Lake Michigan Monster Blu-ray Review
Score: 75
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Lake Michigan Monster’s inventive presentation and overbearing humor, along with Arrow Video’s excellent Blu-ray release and engaging extras, make it a recommended niche addition.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
Lake Michigan Monster's Blu-ray from Arrow Video features an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 1.78:1, delivering an intentionally distressed, lo-fi aesthetic with intense close-ups and fluctuating detail levels. While some scenes are extremely dark, fine detail shines through in character faces and set designs, making this a unique cinematic experience.
Audio: 72
Lake Michigan Monster features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track with surprising immersion despite its low budget. The LFE is rumbly, and the glut of outdoor materials offers good ambient effects. Dialogue, effects, and score showcase fine fidelity with good dynamic range. Optional 2.0 LPCM track and English SDH subtitles are available.
Extra: 75
The Blu-ray of 'Lake Michigan Monster' comes loaded with an array of engaging and insightful extras including multiple audio commentaries—both sober and drunk—from the cast and crew, a critics' commentary, a VFX breakdown, several interviews, music video, behind-the-scenes photos, and exclusive episodes of the L.I.P.S. web series, providing a comprehensive look into the film’s creative process.
Movie: 72
Lake Michigan Monster is a surreal, inventive, and humorous tribute to low-budget filmmaking, offering an eclectic blend of styles such as black and white photography, stop motion animation, and CGI. With a threadbare story driven by comedic antics, it features standout performances and could easily achieve cult status.
Video: 79
"Lake Michigan Monster" is presented on Blu-ray by Arrow Video with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in its original 1.78:1 aspect ratio. The release maintains the original 5.1 surround and stereo audio. According to Arrow's booklet, the High Definition master was provided by director Ryland Tews. There is some ambiguity regarding whether the film was shot on 16mm or digitally manipulated to achieve a similar aesthetic. Regardless, digital tweaking has been employed to deliberately distress and damage the imagery, including drastically pushed contrast, creating a lo-fi but visually striking result.
The intent to emulate a damaged film print adds a distinctive patina that delivers a unique viewing experience. Although the contrast levels are generally stable, black levels frequently struggle, leading to some scenes where even actors' faces are obscured by shadow. Fine detail is evident in facial features, costuming, and set design when scenes allow, yet the layered effects can lead to variability in clarity and detail. Despite these artistic choices, the film's visually engaging approach transcends technical shortcomings, resulting in an "unabashedly lo-fi" production with standout close-ups that accentuate detail amidst the visual chaos.
In summary, the "Lake Michigan Monster" Blu-ray presentation embraces its stylistic distortions, offering a one-of-a-kind visual experience that complements its no-budget roots. The varying levels of detail and contrast emphasize the film's creative vision, making it memorable and faithful to the director's intent.
Audio: 72
The audio presentation of the Blu Ray for "Lake Michigan Monster" boasts a formidable DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, complemented by an English 2.0 LPCM option. Despite the film's low-budget origins, the 5.1 track surrounds the viewer with surprising depth and immersive qualities, leveraging ambient environmental effects and panning to solid effect. This results in an audio experience rife with dynamic range and precise dialogue, even though all dialogue appears to be post-looped, leading to occasional sync discrepancies. The LFE channel delivers rumbling bass that punctuates key moments without overwhelming the mix.
Furthermore, the sound effects and whimsical score are presented with notable fidelity, bringing vivid energy to the film's immersive experience. The film’s theme song, "Dear Old Captain Seafield," is particularly well-rendered, offering rich, full-bodied audio. The surround channels maintain a confident and effective placement of audio elements, keeping viewers firmly anchored within the film’s fantastical world. While the 5.1 track is clearly the superior option for a cinematic experience, the 2.0 LPCM track remains a solid alternative for those with simpler audio setups.
Optional English subtitles are available and enhance accessibility without detracting from the film’s whimsical auditory landscape. Overall, the audio presentation here effectively handles the blend of dialogue-heavy sequences, colorful effects, and musical interludes, ensuring an engaging and robust listening experience that complements "Lake Michigan Monster's" unique charm.
