Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 58
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Enjoyable yet flawed sequels; decent 4K upgrades and solid action, with some standout elements.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 52
Thor: The Dark World's 4K release offers a clear upgrade with HDR/WCG enhancements, despite some softness. Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars struggles with aliasing and lacks 4K rendering, yet shows minor detail improvement.
Audio: 62
The UHD 4K releases of both Thor: The Dark World and Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars enhance audio with Dolby Atmos, delivering cleaner dialogue, impactful effects, and robust scores, though mixed in execution.
Extra: 67
The Blu-ray includes comprehensive extras like commentaries, featurettes, and a look at the film's legacy, while the 4K disc offers minimal content. Features highlight the series' history, character arcs, and technical insights, largely in Japanese with English subs.
Movie: 50
Both *The Dark World* and *Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars* struggle with identity and execution but offer enjoyable elements within their larger franchises.
Video: 52
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars" intriguingly stands as both an improvement and a challenge when juxtaposed against its Blu-ray counterpart. On the positive spectrum, the upgrade to 2160p resolution coupled with HDR/Dolby Vision technology markedly elevates the visual potency of the film. This enhancement is especially apparent in the vividness of colors—Martian landscapes, explosions, and even subtler details like characters' lips are imbued with a depth and vibrancy that far surpass what we've seen on the standard Blu-ray. Additionally, there's a noticeable boost in image sharpness and detail, making textures like skin, Martian terrain, and the iconic power suits of the Mobile Infantry more defined and tactile than before.
However, this leap in visual fidelity is somewhat marred by persistent technical issues. Aliasing, characterized by shimmering and jagged lines, frequently intrudes upon the viewing experience, undermining the otherwise notable clarity offered by the 4K resolution. Scenes abundant with small, intricate details often suffer from this detriment, suggesting potential limitations in the source material's resolution. Despite efforts to mitigate these drawbacks through digital clean-up techniques such as ringing and edge enhancement, these interventions tend to exacerbate rather than alleviate the film's visual shortcomings, leading to a loss in image detail and a somewhat artificial enhancement of sharpness.
Moreover, while HDR colors enhance the visual experience, certain aspects of the film's color design and dynamic range underwhelm. The choice of a drab color palette and muted shadows, presumably to reflect a dusty Martian atmosphere, results in a flat contrast that only marginally benefits from HDR's capability to extend brightness and darkness ranges. This issue is compounded by occasional noise and macroblocking, hinting at constraints within the source material or encoding process. Despite these visual hurdles, the enhanced resolution and color reproduction of the 4K UHD Blu-ray edition do offer a definitive upgrade over its Blu-ray counterpart, albeit with caveats that temper the overall enhancement.
Audio: 62
The audio presentation for "Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars" 4K UHD Blu-ray elevates the auditory experience with a Dolby Atmos track, showcasing a modest but notable improvement over its standard Blu-ray counterpart. This advanced audio mix delivers not only more raw aggression and a fuller acoustic stage but also incorporates scattered, effective use of overhead components to create a more immersive soundscape. While not all elements consistently engage the top layer—most notably in quieter, dialogue-heavy scenes—the mix shines in its handling of dynamic action sequences. Explosions and the roar of spacecraft engines utilize the overhead channels effectively, adding significant depth and dimensionality to the auditory field. Moreover, the staging never feels closed off, maintaining clarity and openness across diversified scenes, from intense battles to more serene moments on Martian landscapes.
Dialogue is consistently clear and well-prioritized, anchored firmly in the central channel, though occasional lip-sync discrepancies are noted. The soundtrack benefits from Bryan Tyler's composition, which, despite its generic leanings, is given ample presence across the soundscape, enriched by a supportive LFE channel that provides a satisfying background thrum. Action set pieces, underscored by the movie's bold score, resonate with added heft in the low-end frequencies, ensuring that each blast and impact feels grounded and impactful. Ships taking hits and missile launches carry a palpable force, demonstrating the mix's effective utilization of bass to lend scale and intensity to the cinematic experience.
Noteworthy is the mix’s active engagement of the soundstage, extensively employing rear channels during high-intensity sequences such as gunfights or alien screeches, effectively capturing the essence of the live-action inspiration. The dynamic range accommodates both ends of the spectrum—from earth-shaking confrontations to subtler atmospheric effects like storm winds—without losing focus on dialogue clarity or spatial positioning. Despite some minor shortcomings in achieving a fully enveloping top-layer experience during quieter moments, "Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars" presents an auditory experience that is as engaging as it is technically proficient, making for a heightened viewing pleasure that audibly distinguishes itself from simpler Blu-ray audio tracks.
