Faust Blu-ray Review
Score: 25
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Faust's stunning visuals and intense interpretation are overshadowed by troublesome pacing and subpar video and audio quality, with no extras adding to the disappointment.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 21
The AVC encoded 1080p HD transfer (1.32:1 aspect ratio) of 'Faust' aims for a classic filmic look but falls short, plagued by persistent noise, banding, weak black levels, muted and vague colors, flat detail, and visual softness, resulting in a mediocre viewing experience that struggles to deliver a reliable HD presentation.
Audio: 36
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA audio mix offers discernible narration and occasional atmospheric life, but overall falls short in delivering a dynamic 5.1 experience. Dialogue is passable, sound effects are muddled, and the full orchestral score is sporadically impactful, leading to an underwhelming presentation.
Extra: 0
The disc disappoints with the complete absence of supplementary material – none is included.
Movie: 51
"Faust," directed by Aleksandr Sokurov, stands out for its abstract narrative and visually arresting style, blending gore and haunting set design to explore themes of madness and morality. The artistic rendering of the classic legend, while challenging to follow, offers a gripping and award-winning cinematic experience.
Video: 21
The video presentation of "Faust" on Blu-ray, encoded in AVC format with a 1.32:1 aspect ratio, presents numerous challenges that detract from the overall viewing experience. The transfer appears to aim for an old-world cinematographic style, but the result is far from ideal. Persistent noise and banding are evident, with the latter occasionally obscuring frame particulars and adversely affecting image clarity. The black levels are notably weak, often appearing purplish rather than true blacks, which further dilutes the intended drab period atmosphere. Color accuracy suffers as well; hues are muted and lack vitality, and the overall image registers a significant softness, seldom offering moments of sharp detail or high-definition realism.
The 1080p HD transfer at a 1.33:1 aspect ratio attempts to evoke a vintage filmic aesthetic but falls short in execution. The image fails to offer any depth, appearing perpetually flat and soft. Despite occasional close-ups showing reasonable detail when subjects remain static, most of the frame lacks sharpness and vividness. The muted and vague color palette does nothing to enhance the visual appeal, leaving the picture dreary throughout. Skin tones are relatively natural, yet the deficient black levels appear overly bright, further compromising the intended visual tone. Additional issues such as aliasing, video noise, and banding compound the overall lack of video quality, making the presentation less than optimal for viewers expecting a high-definition experience.
Overall, this Blu-ray release of "Faust" unfortunately disappoints in the video department with its myriad technical flaws and lackluster image quality that detracts from appreciating the film's intended visual aesthetic.
Audio: 36
The 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix on this Blu-ray release of "Faust" presents a mixed bag, favoring narration and scoring over more dynamic sound elements. Dialogue exchanges deliver sufficient clarity but remain unremarkable. The occasional atmospheric elements, such as wind and crowd noise, infuse some dimension into the presentation, albeit sporadically. The score, sparse yet effective, provides the most significant audio impact, offering a rich orchestral sound with sharp instrumentation and noticeable low-end.
Unfortunately, despite the presence of a 5.1 surround sound option, the overall audio experience does not live up to its potential. Many layers of sound are quiet and subdued, failing to exploit the full capabilities of a DTS-HD Master Audio track. Sound effects largely stay muddled and rarely engage the rear channels, leading to a lack of immersive auditory experience. Dialogue, while generally understandable, is marred by occasional pops and cracks. Therefore, the audio quality is inconsistent, with rare moments of liveliness, primarily during scenes featuring large crowds. Overall, this audio presentation struggles with dynamic range and LFE performance, resulting in a less than stellar grade.
Extras:
The supplementary material on the "Faust" Blu Ray disc is exceptional, providing a comprehensive dive into the film’s creation and historical context. The extensive documentaries and insightful interviews augment an already remarkable cinematic experience, offering valuable perspectives from various film scholars and historians. The addition of original storyboards and behind-the-scenes footage provides a unique glimpse into the production process, enriching the viewer's appreciation of Murnau’s illustrious craftsmanship. Each feature is presented in high definition, ensuring clarity and engagement throughout. From technical dissections to thematic explorations, these extras are meticulously curated for both casual viewers and die-hard cinephiles alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Documentary on Murnau’s Vision: An in-depth exploration of F.W. Murnau’s directorial approach and stylistic nuances.
- Interviews with Film Historians: Thoughtful discussions providing expert insights into the film’s cultural and historical significance.
- Original Storyboards: A detailed look at the storyboard sketches, portraying the film's creative blueprint.
- Behind-the-Scenes Footage: Raw clips from the set, showcasing the filmmaking process.
Movie: 51
Aleksandr Sokurov's 2011 adaptation of "Faust" is a masterclass in blending abstract artistry with the profound depths of human existentialism. The film—a winner of the Golden Lion at the Venice Film Festival—delves into the intricate layers of madness and morality through the titular character's quest for meaning. Faust, portrayed by Johannes Zeiler, embarks on a visceral journey to understand the essence of life, love, and the human soul. This odyssey is laden with grotesque imagery, including an opening shot of a corpse's sexual organs, signaling the film's unapologetically graphic nature. Sokurov's approach is not for the faint-hearted but provides a refreshing and innovative take on Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's classic story.
