Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
With stellar Ultra HD visuals and impressive Dolby Atmos sound, 'Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas' is an informative yet brief IMAX documentary that dazzles visually but lacks deeper emotional engagement.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 75
Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas on 4K UHD offers breathtaking IMAX-shot visuals with HDR enhancing vibrant colors and deep contrast, despite occasional issues with archival footage and some digital artifacts. Overall, it provides an impressive Ultra HD experience with lifelike textures and spectacular imagery.
Audio: 73
The Dolby Atmos track on the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas" provides a clear and engaging audio experience with solid dialog clarity and effective, but not overpowering, use of ambient sounds and panning effects. Though not top-tier, the mix enhances the documentary's immersive quality, particularly with regards to jet engines and carrier operations.
Extra: 45
Shout! provides a brief yet colorful array of extras on both discs, highlighted by the enthusiastic audience testimonials from IMAX screenings and quirky, albeit poorly animated, speed comparisons involving F-35s, Bugattis, and even Usain Bolt. A mixture of promotional trailers rounds out the set, ensuring a comprehensive package for aviation enthusiasts.
Movie: 67
Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas provides a visually stunning IMAX experience showcasing naval aviation, RIMPAC exercises, and historical insights, despite fragmented delivery and limited human engagement. Its dazzling aerial shots and CGI integrations highlight modern warfare tech aboard the USS Ronald Reagan, making it compelling yet niche.
Video: 75
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas" from Shout! Factory offers an outstanding video presentation, distinguished by its breathtaking IMAX cinematography captured on 15 perf. 70 MM negative. Rendered from a 4K Digital Intermediate (DI), the disc maintains a pristine visual quality, showcasing awe-inspiring detail and accuracy particularly in the 1.78:1 framed sequences. The HDR presentation substantially enhances the color vibrancy and contrast, with deeper blacks and more intense highlights compared to the SDR version. The HDR's impact is particularly noticeable in scenes depicting the ocean and carrier deck, where colors like the vivid uniforms of crewmen and missile trails vividly stand out against the blue and gray backdrops.
While the video quality usually dazzle with its precision in textures on naval vessels and equipment, some drawbacks are noted in the form of banding, posterization, and aliasing, particularly in shots involving skies and some submarine sequences. Although these issues are brief, they detract from the overall experience. Archival footage also varies significantly in quality, occasionally appearing degraded or digitally manipulated. Despite these minor setbacks, the disc nonetheless serves as an excellent IMAX demo, especially in scenes where HDR truly accentuates the natural maritime vistas and complex machinery details.
In summary, though the disc has a few notable visual imperfections such as banding and noisy reduction effects, "Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas" delivers an impressive 4K UHD presentation that makes compelling use of HDR technology. The enhanced contrast and vibrant hues substantially elevate the viewing experience, particularly in IMAX-shot sequences featuring detailed close-ups and sweeping oceanic panoramas. This release exemplifies Shout! Factory's dedication to producing high-quality 4K content despite some occasional lapses in execution.
Audio: 73
The Dolby Atmos audio track featured in the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas" offers a moderately active and primarily atmospheric experience. This is a well-rounded mix that leverages discrete effects judiciously, focusing on the ambient sounds of the ship and aircraft. While not overly aggressive, it effectively employs the capabilities of Atmos to enhance immersion during key sequences, such as aircraft take-offs and CGI deconstruction of the carrier's interior. The subwoofer provides a subtle yet appropriate rumble, particularly noticeable during engine roars and the documentary's score, though it's not as booming as some might expect. Notably, the narration is exceptionally clear and centered, making it easily comprehensible even amid background sounds.
The design ensures that overhead audio objects are utilized for specific, enhancing moments rather than continuously dominating the soundscape. This balance results in a harmonious integration with the visual elements, especially evident during training sequences and scenes depicting hovering aircraft or a submarine's movement. The surround channels support the soaring musical score while handling ambient effects with precision. Both the 4K disc and the Blu-ray come with an English Dolby Atmos track, and while it doesn't reach the heights of reference-quality mixes, it competently enhances the documentary's pivotal moments.
In addition to Atmos, the audio package includes additional tracks: a French 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track on the 4K disc and a French 5.1 Dolby Digital track on the Blu-ray. Subtitles are available in English SDH on both discs. Overall, the audio presentation complements and elevates the viewing experience of "Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas," making it a technically proficient offering suitable for fans and audiophiles alike.
