A Simple Life Blu-ray Review
Tao jie
Score: 55
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
With its genuine warmth and affecting drama, 'A Simple Life' is an exceptionally nuanced film showcasing indelible human bonds, presented on Blu-ray with excellent video and audio.
Disc Release Date
Video: 69
A Simple Life's AVC-encoded 1080p Blu-ray transfer by Well Go USA, with precise detail and clean imaging, maintains Hui's intended muted browns and beiges. Despite some minor banding in transitions and shadow crush, it remains one of Well Go USA's most elegant and crisp presentations.
Audio: 64
A Simple Life's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track offers artful and subtle channelization, delivering clear dialogue and minimal, effective ambient sound, perfectly complementing the film's intimate and subdued nature, despite low-end sonics being nearly non-existent.
Extra: 6
Extras on the Blu-ray of 'A Simple Life' are limited to a single theatrical trailer, available in both 1080p and SD formats, spanning approximately two minutes.
Movie: 76
"A Simple Life" eschews conventional cinematic formulas to deliver a heartfelt, profound exploration of caregiving and human connection. Anchored by the incredible performance of Deannie Yip, the film captures nuanced emotions through simple yet powerful storytelling, rendered beautifully on Blu-ray by Well Go USA.
Video: 69
Well Go USA's Blu-ray release of "A Simple Life" comes with a commendable AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. This release appears to utilize the same transfer as the British Blu-ray version, delivering a superbly clear and sharply defined image that features an abundance of fine detail, particularly in close-ups—a visual choice favored by director Ann Hui. While the film’s aesthetic predominantly revolves around muted palettes of browns and beiges, contributing to a somewhat understated visual presentation, this transfer does justice to Hui's intentional drab cinematography, rendering it with elegance and precision.
Despite being shot digitally, the transfer manages to avoid the significant flatness often associated with Red One shot features. Instead, it offers a well-rounded texture that enhances the tactile quality of facial lines, hair, and clothing textures, making them appear almost tangible. Although the colors might seem a bit muted and blacks not as deep as expected, the overall detail remains impressive. Some minor issues do persist; specifically, there is occasional crush in darker scenes and slight banding during transitions between scenes. However, these elements do not significantly detract from the viewing experience.
This transfer is not designed to dazzle videophiles looking for a high-octane display of color and contrast but serves its purpose admirably by staying true to the film's subdued aesthetic. It is a solid entry in Well Go USA's catalog, delivering a clean and precise visual representation that should satisfy the broader audience. Overall, "A Simple Life" on Blu-ray is a thoughtfully executed presentation that respects the director's vision while offering nearly flawless detail and clarity.
Audio: 64
The audio presentation of "A Simple Life" on Blu-ray features a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that, while not overwhelmingly immersive, is effectively crafted to support the film's intimate and subdued nature. The film, characterized by its quiet and dialogue-heavy scenes, utilizes discrete channelization for ambient environmental effects that provide a pleasing depth, particularly noticeable in the hospital and nursing home settings. Dialogue is presented with impeccable clarity, and the minimalistic score generously extends into the surround channels, adding to the overall atmospheric experience. Additionally, a standard Dolby Digital 2.0 track is available as an audio option for those preferring a simpler configuration.
Given the film’s conversational style, the rear speakers are sparingly engaged, which aligns well with the movie’s intent and structure. While there are few moments that necessitate surround sound involvement, such as the movie premiere scene, these are handled adeptly by the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix, providing an authentic and appropriate ambiance. The audio mix’s performance in delivering clear dialogue is commendable, though it should be noted that a few scenes involving Roger's mother suffer from subpar ADR quality.
Bass response is largely absent, aligning with the film’s composition that seldom requires low-end sonics. In fact, the lack of LFE engagement is significant enough to occasionally cause auto-power off and on cycles in some sub-woofers. Despite this, the audio mix aptly mirrors the film’s subdued emotions and intentions, ensuring that it remains true to its core essence without unnecessary embellishments.
Extras: 6
The extras included in the Blu-ray of "A Simple Life" provide a limited yet noteworthy enhancement to the viewing experience. The trailers offer a succinct and engaging preview of the film, though the lack of additional in-depth features may leave enthusiasts wanting more. The presence of trailers in both SD and HD formats ensures that the primary allure remains accessible regardless of one's viewing setup. The theatrical trailer encapsulates the essence of the film effectively, delivering a concise teaser that serves to heighten interest and anticipation for the full feature.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer (1080p; 2:14): Provides a crisp, high-definition preview of the film.
- Trailer (SD, 2 min.): Offers the same engaging preview in standard definition.
