The Indian Fighter Blu-ray Review
Score: 46
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Entertaining Western with stunning CinemaScope visuals and a gritty Kirk Douglas, 'The Indian Fighter' is a pleasantly surprising genre film with a solid A/V presentation.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 58
The AVC encoded 1080p transfer of The Indian Fighter (2.35:1 aspect ratio) delivers a lively HD presentation with bold colors and consistent black levels, capturing the CinemaScope expanse and thespian presence, despite some period cinematography limitations and minor image quality issues like scene dissolves and intermittent specs.
Audio: 38
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA audio mix of 'The Indian Fighter' is functional with noticeable hiss and varying volume levels, requiring adjustments; the score and sound effects are adequate but not exceptional.
Extra: 36
The Blu-ray extras of 'The Indian Fighter' include a valuable and intriguing commentary by film historian Toby Roan and a notable theatrical trailer in standard definition, providing a comprehensive and enriching addition to the film.
Movie: 56
1955's 'The Indian Fighter' offers an early attempt at a revisionist Western, starring Kirk Douglas whose energetic performance shines amidst stunning CinemaScope visuals. Despite struggling with clichés and an underdeveloped love story, the film is noted for its sympathetic view of Native Americans and solid supporting cast.
Video: 58
The AVC encoded image (2.35:1 aspect ratio) presentation of "The Indian Fighter" on Blu Ray offers a vibrant viewing experience, particularly considering the film's age. While it may not be the sharpest transfer due to period cinematography limitations, the CinemaScope expanse and thespian presence are well-handled, adding texture to the location shooting and costuming. Rare close-up shots are effectively utilized, with colors that are bold and lively, capturing the essential visual elements of the Oregon setting. Reds and greens stand out, despite some minor fading, adding to the overall appeal.
Presented in 1080p, the transition to high definition reveals fine film grain throughout, with only occasional specs disrupting the clarity. Black levels remain mostly consistent, contributing to a fresh and dynamic color palette. Scene dissolves present some minor quality drops, but wide-angle shots are particularly impressive, featuring lush mountainous backgrounds that evoke a grand, matte painting-like aesthetic. The source material is in decent condition without overt damage, ensuring an immersive viewing experience.
Audio: 38
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA audio mix of "The Indian Fighter" presents a utilitarian listening experience. While handling the dramatic elements of war and journey competently, it falls short of being distinctive. Persistent hiss throughout the track compromises the overall clarity, and the volume is notably lower than standard, necessitating frequent manual adjustments to maintain audio balance. The musical score, while fulfilling its purpose, lacks the pristine quality one might expect, though it provides an acceptable underpinning to the film’s dynamic sequences.
Sound effects in this mix are more refined, delivering snappier responses that enhance the immersive experience somewhat. The atmospherics are articulated as intended, contributing positively to the narrative’s ambiance. However, potential inconsistencies in volume levels further highlight the necessity to keep the remote within reach for on-the-fly adjustments. The full spectrum of audio elements is managed competently by the 2.0 DTS-HD MA track, offering an adequate backdrop for "The Indian Fighter's" visual storytelling without reaching exemplary sound quality standards.
Extras: 36
The Blu Ray of "The Indian Fighter" includes a selective yet informative range of extras that will engage both casual viewers and serious cinephiles. The standout feature is the audio commentary from film historian Toby Roan, who provides a deep dive into the film’s production nuances, historical context, and cinematic techniques. This commentary enriches the viewing experience and is highly recommended for those interested in film history. Additionally, the package contains a theatrical trailer, allowing audiences to appreciate the original promotional material in high definition.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary: Film historian Toby Roan offers insightful details about the film’s background and production.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional material presented in high definition.
Movie: 56
1955's "The Indian Fighter" is a fascinating entry in the Western genre's pantheon, marking a period when Hollywood sought to understand, rather than vilify, Native American cultures. Starring Kirk Douglas as trail guide Johnny Hawks, this movie balances his star power with a genuine attempt at moral complexity. The film unfolds as Hawks navigates his role between settlers and the Sioux tribe, delicately handling his affiliations while wrestling with personal conflicts. His evolving relationship with the Chief's daughter Onahti (Elsa Martinelli) adds an additional layer of tension, though it sometimes intrudes on the main storyline focused on peace and conflict resolution.