Extras: 45
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas" includes a concise suite of extras that provide supplementary entertainment and insight into the main feature. The "Audience Testimonials" from IMAX screenings highlight enthusiastic viewer reactions but primarily serve as promotional material. The animated segments like "F-35 vs. Bugatti vs. Human Cannonball" and "Usain Bolt vs. Giraffe vs. Nuclear Carrier" offer amusing yet simplistic speed comparisons, albeit with less-than-stellar animation quality. The "F-35 Navy Selects Reel" showcases captivating aerial footage and onboard activities, accompanied by music sans commentary. Rounding out the extras are the official trailer and TV spots, enhancing the overall context for interested viewers.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audience Testimonials: Viewer reactions from IMAX screenings.
- F-35 vs. Bugatti vs. Human Cannonball: Animated speed comparison.
- Usain Bolt vs. Giraffe vs. Nuclear Carrier: Another animated speed comparison.
- F-35 Navy Selects Reel: Montage of F-35 flight sequences with music.
- Aircraft Carrier Trailer: Official trailer for the documentary.
- Aircraft Carrier TV Spots: Set of promotional TV spots.
Movie: 67
Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas, directed by Stephen Low and released by Shout! Factory, delivers a visually stunning experience that serves as both an introduction to the history and modern significance of military aircraft carriers. This 43-minute IMAX documentary offers mesmerizing aerial shots and up-close imagery that showcase the sheer magnitude and capacity of these naval behemoths. The film primarily revolves around the Pacific Rim exercises (RIMPAC), emphasizing the collaboration among various nations’ navies. Featuring the USS Ronald Reagan, the film delves into technological advancements, such as the inclusion of F-35 fighters, while providing brief historical context with archival footage.
Where the documentary excels is in its portrayal of the operational aspects of aircraft carriers. We see the intricacies of flight deck operations, from jets taking off and landing to detailed introductions to crew roles marked by colored shirts. However, the use of computer-generated imagery (CGI) to explain internal functionalities somewhat diminishes the impact, leaving viewers wishing for real footage of these critical components. Despite this, the visual splendor captured in IMAX format remains a hallmark, with scenes of synchronised naval exercises and jet maneuvers providing awe-inspiring moments.
Narratively, Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas strikes a balance between awe and caution, juxtaposing the magnificence of naval technology with somber reminders of the perils of war. Despite its engaging visuals and technological insights, the documentary falls short in forging a human connection. The narration by Maurice Dean Wint and brief snippets of crew interviews lack depth, making the documentary feel somewhat impersonal. Overall, while it is a captivating display for enthusiasts of military hardware and naval aviation, its fragmented storytelling and absence of emotional engagement may not appeal universally.
Total: 68
"Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas" is a captivating IMAX documentary provided by Shout! Factory, offering a visually stunning portrayal of modern naval power. Directed by Stephen Low, the film skillfully balances detailed technical aspects with a broader message advocating for peace. The documentary benefits from remarkable cinematography, presenting both sweeping aerial views and intimate close-ups of various aircraft carriers. The immersive visuals are complemented by exceptional audio, available in both Dolby Atmos and DTS-HD MA 5.1 formats, ensuring a rich viewing experience.
The runtime of 43 minutes ensures a concise yet impactful narrative, although it might leave some viewers yearning for more depth. The content showcases the dedication and training of military personnel while exploring the intricate workings and sheer scale of these colossal war machines. Despite the occasional video glitch likely sourced from the original material, the Ultra HD quality mostly delivers breathtaking imagery. However, the documentary's attempt at emotional engagement falls short as it misses developing individual crew members' stories.
In conclusion, "Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas" is a technically impressive documentary that effectively highlights the marvels of naval technology and the importance of military forces in ensuring global security. While the supplemental features are somewhat sparse, the primary content serves as a visually and aurally rewarding experience. This film is a commendable watch for military enthusiasts and those interested in naval engineering, proving to be both informative and engaging despite its brief duration and minor flaws.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 100
Intimately detailed and neutrally graded, the razor sharp image shows off every crook and cranny of the giant aircraft carriers, and the beautiful oceans surrounding them....
Audio: 90
Dialog for the narration is clean and clear, and even some of the older footage used shows great audio clarity....
Extras: 50
Audience Testimonials • F-35 vs. Bugatti vs. Human Cannonball • Usain Bolt vs. Giraffe vs. Nuclear Carrier • F-35 Navy Selects Reel • Aircraft Carrier Trailer & TV Spot...
Movie: 80
We get to see at least 4 different carriers up close, and Low delves pretty deep into how the technology for the various ships has stayed the same, and how it has adapted and been updated to serve a more...
