5-25-77 Blu-ray Review
Score: 70
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
5-25-77 is a heartfelt ode to cinema with solid technical merits; an enjoyable watch despite a few minor missteps. Highly recommended.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/344c7/344c7e4f133f607c9fa199f72228548ef86a0d4b" alt="5-25-77 Blu-ray Front Cover"
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
The Blu-ray of '5-25-77' presents an engaging, mixed-media journey with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer that plays with varied aspect ratios and uses a range of filming technologies. The result is a nostalgic yet stable presentation, rich in primary colors and contrast, with minor grain artifacts enhancing its cinematic ethos.
Audio: 74
5-25-77 offers a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and LPCM 2.0 track delivering unexpected audio quality for its budget, with a spacious score by David E. Russo and intermittent immersion via ambient effects. Dialogue is crisp, and the stereo split and frequent rear activation enhance the engaging auditory experience.
Extra: 46
Engage with insightful content including an audio commentary featuring director Patrick Read Johnson and moderator Seth Gaven, an extensive 52:43 Q&A from the 2013 Fantasia Film Festival, and a series of high-definition photo galleries, all beautifully packaged with a slipcover.
Movie: 71
5-25-77 is a heartfelt, autobiographical journey capturing Patrick Read Johnson's turbulent, ADD-riddled creative mind and deep geek persecution complex, resonating with inveterate movie lovers through its sweet nostalgia and earnest portrayal of cinema's transformative power amid uneven pacing and digital compositing flaws.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2b2cc/2b2cc9080010215c816d97adcf7cb0c140e39aa9" alt="Loading"
Video: 79
The Blu-ray presentation of "5-25-77" by MVD Visual offers a fascinating and varied visual experience. With an AVC encoded 1080p transfer, the film predominantly uses a 1.78:1 aspect ratio but plays with others such as 2.05:1 for specific narrative elements, showcasing the protagonist's whimsical journey. The eclectic use of technology ranging from Arriflex to Panavision, and digital capture with the Red Dragon, underscores the production’s creative tapestry. Although there is a noticeable grain field throughout, which may be real or digitally simulated, the transfer handles it adeptly, preserving the nostalgic cinematographic ethos. Clarity and detail fluctuate in service to the film's stylistic goals, balanced by a nuanced approach to palette saturation and color grading.
The mixed-media approach with formats from digital to 8mm presents challenges that the disc mostly overcomes. Grain maintains cohesion, imparting a tangible texture to facial and other details. While certain scenes retain the grit that can introduce artifacts, stability endures across the board. A slight amber grade imbues a vintage warmth, with restrained yet enriched colors and strong primary tones, maintaining notably realistic flesh tones. The contrast remains excellent, enlivening the image, while black levels exhibit minimal crush that remains largely insignificant to the overall viewing experience. The transfer triumphs as a visual homage to its cinematic inspirations, capturing the nostalgic essence with dedication and precision.
Audio: 74
The audio presentation of the Blu-Ray for "5-25-77" encompasses DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and LPCM 2.0 stereo options, delivering an engaging auditory experience that exceeds expectations given its budget constraints. The DTS-HD 5.1 track excels with its ability to create a spacious soundscape, largely propelled by David E. Russo's impressive score. While the immersion provided by ambient environmental effects is somewhat periodic, it enhances both interior and outdoor scenes effectively. Dialogue is consistently rendered with clarity and precision, ensuring seamless narrative delivery.
The LPCM 2.0 stereo track also performs admirably, with a commendable stereo split that broadens the sound field. It utilizes rear channels efficiently, creating intricate layers of sound that enlivens various scenes, such as those taking place in school halls or faux movie moments where audio dynamically moves around the listener. The activation of the rear channels contributes significantly to the fun, immersive quality of the viewing experience. Optional English subtitles further support accessibility without detracting from the audio quality.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras for "5-25-77" provide a rich, engaging exploration of the film's development and insights into both the creative process and personal journeys of the cast and crew. Patrick Read Johnson's audio commentary, moderated by Seth Gaven, offers a deep dive into the film's creation, rendering it essential for enthusiasts and aspiring filmmakers. The 2013 Fantasia Film Festival Q&A provides an in-depth discussion reflective of the audience's curiosity and the director's passion. Accompanying photo galleries showcase a visual narrative of the cast and crew, filming locations, and detailed miniatures used in the production. Packaged with a slipcover, these features enhance the physical experience of owning this Blu-ray.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Conversation with director Patrick Read Johnson and moderator Seth Gaven.
- 2013 Fantasia Film Festival Q&A: Discussion with director Patrick Read Johnson post-screening.
- Cast and Crew Photo Gallery: Visual collection of the team behind the movie.
- Locations Photo Gallery: Display of filming sites.
- Miniatures Photo Gallery: Images of miniatures featured in production.
Movie: 71
"5-25-77" offers a sincere and heartfelt cinematographic journey through the formative years of filmmaker Patrick Read Johnson as depicted by John Francis Daley. The film is a reflective autobiographical piece capturing the young filmmaker's ambitious but whimsical mindset, which resonates with themes of nostalgia and passion for cinema. Johnson's narrative intertwines his obsession with iconic films such as "Star Wars," while accentuating the deep-rooted impact of "2001: A Space Odyssey" in his life and creative process. The film's narrative mirrors Spielberg's style in "The Fabelmans," without concealing the real names, providing an unfiltered glimpse into Johnson's authentic childhood experiences and familial dynamics.
