A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 78
from 6 reviewers
Review Date:
Moving tribute to Mr. Rogers, blending emotional depth & technical prowess.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
DTS:X
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood's UHD release enhances its warm, authentic visuals, offering greater clarity and vibrancy while staying true to its unique, intentionally softer cinematographic style.
Audio: 77
The DTS:X audio in 'A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood' enriches immersion with effective object-based sound and venue replication, despite its modest use of height channels and a visually peculiar yet intentionally soft 4K presentation.
Extra: 73
A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood Blu-ray boasts insightful filmmaker commentary, deleted scenes, bloopers, detailed featurettes on Tom Hanks' role, and puppetry, offering a rich behind-the-scenes look, with a Movies Anywhere digital code.
Movie: 88
A journalist's skeptical view transforms through Fred Rogers' empathy, highlighting the profound impact of kindness and understanding on personal healing.
Video: 79
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood" brings a noticeable but nuanced upgrade in visual quality from its Blu-ray counterpart, thanks to its 2160p resolution and native 4K digital intermediate. This results in an enhanced clarity and sharpness, bringing the finer details, such as the texture of clothing and subtle facial features, into sharper focus. Despite the lack of dramatic transformations, the improvements in texture and image depth offer a more authentic viewing experience. However, it's worth noting that the HDR color grading introduces a slightly darker overall tone without desaturating colors, leading to a more accurate and aesthetically pleasing representation of deeper tones and environmental elements. Enhanced black levels and white balance add to the image's refined appearance, ensuring that this is the definitive version for aficionados, despite its low-key cinematography reflective of its subject matter.
Interestingly, the movie employs various filming techniques to achieve a unique visual aesthetic, blending digital cinematography with footage intended to mimic the look of 1970s television broadcasts. This includes scenes shot in Super 16 mode for a low-resolution film look and segments captured with vintage video cameras for authenticity in recreating the distinct style of "Mister Rogers' Neighborhood." Such choices result in an unusual UHD image that deliberately eschews typical sharpness for softer visuals, complete with nuanced colors and intentionally muted black levels—a decision that serves as a metaphorical nod to the absence of complete darkness in Mr. Rogers' world. While these artistic licensees lead to a picture that may defy conventional UHD expectations, they are essential in maintaining the film’s tonal authenticity.
Regarding technical aspects, this release is adorned with detailed textural clarity, including striking realness in skin tones and clothing textures, thanks to its HEVC / H.265 encoding and native 4K finish. The depth of field is impressive, especially in the set pieces of Mr. Rogers' neighborhood, bringing out a three-dimensional quality that adds to the film's immersive experience. Colors remain naturally vibrant within the film's deliberately muted palette, with HDR enhancing the visual potency of key elements like Fred Rogers' iconic red sweater and the vivid Land of Make Believe. This 4K UHD treatment remains faithful to its source material, presenting a clean, artifact-free image that respects the film's intended visual narrative, despite lacking the typical "wow" factor of more visually stunning 4K releases.
Audio: 77
The DTS:X soundtrack of "A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood" on 4K UHD brilliantly elevates the film's audiovisual experience, offering a noticeable improvement over its Blu-ray counterpart. The immersion effect is substantially heightened, thanks to an adept use of object-based audio, particularly during musical numbers and scenes set in varied interior and exterior locales. The soundtrack’s handling of acoustics, from point to point imaging to the expansion of the soundstage, impresses with its precision. This results in a more robust, stage-filling sound that not only showcases instrumental clarity but also enhances the overall spatial awareness. Details like the denser beats of a piano or the ambient sounds of city streets and crowds are rendered with a stronger command, making every moment feel more alive and textured.
Despite the film’s relatively sedate nature, which doesn’t fully exploit the dynamic range typically associated with the 12.1 DTS:X MA track, the presentation still marks a significant upgrade. Subtle yet effective, the surround effects and nuanced bass frequencies add depth and dimension without overwhelming. The implementation of overhead audio may be minimal, focusing mainly on atmospherics and occasional panning, yet it contributes to an enriched layer of immersion seldom found in drama-focused audio tracks. Moreover, dialogue remains crisply prioritized, emanating predominantly from the front-center position, ensuring clarity and coherence throughout.
