Madame Curie Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 70
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Mervyn LeRoy’s Madame Curie blends accurate science with Hollywood flair, boasting excellent A/V quality on Blu-ray—worth the purchase.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 87
Madame Curie's Blu-ray boasts a stunning 1080p transfer, capturing its nitrate roots with exceptional clarity and texture. The film's 1.37:1 aspect ratio is beautifully rendered, featuring natural film grain, excellent contrast, and impressive shadow detail, making it a standout presentation for fans.
Audio: 82
The DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio mix impresses with its faithful, dynamic range, clear dialogue, and seamless integration of music and effects, maintaining a mono sound that provides modest depth without distractions or sync issues, ensuring an authentic, professional audio presentation.
Extra: 21
The Blu-ray of 'Madame Curie' includes the Oscar-nominated short 'Romance of Radium,' directed by Jacques Tourneur, offering a charming glimpse into the discovery of radioactivity, complemented by a vintage theatrical trailer to provide historical context.
Movie: 71
Madame Curie adeptly balances scientific rigor with human emotion, capturing the perseverance of the Curies through careful narrative and a top-tier Blu-ray presentation, though its Hollywood gloss occasionally detracts from authenticity. The film remains an appealing historical biopic and value buy.
Video: 87
The Blu-ray release of "Madame Curie" presents a stunning visual restoration that captures the film's original nitrate roots with excellence. The 1080p transfer, adhering to the 1.37:1 theatrical aspect ratio and utilizing the AVC codec, showcases a meticulous restoration effort that offers a crisp and clean image. This release delivers on contrast levels, preserving natural film grain that enhances texture, while providing bright whites and deep blacks without any clipping, crush, or posterization issues. Whether depicting lavish locales or less elaborate settings, the transfer maintains stable, film-like quality throughout.
Particularly noteworthy are the grayscale representations, which excel in portraying the deep shadows favored by LeRoy for dramatic effect, especially during scenes of scientific experimentation. The consistent shadow detail and absence of artifacts make for an immersive viewing experience. Although some glamour close-ups sacrifice minor details, the overall presentation is unparalleled compared to previous DVD iterations.
Warner Archive’s careful cleanup and minimal image processing ensure that fans and aficionados of "Madame Curie" will find this release exceptionally pleasing. Divided into 32 chapters, the Blu-ray's pristine visuals provide both faithful reproduction of the film's original aesthetic and a testament to the virtues of high-definition restoration processes.
Audio: 82
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono sound mix of the "Madame Curie" Blu-ray offers an adept balance of faithful presentation and technical precision, catering specifically to purists. The dynamic range is particularly notable during music cues, maintaining a seamless blend with Herbert Stothart’s Oscar-nominated score. Dialogue clarity is exemplary, articulated with exceptional precision, ensuring that no element is overpowering or lost in the mix.
Despite its preservation of the film's original one-channel roots, this audio presentation achieves a modest sense of depth, especially in crowded scenes where overlapping conversations are skillfully placed. Notably absent are distractions like age-related hiss, crackle, pops, or flutter, presenting an exceedingly clean auditory experience. Optional English (SDH) subtitles are likewise well-synchronized and legibly formatted, preserving the integrity of the viewing experience.
This sound mix represents a pinnacle of professional audio competence, offering both purists and first-time viewers a vibrant, unobtrusive listening experience that underscores the film’s rich narrative without overshadowing it. It's a testament to the mastery of audio preservation and presentation, enhancing both dialogue clarity and musical compositions authentically and effectively.
Extras: 21
The Blu-ray release of "Madame Curie" includes a well-curated selection of extras that enrich the viewing experience. These features, largely sourced from previous DVD releases, provide historical context and promotional nostalgia for the main film. Notably, the Pete Smith Specialty Short, "Romance of Radium," directed by Jacques Tourneur, offers viewers an engaging and informative journey through the discovery of radioactivity, highlighting the collaborative efforts of Henri Becquerel and the Curies. This short complements the main feature, providing both educational value and classic cinematic charm. Additionally, the set includes a theatrical trailer, offering a glimpse into how the film was initially marketed. While the packaging is minimalistic, void of any inserts, it retains the original one-sheet poster artwork, presenting a thematic continuity.
Extras included in this disc:
- Romance of Radium: 1937 Oscar-nominated short covering the discovery of radioactivity.
- Theatrical Trailer: Vintage promotional piece accompanying the main feature.
Movie: 71
"Madame Curie," directed by Mervyn LeRoy and starring Greer Garson and Walter Pidgeon, is a quintessential example of classic Hollywood's approach to biopics. Nominated for seven Academy Awards in 1943, the film traces the life of Polish scientist Marie Curie, capturing her partnership with her husband, Pierre, and their groundbreaking discovery of radium. The narrative, based on a novel by Marie's daughter, Ève Curie, remains surprisingly faithful to historical events. It portrays Curie's exhaustive focus on science, though it occasionally succumbs to the glossy dramatization typical of its era, which veils the rigor of Marie's scientific achievements under a sheen of dramatized dialogue.
Both Garson and Pidgeon deliver compelling performances that explore their characters' intellectual camaraderie rather than emotional passion. The screenplay, assisted by James Hilton’s narrations, simplifies complex scientific concepts for clarity and understanding, keeping audiences engaged with the film's academic intricacies. However, it avoids delving into deeper aspects of Marie’s social and political engagements, focusing instead on the Curies' professional achievements and their relationship dynamics. Despite the Hollywood embellishments, the film skillfully balances scientific exploration with human elements, maintaining audience interest without resorting to melodrama.
