Mortal Engines 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 82
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Mortal Engines" visually stuns but lacks character empathy; excels in 4K UHD quality.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 92
Mortal Engines' Ultra HD Blu-ray release showcases a visually stunning 4K image with remarkable sharpness, depth, and vibrant colors, setting a new standard for home video quality.
Audio: 89
Mortal Engines' Dolby Atmos soundtrack delivers an immersive, dynamic experience, with precise audio detail and impactful bass, enhancing both action scenes and quieter moments.
Extra: 69
Mortal Engines' Blu-ray release features insightful extras including a detailed commentary by director Christian Rivers, a comprehensive five-part making of 'Welcome to London,' character deep dives, and a tribute to New Zealand's filming location.
Movie: 51
Mortal Engines offers a visually stunning yet familiar dystopian adventure lacking deep character engagement but excels in creative world-building and action.
Video: 92
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Mortal Engines" showcases a remarkable achievement in home video quality, featuring a native 3840 x 2160p resolution image, delivered in the cinematic 2.39:1 aspect ratio. Utilizing RED Weapon Helium 8K cameras for principal photography and finishing with a 4K Digital Intermediate, the filmmakers have leveraged every pixel to its maximum potential. The Ultra HD disc employs the HEVC (H.265) codec and supports both HDR10 and Dolby Vision HDR formats, making for an image that's not only pristine but dynamic in its color range and contrast levels. The region-free UK Ultra HD Blu-ray was reviewed on a high-end setup, including a Panasonic 65DX902B Ultra HD 4K TV and Panasonic DMP-UB400 Ultra HD Blu-ray player, ensuring top-tier viewing conditions.
Detail reproduction is nothing short of extraordinary, showcasing an unmatched clarity in everything from the texture of skin and fabric to the intricate designs of machinery and the sprawling digital landscapes. Contrast is significantly enhanced, allowing for deep blacks and brilliant highlights which elevate the depth and three-dimensionality of the image. Colors are richly saturated yet remain natural, with the WCG (Wide Colour Gamut) contributing to a vivid portrayal of the film's varied palette. Scenes featuring lush greens, deep reds, and striking purples benefit from HDR, displaying a level of vibrancy that’s compelling. However, it's worth noting some instances of increased pastiness in skin tones due to Dolby Vision grading, though these occurrences are few.
Noise and artifacts are virtually non-existent, maintaining a clean and consistent presentation throughout. The black levels are exemplary, furnishing the night scenes and darker interiors with ample detail without succumbing to crushing. This 4K UHD release is poised to be a reference disc for home theater enthusiasts, combining stunning visuals with exceptional depth and detail. The blend of practical and digital elements is seamless, presenting a natural yet awe-inspiring image that enhances the overall immersion into the world of "Mortal Engines.
Audio: 89
The Dolby Atmos track of "Mortal Engines" on 4K UHD Blu-ray delivers an exemplary audio experience, highlighting the film’s intricate sound design with precision and depth. The soundtrack fully immerses viewers in the steampunk universe, utilizing every channel to envelop the audience in the film's elaborate actions and environments. From the rumble of city-consuming machinery to the subtle ambiance of quieter scenes, the audio presentation is meticulously crafted. The surrounds and overhead channels actively engage to create a seamless 360-degree soundscape, with particular attention to cinematic moments - whether it’s the rush of colossal engines or the buzz of airships overhead, fostering an unparalleled sense of immersion. Dialogues are rendered with crystal-clear clarity, strategically anchored to the front but with nuanced directionality, ensuring that every spoken word is both audible and impactful.
The technical prowess of the soundtrack extends to its dynamic range, especially in its handling of bass. The low-frequency effects are robust and meticulously controlled, providing a solid foundation that enhances the visual feast without overpowering it. Explosions and mechanical sounds are given substantial depth, although there is a noted desire for more intensity in the low-end to match the visual scale fully. Nonetheless, the balance mix demonstrates exceptional precision across all environments, effectively transforming the viewing area into an audibly realistic war zone during action-packed sequences.
Furthermore, the score's incorporation into the surround mix adds a layer of emotional depth without detracting from the dialogue or on-screen action. The orchestration subtly supports the narrative, enriching the storytelling without overwhelming the senses. Vocal clarity is another high point, with each line delivered with detail and nuance, ensuring that characters' voices, particularly Hugo Weaving’s, cut through the bustling background without loss of fidelity. This audio presentation not only complements but elevates the source material, ensuring an engaging and memorable experience for audiences.
Extras: 69
The 4K UHD Blu-ray edition of "Mortal Engines" offers a well-rounded collection of extras, rich in detail and insight into the film's production. Director Christian Rivers delivers an informative audio commentary, walking viewers through various aspects of the filmmaking process. The standout "Welcome to London" featurette, available in both the UHD and Blu-ray discs, is a comprehensive 26-minute exploration hosted by Robert Sheehan (Tom Natsworthy), diving deep into the creation of the film's central locale through five distinct parts. Additionally, viewers are treated to a series of character vignettes, featuring main characters Hester Shaw, Tom Natsworthy, Anna Fang, Thaddeus Valentine, and Shrike, which are constructed through interviews and behind-the-scenes footage. Other highlights include "End of the Ancients," a brief historical overview, and "In the Air," a closer look at the film's flying capabilities. The package also comes with a digital copy. This collection is notably enhanced by its technical presentation and the passion of its contributors, particularly Rivers and producer Peter Jackson, making it a compelling addition for fans.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Christian Rivers discusses key aspects of the film.