Extras: 75
The Blu-ray of "Lake Michigan Monster" offers an impressive array of extras to captivate and inform viewers. Three engaging audio commentaries feature the cast and crew both sober and inebriated, providing amusing and insightful perspectives on the film's production, while Alexandra Heller-Nicholas and Emma Westwood offer an analytical take. The exhaustive list of extras also includes a split-screen Effects Breakdown, multiple interviews at different festivals, themed music videos, a hybrid animation/live-action web series, promotional videos, and a comprehensive behind-the-scenes photo slideshow. All the content is meticulously compiled, offering tantalizing glimpses into the creative process.
Extras included in this disc:
- Cast/Crew Audio Commentary: Features Ryland Tews, Daniel Long, Beulah Peters, Erick West, and editor Mike Cheslik.
- Drunk Audio Commentary: The same group as above, but inebriated.
- Critics Audio Commentary: From Alexandra Heller-Nicholas and Emma Westwood.
- Effects Breakdown: Split-screen comparison of original footage and final effects.
- Dear Old Captain Seafield: A lyrics video featuring the Seafield Monster Sextet.
- Interview in a Cabin: Ryland Tews and Daniel Long at the 2019 Fantasia International Film Festival.
- Interview in a Bar: Cast and crew at the 2019 Beloit International Film Festival.
- Interview by a Fire: Audio interview with Mike Cheslik on Cinema Fireside.
- L.I.P.S. Season One: Hybrid animation/live-action sci-fi comedy web series by Ryland Tews and Mike Cheslik.
- L.I.P.S. Pilot: Pilot episode from the aforementioned series.
- Arrow Video Channel Promotional Videos
- Call to Action: Director’s message urging viewership.
- Filmmaking Guide: A humorous take on no-budget filmmaking.
- Manufacturer's Guarantee: A satirical guarantee of the film’s authenticity.
- Theatrical Trailer: Official trailer for the film.
- Behind the Scenes Photos: Slideshow detailing the film's production.
Movie: 72
"Lake Michigan Monster" is a whimsical and unorthodox cinematic experience. Directed, written, and starring Ryland Brickson Cole Tews, this film defies traditional low-budget filmmaking by delivering an unconventional narrative filled with absurd humor and surreal sequences. Tews plays Captain Seafield, a brash and slightly deluded character on a mission to avenge his father's death at the hands of a mysterious monster in Lake Michigan. Alongside him are eccentric team members Sean Shaughnessy (Erick West), Nedge Pepsi (Beulah Peters), and Dick Flynn (Daniel Long), contributing to a series of whimsical and chaotic "operations" that include hilariously named missions like “Operation Master Baiters.”
The film’s stylistic ambition is noteworthy, incorporating dingy black and white photography, stop-motion animation, CGI, and various optical effects in a way that evokes the sensibilities of filmmakers such as Wes Anderson and Edgar Wright while maintaining a unique voice. Within its lean 78-minute runtime, "Lake Michigan Monster" ambitiously blends genres, from sci-fi horror to outright comedy, peppered with musical numbers and non-sequiturs. The jokes can be hit or miss; however, the rapid pacing and creative visual techniques keep the momentum engaging, culminating in an increasingly surreal final act.
The film's technical execution is impressive given its budget constraints. It employs inventive visual effects inspired by early cinema, making the most of practical effects juxtaposed with contemporary methods to create an aesthetically distinctive piece. The performances, particularly Tews' commitment to the ludicrous persona of Captain Seafield, elevate the narrative's comedic elements. Supporting cast members add depth to the absurdity, handling snappy banter and outlandish situations with aplomb. Overall, "Lake Michigan Monster" stands as an exemplar of imaginative low-budget storytelling, potentially earning cult status among cinephiles attracted to its bizarre and whimsical charm.
Total: 75
"Lake Michigan Monster" stands out as a truly unique cinematic experience, blending elements of dark comedy, experimental visuals, and whimsical storytelling. Influenced by the idiosyncratic styles of Sam Raimi and Guy Maddin, the film offers a quirky, irreverent approach reminiscent of works from Adult Swim's more avant-garde lineup. Despite its eccentricity, the humor may not resonate universally, oscillating between genuinely clever and undeniably foolish, yet the film's inventive presentation remains a noteworthy achievement.
