The Front Page Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The 1931 version of 'The Front Page' stands as the most authentic adaptation, with exceptional visual quality on Blu-ray, though the audio shows its age.
Disc Release Date
Video: 66
The Blu-ray of 'The Front Page' offers the best visual experience since its initial release, with a 1080p transfer in a 1.33:1 aspect ratio. Despite age-related issues like scratches and judder, the AVC encoded image boasts adequate clarity, impressive detail, strong black levels, and well-preserved film grain.
Audio: 41
The 2.0 LPCM Mono mix of 'The Front Page' shows marked signs of age, with intermittent pops, hiss, and inconsistent levels necessitating occasional volume adjustments. While dialogue largely remains clear and intelligible, the audio track's overall quality is hindered by sporadic drops and mild damage.
Extra: 56
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Front Page' include engaging radio adaptations from 1937 and 1946, featuring notable performances by Walter Winchell, James Gleeson, Adolphe Menjou, and Pat O'Brien, complemented by Bret Wood's insightful commentary and a brief yet informative mini-documentary on film preservation by the Library of Congress.
Movie: 86
1931's 'The Front Page' stands as a timeless classic with its incisive look at journalism and sharp satire, perfectly balanced through Lewis Milestone's direction and standout performances from Adolphe Menjou and Pat O'Brien. This Blu-ray debut by Kino Lorber, preserved by the National Film Registry, is an essential addition for any cinephile.
Video: 66
The video presentation of "The Front Page" on Blu-ray showcases the film in what is likely its best condition since the initial theatrical release. Encoded with AVC and presented in a 1.32:1 aspect ratio, the image maintains adequate clarity with welcoming details, despite encountering focus issues and period-specific limitations inherent to the 1931 production. The picture benefits from secure contrast and preserved filmic textures, with delineation being spot-on. While the source material does show its age with extensive scratches, judder, and occasional chemical burn marks, these imperfections are handled with care, ensuring they are not overly distracting. The transfer effectively balances between preserving authenticity and ensuring a visually pleasing experience.
Struck from 35mm preservation elements, the 1.33:1 1080p transfer offers impressive detail levels that elevate the viewing experience. The image retains a respectable amount of film grain, which enhances the individuality and characteristics of the characters in the newsroom. Black levels are robust for the most part, though they occasionally falter due to replacement elements from different sources. While there is some speckling, scratches, and occasional haziness, these are forgivable considering the film's age. Overall, this Blu-ray transfer brings "The Front Page" to life in an admirable fashion, potentially only surpassed by a prohibitively expensive and meticulous restoration effort.
Audio: 41
The 2.0 LPCM audio track of the Blu-ray for "The Front Page" reflects its age with notable wear and tear. While mild hiss, pops, and occasional inconsistencies in volume levels are evident, the overall intelligibility of dialogue remains adequate. Exchanges between characters, though thin and crispy at times, support the performances without losing essential timing or emphasis. Music tends to sound muffled but retains a degree of definition that is acceptable given the circumstances.
Despite these limitations, the track manages to capture some resonance in sound effects, notably with elements like the hangman's test bag. However, audio levels can fluctuate dramatically from one scene to another. This requires active volume adjustments to maintain a consistent listening experience. Although problematic at times, these issues do not completely undermine the soundtrack's effectiveness, but they do prevent it from reaching higher quality standards. Overall, while the LPCM 2.0 Mono track provides a functional and mostly clear audio experience, it's held back by aging artifacts and inconsistent levels that necessitate some manual intervention.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray edition of "The Front Page" presents a robust set of extras that enrich the viewing experience with historical insights and behind-the-scenes content. The two radio adaptations from 1937 and 1946 are standout features, providing nostalgic auditory experiences with performances from notable actors such as Walter Winchell, James Gleeson, Adolphe Menjou, and Pat O'Brien. Film Historian Bret Wood contributes an engaging audio commentary that delves into the production's history, highlights differences between stage and screen versions, and shares intriguing anecdotes. Moreover, the Library of Congress mini-documentary elucidates the meticulous process of film preservation, spotlighting "The Front Page" and its addition to the National Film Registry in 2010.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Bret Wood discusses production history, adaptation differences, and fun anecdotes.
- Lux Radio Theater - 1937: Audio adaptation hosted by Cecil B. DeMille, with Walter Winchell and James Gleeson.
- Academy Award - 1946: Radio adaptation starring Adolphe Menjou and Pat O'Brien.
- On Film Preservation: The Library of Congress: Insight into film preservation processes.
Movie: 86
1931’s “The Front Page”, directed by Lewis Milestone, remains a quintessential classic in cinema history, having secured its place in the National Film Registry in 2010. This film ingeniously adapts a popular Broadway play with finesse and speed, embodying a screwball tone that overlays the grim realities of sensational journalism and the lure of personal corruption. While some comedic elements may not resonate as freshly today, the sharp, finger-snap timing, and bellowed performances from stars like Adolphe Menjou, Pat O'Brien, and Mary Brian spotlight a witty, satirical take on journalism’s transformation. The narrative balance between demoralizing routine and a pursuit of justice ensures the film's relevance even in the modern era.
