Chato's Land Blu-ray Review
Limited Edition to 3000
Score: 57
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Chato's Land offers a solid Blu-ray with a good image and audio, featuring intriguing political undertones and valuable extras, though the video has some flaws.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 58
Chato's Land's 1080p AVC-encoded Blu-ray transfer in 1.85:1 provides a healthy, colorful HD upgrade with detailed facial features, costuming, and expansive Spanish locations. Despite some age-related wear and specks, fine grain is stable, shadow separation robust, and depth of field impressive, though flesh tones occasionally appear ruddy or pink.
Audio: 61
Chato's Land features a DTS-HD MA 1.0 mono track that capably supports dialogue, effects, and Jerry Fielding's score with fine fidelity and prioritization. While there's minimal imaging or spatial dimension, the nuanced ambient sounds and clear audio presentation manage to deliver a convincing experience.
Extra: 42
The Blu-ray extras for 'Chato's Land' feature a compelling DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 isolated score track and an insightful interview with screenwriter Gerald Wilson, rich with production anecdotes, adding value for enthusiasts. The package is rounded out by the original theatrical trailer and MGM's 90th Anniversary Trailer.
Movie: 72
Chato’s Land, an early collaboration between Bronson and Winner, blends a lean revenge narrative with evocative locations and memorable performances, though its violent content and languid pace were criticized. This Blu-ray release offers a fresh presentation that should satisfy Bronson fans.
Video: 58
"Chato's Land" receives a commendable presentation on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 1.85:1. While the transfer is sourced from the MGM catalog, there are some expected age-related artifacts such as dirt, specks, and minor damage. However, these issues do not significantly detract from the overall viewing experience. The color palette is generally robust, displaying healthy hues though occasionally flesh tones appear slightly ruddy or pinkish, possibly due to natural sun exposure depicted in the film. Depth of field is notably good in the expansive outdoor scenes, and detail levels are impressive, especially during the frequent close-ups achieved through zoom lenses.
Film grain is consistently present throughout the film, maintaining a stable appearance save for specific bright blue sky scenes where it becomes more pronounced. The black levels are quite commendable, offering strong shadow separation without reaching deep inky blackness. Costumes, facial features, and the picturesque Spanish locations are presented in notable detail. This release offers a solid HD upgrade with stable colors, including vivid earth tones and primary colors that occasionally pop with presence. Although there is some slight speckling, particularly during the opening credits, the image quality significantly improves once these optical effects transition. Overall, this Blu-ray transfer stands out as a favorable back catalog release, balancing a respectful preservation of film grain with enhanced detail and color stability.
Audio: 61
The audio presentation of "Chato's Land" features a DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track that, while narrow, is convincingly robust in supporting the film's dialogue, sound effects, and Jerry Fielding's score. The mix captures the nuanced ambient environmental sounds critical to this western setting, rather than relying on loud shootout effects. Fidelity is notably fine, and the prioritization ensures clear dialogue throughout, allowing for an immersive auditory experience.
While the English DTS-HD MA 1.0 mono mix delivers clean and comprehensible dialogue, certain sound effects may come across as somewhat canned. That said, the track excels in the clarity with which Fielding's score is presented. Although it lacks notable imaging or a strong sense of spatial dimension—missing the more subtle environmental sounds like wind or distant hoof beats—the overall audio remains compelling. While it may not entirely transport listeners into the heart of the film's rugged landscape, it surpasses average expectations and offers a solid auditory accompaniment to the visual experience.
Extras: 42
The Blu-ray extras for "Chato's Land" provide a rich, informative experience, aimed at both film enthusiasts and scholars. The Isolated Score Track, presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, offers an immersive audio experience, perfect for appreciating Jerry Fielding's musical compositions. The highlight is the interview with screenwriter Gerald Wilson, who shares compelling anecdotes and insightful commentary on the film's production and reception. This 17-minute segment, in HD, is both enlightening and entertaining, reflecting Wilson's engaging storytelling prowess. Additionally, the Original Theatrical Trailer and the MGM 90th Anniversary Trailer provide a historical perspective on the film's initial promotion.
Extras included in this disc:
- Isolated Score Track: Presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0.
- Screenwriter Gerald Wilson on Chato's Land: Gerald Wilson shares anecdotes and production insights.
- Original Theatrical Trailer: A glimpse into the film's original promotion.
- MGM 90th Anniversary Trailer: Celebrates MGM's legacy.
Movie: 72
Michael Winner's 1972 film "Chato's Land," featuring Charles Bronson, presents a gritty, revenge-focused Western that deftly combines elements of racial tension and raw violence. Bronson plays Pardon Chato, a half-white, half-Apache man whose peaceful bar visit rapidly devolves into lethal self-defense against a racist sheriff. The film promptly shifts into a relentless chase as Chato flees from a vindictive posse led by Jack Palance's Quincey Whitmore, a former Confederate captain. The narrative spends little time on backstory, thrusting viewers into immediate action that sets the stage for Bronson's stoic yet physically imposing portrayal of a man reclaiming his identity through primal means.
