Whale Rider Blu-ray Review
15th Anniversary Edition
Score: 69
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Whale Rider's long-overdue Blu-ray release by Shout Select delivers excellent transfer and lossless audio, retaining most original bonus materials; highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
Shout Factory delivers a respectable Blu-ray debut for 'Whale Rider' in North America with a 2.35:1 AVC encoded transfer. The well-encoded video showcases natural skin tones, detailed close-ups, and striking New Zealand landscapes amidst intentional grain and muted colors. Minor artifacts do not detract from the filmic presentation.
Audio: 68
Shout Factory's presentation of 'Whale Rider' features a well-balanced 5.1 DTS-HD MA mix and a 2.0 DTS-HD MA downmix, capturing clear vocals, ambient oceanic and school sounds, and a punchy LFE. Despite minor issues with windy outdoor scenes, the overall audio is immersive and dynamics are well-executed.
Extra: 66
The Whale Rider Blu-ray Extras include a thoughtful commentary from director Niki Caro, a comprehensive behind-the-scenes featurette, insightful deleted scenes with commentary, and exclusive screen tests of Keisha Castle-Hughes. Despite some technical issues and missing features, the set offers rich insights into the film's production.
Movie: 81
"Whale Rider" is an engrossing and moving film showcasing the journey of a young Maori girl, Pai, against cultural prejudice and steeped traditions, delivering a powerful performance by Keisha Castle-Hughes that captures both the cultural authenticity and emotional depth of the Maori community, amplified by its exceptional cinematography and ethereal score.
Video: 68
Shout Factory’s Blu-ray release of "Whale Rider" offers a robust and faithful presentation of the acclaimed 2002 film. Presented in its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio with a 1080p resolution on a BD-50 disc, the transfer employs an AVC encode averaging in the mid 30 Mbps range, with peak bitrates reaching the low 40s. Leon Narbey's cinematography, intentionally gritty and realistic, translates exceptionally well to the screen, with Shout's encoding offering impressive fine detail, particularly in close-ups, where facial features and textures stand out vividly. Colors are deliberately muted to convey the natural element of New Zealand landscapes, yet ocean scenes exhibit a rich, lovely blue that adds depth to the visuals.
The encode remains clear of artificial sharpening, preserving the natural film grain and maintaining a cinematic quality across the board. Black levels possess slight hints of gray but manage to retain adequate detail in darker scenes without evident crushing. The transfer occasionally shows minor compression noise, particularly in grain-heavy sequences, but this does not detract significantly from the overall viewing experience. Skin tones are rendered realistically and consistently, showing details such as wrinkles and sweat convincingly. Despite some flat contrast in certain areas, and occasional scenes with a slight hint of ringing producing thin halos, the presentation remains largely untampered and true to its source.
Overall, Shout Factory’s technical execution provides fans with a satisfying and authentic viewing experience, delivering on clarity and maintaining the filmic integrity of "Whale Rider". The presentation is nicely rounded with added features such as twenty-six chapter selections and an included digital download code, making it a well-rounded package for enthusiasts of this beloved film.
Audio: 68
Shout Factory delivers an impressive audio experience for "Whale Rider" with a 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix and a well-executed 2.0 DTS-HD MA downmix. The 5.1 mix, running at 3202 kbps (24-bit), particularly stands out despite this being a dialogue-driven film. Vocals are consistently crisp and clear, although in some windier outdoor scenes they benefit from the optional English SDH subtitles. With the cast primarily speaking English and occasionally Maori, the track ensures that dialogue remains accessible, automatically subtitling the latter.
The mix achieves an excellent ambient soundscape. Gerrard's atmospheric score benefits from good channel separation and a balanced soundstage, contributing effectively to the overall immersive experience. Front soundstage elements drive much of the audio, but rear channels offer subtle enhancements, injecting life into quieter scenes. Dynamics are well managed, providing a lifelike quality without overpowering the film's more delicate moments.
Low-frequency extension is particularly notable, adding depth to the environmental sounds like ocean waves and rumbling engines. The surround sound presentation is adeptly executed, with thoughtful sound traveling and discrete channel usage that enrich the listening experience. Despite a few moments where dialogue dips into mumbling, the sound reproduction overall maintains clean transitions and solid bass integration. The dual options of 5.1 and 2.0 mixes ensure flexibility for different listening environments while both delivering robust audio quality.