Milestone’s film introduces us to ace reporter Hildy Johnson (Pat O'Brien), who’s ready to leave his high-pressure job for an adman's gig in New York, away from the manipulative grasp of his editor, Walter Burns (Adolphe Menjou). Yet, when convicted murderer Earl Williams escapes moments before his execution, Hildy’s plans are thwarted by an opportunity for an irresistible scoop. The film's dynamic plot is driven by Hildy's moral struggle and his editor's relentless schemes. The constant tension between professional duties and personal aspirations underscores how news media can be a stage for both heroics and manipulations. The timeless nature of this story is evidenced by its numerous adaptations across films, radio shows, and stage productions.
"The Front Page" earned three Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture and Best Actor for Adolphe Menjou. Written by Bartlett Cormack, based on the stage play by Ben Hecht and Charles MacArthur, and buoyed by Lewis Milestone’s effective direction, this film stands out with its clever dialogue and memorable characters. The restoration of this classic on Blu-ray by Kino Lorber represents a significant preservation effort, making it readily accessible for future generations to appreciate.
Total: 57
The Blu-ray release of "The Front Page" offers a virtually timeless viewing experience, reflecting the film's enduring quality. The 1931 version directed by Lewis Milestone stands as the most authentic adaptation of the original play, possessing an acute sense of the era and an inherent wit. Although various subsequent remakes, such as the 1974 Billy Wilder adaptation and 1988's Switching Channels, have presented their unique takes on the source material, none capture the original's pure essence quite like this classic. Viewers will appreciate the formidable performances and sharp script that have cemented this film as a revered piece of cinema history.
Visually, Kino Lorber's Blu-ray transfer is stunning, bringing out the crispness and detail expected from high-definition restoration. The picture quality presents clarity and richness that breathes new life into the film's historical setting. However, it should be noted that the age of the original audio elements does show some wear, detracting slightly from the overall aural experience. Despite this, the disc includes a collection of valuable extras that give further context and appreciation for the film, enhancing its appeal for both new viewers and long-time fans.
In conclusion, "The Front Page" Blu-ray is a standout release retaining its classic charm while benefitting from modern restoration techniques. Although not without minor flaws in audio fidelity due to the age of the source material, it remains an essential addition for any serious collector. Its faithful representation of Ben Hecht and Charles MacArthur's legendary play makes this Blu-ray not only a purchase but an investment in cinematic history.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
Nothing is distracting, with the overall visual push of "The Front Page" secured with as much care as possible, stopping just short of a meticulous, cripplingly expensive restoration....
Audio: 70
Dialogue exchanges are thin and crispy, but never completely lost, supporting performances with adequate intelligibility, preserving timing and emphasis....
Extras: 60
A discussion of "The Front Page" is included, with a print acquired from East Germany in 1970....
Movie: 80
It's easy to see why the feature was picked, presenting a sharp, incisive look at journalism of the day, finding its depiction of sensationalism and the lure of personal corruption still resonate in 2015....
Total: 80
The 1931 version of "The Front Page" appears to be the most pure representation of the play, remaining in the era depicted, giving it special insight and realism that's buttered up with a distinct sense...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The only way this film could possibly look any better is through some kind of extensive restoration effort - and since this film is part of the National Film Registry, that could well be a possibility....
Audio: 40
With only mild hiss and popping, the audio track is for the most part very strong as much of the dialogue can be clearly heard and sound effects like the hangman's test bag have some impressive resonance....
Extras: 60
Film Historian Bret Wood provides a solid commentary track that goes through the history of the production, adaptation differences from stage to screen, and provides a number of fun anecdotes....
Movie: 100
While just about every adaptation of this film has something of value and is worth a watch in its own right, it's difficult to watch those versions and not come back to the original film production of...
Total: 60
With a great cast and a razor sharp script, the film is a joy from start to finish, and is a genuine classic....
Director: Lewis Milestone
Actors: Adolphe Menjou, Pat O'Brien, Mary Brian
PlotReporter Hildy Johnson is eager to leave his job at the newspaper to get married and settle down. However, his manipulative editor, Walter Burns, is determined to keep him at the paper, especially with the imminent execution of Earl Williams, a convict whose story could sell a lot of newspapers. As Hildy tries to bid farewell to his journalistic career, he stumbles upon a twist in the Williams case that could dramatically change the convict's fate. The discovery pulls Hildy back into the chaotic world of headlines and deadlines, much to the delight of Walter, who seizes every opportunity to keep Hildy entrenched in the newsroom.
Amidst the frenetic efforts to secure an exclusive scoop, Hildy maneuvers through a labyrinth of deception and double-crosses, while trying to maintain his promise to his fiancée and her disapproving mother. Complications escalate as corrupt politicians and hapless law enforcement officers contribute to the pandemonium surrounding the impending execution. The tension mounts as Hildy struggles to balance his loyalty to his profession with his desire for a new life. The gripping pace and swirling events lead to a crescendo that tests Hildy's resolve and underscores the moral complexities inherent in the pursuit of truth and justice.
Writers: Ben Hecht, Charles MacArthur, Bartlett Cormack
Release Date: 04 Apr 1931
Runtime: 101 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English