Whitney Blu-ray Review
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Whitney does an admirable job presenting the real woman behind the superstar. Melancholy pervades the documentary, offering a fascinating and moving tribute.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
Whitney’s Blu-ray showcases a visually varied experience with a 1080p AVC encoded transfer: contemporary interviews display sharpness and natural color in 1.85:1, while archival footage remains inconsistent, softer—sometimes rough—yet significant for its rarity; overall, the presentation is commendably crisp.
Audio: 72
Whitney's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is often overshadowed by voiceovers and talking heads, making it feel almost mono. Brief music snippets gain depth, yet much content feels backgrounded. Fidelity holds strong, even with archival segments, though nostalgic imperfections appear occasionally.
Extra: 36
The Blu-ray extras of "Whitney" offer a comprehensive behind-the-scenes experience, featuring an insightful audio commentary by Producer Simon Chinn and Director Kevin Macdonald, a motion photo gallery of images from Whitney Houston's estate, and a theatrical trailer, all presented in high-definition.
Movie: 81
Using rare archival footage and revealing interviews, Kevin Macdonald’s documentary, 'Whitney,' is a fascinating, yet heartbreaking, exploration of Whitney Houston's unparalleled rise and tragic fall, capturing her extraordinary vocal talent while confronting her personal struggles and complex family dynamics.
Video: 74
The video presentation of "Whitney" on Blu-ray is a commendable effort by Lionsgate Films, featuring an AVC encoded 1080p transfer that navigates a diverse range of source materials. The documentary’s contemporary interviews and new footage stand out with impressive clarity, sharp definition, and stable contrast, delivering natural colors and deep blacks. These elements appear in the 1.85:1 aspect ratio, maintaining visual consistency and professionalism. Conversely, the older, lower resolution archival footage presents a mix of quality, occasionally exhibiting minor artifacts that are non-disruptive to the overall viewing experience.
As expected with documentaries that draw heavily from varied historical sources, there is an inherent variability in video quality. The archival segments, which include home movies and older television footage, display a broad spectrum of visual fidelity—some material appears notably rough and less vibrant. Despite the drab and somewhat muted palette of grays and browns in some sequences, the value of the rare footage outweighs the occasional roughness of its presentation. Ultimately, this amalgamation of diverse video quality is both a testament to the film’s archival richness and a necessary compromise, contributing to a viewing experience that is both engaging and historically significant.
Audio: 72
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray for "Whitney" is largely defined by a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track. However, due to the documentary's format, predominantly consisting of talking heads and voiceovers, the surround sound capabilities often feel underutilized. The majority of the film's impactful content is restricted to the center channel during these segments. Yet, the inclusion of brief musical interludes where the surround track comes into play does provide a fuller, more immersive auditory experience during those moments.
The fidelity throughout the film remains consistently high, ensuring clear and precise delivery of dialogue and spoken elements. Despite some older archival footage showing its age in both visual and audio quality, the overall sound engineering maintains a professional standard that respects the source material. Particularly noteworthy are the candid recordings of Whitney Houston strewn throughout the documentary, which, despite being less polished, contribute significantly to the authenticity and depth of the film’s narrative.
In summary, while the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track adds value during musical segments, much of the documentary’s audio leans towards a more mono-centric presentation due to its heavy reliance on dialogue. Nonetheless, the meticulous attention to audio fidelity, especially for archival recordings, enhances the viewing experience, paying homage to Whitney Houston’s legacy.
Extras: 36
The Blu-ray edition of "Whitney" offers a comprehensive suite of extras that deeply enhance the viewer's experience. The Audio Commentary with Producer Simon Chinn and Director Kevin Macdonald is particularly insightful, providing an intimate look into the making of the film, their creative choices, and behind-the-scenes stories. The Motion Photo Gallery, showcasing images courtesy of The Estate of Whitney E. Houston, is a poignant visual history celebrating Whitney's life and career. Additionally, the included Digital Copy and Theatrical Trailer (1080p; 2:32) add value, ensuring viewers can enjoy the film across multiple platforms and revisit its promotional materials. Collectively, these extras offer a rich mix of visual and narrative content, catering to both casual fans and documentary aficionados.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Producer Simon Chinn and Director Kevin Macdonald: In-depth discussion on making of the film.
- Motion Photo Gallery Featuring Images Courtesy of The Estate of Whitney E. Houston: Visual history of Whitney Houston.
- Digital Copy: Additional viewing flexibility.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional content for the film.
Movie: 81
"Whitney," directed by Oscar® winner Kevin Macdonald, is a revelatory documentary that delves deep into the life and career of Whitney Houston, an iconic figure in music history. Through the use of never-before-seen archival footage, exclusive demo recordings, rare performances, and comprehensive interviews, the film brings to light both the meteoric rise and tragic decline of Houston. For those unfamiliar with her impact, Houston was a musical phenomenon whose influence extended well beyond the ephemeral nature of pop culture. The documentary effectively captures this, showcasing her artistic brilliance against the backdrop of her personal struggles.