Surprisingly, the film also demonstrates strong bass response when necessary, adding an unexpected vibrancy to its more subdued soundscape. This nuanced handling of the low-end, together with meticulous attention to detail in the reproduction of Nate Heller's score, presents a wide dynamic scale that captures both the highs and lows with elegance. Although not a demo track by any means, this audio presentation outshines its Blu-ray counterpart by maintaining the core excellence of localized sound while expanding upon it to offer a richer, more immersive listening experience that perfectly complements the visual storytelling.
Extras: 73
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood" provides an enriching experience, primarily facilitated through the contents housed in the supplemental Blu-ray disc. Notably devoid of extras itself, the 4K disc defers to its Blu-ray counterpart, which houses a treasure trove of material. It offers an insightful filmmaker commentary with Director Marielle Heller and Director of Photography Jody Lee Lipes, shedding light on the intricate process behind the movie's creation. Viewers are treated to over 15 minutes of deleted and extended scenes that add depth to the story, alongside a novel blooper reel showcasing Tom Hanks' struggles with Fred Rogers’ iconic sweater. The disc excels in its featurettes, offering comprehensive insights—ranging from Hanks' embodiment of Fred Rogers to the detailed recreation of the show's miniature world. Exemplary is the attention to authenticity and careful preservation of the original show's spirit, underscored by contributions from those who knew Rogers personally and professionals involved in the project. This collection not only extends the narrative’s context but also enriches the viewer's appreciation for both the film and its beloved real-life protagonist.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Marielle Heller and Director of Photography Jody Lee Lipes provide their insights.
- Deleted & Extended Scenes: Over 15 minutes of additional content.
- Blooper Reel: Amusing on-set goofs.
- Tom Hanks as Fred Rogers: Examination of Hanks’ portrayal.
- The People Who Make a Neighborhood: The Making Of: Dive into the film's creation.
- Dreaming Big, Building Small: The Puppets & Miniatures: The craftsmanship behind the miniatures and puppets.
- Daniel Tiger Explains: Practice Makes Perfect: A humorous puppet-led featurette.
Movie: 88
A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood," presented in 4K UHD Blu-ray by Sony Pictures Home Entertainment, transcends the conventional cinematic narrative to deliver a poignant and compelling story, cleverly using the beloved figure of Fred Rogers (portrayed by Tom Hanks) as a lens through which the transformative journey of a cynical journalist, Lloyd Vogel (Matthew Rhys), is explored. Directed by Marielle Heller, the film delves into themes of kindness, forgiveness, and the profound impact one individual's genuine care can have on another's life. It's a narrative that skillfully intertwines Rogers' philosophy with Vogel's skepticism and eventual emotional enlightenment, rather than focusing solely on Rogers' biography.
The presentation captures the essence of Fred Rogers in both substance and style, paying homage to his influence not by duplicating his life story but by emphasizing his ability to evoke change in others. The choice to showcase Rogers as a pivotal yet supporting figure in Vogel's tale is underscored by Tom Hanks' sublime, Oscar-nominated performance, which bridges the gap between the television persona and the man himself, showcasing Rogers' unfeigned warmth and empathy. The narrative evolves from a potential exposé to a touching exploration of personal healing, highlighting the universal relevance of Rogers' messages of love and understanding. Supporting performances by Matthew Rhys, Susan Kelechi Watson, and Chris Cooper add depth to this deeply human story, with Rhys' portrayal of Vogel offering a relatable and transformative arc that mirrors the film's broader themes.