- Welcome to London: A detailed look at constructing the film's setting.
- End of the Ancients: A museum tour-style feature filling in historical background.
- Character Series: Introductions to main characters through interviews and clips.
- In the Air: Examination of the film's flying cities and vehicles.
- Film New Zealand: A feature on the benefits and beauty of filming in New Zealand.
Movie: 51
Mortal Engines, presented in stunning 4K UHD Blu-ray, unfolds in a visually mesmerizing dystopian future where civilization has collapsed, and mobile cities prey upon smaller towns across a scarred Earth. This adaptation of Philip Reeve's novel, directed by Christian Rivers with Peter Jackson among the producers, aims for a high mark in cinematic achievement with its grand visual design and ambitious world-building. The narrative follows young Hester Shaw's quest for vengeance against Thaddeus Valentine, a storyline intertwined with themes of survival and rebellion against a backdrop of "Municipal Darwinism." However, despite its visual appeal and the technological marvel of its mobile cities, the film falls short in its character development, leaving audiences with a lack of empathy for its protagonists and ultimately diminishing the impact of its otherwise exhilarating action sequences.
The film excels in its technological spectacles - the mobile cities, notably London, are portrayed with intricate detail, showcasing impressive CGI work that brings the fantasy of a nomadic civilization to life. Chase sequences and action scenes captivate with their scale and intensity, particularly the opening scene which sets an exciting pace for the story. Yet, beneath this veneer of spectacle, Mortal Engines struggles to provide a compelling narrative core. The characters feel underdeveloped, and their journeys lack the emotional depth necessary to engage viewers fully. The antagonist Thaddeus Valentine and the mechanically menacing Stalker Shrike stand out not for their roles in the human drama but more so for their portrayal through digital effects.
Despite its shortcomings, Mortal Engines is a testament to the potential of adapting unique fantasy worlds into visual epics. Its premise - featuring towering mobile cities in a post-apocalyptic landscape - offers a fresh take amidst a sea of dystopian narratives. However, the execution falters in balancing its ambitious visual design with the storytelling depth required to make the characters' plights genuinely resonate. While not without its merits, particularly in action and production design, the film ultimately serves as a reminder that technical brilliance alone cannot sustain a story's heart.
Total: 82
Mortal Engines," despite its ambitious visual spectacle and the formidable team of Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, and Peter Jackson behind it, arrives on 4K UHD Blu-ray with mixed reviews concerning its narrative and character engagement. The film, directed by Christian Rivers in his feature debut, showcases impressive sets, designs, and action sequences. However, it struggles to evoke empathy for its characters, leaving much to be desired in terms of plot coherence and emotional investment. Despite these narrative shortcomings, the technical presentation of the film’s 4K UHD Blu-ray release by Universal Pictures Home Entertainment is outstanding. The native 4K image dazzles with exceptional detail, vibrant coloring, and deep black levels that maximize visual impact. This visual excellence is complemented by a robust Dolby Atmos soundtrack, delivering an immersive audio experience that elevates the film's extensive action sequences. The included extras offer valuable insights into the film’s production process, enriching the overall viewing experience.
The Ultra HD Combo Pack presents "Mortal Engines" in an excellent Ultra HD video quality, employing Dolby Vision HDR to enhance the source material's depth and texture. While the film itself stumbles as a genre piece due to its underwhelming script and direction, this home release shines with solid high-definition video and dynamic, engaging lossless surround sound. The effort put into the film’s audiovisual presentation does not go unnoticed, making it a treat for home video enthusiasts seeking reference quality visuals and sound. The supplemental materials provided prove to be a worthy addition, offering a glimpse behind the scenes of this visually stunning, albeit narratively flawed, cinematic endeavor.
In conclusion, while "Mortal Engines" may falter as a potential franchise starter due to its narrative weaknesses and lackluster character development, its 4K UHD Blu-ray release stands as a remarkable example of home entertainment technology. Universal's meticulous attention to audiovisual quality and detailed extras make it a must-own for collectors and enthusiasts eager to explore the film’s technical merits. Despite the film's missed opportunities in storytelling, this release serves as a compelling reason to experience or revisit "Mortal Engines" from a new perspective, offering a spectacular home viewing experience that partially redeems its theatrical shortcomings.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 100
Add to this the benefit of HDR and the WCG and you have something really special; all the primaries come off well and when they are on screen together, such as inside St. Pauls, it is spectacular....
Audio: 90
The surrounds and overhead channels are used extensively throughout, the various battle scenes are clear examples, but in lesser moments, such as being trapped in a room of a mechanical caterpillar or...