While the film excels in celebrating Houston's unparalleled talent, it does not shy away from addressing the darker aspects of her life. Interviews with family members reveal troubling histories, including early drug use introduced by her brothers and other familial traumas. These insights highlight the complexities of Houston’s character and the multifaceted challenges she faced. The documentary also touches on contentious moments within her career, offering an unfiltered look at how external perceptions and internal strife converged to shape her fate.
Despite some discomforting content—such as instances where Houston's personal issues are manipulated for comedic purposes—the film remains a poignant reminder of her indelible legacy. Amidst the turmoil, "Whitney" reaffirms the sheer power and purity of her voice, whether belting out gospel tunes or pop hits. While it exposes the harsh realities of fame, it ultimately serves as a tribute to Houston's enduring artistry, leaving viewers with a deeper understanding of the woman behind the icon.
Total: 66
The Blu-ray release of "Whitney" delivers a poignant exploration of Whitney Houston's life, capturing both the brilliance and the tribulations of her career. The documentary does not shy away from the more sorrowful chapters, accentuated by heart-wrenching moments when interviewees break down in tears. Despite her immense talent and success, Whitney Houston's life was marred by a constant struggle between overwhelming abundance and perpetual insufficiency. The film meticulously portrays these dichotomies, providing a deeply authentic and humanizing glimpse into her world.
The audiovisual quality of the Blu-ray is commendable. The high-definition presentation ensures that archival footage and performance scenes are rendered with exceptional clarity and vibrancy. The sound mixing accentuates Whitney's captivating voice, doing justice to her legacy as a powerhouse vocalist. Viewers will find themselves immersed in the experience, thanks to the diligent technical craftsmanship that supports this emotional narrative.
In conclusion, "Whitney" is a documentary that excels both in its storytelling and technical execution. Whether you are an ardent fan of Whitney Houston or someone interested in an intimate behind-the-scenes look at a musical icon, this Blu-ray is a must-own. The film's ability to balance admiration with a candid portrayal of personal struggles makes it compelling viewing. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
Nothing is unwatchable by any stretch, but there's a certain heterogeneity to this presentation that has to be accepted, and which actually should be welcomed, given the relative rarity of some of the...
Audio: 80
While Whitney features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, some may feel it's unnecessary, since so much of the documentary is simply talking heads and/or voiceovers, with most of the music left to interstitial...
Extras: 30
Audio Commentary with Producer Simon Chinn and Director Kevin Macdonald Whitney Photo Gallery (1080p; 1:09)...
Movie: 80
And in fact some of her psychological turmoil is seen as having been at least exacerbated by her childhood trauma with one of the Warwicks, but later with regard to a sexuality one of the talking heads...
Total: 80
Whitney does an admirable job of presenting the real woman behind the superstar, and anyone who loved Whitney's singing or even her somewhat limited film career should find this documentary fascinating...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 88
I had no real complaints with the video quality and on a whole thought that this presentation looked quite good....
Audio: 84
Using never-before-seen archival footage, exclusive demo recordings, rare performances, interviews, and audio archives, this fascinating film from Oscar® winner Kevin Macdonald reveals the truth behind...
Extras: 50
Audio Commentary with Producer Simon Chinn and Director Kevin Macdonald Motion Photo Gallery Featuring Images Courtesy of The Estate of Whitney E. Houston Digital Copy...
Movie: 90
Using never-before-seen archival footage, exclusive demo recordings, rare performances, interviews, and audio archives, this fascinating film from Oscar® winner Kevin Macdonald reveals the truth behind...
Total: 78
Gen 3 Seven Channel Amplifier Emotiva XPA-11 Gen 3 Amplifier Oppo UDP-203 Ultra HD Blu-ray Player Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control...
Director: Kevin Macdonald
Actors: Whitney Houston, Ellen White, Michael Houston
PlotThe film chronicles the meteoric rise of a gifted singer from her early beginnings singing in a church choir to becoming an international superstar. Born into a musical family, she is guided by her formidable mother, who instills in her a disciplined approach toward her craft. With a powerful voice and charismatic presence, she quickly captures the attention of record producers and earns a contract that launches her into the limelight. Her debut album garners critical acclaim and commercial success, establishing her as a force to be reckoned with in the music industry. The pressures of fame soon begin to weigh on her, affecting her personal relationships and mental well-being.
As she ascends to unparalleled fame, the singer grapples with the challenges that come with such heights. Her life becomes a whirlwind of constant public scrutiny, leading her to make choices that have significant ramifications for her career and personal life. Her tumultuous relationships, dependence on substances, and the inner demons she battles lay bare the darker side of stardom. Despite these struggles, her talent remains undeniable and her music continues to touch the lives of millions. The narrative delves deep into the dichotomy of her public persona versus her private turmoil, painting a poignant picture of a legend whose life is marked by both extraordinary triumphs and heartbreaking challenges.
Writers: Kevin Macdonald
Release Date: 05 Jul 2018
Runtime: 120 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English