Movie: 76
"A Simple Life" transcends traditional cinematic formulas, delivering a heartfelt narrative that resonates deeply with anyone who has experienced caregiving or the loss of a loved one. The film centers on Ah Tao (Deannie Yip), a long-serving maid who has been dedicated to a single family for over four generations, and her charge, Roger (Andy Lau), a filmmaker. When Ah Tao suffers a stroke, she selflessly decides to move into a nursing home to avoid burdening Roger. The story explores the quiet yet profound transitions both characters undergo as they adjust to new realities. The film shuns forced melodramatics and clichéd misunderstandings, opting instead for a genuine portrayal of mutual respect and love between two people. The narrative’s simplicity is its strength, quietly summoning deep emotions through subtle gestures and interactions.
The poignant relationship between Ah Tao and Roger takes center stage, offering a candid look into their lives without succumbing to dramatic contrivances. Both characters evolve uniquely—Ah Tao adapting to her new life in a nursing home, while Roger learns to navigate his world without Ah Tao's daily support. Their interactions are tender and authentic, capturing the essence of human compassion and duty. Anchored by superb performances, particularly from Deannie Yip, the film encapsulates a lifetime of shared emotions through almost imperceptible yet powerful moments.
In essence, "A Simple Life" is a testament to the enduring bonds of kinship and the inherent dignity in caregiving. It’s a film that eloquently captures the cyclical nature of caring, portraying the graceful acceptance of life's later stages with dignity and grace. Far from wallowing in sentimentality, it celebrates the simple, humane acts that define our most important relationships.
Total: 55
"A Simple Life" is a quiet, bittersweet drama that captures the profound bond between two individuals connected by decades of shared history. The film skillfully avoids drifting into melodrama, instead opting for a genuinely warm, life-affirming narrative that invokes a deep sense of empathy and introspection. The relationship at the core of the story is profoundly touching, depicting the undying dedication and mutual respect that can develop between two people over a lifetime. It's a film designed to evoke emotion, bringing a lump to the throat while affirming the subtle beauty found in human connections.
Visually, the Blu-ray excels with outstanding video quality that brings the carefully composed scenes to life with clarity and detail. The audio presentation is equally impressive, delivering dialogue and ambient sounds with precision, enhancing the film's immersive and intimate atmosphere. Although the Blu-ray lacks substantial supplemental features, the superb quality of the main content compensates for this shortcoming.
In conclusion, "A Simple Life" may have moments where a tighter edit could benefit its pacing. However, its affecting portrayal of human relationships and poignant narrative makes it a compelling watch. The Blu-ray's excellent technical presentation only serves to heighten the movie's emotional impact. This release is highly recommended for those seeking a genuinely heartfelt cinematic experience devoid of modern-day pessimism.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
A Simple Life is intentionally rather drab looking quite a bit of the time, with an emphasis on browns and beiges that mean there isn't a lot of "wow" inducing palette here that the high definition presentation...
Audio: 80
A Simple Life is by its very nature a rather quiet, subdued film, and so there's not a whole heck of a lot that the lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track has to offer in terms of overwhelming immersive...
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 80
A Simple Life is in fact rather simple on its face, a slow but steady examination of two people coming face to face with what they've meant to and for each other, but the film is also devastatingly profound,...
Total: 80
A Simple Life might have benefited from a little judicious cutting, but even at its slightly bloated feeling running time, it's an often extremely affecting and effective drama showing the last "dance"...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Even though the fine detail shines through in well-lit scenes, there are some darker scenes that feature some crush from flatter shadows....
Audio: 80
The few scenes, like a movie premiere that Roger takes Ah to, require there to be some nice ambient sound....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 80
They never find themselves bickering simply because that's what a movie script is supposed to do at the end of the second act....
Total: 60
The phrase "breath of fresh air" is thrown around a lot in movie reviewing, but I'd have to say if I were to apply that saying to any movie this would be it....
Director: Ann Hui
Actors: Andy Lau, Deannie Ip, Hailu Qin
PlotRoger is a successful Hong Kong film producer who has been cared for by Ah Tao, an elderly housemaid, for over sixty years. Ah Tao has served Roger's family dutifully across multiple generations, effectively becoming a vital part of their lives. One day, Ah Tao suffers a stroke, prompting her decision to retire and move into a nursing home. Roger, recognizing her lifetime of dedication and care, steps in to ensure that she receives the best possible attention and adjusts his life to support her in this new chapter.
As Roger becomes increasingly involved in Ah Tao's care, their relationship deepens, allowing him to see beyond her role as a servant and appreciate her as an individual with her own rich history and experiences. He visits her frequently and involves her in important family gatherings, acknowledging her importance beyond the professional realm. Through this process, Roger's own perspectives on life and family are challenged and transformed, revealing underlying themes of gratitude, respect, and the redefinition of familial bonds. The story poignantly examines the long-lasting impact of a caregiver and the reciprocation of care when the roles are reversed, offering a heartfelt exploration of mutual dependency and respect between two deeply connected individuals.
Writers: Susan Chan, Susan Chan, Gustave Flaubert
Release Date: 09 Mar 2012
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Cantonese, English, Mandarin