What Have They Done to Your Daughters? Blu-ray Review
La polizia chiede aiuto
Score: 77
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Arrow Video delivers a solid Blu-ray of 'What Have They Done to Your Daughters?', a suspenseful film with unique content, lovely cinematography, and enjoyable extras.
Disc Release Date
Video: 82
The Blu-ray release of 'What Have They Done to Your Daughters?' by Arrow Video features a remarkable 1080p transfer in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, using a restored HD master by Camera Obscura. The palette is healthy with only occasional coarse grain, offering a consistently organic and detail-rich viewing experience.
Audio: 72
The Blu-ray of *What Have They Done to Your Daughters?* features English and Italian LPCM Mono audio tracks with no major differences in mix or amplitude, a dynamic score by Stelvio Cipriani, and sync issues that do not affect fidelity; Arrow Video's 2K restoration delivers potent detail with strong color and deep blacks, providing a mostly stable and clean presentation.
Extra: 79
With insightful audio commentary by Troy Howarth, engaging video essays and interviews, and unique extras like the 'Hardcore Footage,' Arrow's Blu-ray of 'What Have They Done to Your Daughters?' offers a comprehensive and professionally curated selection of bonus content that enriches the viewing experience.
Movie: 71
"What Have They Done to Your Daughters?" masterfully blends giallo and poliziotteschi elements, featuring a gritty storyline with unexpected political subtext and innovative cinematography by Massimo Dallamano. Critical discussions highlight its procedural depth, inventive framings, and somber historical context involving tragic on-set deaths.
Video: 82
Arrow Video presents "What Have They Done to Your Daughters?" on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio, utilizing a restored HD master provided by Camera Obscura. The transfer maintains a healthy palette, capturing the essence of the film's visual style. The grain, while occasionally coarse, adds an authentic texture to the viewing experience. Detail levels are generally high, even amidst the film’s unique framing choices, contributing to a clean and organic visual quality. Importantly, the restoration process has effectively eliminated nearly all age-related wear and tear, ensuring a smooth and immersive presentation.
In comparison to other releases, such as Camera Obscura’s previous German market Blu-ray, there appears to be no significant difference in quality, reinforcing the consistency of this edition. Unlike Arrow's release of "What Have You Done to Solange?" which had to utilize secondary elements, leading to some inconsistencies in clarity and color reproduction, "What Have They Done to Your Daughters?" exhibits a commendable uniformity throughout. This homogeneous appearance ensures that viewers receive an uninterrupted and consistent viewing experience, making Arrow Video’s presentation a reliable choice for aficionados and new viewers alike.
Audio: 72
Arrow Video's Blu-ray release of "What Have They Done to Your Daughters?" offers a commendable audio presentation, featuring both English and Italian audio tracks in LPCM Mono. Both audio tracks present no significant differences in overall amplitude or mix. The film’s score by Stelvio Cipriani is delivered energetically and remains free from distortion throughout, adding to the immersive experience. Both soundtracks exhibit fine fidelity, with clear, discernible dialogue, even though sync occasionally exhibits minor looseness. Importantly, the audio tracks are devoid of any dropouts or damage, ensuring a consistent auditory experience.
The release includes optional English subtitles for the Italian track and English SDH subtitles for the English track, catering to a variety of viewer preferences. Both tracks maintain a high level of clarity and cleanliness, with the English track being marginally louder. The film’s notable score—including its memorable opening number—benefits substantially from this clarity boost, enhancing overall viewer engagement. Overall, Arrow's audio presentation ensures that dialogue, music, and ambient sounds are effectively balanced and clear, making for an elevated viewing experience on this Blu-ray release.
Extras: 79
Arrow Video's Blu-ray of "What Have They Done to Your Daughters?" delivers an impressive array of extras, catering to enthusiasts of Massimo Dallamano's work. The disc includes a range of video essays and interviews, delivering comprehensive insights into the thematic and technical aspects of the director's films. Particularly notable is Kat Ellinger’s video essay, offering an in-depth analysis of Dallamano's thematic exploration, and the extended interview with composer Stelvio Cipriani that delves into his contributions to the film's haunting score. Another highlight is the silent, uncut hardcore footage which provides a rare glimpse into unedited scenes. The inclusion of an image gallery and theatrical trailer round out this robust package, showcasing Arrow's commitment to preserving cult cinema.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Troy Howarth: In-depth commentary by film historian.
- Masters and Slaves: Video essay by Kat Ellinger on Dallamano's themes.
- Eternal Melody: Interview with composer Stelvio Cipriani.
- Dallamano's Touch: Interview with editor Antonio Siciliano.
- Hardcore Footage: Uncut, silent scenes.
- English Titles: Alternative opening titles.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional trailer.
- Image Gallery: Collection of still images from the film.
Also includes a nicely appointed insert booklet.