The film effectively encapsulates the era’s ethos, centered around a small-town high schooler marginalized for his geeky obsessions. It poignantly portrays Patrick's struggles and societal alienation pre-"Star Wars," juxtaposing that with his adventurous spirit nudged by supportive but flawed family relationships. While occasionally hampered by uneven performances and technical inconsistencies—such as subpar digital compositing—the film thrives on its emotional sincerity and genuine affection for film culture. Patrick's Los Angeles journey, interacting with industry veterans, delineates a quintessential bildungsroman layered with pop culture icons and personal introspection, deepened by his mother's encouragement and a complicated romance with his dream crush, Linda.
Ultimately, despite its imperfections like pacing issues or overreliance on cultural references, "5-25-77" succeeds in an earnest portrayal of creative passion and personal growth. It ventures deep into the psyche of an artist who finds solace and belonging in movie theaters—a sentiment epitomized by Johnson’s yearning for connection and understanding through cinema’s transcendent power. Its authenticity and distinct period ambiance remain inviting for fellow cinephiles who find solace in the unpretentious joy and familial complexities depicted therein, ensuring its relevance alongside other cinematic autobiographies.
Total: 70
"5-25-77" is a heartfelt cinematic venture that resonates with both movie enthusiasts and budding filmmakers. The Blu-ray release encapsulates the film's essence through impressive technical merits. Video quality offers a clear, crisp presentation with vibrant colors that stay true to the film’s nostalgic vibe, reflecting the late 1970s era authentically. The audio tracks are well-mixed, providing an immersive soundscape that complements the on-screen events. The special features, especially Patrick Read Johnson’s commentary, offer considerable insights into the thematic ambitions and the exhaustive journey behind bringing this personal narrative to fruition.
The film’s storytelling is both a strength and a slight drawback. While the passion and enthusiasm are palpable, a smattering of narrative missteps could have been refined for a more cohesive viewing experience. However, Johnson’s commitment shines through, creating a work that is as much an ode to moviemaking as it is to cinema audiences. The Blu-ray ensures an engaging experience, providing viewers with various angles to appreciate the director's homage to his own youthful aspirations and influences.
In conclusion, "5-25-77" stands as a cinematic love letter, celebrating both film and its audiences with genuine affection. Despite some minor hiccups in pacing or structure, Johnson delivers a story suffused with heart and determination. The Blu-ray’s technical aspects and insightful commentary enrich the experience, making "5-25-77" a captivating addition to any movie lover’s collection. Highly recommended for those who cherish the art of filmmaking and the impact of cinema on our lives.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
A rather wide variety of technologies was utilized for all of this imagery, and while the IMDb lists everything from Arriflex to Canon to Sony to GAF to Panavision cameras, with assorted millimeters ranging...
Audio: 80
A rather nice score by David E. Russo definitely attains greater spaciousness in the surround track, but the 5.1 track also offers some good if admittedly intermittent immersion courtesy of ambient environmental...
Extras: 40
2013 Fantasia Film Festival Q & A with director Patrick Read Johnson (HD; 52:43) occurred after a screening in Canada....
Movie: 90
A Space Odyssey Blu-ray review, but kind of hilariously one thing I left out of that review that is more or less depicted in this film is that some folks actually fell asleep during Dave's journey to the...
Total: 90
It may be the time of year when people's tastes are more attuned to turkey than to candy and flowers, but I have to say 5-25-77 is about as big of a Valentine's Day love letter to not just movies, but...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
Hazier, nostalgic cinematography can take visual bite in typical terms, but it’s pleasing overall in the effect....
Audio: 80
Extras: 60
...
Movie: 60
Autobiographical, Patrick Read Johnson spent well over a decade trying to piece this project together and even still, the look is that of something stitched up, at times incomplete, and that’s why it’s...
Total: 70
Director: Patrick Read Johnson
Actors: John Francis Daley, Austin Pendleton, Kevin Rosendo
PlotIn a small town during the late 1970s, a young aspiring filmmaker named Pat is captivated by the world of movies, dreaming of creating his own cinematic masterpiece. Despite the lack of resources and the skepticism from those around him, Pat remains undeterred as he immerses himself in the art of filmmaking, crafting homemade movies with his closest friends. His passion is fueled by visits to a dilapidated local theater and an insatiable thirst for film knowledge. As high school graduation approaches, Pat's ambitions are met with the harsh reality of leaving his hometown and saying goodbye to his loved ones, including the girl he secretly admires. Torn between chasing his dreams and staying put, Pat's life is poised for change when he receives an unexpected invitation to visit Hollywood and meet some industry icons.
Encouraged by his resolute mother, Pat embarks on an unforgettable road trip to Los Angeles, where he encounters both challenges and breakthroughs that test his resolve to become a filmmaker. The trip exposes him to the glimmers of potential fame and fortune but also reveals the disparate nature of Hollywood's glamorous exterior and its underlying struggles. On this journey, Pat forms connections with other dreamers like himself, learning lessons about creativity, collaboration, and self-discovery. However, back home, uncertain relationships and unanswered questions linger on the horizon. Pat's journey reaches a pivotal point as he grapples with the defining moment of seizing his dreams or facing the chance they might fade into obscurity, venturing forward with newfound inspiration and an unshakable belief in himself.
Writers: Patrick Read Johnson
Release Date: 25 May 2007
Runtime: 132 min
Rating: N/A
Country: United States
Language: English