Pompeii Blu-ray Review
Score: 70
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Pompeii delivers impressive audio-visual spectacle but falls short on narrative depth, blending recycled gladiator scenes with grandiose yet mindless destruction.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
Pompeii on Blu-ray offers a near-reference 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer with spectacular color fidelity, deep black levels, and incredible detail sharpness. While minor noise appears in darker shots, the digital photography maintains crisp clarity, vivid colors, and rich textures throughout.
Audio: 86
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack for 'Pompeii' is both engaging and immersive, excelling with its dynamic range and precise acoustics. Dialogue remains clear throughout, while explosive scenes are supported by powerful low frequencies, creating a rich, 360° panoramic soundfield.
Extra: 50
The Blu-ray extras for 'Pompeii' are comprehensive and engaging, featuring a balanced and detailed commentary by Paul W.S. Anderson and Jeremy Bolt, 20 deleted scenes, and featurettes on costume design, set construction, visual effects, and gladiator battles, while 'Pompeii: Buried in Time' melds historical context with production insights.
Movie: 47
While *Pompeii* delivers technically impressive visual effects and grand destruction scenes, its thin plot, formulaic character narratives, and lack of depth leave it as a mindless, not particularly engaging blend of historical epic and disaster movie that takes itself too seriously without delving into meaningful storytelling.
Video: 72
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Pompeii" impresses with its near-reference quality, ensuring an engaging visual experience. The 1080p transfer, encoded in AVC MPEG-4, delivers exceptional clarity and detail, capturing every facet from facial complexions with visible pores to the nuanced textures of armor and vegetation. Shot on the Red Epic digital system, the deliberately stylized image is imbued with a subtle amber glow, and an earthy color palette that contrasts vibrantly with primary colors to keep the imagery lively and energetic. Despite minor instances where darker shots exhibit sporadic noise, the general clarity and sharpness remain top-notch, with an absence of post-production tinkering detracting from the overall picture.
The use of a 2.40:1 aspect ratio emphasizes the grandeur of the film’s cinematography. Bright daytime scenes particularly stand out with purples and golds displaying incredible nuance and accuracy, complementing the earthy background tones. The film channels an oil painting quality in its color reproduction—bold and striking at times yet capable of retreating to more subdued hues when needed. The black levels are deep and pure, maintaining a sense of immersion without significant crush or anomalies during nighttime scenes. Throughout, the final act showcases red fireballs and lava in ways that dramatically leap off the screen. The clean digital file is absent of distracting noise, dirt, artifacts, or anomalies, contributing to an overall visually stunning experience that stays true to the director's artistic vision.
Audio: 86
"Pompeii" storms onto Blu-ray with an awe-inspiring DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack that captures the intensity and grandeur of this disaster epic. The sonic design is exceptional, particularly in the film's latter half where the volcanic eruption sequences deliver a barrage of highly dynamic and richly detailed audio. Explosions, collapsing structures, and other sonic elements create a chaotic yet immersive soundscape that places the listener at the heart of the devastation. The soundtrack excels in its full-bodied richness and detailed layering, with precise placement and movement enhancing the overall experience. Musical scores are rendered with clarity and balance, while atmospheric sounds from bustling streets to eerie calm in the gladiators' cells contribute significantly to scene immersion. Dialogue is well-prioritized, clear, and perfectly enunciated from the center channel.
The DTS-HD MA soundtrack really shines by offering a broad and expansive sonic landscape with excellent channel separation. Off-screen effects and fluid panning are seamlessly executed, creating a convincing multi-dimensional auditory experience. Dynamic range and acoustics resonate with precision, capturing both subtle ambient noises and overwhelming cataclysmic events vividly. LFE performance is particularly notable; it delivers deep, palpable low-end frequencies that shake the surroundings, from rumbling earthquakes to crashing tidal waves and fiery eruptions. This impressive low-frequency extension adds a visceral quality to the audio experience. Whether it’s the quieter, dialogue-driven moments or the all-encompassing chaos of volcanic destruction, "Pompeii" delivers a well-balanced, immersive audio track.
Thus, the Blu-ray of "Pompeii" provides a thrilling and engaging listening experience supported by a robust DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix. The detailed implementation of atmospheric effects, robust low frequency extension, and clarity in dialogue ensure this soundtrack stands as a reference-quality example for disaster genre films.