Extras: 67
The "Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars" 4K UHD Blu-ray extras, predominantly housed on the accompanying Blu-ray disc, offer an in-depth look into the making and continuation of the Starship Troopers saga. The main draw includes a comprehensive collection of special features that delve into both the legacy of the original film and the specifics of this installment. Notable features include detailed interviews with key franchise figures Casper Van Dien and writer Ed Neumeier, accompanied by insights into character arc developments, design specifics such as the powered suits and bug design tweaks, as well as narrative construction, emphasizing the longstanding and evolving universe of Starship Troopers. The 4K disc itself offers only minimal extras, including a small set of cast and crew photos and demo moments highlighting key characters and action sequences, distinguishing itself with superior visual quality but lacking in substantial content. The collection represents a blend of reverence for the franchise’s roots and an exploration of its latest narrative extension, albeit most extras are rerouted through standard Blu-ray presentation rather than the 4K medium itself.
Extras included in this disc:
Commentary: Includes insights from crew and cast.
Deleted Scenes: Features removed clips from the final cut.
Gag Reel: A compilation of bloopers and humorous moments.
Featurettes: A collection of behind-the-scenes looks at the making of the movie.
One Shot: A focused feature on a specific aspect of the film.
Traitor of Mars: A Look Inside: A two-part deep dive into designs, digital work, narrative details, and more.
Expanding the Universe: 20 Years and Counting: Casper Van Dien and Ed Neumeier discuss the franchise's history.
Expanding the Universe: Continuing the Universe: Insights into adapting the novel for the screen and discussions on the original movie's tone.
Expanding the Universe: Traitor of Mars: Focuses on character arcs and filmmaking processes.
Deleted Scene: A short, underdeveloped clip.
Gallery: Concept art collection.
Previews: Trailers for additional Sony titles.
Movie: 50
Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars," the latest entry into the "Starship Troopers" franchise, ambitiously attempts to recapture the original's satirical essence and its critique of militarism and fascism, albeit with mixed success. Directed by Shinji Aramaki and featuring the scriptwriting prowess of Edward Neumeier, the film is entrenched in a storyline that mirrors contemporary political climates, eerily written before the 2017 U.S. Presidential election. The narrative revolves around Johnny Rico, demoted and relegated to training duties on Mars, and Sky Marshall Amy Snapp's morally ambiguous decisions driven by her pursuit of popularity and power, highlighting themes of media manipulation, political ambition, and the cost of war.
The animation, while endeavoring to breathe life into this digital sequel through the introduction of power suits and action sequences reminiscent of Japanese anime, struggles to find consistent footing. The visual appeal often fails to match that of higher-budget productions or even top-tier video game cutscenes, leaving much to be desired in terms of immersion and visual engagement. The return of Casper Van Dien as Johnny Rico adds a layer of nostalgia and continuity, although the absence of other original voices is felt, particularly in their characters’ transition to supporting roles.
Despite these shortcomings, "Traitor of Mars" does succeed in spots, particularly with its political commentary—sharp and as relevant as ever. The dichotomy of American and Japanese production styles presents an interesting, though not entirely cohesive, visual and thematic experience. The action, central to the film's appeal, ranges from standard fare battles against insectoid adversaries to more creative engagements, including hand-to-hand combat scenarios that hint at potential yet fully unrealized. Ultimately, "Traitor of Mars" stands as a testament to the enduring charm and message of its predecessors, even if it doesn’t quite reach the same heights.
Total: 58
Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars," in its 4K UHD Blu-ray rendition, positions itself as a somewhat mixed bag in the expansive universe of the Starship Troopers franchise. The film navigates through familiar territory with a script that showcases Edward Neumeier's keen observational skills, albeit hindered by a somewhat sluggish pace. Despite its narrative shortcomings, the film manages to deliver a satisfactory level of action, a sprinkle of social commentary, and a compelling villain that somewhat elevates it above its live-action sequels.
Sony's 4K UHD release enhances the viewing experience with a visually superior 4K/HDR presentation that notably outshines its Blu-ray counterpart, albeit with a few imperfections. The transition to Dolby Vision is particularly commendable, improving the overall visual depth and color palette. The sonic landscape also undergoes a transformation with an Atmos soundtrack that presents a discernible improvement, adding an immersive layer to the film's audio presentation. While the extras packaged with the Blu-ray disc are entertaining and add value to the overall package, they are not without their flaws.