The film's strength also lies in its visual conception. Cinematographer Joseph Ruttenberg attempts to adapt Garson into her youthful role while later successfully capturing her tenacity during her experimental work. Supporting roles from actors like Henry Travers and Albert Bassermann help portray the collaborative atmosphere around the Curies, although some characters lack depth due to limited screen time. Overall, "Madame Curie" offers a captivating glimpse into the life of one of history's most renowned scientists, enhanced by its classic Hollywood depiction and supported by Warner Archive’s high-quality Blu-ray presentation.
Total: 70
Mervyn LeRoy's "Madame Curie" is a biographical film that delicately balances scientific accuracy with cinematic flair. Released in 1943, it navigates the compelling story of Nobel laureates Pierre and Marie Curie, presented with a stylistic gloss typical of the era's Hollywood treatments. While certain dramatic moments are rendered somewhat melodramatic, the film's fundamental strengths—such as meticulous production design, skilled cinematography, and an evocative musical score—ensure it maintains a captivating narrative. This balanced portrayal invites both audiences drawn to historical narratives and those fascinated by exemplary filmmaking.
The Warner Archive Blu-ray release enhances the film's inherent qualities with a superior audiovisual presentation. The picture quality is pristine, capturing the film's intricate visual aesthetics, while the robust soundtrack underscores critical narrative moments effectively. This Blu-ray release comes with a suite of thoughtful bonus features, offering additional context and insight which will be appreciated by collectors and cinephiles alike. The nominal price point makes it an attractive acquisition for anyone invested in classic cinema or the film's notable cast and crew.
In conclusion, "Madame Curie" not only preserves its historical and cinematic significance but also gains new life through this well-executed Blu-ray release. Despite being overshadowed in its time by contemporaries like "Casablanca," its authentic recounting of an extraordinary scientific journey offers timeless appeal. For enthusiasts of film history or science stories, it remains a worthy addition to any collection, amplified by this meticulously restored version.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
Overall, it's another stable and film-like presentation that's clean as a whistle, thanks to the boutique label's usual round of careful cleanup and minimal image processing....
Audio: 80
The DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio mix is likewise aimed at purists, as it features a strong dynamic range during music cues and very clear dialogue with overly distracting damage but a few stray pops and hisses....
Extras: 20
This Oscar-nominated 1937 short, directed by Jacques Tourneur (yes, that Jacques Tourneur), briefly covers the accidental 1896 discovery of radioactivity in uranium by Henri Becquerrel, which led to the...
Movie: 70
The rest, as they say, is history, though not without cost: Marie's careless handling of the radioactive material led to curious burns on her fingers, which resulted in a real-life serious condition strangely...
Total: 70
It's also partially held back by sugary Hollywood treatment that makes a few of the critical moments, relationships, and dialogue ring hollow, but very strong fundamentals -- production design, cinematography,...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 100
It’s a beautiful job all around with the image clean, crisp, and appealing (save for glamour close-ups which sacrifice some detail) and an excellent grayscale which has impressive blacks particularly in...
Audio: 100
Dialogue has been recorded beautifully and has been mixed with Herbert Stothart’s Oscar-nominated background score and the many sound effects with great surety....
Extras: 30
Romance of Radium (9:43, SD): 1937 Oscar-nominated Pete Smith short, directed by Jacques Tournier Theatrical Trailer (2:09, HD)...
Movie: 80
Director Mervyn LeRoy uses montage skillfully at several junctures: during their picturesque honeymoon (after Curie’s amusing proposal of marriage is fashioned more as a chemical formula) and later as...
Total: 80
Nominated for seven Oscars (but up against that year’s equally popular Casablanca, The Song of Bernadette, and For Whom the Bell Tolls which dominated the ceremony that year), Mervyn LeRoy’s Madame Curie...
Director: Mervyn LeRoy, Albert Lewin
Actors: Greer Garson, Walter Pidgeon, Henry Travers
PlotIn late 19th-century Paris, a driven Polish student arrives at the University of Paris to pursue scientific studies against the backdrop of a predominantly male academic environment. Amidst facing skepticism and challenges, she displays exceptional brilliance and dedication towards her research. During her studies, she meets a reserved but equally passionate scientist. Their shared fascination with physics and chemistry leads to a partnership, both personally and professionally. Motivated by curiosity and scientific ambition, they delve into groundbreaking experiments on radioactivity, a field just beginning to emerge at the time. Their relentless work ethic and determination pave the way for significant discoveries, laying the foundation for a new scientific frontier.
The couple endures numerous hardships, including financial constraints and persistent health issues caused by their work’s inherent dangers. Despite these obstacles, their tenacity and mutual support drive them forward in their quest for knowledge and recognition in the scientific community. The story captures the essence of dedication to understanding the uncharted territories of science, marked by their tireless labor in poorly equipped lab conditions. As they face numerous challenges, including societal skepticism and personal sacrifices, the unfolding narrative showcases the strength of their collaboration and continued pursuit despite the odds. Their journey through innovation and discovery reveals a world resonating with both the brilliance of their minds and the depth of their personal bond, setting the stage for what would become landmark contributions to science.
Writers: Paul Osborn, Hans Rameau, Ève Curie
Release Date: N/A
Runtime: 124 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English