From a technical standpoint, Arrow Video’s Blu-ray release excels in delivering an outstanding audio-visual experience. The digital manipulation and distinctive visual style translate beautifully in high-definition, underscoring the film's offbeat charm. Coupled with a robust selection of supplementary features, this release ensures an immersive experience for fans and first-time viewers alike. The commitment to high-quality production and generous bonus content highlights Arrow Video's dedication to celebrating indie cinema.
In conclusion, director Ryland Tews' "Lake Michigan Monster" commands attention through its audacious creativity and memorable characters. While not every comedic moment lands perfectly, the film's originality and visual panache make it a compelling watch. The Blu-ray release by Arrow Video is exemplary, offering top-notch technical merits and an engaging array of extras. For those searching for something refreshingly different and enthusiastically unconventional, "Lake Michigan Monster" comes highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
The differences in contrast as well as some of the other tweaks applied can mean clarity and detail levels ebb and flow (no nautical pun intended), and some of the special effects work can be a little...
Audio: 80
Dialogue (evidently all post-looped, so sync is loose, as they say), effects and the wacky score are all presented with fine fidelity and some nice dynamic range....
Extras: 60
Interview in a Bar (1080p; 12:43) features various cast and crew at the Beloit International Film Festival in Feburary 2019....
Movie: 70
A couple of horror films put out by Arrow over the past year or so also featured northern Wisconsin's Eagle River area (where my wife's family has a wonderful cabin on one of Wisconsin's multitudinous...
Total: 70
Tews is on record as stating two of his primary influences for Lake Michigan Monster were Sam Raimi and Guy Maddin (Maddin gets a special thanks in the closing credits), while commentators Alexandra Heller-Nicholas...
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 100
Despite the fact that the audio carries a few of the same qualities as the video portion, it’s presented in a more modern fashion in a surprisingly robust fashion....
Extras: 95
The Effects Breakdown is a four quadrant, split-screen comparison of the original footage, various effects elements, and the final film....
Movie: 75
Judging it from a purely subjective point of view, it’s certainly put together well, free of traditional approaches and totally outside the box—basically the polar opposite of most low budget filmmaking....
Total: 90
If anything, it’s experimental in the way that TV shows on Adult Swim like Off the Air and Dream Corp LLC continue to explore new boundaries through dark comedy, animation, and style....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Judging the presentation here is difficult due to all the stylized layers but there is so much activity within the image that whatever slights are noticeable doesn’t matter for this no-budget feature....
Audio: 60
Dialogue heavy with plenty of effects and musical interludes, the audio track bursts at the seams to handle the mayhem....
Extras: 80
Interview in a Bar (HD 12:43) interviews with the cast and crew at the Beloit Wisconsin International Film Festival Interview by a Fire (HD 23:58)Audio interview with Mike Cheslik on Mark Borchardt’s Cinema...
Movie: 80
You never see any technical limitations inhibiting the oddly grandiose storytelling techniques which showcase the imagination and inventiveness of the feature....
Total: 80
Lake Michigan Monster is a bizarre nautical fairy tale that utilizes an interesting visual aesthetic to lure audiences into the depths of its weird characters and monster mythology....
Director: Ryland Brickson Cole Tews
Actors: Ryland Brickson Cole Tews, Beulah Peters, Erick West
PlotOn the shores of Lake Michigan, an eccentric sea captain named Seafield embarks on a mission to avenge his father's death, which he claims was caused by a mysterious monster lurking in the depths. Driven by a mix of bravado and absurdity, Seafield assembles a misfit team of specialists: a weapons expert named Sean Shaughnessy, sonar technician Nedge Pepsi, and former N.A.V.Y. sonar officer Dick Flynn. Each member brings unique, albeit questionable, skills to the mission. The team members are not entirely convinced of Seafield's tales but agree to help in the hunt for the illusive creature.
As they venture into the lake, their attempts to locate and confront the monster lead them through a series of increasingly bizarre and comedic mishaps. The group's various plans—from using cutting-edge sonar technology to setting elaborate traps—seem to do little more than showcase their collective ineptitude. Amidst their chaotic efforts, tensions rise and personal agendas start surfacing. As the group teeters on the edge of falling apart, Seafield's obsession grows stronger, pushing them all into a final, unpredictable confrontation with the dark forces beneath the water.
Writers: Ryland Brickson Cole Tews, Mike Cheslik
Release Date: 31 Jul 2020
Runtime: 78 min
Rating: TV-MA
Country: United States
Language: English