Movie: 71
Massimo Dallamano's "What Have They Done to Your Daughters?" straddles the giallo and poliziotteschi genres, offering a compelling mix of gritty procedural and deeply unsettling themes. The film kicks off with a teenage girl's apparent suicide, unraveling into a complex web of sexual exploitation, institutional corruption, and societal decay. Central to the narrative is Assistant District Attorney Vittoria Stori (Giovanna Ralli), whose role introduces a nuanced layer of gender politics; her interactions subtly question the pervasive male gaze typical of the genre. The film’s prurient elements are indeed discomforting but serve to underline its grim realism rather than mere titillation.
Technically, Dallamano's cinematographic expertise shines through, transforming potentially lurid material into visually sophisticated sequences. "What Have They Done to Your Daughters?" distinguishes itself not just through its scandalous content, but through stylish framing and inventive use of visual storytelling, reminiscent of Dallamano’s earlier work on "A Fistful of Dollars" and "For a Few Dollars More." A notable point of comparison within the schoolgirls-in-peril trilogy is the thematic and structural kinship with "What Have You Done to Solange?" and "Enigma Rosso," although each film offers a unique take on the central premise.
The film's unsettling subtext analogizes the misconduct among adolescents with broader governmental malpractice, delivering potent, albeit grim, socio-political commentary. The untimely deaths of both Dallamano and actor Claudio Cassinelli post-release add an eerie layer to the film's historical context. This Blu-ray release benefits from Arrow’s characteristic dedication to quality, ensuring that this significant, if disturbing, entry in Italian genre cinema can be appreciated in its full restored glory.
Total: 77
Arrow Video's Blu Ray release of "What Have They Done to Your Daughters?" offers a compelling blend of suspense, solid cinematography, and unique narrative elements. Directed by Massimo Dallamano, this film manages to stand out from its better-known predecessor, "What Have You Done to Solange?", and the subsequent "Enigma Rosso" due to its intriguing content and execution. The Blu Ray presentation showcases the film's atmospheric visuals, effectively utilizing lighting and composition to maintain the tension that is so integral to the narrative.
The technical merits of the Arrow release are commendable. The image quality is both clear and consistent, allowing Dallamano’s directorial nuances to shine through. Notable too are the supplements included, which add significant value to the package with insightful behind-the-scenes content and interviews that contextually enrich the viewer’s understanding of the film. While some may find the press briefing sequences somewhat drawn out, they serve a purpose in developing the intricate plot and building suspense.
In conclusion, while "What Have They Done to Your Daughters?" may not reach the same dramatic peaks as "What Have You Done to Solange?", it stands firm with its own distinct charm and narrative strength. Arrow Video delivers a finely crafted release that balances technical excellence with enjoyable bonus features, making this an essential addition for fans of Italian cinema and suspense thrillers alike. Recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Arrow's insert contains only the following very brief and generic verbiage on the transfer: What Have They Done to Your Daughters? is presented in its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio with Italian and English...
Audio: 80
As with What Have You Done to Solange?, I toggled back and forth between them as I watched the film and once again noticed no major differences in terms of the mix or overall amplitude....
Extras: 80
Dallamano's Touch (1080p; 22:22) is another 2016 interview, this time with longtime Dallamano collaborator, editor Antonio Siciliano....
Movie: 70
As commentator Troy Howarth mentions early on in his appealing analysis of What Have They Done to Your Daughters?, it's possible for Italian genre enthusiasts to split into camps as to whether this film...
Total: 70
that may prevent it from reaching the kind of florid heights of its predecessor, but taken on its own terms, What Have They Done to Your Daughters? has some really interesting and really rather unique...
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 85
The color palette is also mostly strong, although there are some daytime shots that appear a bit anemic, but for the most part, the use of reds and greens stand out the most....
Extras: 85
Movie: 80
During the giallo explosion of the late 1960s and early 1970s, filmmaker Massimo Dallamano made a number of sophisticated crime films that covered familiar subject matter, but did it in more of an envelope-pushing...
Total: 86
What Have They Done to Your Daughters? is considered the lesser of the two films that Massimo Dallamano directed with similar subject matter, but it’s no less entertaining....
Director: Massimo Dallamano
Actors: Giovanna Ralli, Claudio Cassinelli, Mario Adorf
PlotA teenage girl's lifeless body is discovered hanging in an abandoned loft, leading Inspector Silvestri and Assistant District Attorney Vittoria Stori to delve into the case. Their investigation begins with the search for the girl's identity, and they soon uncover evidence linking her to a secret network of underage prostitution. As they dig deeper into the shadowy world of exploitation and corruption, they encounter resistance and threats from powerful figures determined to keep their nefarious activities hidden. The villains engage in increasingly violent acts to protect their secrets, confirming the investigators' suspicions of a far-reaching criminal conspiracy.
As Silvestri and Stori follow the trail of clues, they are forced to confront personal and professional challenges. The investigation not only tests their resolve but exposes dark realities about the institutions meant to protect society's most vulnerable. Tensions rise, trust is eroded, and moral dilemmas abound as they edge closer to exposing those responsible. With each discovery, the stakes grow higher, leading to a gripping climax that underscores the profound human cost of systemic corruption and the quest for justice.
Writers: Ettore Sanzò, Massimo Dallamano
Release Date: 18 Mar 1977
Runtime: 96 min
Rating: R
Country: Italy
Language: Italian