McCabe & Mrs. Miller Blu-ray Review

The Criterion release of "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" showcases a meticulous 1080p Blu-ray transfer in a 2.40:1 aspect ratio, processed from a new digital transfer created in 4K 16-bit resolution from the original 35mm camera negative. The color grading, supervised by cinematographer Vilmos Zsigmond and matched to a reference print from the Academy Film Archive, retains the film's authentic visual style. Thousands of imperfections, including dirt, debris, and scratches, were painstakingly removed using MTI's Film DRS, while Digital Vision's Phoenix was employed for managing jitter, flicker, grain, and noise. This careful restoration ensures the film appears exceptionally clean and precise without any unwarranted compression issues or sharpening artifacts.

In terms of image quality, this Blu-ray edition breathes new life into the film’s visual aesthetics. Detail and clarity are superb, from capturing the intricacies of individual snowflakes and beard hairs to showcasing the texture of fur coats under various lighting conditions. The outdoor scenes, particularly the climactic shootout, possess a raw vibrancy that was absent in previous DVD releases. The visual presentation maintains a harmonious level of film grain that enhances the movie’s vintage feel without succumbing to digital over-processing. Color reproduction is visually striking with naturally warm tones dominating due to the period-specific lighting choices, while black levels remain deep and consistent. The transfer stability is excellent, ensuring viewers can appreciate Robert Altman's unique use of light and shadow without distraction from image abnormalities.

Overall, "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" stands out as an exceptional presentation on Blu-ray, harmonizing technical precision with artistic integrity. Viewers are treated to a visual experience that not only honors Vilmos Zsigmond's original cinematographic vision but also enhances it with modern restoration techniques.

The audio track on the Blu-ray of "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" is presented in English LPCM 1.0. Criterion has taken notable care in remastering the original monaural soundtrack from the 35mm magnetic track, effectively eliminating clicks, thumps, hiss, hum, and crackle through meticulous use of Pro Tools HD. While some enthusiasts might wish for an optional 5.1 mix, the existing LPCM 1.0 track does not disappoint. Ambient noises such as nature sounds, gunshots, and the townsfolk's chatter are reproduced with impressive definition and fullness.

In terms of design and performance, the audio presentation maintains a distinctive organic character, with only minor dynamic and clarity fluctuations in select segments, primarily noticeable in scenes set within the brothel. Importantly, no purely age-related anomalies like background hiss, pops, or distortions detract from the experience. Music excerpts, particularly Leonard Cohen’s contributions, retain excellent stability and fluidity, adding a peculiar yet enriching layer to the film's narrative without overshadowing other audio elements. Dialogue is consistently crystal clear and well-balanced against sound effects, ensuring a coherent and immersive listening experience.

The Blu-ray release of "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" comes equipped with a robust selection of extras, catering to both die-hard fans and newcomers alike. The commentary track brings invaluable context with director Robert Altman and producer David Foster reflecting on the production. Newly made content, like the documentary "Way Out on a Limb," offers fresh insights, casting light on Altman's methodologies. Conversations with film historians Cari Beauchamp and Rick Jewell further explore the movie's unique style and niche. Archival materials, including rare interviews with cinematographer Vilmos Zsigmond and segments from "The Dick Cavett Show," provide a glimpse into the film's reception and technical craft. Additionally, the compilation includes a detailed photo gallery by Steve Schapiro and a historically enriching Art Directors Guild Q&A.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Featuring director Robert Altman and producer David Foster.
• Way Out on a Limb: Making-of documentary with cast and crew interviews.
• Cari Beauchamp and Rick Jewell Conversation: Discussion of Altman's career and film style.
• Behind the Scenes: Footage of the construction of the Northwestern mining town set.
• Leon Ericksen: Q&A about production design with insights from 1999.
• Vilmos Zsigmond: Archival interviews with the cinematographer.
• Steve Schapiro Photo Gallery: Archival stills from the set.
• The Dick Cavett Show: Two segments featuring Pauline Kael and Robert Altman.
• Trailer: Original promotional trailer.
• Criterion Booklet: Illustrated leaflet with an essay by Nathaniel Rich.

Robert Altman's "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" is a defining anti-western that deglamorizes the genre through a gritty, innovative approach. Set in the fledgling mining town of Presbyterian Church, the film stars Warren Beatty as John McCabe, a gambling gunslinger with aspirations of establishing a brothel. Julie Christie co-stars as Constance Miller, a savvy prostitute who partners with McCabe to transform his fledgling business into an upscale establishment. Their plans are jeopardized by the arrival of representatives from a powerful mining company intent on taking over their operation by any means necessary. The film masterfully leverages overlapping dialogue and Leonard Cohen's haunting music to create a raw, authentic portrayal of the American West.

The visual artistry of the film is nothing short of remarkable, with Vilmos Zsigmond's evocative cinematography playing a pivotal role. Utilizing oversaturated and desaturated colors, unique contrasts, and meticulous light and shadow management, Zsigmond and Altman create a distinctively poetic 'antique' look that captures the harsh realities and stark beauty of the setting. The layered textures and unconventional framing lend the film an aura of authenticity often missing in traditional Westerns. Altman's use of Leonard Cohen's lyrical soundtrack further enhances the narrative's melancholic and contemplative tone, making "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" a seminal piece that redefined genre conventions.

In essence, "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" stands out not just for its thematic boldness but also for its technical brilliance. Altman's direction eschews genre norms in favor of flawed, deeply human characters navigating a morally ambiguous frontier. This film isn't just about its plot – it’s a study in palpable human emotions and societal transformation within the Old West. Criterion's Blu-ray release preserves these qualities with excellent visual fidelity and enriching supplemental features, ensuring that this landmark film remains both accessible and enduring for future generations.

Criterion's Blu-ray release of Robert Altman's "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" delivers a transformative experience with its brand new 4K restoration sourced from an impeccably detailed transfer. This film, often heralded as one of the finest avant-garde pieces of Western cinema, showcases Altman’s ability to redefine conventional genre boundaries. The compelling characters, nuanced performances, and Leonard Cohen's evocative score are rendered with stunning fidelity in this edition, making every frame and note resonate uniquely.

The restoration showcases remarkable resolution and clarity, bringing out the fine details and textures that immerse viewers in the gritty atmosphere of the American West. Black levels and shadow details are well-maintained, enhancing the film's distinctive, ambient settings. The color reproduction remains faithful to Altman's original vision, offering a palette that is both period-accurate and vividly engaging. Fleshtones are natural and consistent throughout, contributing to the authenticity and depth of the characters portrayed. The stability of the image and absence of compression artifacts further underscore the technical excellence of this release.

Criterion's release is not just a visual and auditory spectacle but also an expansive tribute to Altman's artistry. The comprehensive set of extras provides invaluable insights, deepening the appreciation of the film's groundbreaking techniques and enduring influence, particularly seen in modern works such as HBO’s "Deadwood." By securing this release, Criterion has once again proven their commitment to preserving and celebrating cinematic milestones in their highest quality.

In conclusion, Criterion’s edition of "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" stands as a definitive collection for both enthusiasts and newcomers. The pioneering film redefines the Western genre with technical brilliance and profound storytelling. Its high-caliber presentation on Blu-ray makes it an essential addition to any serious film collection. Highly recommended.