Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review

Criterion’s 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid" is a remarkable presentation of three distinctive versions of the film. The original Theatrical Release and the new 50th Anniversary Edition have been meticulously restored from the original negatives in native 4K and are enhanced with Dolby Vision. Both versions exhibit stellar visual qualities, with excellent image stability, and no damage or age-related artifacts. The cinematography's organic visual texture is well-preserved, showcasing rich panoramic footage and detailed close-ups. The color balance is vibrant and precise, maintaining lush and balanced primaries along with superbly nuanced supporting hues. Notably, both 4K and 1080p presentations are virtually indistinguishable in terms of quality, though some viewers may prefer the slightly richer color depth seen in the 4K format.

The Sam Peckinpah’s Final Preview Cut is presented in 1080p resolution and does not enjoy the same level of restoration, displaying a somewhat dated and rougher aesthetic. Despite this, it retains a stable and attractive organic appearance that is nostalgic for its time. Minor inconsistencies in color timing and light scratches are present but do not detract significantly from the viewing experience. This version exudes an authentic 1973 filmic quality, akin to watching a vintage 35mm print in a repertory theater. The decision to present this cut in 1080p rather than 4K is justified, as the source material likely lacks the necessary detail to benefit from a higher resolution.

Overall, Criterion has delivered an exemplary release with the two 4K restored versions setting a high standard for film preservation and presentation. Whether in native 4K or 1080p, the visual quality of "Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid" is impressive, making it a definitive purchase for film enthusiasts and collectors.

The audio presentation for the 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid" offers a meticulously crafted auditory experience. Each of the three versions of the film is equipped with an English LPCM 1.0 track, ensuring uniform quality across multiple renditions. The use of uncompressed PCM greatly enhances clarity and stability, particularly in dialogue, while Bob Dylan’s intricate score and songs are delivered with a warm and airy resonance that integrates well with the film's thematic elements. Optional English SDH subtitles are also included, facilitating accessibility for all viewers.

Dynamic intensity is notably robust during the film’s numerous shootouts, capturing the essence of these sequences effectively without succumbing to the potential pitfalls of age-related imperfections. The sound design strikes an excellent balance, ensuring that sound effects supplement rather than overshadow spoken dialogue. However, it may be necessary to manually adjust the volume during certain exchanges, especially given the accentuated dialogues that might require a slight amplification for full comprehensibility.

Overall, the audio tracks—consistent and accurate across all three film versions—are a testament to the careful attention to detail invested in this 4K UHD release. The preservation of the monaural format accentuates the film’s original audio integrity, thereby providing a nostalgic yet technically sound auditory experience.

The extras on the 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid" are a comprehensive and engaging collection that significantly enhances the viewing experience. The commentary from Michael Sragow, Paul Seydor, and Roger Spottiswoode stands out by offering in-depth insights into the film’s production, its various versions, and Sam Peckinpah's overarching vision. The content-rich documentary "Passion & Poetry: Peckinpah's Last Western" features archival interviews and newly produced segments, creating a robust picture of the film's making. Additional programs like "Dylan in Durango" and "Champlin on Film: James Coburn" delve into Bob Dylan's contributions and James Coburn’s involvement, providing further depth. These extras, including vintage trailers and TV spots, collectively offer a rich array of historical and production-related content that complements the main feature compellingly.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Insightful commentary covering film production and different versions.
• Passion & Poetry: Peckinpah's Last Western: Documentary with archival interviews and new footage.
• Dylan in Durango: Discussion of Bob Dylan's contribution to the soundtrack.
• Champlin on Film: James Coburn: Archival interview about Coburn's role.
• Trailer: Vintage trailer showcasing the film's marketing.
• TV Spots: Several original TV commercials for the film.

Criterion's release of "Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid" on 4K UHD Blu-ray presents an intriguing study of Sam Peckinpah's polarizing western. The film is offered in three distinct versions: the original Theatrical Release (106 minutes), a new 50th Anniversary Release (117 minutes), and Peckinpah's Final Preview Cut (122 minutes). The first two versions have been restored in 4K, while the latter remains in 2K. The variations reveal the troubled production process, influenced by Peckinpah’s evolving vision and struggles with alcoholism. The narrative remains consistent across the versions, focusing on the divergent paths of Pat Garrett (James Coburn) and Billy the Kid (Kris Kristofferson).

While the film’s structure and continuity have been points of contention, the Criterion release allows viewers to explore its permutations and form their own interpretations. Bob Dylan's involvement, both in the soundtrack—originating the song "Knockin' on Heaven's Door"—and his acting role as Alias, adds a distinctive layer. Dylan’s music provides a unique ambiance, though his on-screen contribution is vastly different from more central performances. James Coburn’s portrayal of Pat Garrett is notably internalized, conveying much through non-verbal cues.

Amongst the three versions, the original Theatrical Release is notably concise but imbued with Dylan's prominent musical score, giving it a sense of completeness. Conversely, the Final Preview Cut feels sprawling and somewhat fragmented, mirroring an unfinished yet dynamic work. The newly orchestrated 50th Anniversary Release aims for comprehensiveness but is critiqued for its sterility and lack of momentum. Criterion's extensive supplements—including commentaries and documentaries—further enrich the viewing experience, offering deep dives into both the film's creation and its storied production history.

Criterion's 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid" is a robust celebration of Sam Peckinpah’s western classic, offering three distinct versions of the film. This set includes two newly restored versions in stunning 4K and 1080p, along with the addition of a newly assembled 50th Anniversary reconstruction by editors Paul Seydor and Roger Spottiswoode. Also featured is Peckinpah’s Final Preview Cut, which has been meticulously restored in 2K, providing fans a comprehensive look at the different iterations of this evolving cinematic work.

While "Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid" is not without its imperfections — much of which can be attributed to its troubled production history — Criterion’s special edition pack enriches the viewing experience with extensive special features. These extras delve deeply into the film's legacy, the director's challenges, and the various "what-ifs" that have intrigued fans for years. Although it omits the two cuts from the 2005 DVD edition, the quality and completeness offered by this set are compelling enough to satisfy both new viewers and long-time followers.

In conclusion, "Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid" remains an engaging and layered film, reflective of Peckinpah's artistic evolution and enduring passion. With its beautifully restored visuals and thorough ensemble of editions and features, this Criterion release is indispensable for aficionados seeking the definitive home media version. VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.