Total: 80
Aircraft Carriers: Guardian of the Seas is another fun IMAX documentary from Shout Factory, and one of the better done ones in recent history....
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
There is also some "night vision" material toward the end of the documentary that also looks like at least part of it may have been sourced from a low res capture, and there is minor but noticeable macroblocking...
Audio: 80
Both the 1080p Blu-ray and 2160p 4K UHD discs boast Dolby Atmos tracks, and while there is intermittent and noticeable engagement of the Atmos channels, predictably with regard to effects like roaring...
Extras: 80
Amazingly, all of the testimonials are raves, and many contain the word "awesome". F-35 vs. Bugatti vs. Human Cannonball (1080i; 1:12) is the first of two patently ridiculous speed comparisons hampered...
Movie: 60
The kind of weird doling out of facts and figures begins almost from the get go in Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas, when a joint military exercise is briefly described, but which is only overtly...
Total: 10
For those who haven't experienced the massive scale of a modern day aircraft carrier "up close and personal", Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas can provide at least a little vicarious experience in...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
HDR work provides a bit of pop, accentuating sun reflecting from waves and especially heightening the glow left from missile trails....
Audio: 60
Predominant stereo use takes up jets panning away from the center, showing some life from this Atmos offering....
Extras: 40
The following six screen shots serve as samples for our Patreon-exclusive set of 30 full 4K screen shots grabbed directly from the UHD:...
Movie: 60
Thousands of Navy members diligently perform their duties, and appropriately, Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas gives them a chance to be on camera....
Total: 55
Following an international military exercise, Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas produces some marvelous imagery while detailing technology....
High-Def Digest review by Shannon T. NuttRead review here
Video: 70
Other shots that seem to have been done via helicopter sometimes have a dark flickering at the top of the screen, which I first thought was some sort of aliasing glitch but then realized was just the HDR...
Audio: 80
Extras: 10
Usain Bolt vs. Giraffe vs. Nuclear Carrier (HD 1:07) – Another short animated clip comparing the speed of these three things (again, no points for guessing which one wins)....
Movie: 60
But the second and more vital problem I had with Aircraft Carrier is that it fails to establish any connection between the viewer and any of the men and women featured in the movie....
Total: 60
But a few video glitches (most likely from the source material) and a lack of a human connection in the feature presentation leave us with a documentary that is informative, but not very engaging....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 100
Whether it be the finest minutia visible in the textural make-up of the interior/exterior of the naval vessels, aircraft, or uniforms worn by staff, or the majestic vistas of the Pacific, the imagery is...
Audio: 90
Examples can be found during many of the training sequences featuring hovering or, ascending/descending aircraft or the CGI deconstruction of the interior components of the Aircraft Carrier....
Extras: 50
Disc 1: Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas Ultra HD Blu-ray Disc 2: Aircraft Carrier: Guardian of the Seas Blu-ray · Audience Testimonials · F-35 vs. Bugatti vs. Human Cannonball · Usain Bolt vs. Giraffe...
Movie: 80
With RIMPAC — the world's largest and most comprehensive maritime training exercise — providing a stunning visual context for the story, find yourself aboard the USS Ronald Reagan alongside the 5,000 highly...
Total: 80
is an enlightening, albeit brief, documentary film that reminds us of the dedication, training and importance of our military personnel and the tools they employ to guarantee the blanket of freedom we...
Director: Stephen Low
Actors: Maurice Dean Wint
PlotNavigating the vast, unpredictable waters of our planet, an elite fleet of naval vessels, centered around the Nimitz-class aircraft carrier, demonstrates the pinnacle of maritime sophistication and military might. This towering stronghold of the seas serves as a floating city, equipped with a full array of fighter jets, helicopters, and state-of-the-art technology. Within this carefully orchestrated ecosystem, highly trained personnel work with unwavering dedication to maintain peace and security across the globe. The film captures the operations and exercises that keep this gigantic vessel and its fleet at the ready, showcasing the skill and coordination necessary to execute their critical missions.
As the documentary delves into life aboard the carrier, viewers are given an intimate look at the daily routines and intricate tasks performed by the sailors and pilots. Training regimens are rigorous, reflecting the perpetual need for operational readiness in an ever-changing world. From the adrenaline-packed launch and recovery of aircraft to the strategic planning within the command center, the film presents a microcosm of a nation's defense mechanisms at sea. Against the backdrop of international waters, cultural exchanges with allied nations further emphasize the role of maritime forces in fostering global ties and ensuring collective security.
Writers: Stephen Low
Release Date: 26 May 2020
Runtime: 41 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Canada
Language: English