Marielle Heller's direction is key to the movie's authenticity and emotional resonance, beautifully complemented by Jody Lee Lipes' cinematography. The film employs creative transitions and a visually engaging style that respects both its subjects and viewers, presenting a cinematic experience that feels both fresh and familiar. By blending the mundane with the profound, "A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood" stands out as a touching testament to Fred Rogers' enduring legacy and the timeless value of his teachings. It is not just a film about the power of kindness; it is a reflective piece that encourages viewers to consider their own lives through the prism of Rogers' enduring wisdom.
Total: 78
Sony's 4K UHD release of "A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood" is a truly heartfelt tribute to the venerable Fred Rogers that manages to capture the essence of his gentle, empathetic personality. Through a presentation that is both technically accomplished and emotionally resonant, this release shines. The dialogue-driven nature of the film is complemented by a 5.1 channel surround mix that beautifully balances the lucid texture of conversations with the fuller sounds of the environment, from spatial ambience to occasional robust low ends underscoring thematic elements. This mix, while not reaching the heights of a DTS:X sound mix, successfully supports the storytelling with clear and transparent realism. On the visual front, the native 4K presentation is crisp and clean, enhancing the film's immersive qualities without relying on visual spectacle.
Tom Hanks' portrayal of Mister Rogers captures the essence of his character, demonstrating not just an imitation but a deep understanding of Rogers' spiritual essence. The film itself, extending beyond a mere biopic into a reflective and moving narrative, brings viewers into the nuanced dynamics of human empathy and connection, highlighted by strong performances and a purpose-driven script. This balanced approach extends into the inclusion of special features on the Blu-ray disc, offering engaging insights into the making of the film and interviews that compliment the core themes.
In conclusion, while "A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood" may not redefine cinematic milestones or fully delve into Fred Rogers' life, it stands as a sincere homage to his legacy and impact. Sony's 4K UHD package not only honors this spirit with high-quality audiovisuals but also enriches the experience with thoughtful extras. It's a release that deserves high recommendation for its successful blend of film presentation and bonus content, making it more than just a one-time viewing but an addition worthy of any collection aiming to celebrate genuine, heartfelt storytelling.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
There are no eye-popping transformations here, but viewers will appreciate the finer intricacies and slightly more accurate feel for clarity and sharpness which speaks to how excellent the Blu-ray is and...
Audio: 90
There's a modest feel for fuller, more stage filling sounds compared to the Blu-ray's smaller scale 5.1 presentation, particularly anything with some weight or density to it: the more intense piano beats,...
Extras: 100
The People Who Make a Neighborhood: The Making Of (1080p, 15:23): Hanks, partially in character, introduces the people who worked hard to bring the movie to life, including Director Marielle Heller and...
Movie: 100
When Vogel first arrives at WQED where an episode of Mister Rogers' Neighborhood is being filmed, the camera shows Rogers live on stage and through TV monitors at the same time, in the same shot, suggesting...
Total: 50
He admires life's simple joys, truly enjoying the opportunity to, for example, be in the presence of a string quartet playing beautiful music....
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 70
But considering this is a dialogue drama, and that it was shot in HD and SD resolution, the choice to “IMAX Enhance” it is baffling.)...
Audio: 75
But considering this is a dialogue drama, and that it was shot in HD and SD resolution, the choice to “IMAX Enhance” it is baffling.)...
Extras: 80
But the featurettes not only reveal Hanks’ take on the role, and Rhys’ insights on his own character, they also give you a chance to see many of the real people who worked on the original TV show marveling...
Movie: 80
And through patience and kindness, Fred instead begins to expose Lloyd’s childhood trauma, and helps him to heal even as they form a lasting bond of friendship....
Total: 76
If you grew up in the 1970s and 80s, as I did, just hearing the name Fred Rogers brings a smile to your face....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
The best material happens on the show itself, where the attractively colored sets were designed to draw young eyes....
Audio: 80
Expect little in the height channels, as if something like A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood was going to stretch things anyway....
Extras: 60
A 10-minute featurette explores Tom Hanks in this role, followed with a 15-minute general making-of....
Movie: 100
That’s why A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood exists, enough to make Rogers real and authentic, while creating a calming force....