Extras: 50
Welcome to London – A 25 minute feature split into 5 parts, each telling a different part of the construction of this major set, titles are: Building the Beast, Levels of London, The Smallest Details,...
Movie: 50
There are a number of story threads that make up the narrative; that of Hester trying to kill Thaddeus in revenge for killing her mother, Shrike (a Terminator-like cyborg) tracking Hester to convert her...
Total: 50
Mortal Engines comes from the successful LotR writing/producing team of Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens and Peter Jackson, but in the hands of first time feature director Christian Rivers, what is indisputably...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
The shot is also a good point of reference for the Dolby Vision color grading, which can leave some skin tones appearing more pasty in certain scenes but also increasing brightness while adding depth and...
Audio: 100
Whether large-scale action scenes in which London absorbs smaller cities and aircraft zip about or less dramatic but no less sonically enticing moments when PA announcements direct new London arrivals...
Extras: 90
Character Series (1080p): Brief introductions to several of the film's main characters, built through interviews, behind-the-scenes footage, and clips from the film....
Movie: 50
Where the film finds its problem is that while its vision of the fantastic may be exclusive to it, audiences can only see so many films with their own take on the "fantastic" before it all begins to feel...
Total: 60
The film is far from a train wreck, but it's also not the franchise-starter the filmmakers and studios certainly envisioned it to be....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 100
Visual effects earn their wow factor, although a touch of aliasing does slip in at times; CG is rendered at 2K, and the upscale becomes visible....
Audio: 100
The finale mixes it all together, with booming explosions and rear channels picking up flying ships scattering about the field....
Extras: 60
A 26-minute making of focuses primarily on Mortal Engines’ design splits into five parts, involving all manner of people, including Peter Jackson....
Movie: 40
That such a city even has space or care for a museum is bizarre enough, but that idea of caring about the past in apocalyptic circumstance never finds a foothold in the story....
Total: 75
...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 96
The 1080p transfer looks solid and this Ultra HD rendering takes it up a notch with a discernible increase in detail, and emboldened highlights, both light and dark....
Audio: 94
This is done well when implemented and creates an enriching level of immersion that coincides with the onscreen events nicely....
Extras: 80
Disc 1: Mortal Engines Ultra HD Blu-ray Disc 2: Mortal Engines Blu-ray Welcome to London (Five-Part Making Of): Building the Beast Levels of London The Smallest Details London Museum Medusa and St. Paul’s...
Movie: 50
A mysterious young woman named Hester Shaw leads a band of outcasts in the fight to stop London – now a giant predator city on wheels – from devouring everything in its path.”...
Total: 80
It comes to Ultra HD Blu-ray from Universal Pictures Home Entertainment in this Ultra HD Combo Pack featuring an excellent Ultra HD video rendering (which includes Dolby Vision HDR) that makes the most...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
Black Levels: Blacks are quite impressive here as they hold onto a vast array of detail and really bring forth the shades and wow with the amount of textures and follicles visible in any given sense of...
Audio: 100
Low Frequency Extension: This adventure really booms as engines are a constant big hum, but you also get blasts, gunfire, crashing, explosions, lightning, energy beams and more that really get your subwoofer...
Extras: 70
Mortal Engines comes with the Blu-ray edition and a digital copy of the film.4K UHDAudio CommentaryBy Director Christian RiversWelcome to London (4K, 26:22) – Hosted by star Robert Sheehan, this 5-part...
Movie: 70
It has a tremendous touch when it comes to the computer effects and world building that feel a great marriage of fantasy but also real at the same time, with costuming that really compliments it as well....
Total: 80
The image looks outstanding and is quite the jump from the standard Blu-ray and the Atmos track is expert work in terms of effectiveness and precision....
Director: Christian Rivers
Actors: Hera Hilmar, Robert Sheehan, Hugo Weaving
PlotIn a post-apocalyptic world ravaged by a catastrophic event known as the Sixty Minute War, humankind has adapted to a new way of life on moving cities. These massive mobile metropolises roam the earth, engaging in a survival of the fittest paradigm known as "Municipal Darwinism," where larger predator cities hunt and absorb smaller traction towns for resources. On one of these behemoth roving cities, the great traction city of London, a young apprentice historian named Tom Natsworthy encounters a mysterious, scarred woman named Hester Shaw. Hester harbors a deep-seated hatred for Thaddeus Valentine, London's revered Head of the Guild of Historians, and attempts to assassinate him, leading to a tumultuous chain of events.
The chaos of the failed assassination attempt causes Tom and Hester to be expelled from the moving city, forcing them to form an unlikely alliance in the perilous Outlands, the vast static remains of the world that predated the roving cities. Together, they discover a conspiracy that threatens the very existence of their world. With the dangers of the Outland and vengeful parties in pursuit, they embark on a quest across the desolate landscapes, encountering disparate societies, and uncovering the relics of the ancient world that hold the secrets to a power capable of changing the future of civilization.
Writers: Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, Peter Jackson
Release Date: 14 Dec 2018
Runtime: 128 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, New Zealand, Japan, China
Language: English