In conclusion, "Starship Troopers: Traitor of Mars" 4K UHD Blu-ray offers an experience that, while not without its flaws, significantly enhances the visual and auditory presentation of the film. It serves as a decent addition to a 4K collection, especially for fans of the franchise looking to complete their set. Despite its pacing issues and narrative simplicity, the movie's technical enhancements on this release make it a recommended pick for those desiring to experience the film in the highest quality available.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 80
Black levels contend with the darker sequences admirably, allowing for a vast range from peak whites to inky blacks, but also new levels of evident shadow detail and, but for that sporadic near-waxy softness...
Audio: 80
A strong audio upgrade Dialogue remains well-prioritised throughout, delivered clearly and coherently, whilst the hardly inexperienced Bryan Tyler offers up one of his most generic cut-and-paste scores...
Extras: 70
The accompanying Blu-ray has all the old extras - Commentary, Deleted Scenes, Gag Reel, Featurettes and One Shot, but there's nothing on the 4K disc...
Movie: 60
It's actually an effective follow-up, particularly if you move past the unmemorable direction and score, ignore the weak heist antics and odd possession of Jane (which looks like a direct victim of the...
Total: 70
A watchable Thor follow-up which may have just been treading water for the MCU, but is still enjoyable, particularly when watching it as part of Thor's own 'Trilogy' After impressive - but not flawless...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
While the animation basics are not improved, obviously, the UHD does deliver a fairly healthy increase in raw detail and sharpness....
Audio: 60
Music is wide and clear and the stage opens up in most every area of opportunity around the more traditional front-rear-sides areas of operation; whether pitch battle scenes or calmer moments of dialogue...
Extras: 80
Expanding the Universe: Continuing the Universe (1080p, 3:35): Ed Neumeier and Casper Van Dien discuss adapting the novel for the screen, the original movie's tone, and brief discussions of the live action...
Movie: 60
Traitor of Mars continues the story of Johnny Rico, plays around with the same style and themes as the original film, brings in the popular power suits, and delivers a fun, but not necessarily memorable,...
Total: 50
Otherwise, it's kind of a classic watch-and-forget, but it's at least better than the live action sequels by quite a bit....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 40
Static backgrounds with bright lights induce an effect I personally call “pasted HDR,” where the source material wasn’t meant for the effect, but it looks like someone overlaid patches of brightness for...
Audio: 80
Extensive use of the rear channels in the middle of gunfights or bug screeches when troops retreat captures the spirit of the live action source....
Extras: 60
The three part Expanding the Universe speaks almost entirely on the legacy and writing the series....
Movie: 40
Yet, Traitor of Mars’ asset is the political hammering scripted out by Neumeier, not the fledgling ground war....
Total: 55
Traitor of Mars continues the Starship Troopers saga with an observant Edward Neumeier script let down by the plodding pace....
Director: Shinji Aramaki, Masaru Matsumoto
Actors: Casper Van Dien, Dina Meyer, DeRay Davis
PlotJohnny Rico, now a General, has been demoted and relocated to a Martian satellite station to train a new batch of recruits. The station is considered a remote and insignificant posting far from the front lines of the war against the Arachnids, a race of insect-like aliens that humanity is battling throughout the galaxy. Feeling sidelined and forgotten, Rico's frustration grows as he tries to impart his extensive knowledge and experience to a group of green recruits who lack discipline and are skeptical of his war tactics. His situation is complicated further by lingering issues back on Earth, where political maneuvering threatens to undermine the war effort.
Meanwhile, Mars is perceived as a non-strategic planet, and its inhabitants are not deemed worthy of heavy military protection. The Martian population is mostly focused on terraforming efforts, and the military presence there is minimal. Unexpectedly, the Arachnids launch a surprise attack on the planet, overwhelming the ill-prepared defenses. Rico and his inexperienced recruits are thrust into the chaos of battle, and he must quickly mold them into a fighting force capable of repelling the invasion. With the situation on Mars deteriorating rapidly, and Earth's support tied up in bureaucracy and politics, Rico and his team find themselves as the last line of defense against a relentless enemy aiming to overrun the planet.
Writers: Edward Neumeier
Release Date: 21 Aug 2017
Runtime: 88 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Japan
Language: English