Director Andre De Toth leverages the magnificent Oregonian landscapes, captured in lush CinemaScope photography, to bolster the narrative. While Douglas’s intense portrayal and physicality add undeniable dynamism to Hawks, the film occasionally succumbs to typical Western movie clichés. The presence of Walter Matthau and Lon Chaney Jr. as antagonistic gold seekers introduces darker elements, challenging Hawks' objectives. Supporting roles played by Diana Douglas and Alan Hale Jr. further enrich the character tapestry, presenting personal stakes amid broader cultural and territorial disputes.
"The Indian Fighter" ventures into early revisionist Western territory with its sympathetic depiction of Native Americans and understated environmental concerns. However, it cannot escape criticisms focused on its sometimes leering focus on Martinelli’s character. De Toth's film ultimately navigates the genre’s familiar terrain while offering glimpses of moral and thematic depth. Though not the pinnacle of Kirk Douglas’s illustrious career, it remains an engaging watch, buoyed by impressive performances and breathtaking scenery.
Total: 46
"The Indian Fighter" on Blu-ray offers an intriguing presentation that melds CinemaScope visuals with traditional Western elements to craft an engaging cinematic experience. The scenic photography captures the vast and rugged beauty of the frontier, emphasizing the grandeur of the West. Anchored by a powerful performance from Kirk Douglas, whose gritty portrayal adds a layer of intensity, the film occasionally sparks with action and drama, maintaining viewer interest through its periodic excitement.
Regarding its technical aspects, the Blu-ray release by Kino stands out for its commendable audio-visual (A/V) quality. The restoration respects the original film's aesthetic, bringing clarity and vibrancy to the CinemaScope visuals and ensuring a pleasing experience for modern viewers. Accompanied by a thought-provoking commentary track, this release delves into the film's production and thematic intricacies, enriching the viewing experience for aficionados and collectors.
In conclusion, "The Indian Fighter" manages to entertain with its blend of action, character-driven narrative, and expansive visuals. While it might not reshape the genre, its message of tolerance and efforts to depict frontier life lend it a certain charm. The Blu-ray edition enhances these attributes with a solid A/V presentation, making it a noteworthy addition to any Western enthusiast's collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
There are period cinematography limitations, and this isn't the sharpest looking feature, but it does fine with CinemaScope expanse and thespian presence, encouraging texture on location shooting and costuming....
Audio: 60
Hiss is present throughout the listening experience, and volume is lower than normal, requiring some dial riding to bring it back to life....
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 60
The effort is appreciated, as director Andre De Toth seems more interested in the feature's heavenly Oregonian locations than the unfolding story, saving a little leer for Martinelli, who spends a good...
Total: 70
Gun fights and CinemaScope sweep charge the viewing experience, and a message of tolerance, however small it ends up being, is worth savoring, with the productions doing what it can to play kindly and...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The Indian Fighter makes the transition to HD with a lively transfer given the film’s age....
Audio: 40
...
Extras: 40
Audio Commentary: Film historian Toby Roan offers an interesting commentary that is worth a listen....
Movie: 60
From leaping onto horseback to ravaging Onahti in a stream, the film is tailored to his strengths and moral dilemmas....
Total: 40
With the CinemaScope photography highlighting the beauty of the West and a gritty Kirk Douglas chewing up the scenery, Kino has resurrected a lovely genre film worth a watch....
Director: André De Toth
Actors: Kirk Douglas, Elsa Martinelli, Walter Matthau
PlotJohnny Hawks, a rugged frontiersman and former scout, returns to the Oregon Territory after the Civil War with aspirations of peace. He agrees to lead a wagon train of settlers through dangerous territory but is quickly drawn into conflict with both white settlers and the Sioux tribe. The Sioux are fiercely protective of their land and led by Chief Red Cloud. Complicating matters, Hawks develops a romantic relationship with Onahti, a beautiful Sioux woman, which stirs tensions among the settlers and the tribal members alike. Emotions run high as misunderstandings and hostile encounters escalate.
As tensions mount, Hawks finds himself in a moral quandary trying to mediate between the settlers who crave expansion and the Native Americans determined to protect their homelands. He uncovers a startling conspiracy involving a pair of unscrupulous gold prospectors seeking to exploit the Sioux land for its resources. This plot discovery intensifies the looming confrontation, and Hawks must navigate dangerous politics and personal loyalties to prevent an all-out war. In doing so, he faces significant challenges that test his bravery, integrity, and commitment to peace.
Writers: Robert L. Richards, Frank Davis, Ben Hecht
Release Date: 27 Feb 1956
Runtime: 88 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English