Total: 80
Gentle and calming, even A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood’s style represents Mr. Rogers’ method in a genuine tribute....
High-Def Digest review by David KraussRead review here
Video: 80
It's still a nice step from the Blu-ray transfer, however, with bolder colors, greater clarity, and more vibrancy....
Audio: 80
Once I achieved the proper balance, the audio exhibited plenty of nuance, and the wide dynamic scale embraced all the highs and lows of Nate Heller's music score....
Extras: 50
Hanks as Mister Rogers introduces this standard making-of featurette that salutes Heller's direction and the cast's performances, analyzes the characters, chronicles the recreation of the Mister Rogers...
Movie: 70
When Mister Rogers is off the screen, A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood loses its luster, yet even when he's front and center, his gentle counseling about compassion, caring, and forgiveness often lends...
Total: 80
But if you're interested in a heartfelt salute to a children's television icon that showcases his empathetic character and ability to connect with and bolster the outlook of people of all ages, then you...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 90
After a jaded magazine writer is assigned a profile of Fred Rogers, he overcomes his skepticism, learning about kindness, love and forgiveness from America’s most beloved neighbor....
Audio: 94
When called upon its ability to render acoustics, point to point imaging and expanding the breadth of the soundstage never disappointed....
Extras: 70
Disc 1: A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood Ultra HD Blu-ray Disc 2: A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood Blu-ray • Over 15 Minutes of Additional Scenes • Blooper Reel • Tom Hanks as Fred Rogers • The People...
Movie: 90
After a jaded magazine writer is assigned a profile of Fred Rogers, he overcomes his skepticism, learning about kindness, love and forgiveness from America’s most beloved neighbor....
Total: 86
This is primarily a dialog driven film however there are elements in the film that require use of the entire system so its ability to clearly render them is essential....
Why So Blu? review by Brandon PetersRead review here
Video: 100
This carries and nice, cozy image that is crisp but with a real flush, bold image with striking realness and a nice collection of texture and detail that are quite clear and clean in this image....
Audio: 80
Extras: 80
The Puppets & Miniatures (HD, 8:37) – The miniatures team, along with puppets lead us through how they went about recreating the show’s little characters and teaching Tom Hanks to perform....
Movie: 90
When looking at the film and seeing the full understanding, that one award nomination for supporting actor makes you wonder if they just tossed that out there for what they thought the film was, rather...
Total: 90
This may be just a rental for some, but for the trifecta of film, presentation and bonus features, this is a terrific pick up....
Director: Marielle Heller
Actors: Matthew Rhys, Tom Hanks, Chris Cooper
PlotLloyd Vogel, a cynical investigative journalist known for his scathing writing style, receives an assignment from Esquire magazine to profile Fred Rogers, the beloved host of the children's television show "Mister Rogers' Neighborhood." Vogel, grappling with his own personal issues, including a strained relationship with his father, Jerry, approaches the assignment skeptically, believing it to be beneath his journalistic talents. He is also soon to become a father himself, which adds to the emotional turbulence he feels. Despite his reluctance, Lloyd agrees to meet Rogers to complete what he assumes will be a straightforward interview.
The initial interaction between Vogel and Rogers doesn't go as the journalist plans. Instead of a simple interview, Rogers' genuine warmth and caring nature begin to chip away at Vogel's jaded exterior. Through a series of interviews and deepening conversations, Lloyd finds himself drawn into Rogers' world, a place where kindness and empathy reign. Rogers' curiosity about Lloyd's life leads to probing questions that force the writer to confront his own unresolved trauma and anger toward his father, pushing him into a journey of self-discovery and healing that challenges his worldview. The interactions with Rogers become a transformative experience for Lloyd, reshaping his understanding of himself and his relationships with his loved ones.
Writers: Micah Fitzerman-Blue, Noah Harpster, Tom Junod
Release Date: 22 Nov 2019
Runtime: 109 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, China
Language: English