Extras: 50
The Blu-Ray release of "Pompeii" offers an extensive selection of engaging and informative extras. Highlights include a detailed audio commentary by Director Paul W.S. Anderson and Producer Jeremy Bolt, who delve into the film’s origins, historical context, technical feats, and visual effects. Complementing this are a gamut of featurettes, including an in-depth documentary "Pompeii: Buried in Time," that interlaces film specifics with historical backdrops. The comprehensive collection of deleted and alternate scenes provides additional layers to the story that were removed for pacing purposes. Each featurette contributes unique insights into the making of the film, from set design to costume creation and special effects.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insightful track by Director Paul W.S. Anderson and Producer Jeremy Bolt.
- Deleted & Alternate Scenes: A compilation of twenty scenes that extend the story.
- The Assembly: Cast interviews and character overviews.
- The Journey: Exploration of film's historical authenticity and technical prowess.
- The Costume Shop: Overview of wardrobe design with Costume Designer Wendy Partridge.
- The Volcanic Eruption: Examination of visual effects and historical eruption details.
- The Gladiators: Insights into gladiator battles and actor training.
- Pompeii: Buried in Time: Comprehensive documentary merging film details with historical context.
- Previews: Trailers for other films.
Optional English subtitles are included.
Movie: 47
In Paul W.S. Anderson's "Pompeii," viewers find an energetic blend of the sword-and-sandal genre with the disaster epic archetype, much akin to mixing "Spartacus" with "2012." The narrative follows Milo (Kit Harington), a capable gladiator and the last survivor of a slaughtered clan, who catches the eye of Cassia (Emily Browning), a wealthy merchant’s daughter. Their burgeoning relationship introduces a love triangle involving Corvus (Kiefer Sutherland), a corrupt Roman senator aiming to control Cassia and her family's wealth. The eruptive centerpiece, Mount Vesuvius, looms in the backdrop, anchoring the film's barrage of action set pieces and computer-generated mayhem.
While characterization is predictably paper-thin—resulting in dialogues ranging from bland to outright cliched—the real star is the visual spectacle. The film excels in its disaster sequences, crafting impeccably detailed scenes of volcanic eruption that showcase high-caliber special effects. Filmmaking technicalities impress, with the swift, relentless pacing capturing the chaotic carnage effectively, ensuring minimal downtime between cataclysmic events. However, the script's superficial treatment of characters often leaves viewers disengaged, framing them merely as pawns to be maneuvered amidst colossal digital destruction. Despite this, Harington and Akinnuoye-Agbaje's bromance injects some charm and adds a touch of human element amid the chaos.
Ultimately, "Pompeii" prioritizes explosive visuals over narrative depth. Anderson's film embraces its identity as a lavishly produced B-movie, indulging in grandiose, bloodless gladiatorial bouts and CGI spectacles while sacrificing historical accuracy and substantive storytelling. Though it might not resonate with viewers seeking intricate drama or meticulous reenactments of ancient Rome, it will likely satisfy those looking for high-octane, mindless entertainment punctuated by epic displays of nature’s wrath.
Total: 70
Paul W.S. Anderson’s "Pompeii" amalgamates various genres yet struggles to harmonize them effectively, mostly due to its shallow script and emphasis on visual spectacle over substance. Prior to the film's climactic volcanic eruption, viewers are subjected to repetitive gladiatorial combat, a burgeoning yet unconvincing depiction of brotherly bonds, and a contrived romance. Despite the film's superficiality, the grandiose depiction of the eruption with a deluge of CGI fireballs, ash, and smoke stands out as the highlight. This movie caters well to those seeking mindless entertainment but leaves much to be desired for audiences looking for depth and meaningful storytelling.
The Blu-ray release of "Pompeii" offers stellar video and audio quality that stands as a reference point for home media presentations. The visuals are sharp with vibrant effects, particularly during the disaster-laden finale. The audio presentation delivers an immersive experience that accentuates the chaotic ambiance of the depicted calamity. Supplementary materials are comprehensive, featuring enlightening extras including an engaging audio commentary. These features provide value to fans of Anderson's unique brand of cinema, although they may not be enough to convert skeptics.