Extras: 66
The Blu Ray release of "Whale Rider" offers a robust collection of extras that provide an in-depth look into the filmmaking process and the cultural significance behind the story. Shout! Factory’s inclusion of features like the audio commentary by director Niki Caro and the comprehensive "Behind-The-Scenes" featurette enriches the viewer's appreciation of the film. The "Te Waka: Building The Canoe" segment gives a detailed exploration of traditional New Zealand craftsmanship, while the deleted scenes and Keisha Castle-Hughes' screen tests offer additional insights into the film's development. Though some elements appear slightly dated or in SD quality, they collectively enhance the viewing experience. The absence of the featurette on the movie’s score is a notable exclusion, but overall, this disc stands as a valuable edition for both fans and collectors.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Director Niki Caro: Insightful discussion on the filmmaking process.
- Behind-The-Scenes of Whale Rider: In-depth documentary featuring cast and crew interviews.
- Te Waka: Building The Canoe: Detailed featurette on canoe construction.
- Deleted Scenes with Optional Commentary: Eight deleted scenes with optional director and editor commentary.
- Keisha Castle-Hughes Screen Tests: Auditions featuring the main actress.
- Theatrical Trailers: Initial promotional trailers.
- TV Spots: Promotional TV advertisements.
- Poster Art and Photo Gallery: Collection of posters and promotional photos.
Movie: 81
Niki Caro’s 2002 film "Whale Rider" stands out as an exceptional piece of cinema, resonating deeply with audiences through its heartfelt portrayal of Maori culture. The film follows the journey of young Paikea (Keisha Castle-Hughes), a twelve-year-old Maori girl living in New Zealand, who challenges a millennium-old tradition that only males can ascend to leadership in her tribe. Adapted from Witi Ihimaera's novel, the story is a nuanced exploration of cultural heritage, confronting the inherent tension between tradition and modernity.
Castle-Hughes' performance as Pai is nothing short of extraordinary, showcasing a depth and maturity that earned her an Academy Award nomination at a remarkably young age. The supporting cast, including Rawiri Paratene as Pai’s stern grandfather Koro, and Vicky Haughton as her nurturing grandmother, add layers of emotional complexity that ground the mythical elements in genuine human experience. The cinematography by Leon Narbey captures the stunning landscapes of East New Zealand, enhancing the film's immersive quality. Complementing this visual splendor is Lisa Gerrard's haunting and ethereal score, which incorporates traditional Maori instruments to create a rich auditory backdrop.
Despite its indie roots, "Whale Rider" transcends genre boundaries, drawing apt comparisons to mainstream coming-of-age narratives like "The Karate Kid". However, it distinguishes itself with its profound cultural context and the authenticity of its storytelling. The film skillfully balances the emotional weight of Pai's struggle against patriarchal expectations with moments of tranquility and hope, making it accessible to a wide audience without compromising its cultural integrity. This blend of heartfelt narrative and technical finesse solidifies "Whale Rider" as a timeless and universally appealing film that continues to captivate viewers years after its release.
Total: 69
"Whale Rider," a powerful coming-of-age tale set against the backdrop of the Maori people in New Zealand, is long overdue for a North American Blu-ray release, and Shout Factory's edition does not disappoint. The film, starring Keisha Castle-Hughes, Rawiri Paratene, and Vicky Haughton, is directed by Niki Caro and based on Witi Ihimaera's book. With its engaging narrative and cultural richness, the movie has been a standout indie film of the 2000s. The Blu-ray release boasts a solid 2.35:1 AVC aspect ratio and offers both English DTS-HD MA 5.1 and 2.0 audio tracks, ensuring a high-quality viewing experience.
The 15th Anniversary Edition retains nearly all bonus materials from its previous DVD releases. While it would have been beneficial to include new interviews with Niki Caro and Keisha Castle-Hughes, fans will appreciate the comprehensive collection of features available. This release is an excellent upgrade for those still holding onto their DVD versions and a worthy addition for any Blu-ray collection. Even though there aren't significant new features, the leap to Blu-ray offers a noticeable enhancement in both picture and sound quality.
