - largely due to the censorship of the time in which it was filmed, but also because it stayed a little too close to the original source material....
Director: Jesús Franco
Actors: Maria Rohm, Marie Liljedahl, Jack Taylor
PlotA young woman named Eugenie is swept into a disturbing world when her stepfather, an eccentric writer, invites her to spend the weekend on an isolated island. There, she is introduced to a libertine circle, presided over by a wealthy and enigmatic woman named Madame Saint Ange. Eugenie is both intrigued and confused by the hedonistic lifestyle and strange rituals she witnesses. The group engages in storytelling that blurs the line between fantasy and reality, often dipping into the erotic and the taboo.
As Eugenie becomes more deeply entangled in the group's games, she discovers that her stepfather has ulterior motives for bringing her to the island. The gatherings grow increasingly bizarre, featuring depraved acts disguised as 'ceremonies' and focused around the writings of the Marquis de Sade. She is forced to question everything she knew about desire, freedom, and morality, while her own sense of self is slowly eroded by the seductive yet dangerous atmosphere. Caught in a web of manipulation and seduction, Eugenie must navigate her awakening sexuality and the dark intentions of those around her.
Writers: Harry Alan Towers, Marquis de Sade
Release Date: 01 Mar 1970
Runtime: 87 min
Rating: X
Country: West Germany, Spain, Liechtenstein, United Kingdom
Language: English, Spanish, German