In conclusion, "Pompeii" is best viewed as a visually captivating spectacle rather than a profound narrative experience. With its exemplary Blu-ray presentation and a roster of supplementary content, it stands as a commendable addition to the collection of Paul W.S. Anderson enthusiasts. For those curious yet unsure, it would be prudent to opt for a rental to gauge personal enjoyment. Ultimately, "Pompeii" will entertain those who prioritize visual grandeur over narrative depth.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Bright daytime scenes fare best, of course, where purples and golds display incredible nuance and accuracy....
Audio: 100
The level of nuance, placement, and movement around the stage is impressive to say the least....
Extras: 50
Audio Commentary: Producer/Director Paul W. S. Anderson and Producer Jeremy Bolt offer a good, balanced track in which they discuss many basic commentary staples, including the movie's origins, the real-life...
Movie: 50
With that in mind, then, Pompeii is the sort of film upon which one really need not focus, to pay close attention, because everything in the movie is built completely on the surface -- and there's, admittedly,...
Total: 70
Prior to the fireworks in the final act, viewers will be treated to some recycled gladiatorial battles, a few decent moment demonstrating the growing bonds of brotherhood formed under the pressures of...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Shot on the Red Epic digital system, the deliberately stylized picture comes with a subtle amber, golden sheen and a color palette that generally favors yellows and various earth tones....
Audio: 100
Of course, with a disaster epic such as this, with all the explosions, the chaos, the destruction, the pandemonium and what not, the second half of the story is usually the best part....
Extras: 40
The Volcanic Eruption (HD, 7 min) — A closer look at the visual digital effects for recreating the Roman city and Mount Vesuvius along with the practical effects for the many action sequences....
Movie: 40
At this point, seeing a historical piece set in Rome involving aristocrats and politicians overcoming the cataclysmic force that is Mother Nature and surviving a catastrophic disaster would be seen as...
Total: 60
Blending the plots of 'Gladiator' and 'Titanic' for a rather dull and generic storyline, the movie's real success is its concluding second half with larger-than-life, grandiose spectacles of destruction...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
I did not detect any annoying postproduction tinkering, with the exception of some weird motion effect towards the end, but I will assume that that was inherent to the 3-D source....
Audio: 100
Pompeii is a disaster epic after all and it gets the sound design right during those scenes in particular and it also knows when to scale it back during scenes of expositions and during the even quieter...
Extras: 70
The Assembly (HD, 7:14) – Fluffy interviews with the cast and how excited they were to participate on a film like Pompeii....
Movie: 60
I remember some of the marketing materials and commentary saying that Pompeii was Titanic meets a giant volcano....
Total: 80
The Blu-ray presentation is phenomenal and the supplemental features are above average, with a very cool audio commentary to boot....
Director: Paul W.S. Anderson
Actors: Kit Harington, Emily Browning, Kiefer Sutherland
PlotIn the thriving Roman city near Mount Vesuvius, a young slave named Milo, who has been forced into gladiatorial combat, dreams of gaining his freedom. Milo belongs to a people who were massacred by Roman soldiers, giving him a deeply personal vendetta against the empire. One day, he is brought to Pompeii to compete in games meant to entertain the masses. While there, he encounters Cassia, the daughter of a wealthy merchant, recently returned from Rome. Despite their vastly different social standings, an undeniable connection forms between them. Meanwhile, Cassia is being relentlessly pursued by the corrupt Roman Senator Corvus, who harbors sinister intentions towards her and her family.
As political tensions rise and games commence, strange tremors and signs of an impending disaster start manifesting around the city. Milo's plight intersects with the fates of Cassia and others as events rapidly escalate towards a catastrophic climax. Unbeknownst to the inhabitants, the volcanic mountain looming over Pompeii is on the brink of eruption. Against this backdrop of impending natural disaster and social upheaval, Milo must navigate gladiatorial battles, treacherous politics, and a burgeoning romance, ultimately seeking his freedom and a chance at love amidst nature's unstoppable fury.
Writers: Janet Scott Batchler, Lee Batchler, Michael Robert Johnson
Release Date: 21 Feb 2014
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Canada, Germany, United States, United Kingdom
Language: English