Conclusively, while I'm often hesitant to recommend indie films due to their niche appeal, "Whale Rider" is a rare exception. Despite its PG-13 rating, it remains family-friendly and universally entertaining from start to finish. Shout Factory’s Blu-ray release of "Whale Rider" excels in presentation and includes substantial special features, making it a highly recommended addition for both longtime fans and newcomers alike. This film has been eagerly awaited on Blu-ray and fulfills expectations royally.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 90
The film isn’t meant to look like a documentary, but the muted style of filming is exquisitely done and lovingly rendered by an excellent encode by Shout Factory....
Audio: 80
LFE is punchy and well placed, and the the overall track is quite well done for a dramatic film....
Extras: 70
• Audio commentary with director Niki Caro • "Te Waka: Building The Canoe" Featurette • "Behind-The-Scenes of Whale Rider" featurette • Deleted Scenes with optional commentary •...
Movie: 90
There are very few films detailing the lives of the Polynesian Maori tribesman (I did a review of Deadlands a few years back), and Whale Rider remains one of the most accessible art films out there on...
Total: 80
It’s got a PG-13 rating, but is very family friendly (the PG-13 rating is really overkill in my opinion), and is a sustainably entertaining flick from beginning to end....
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Stephen LarsonRead review here
Video: 90
The main feature is housed on a MPEG-4 AVC-encoded BD-50 and averages a bitrate of 31996 kbps....
Audio: 80
Dialogue is usually clear but for the windier outdoor moments, the optional English SDH come in handy....
Extras: 70
Eight Deleted Scenes with Optional Commentary by Director Niki Caro and Editor David Coulson (8:34, upconverted to 1080i) - Eight scenes that landed on the cutting room floor before the wide theatrical...
Movie: 90
In contradistinction to that myth, the villagers of Whangara believe that Paikea, their direct ancestor, arrived on the back of a whale after his canoe tipped over....
Total: 80
Whale Rider has long been overdue for a North American Blu-ray release and Shout Select has added one of the better indies during the 2000s to their catalog....
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 60
Aside from a few stray blips of compression noise in the heaviest visible grain, it’s a flawless presentation....
Audio: 60
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA experience largely comes from the front soundstage, opening up a bit in the rear channels for its moody score by Australian composer Lisa Gerrard....
Extras: 80
behind-the-scenes documentary is excellent and this is generally a fine set of special features, all produced back in 2003 when the DVD market was thriving and studios still cared about extras....
Movie: 80
The complex, bittersweet relationship between Koro, Pai and Porourangi is an engaging metaphor for the plight of the traditional Maori people as they attempt to hold onto customs dating back hundreds of...
Total: 70
A powerful coming-of-age tale set against the backdrop of the Maori people in New Zealand....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 70
Flesh Tones: Skin tones are natural and maintain a consistent appearance from the start of the film to the close....
Audio: 90
The balance of the music, vocals and sound effects is quite good, with each getting to showcase themselves without stepping on one another’s feet....
Extras: 50
Te Waka: Building The Canoe (SD, 11:15) – Ported over from the DVD, this is a history about the canoe featured in the film....
Movie: 70
Whale Rider is a nice coming of age story of a young girl and in a setting and culture that still feels untapped, fresh and original....
Total: 70
Its comes to Blu-ray in this 15-th Anniversary Edition, but aside from jumping to the Blu-ray format, I’m not sure what else is new....
Director: Niki Caro
Actors: Keisha Castle-Hughes, Rawiri Paratene, Vicky Haughton
PlotIn a small coastal village in New Zealand, the Maori community believes that their leader, the chief, must be a direct descendant of Paikea, the Whale Rider. When twins are born to the chief's family and the male twin dies, leaving only a girl named Paikea (Pai), her grandfather Koro is devastated. Koro, who is deeply rooted in tradition, refuses to acknowledge Pai as a potential leader because of her gender. Despite his love for Pai, he continues his search for a male successor, instructing the village boys in ancient customs and tribal practices to find the next chief.
Despite her grandfather's disapproval, Pai feels a deep connection to her ancestry and the sea, and she quietly perseveres in learning the traditions on her own. Struggling against the gender expectations imposed by her community and driven by her profound respect for her culture, Pai's journey of self-discovery and determination showcases the clash between old customs and new beliefs. As challenges arise, Pai’s conviction begins to awaken a sense of acceptance and transformation within her community, leading to unforeseen consequences that challenge the preconceived roles and beliefs.
Writers: Niki Caro, Witi Ihimaera
Release Date: 29 Aug 2003
Runtime: 101 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: New Zealand, Germany
Language: English, Maori