"Chato's Land" diverges from mainstream Westerns by offering a stark depiction of the American Southwest, utilizing barren landscapes that emphasize Chato's isolation and survivalist tactics. The film's middle section primarily involves cat-and-mouse sequences, leading to harrowing scenes of violence and vengeance that escalate after Chato's wife is brutally attacked by Whitmore's posse. The climax sees Chato methodically decimating his pursuers with both cunning and brutality. This relentless pursuit of justice parallels thematic undercurrents reflecting the era's sociopolitical tensions, albeit in a manner often overshadowed by the screenplay's predictability.
The performances in "Chato's Land" vary widely: while Bronson provides his signature laconic intensity, Palance amplifies his role with dramatic fervor. Supporting actors like Ralph Waite and Richard Basehart offer nuanced character work that offset the film’s more outlandish moments. Winner's direction, praised for its effective use of evocative locales, balances the narrative’s coarse violence with an atmosphere only occasionally verging on high-flown symbolism. Despite its initially mixed reception and relative obscurity when compared to other Bronson-Winner collaborations, "Chato's Land" emerges as an engaging Western that should appeal to fans for its unflinching approach to themes of justice, revenge, and identity.
Total: 57
"Chato's Land" is an intriguing yet flawed neo-Western that blends elements of horror and social commentary, making it unsuitable for those with delicate sensibilities. The film's eclectic cast, helmed by Charles Bronson, elevates the otherwise tawdry narrative. Although the video quality presents some issues, perhaps owing to the neglect of the original source materials, the audio track compensates well and is solidly rendered. This Blu-ray edition provides an engaging, albeit imperfect, viewing experience that is compelling for genre enthusiasts.
The Blu-ray release of "Chato's Land" stands out due to its insightful supplementary content. Screenwriter Gerald Wilson's interview adds considerable depth, drawing clear parallels between the film's themes and the real-life Vietnam conflict. Julie Kirgo’s liner notes further explore the movie's significance and production intricacies. Despite the transfer flaws and less-than-ideal preservation by corporate stewards, this edition marks a significant improvement over previous versions and showcases the film better than ever before.
In conclusion, while "Chato's Land" may not rank as the pinnacle of Charles Bronson's career or Western cinema, it offers solid entertainment value and will particularly appeal to Bronson fans and genre aficionados. Twilight Time's Blu-ray release is recommended with reservations due to its technical imperfections but lauded for its enlightening extras and vastly improved presentation.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
Sharpness is slightly variable as well, with a lot of the transfer looking at least slightly soft, but detail levels are uniformly very good to excellent, especially when Winner and DP Robert Paynter employ...
Audio: 80
Chato's Land features a narrow but convincing sounding DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track, one which capably supports the film's dialogue, effects and winning score by Jerry Fielding (also available as an...
Extras: 30
Wilson, who looks and sounds a lot like the venerable John Huston, is a wonderful raconteur and includes anecdotes about his own experiences in the wilds of Canada with various Indians (as he calls them)....
Movie: 60
A cursory search of the usually at least slightly questionable internet turned up no archival material to suggest that casting Charles Bronson as a Native American in Chato's Land "offended" anyone, but...
Total: 60
Chato's Land is a bit silly at times, though that tendency may be subsumed by some of the more horrifying aspects that are also on display (this is not a film for the faint of heart or queasy of stomach)....
The Digital Bits review by Jim HemphillRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 80
Extras: 85
Movie: 85
The stone-faced messenger of vengeance that would become Bronson’s trademark character, however, was honed to brutal perfection by Winner; Chato’s Land was the rough draft, but two years later the director...
Total: 83
In fact, the political and allegorical implications of the material, which clearly evokes Vietnam in its story of poorly prepared white men heading into an environment they don’t understand and having...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Black levels are pretty strong, not quite deep inky black, but there is still enough shadow separation to give the image a sense of depth....
Audio: 60
It isn't entirely flat and lifeless but it's missing the subtle sounds like wind or the distant crunch of a hoof clopping on gravel that would give the track much shape....
Extras: 20
A pretty great interview with the writer of the film, he's got a lot to say in the little time he's given and offers up a lot of interesting tidbits about the production and the film's reception....
Movie: 80
At this point, Chato is almost like a phantom, only popping up here and there for a second or two; long enough to see the outcome of a trap he recently laid and Bronson plays him with an honest curiosity...
Total: 60
'Chato's Land' may not be the greatest Bronson film ever or the best Western for that matter, but it's a solid piece of entertainment....
Director: Michael Winner
Actors: Charles Bronson, Jack Palance, James Whitmore
PlotA Native American, who also happens to be half-white, gets into a fatal altercation with a racist sheriff in a saloon situated in the Old West. Following this incident, he escapes into the desert, leaving the small town in turmoil. A posse is quickly formed by a ruthless former Confederate officer, determined to bring him to justice for the perceived crime. This posse consists of various men, each bringing their own prejudices and motives for joining the hunt, but they are united by a common goal: capturing or killing the fugitive.
As they venture deeper into the harsh wilderness, the dynamics within the group start to fray due to mounting tensions and the relentless environment. Their target, skilled in survival and well-versed in guerrilla tactics, methodically leads them into ever more perilous situations. Along the way, their weaknesses and deeply ingrained biases are exposed, testing their resolve and revealing the true nature of justice and vengeance they each harbor. The manhunt transforms into a psychological battle, where each member of the posse must confront both external dangers and their own inner demons.
Writers: Gerald Wilson
Release Date: 01 Jun 1972
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: PG
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English, Spanish