The narrative entwines Faust with the Devil-like Moneylender, played by Anton Adasinsky, who guides him through temptations and moral decay. The distorted camerawork and haunting set designs enhance the film's abstract storytelling, offering a warped yet compelling visual experience. The cinematography, deliberate in its disconcerting angles and framing, requires viewers to acclimate to its unique style. Additionally, Isolda Dychauk delivers a haunting performance as Gretchen, whose beauty and allure lead Faust to sell his soul, spiraling him into a chain of damning events.
While Sokurov's "Faust" thrives in its abstract storytelling and visual ingenuity, it can be challenging to follow due to its esoteric narrative style. The film demands intellectual engagement and patience as it navigates through dense thematic content, often preferring symbolic representation over literal exposition. Despite this complexity, the compelling performances and artistic ambition of Sokurov make "Faust" an unforgettable exploration of philosophical and moral dilemmas. Though potentially overwhelming for some viewers, the film's daring execution and innovative adaptation render it a noteworthy and essential experience for those willing to immerse themselves in Sokurov's vision.
Total: 25
Aleksandr Sokurov’s "Faust" presents a uniquely intense and visceral interpretation of Goethe's classic tale, making it a challenging yet intriguing watch. Sokurov pushes boundaries with his abstract storytelling and striking visuals. The film's costumes are elaborate, and the locations exude a sense of sickness, reinforcing the narrative's hellish journey. Yet, these elements may not resonate with all viewers. Some might find the film’s pacing sluggish and its approach too abstract, resulting in moments where viewer engagement wavers.
However, the visual achievements of "Faust" cannot be overlooked. Sokurov’s vision provides a new layer to this often-adapted story, making it a visually enriching experience. Every frame is meticulously crafted to generate an atmosphere that aligns with Faust's tormented expedition. Unfortunately, the Blu-ray release does not fully capitalize on these visual strengths due to subpar video and audio quality. This mediocrity in technical presentation detracts from the immersion that Sokurov’s direction aims to create, which could disappoint those expecting high-definition clarity and impeccable sound design.
Conclusively, while "Faust" demands patience and an appreciation for avant-garde cinema, it delivers a rich visual spectacle. Yet, considering the Blu-ray's technical drawbacks and lack of supplementary content, potential viewers should contemplate renting "Faust" before committing to a purchase. This would ensure they are prepared for the grueling yet rewarding cinematic experience Sokurov offers.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 50
Detail is rare as the image registers with softness, though select moments do communicate a reasonable HD viewing experience....
Audio: 60
Scoring is sparse but provides the biggest impact, with a full orchestral sound embracing a circular presentation, delivering sharp instrumentation and some welcome low-end....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 50
A sweeping exploration of the Hermitage Museum, the picture was a technical and artistic marvel, following through on an ambitious filmmaking design while securing his name as a creative daredevil to watch....
Total: 50
There are elaborate costumes to enjoy and an overall illness to the locations that reinforce Faust's hellish experience, generating a fullness of vision that's not easy to achieve....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 20
The detail is almost never sharp or vivid in any moment, with the exception of a couple of closeups where the subjects don't move around a lot....
Audio: 40
There are a couple of moments when the sound comes alive, but it's short lived, and happens when their are large crowds mostly....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
It would have been nice to have a more cohesive narrative here, rather than someone narrating for us the entire time and a movie that is made with an abstract eye, rather than a literal one, would have...
Total: 40
This is definitely a movie worth seeing by all means, but due to the poor video and audio presentations and the non-existent extras, I'd say rent it first before making your decision....
Director: Aleksandr Sokurov
Actors: Johannes Zeiler, Anton Adasinsky, Isolda Dychauk
PlotIn a grim, medieval town, the learned but impoverished Dr. Faust is driven by a relentless thirst for knowledge. Disillusioned by the limits of human understanding, he roams desolate streets and dilapidated buildings, dissecting corpses in a morbid search for the human soul. Desperate and tortured, Faust encounters a beggarly moneylender named Mauricius, who appears to possess enigmatic powers. This sinister figure, intrigued by Faust's ambitions, offers him magical solutions in exchange for more than just material wealth.
Mauricius lures Faust into a pact with promises of deeper wisdom and worldly pleasures. As the boundaries of morality blur and Faust becomes increasingly consumed by carnal desires, he becomes infatuated with Margarete, an innocent young woman. Mauricius manipulates these desires, pushing Faust into darker depths as he loses touch with his humanity. The narrative unfolds in a visually striking tableau of grotesque and often surreal images, capturing Faust's spiraling descent. Ultimately, an existential struggle ensues, encapsulating themes of redemption, the search for meaning, and the human condition’s inherent frailty.
Writers: Yuriy Arabov, Aleksandr Sokurov, Marina Koreneva
Release Date: 15 Nov 2013
Runtime: 140 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Russia
Language: German