Killing Lincoln Blu-ray Review

The video presentation of "Killing Lincoln" on Blu-ray demonstrates a solid high-definition transfer that retains the film's intended aesthetic, yet presents certain technical inconsistencies. Shot digitally using Red Epic cameras, the video is intentionally subdued in its color palette to evoke a historical feel. The colors are largely desaturated, contributing richly to the period setting with evocative dusty neutral tones and soft candlelight glows. However, the non-filmic digital texture can be conspicuous, as the absence of film grain leaves the image overly smooth at times, which might seem out of place given the historical context.

The level of detail in the presentation fluctuates; close-ups reveal excellent fine detail, particularly in actors' faces and period-specific clothing, but mid-level and long-range shots may appear less defined and somewhat soft. Black levels and contrast are generally adequate but can vary. Darker scenes, especially prevalent in the program's latter half, sometimes lack depth and precision due to the soft presentation, detracting from the overall visual impact. Highlights occasionally look harsh and don't roll off smoothly, revealing the digital nature of the production.

Moreover, viewers may notice banding around light sources, particularly in candlelit scenes, which seems to be a deliberate choice rather than an oversight in the transfer. Despite these minor drawbacks, the absence of excessive compression and artificial enhancements like DNR or edge sharpening ensures a nearly cinema-like experience with stable video quality throughout. Overall, while this Blu-ray isn't the pinnacle of high-definition excellence, it delivers a reasonably engaging visual representation fitting for the film's narrative and thematic ambitions.

The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 presentation on the Blu Ray of "Killing Lincoln" is both dynamic and detailed, achieving a fine balance that elevates the overall listening experience. While it doesn't feature aggressive soundscapes typical of high-octane blockbusters, its use of extended dynamics and nuanced details enrich the storytelling. The soundtrack prioritizes dialogue and music, both of which are rendered with exceptional clarity and intonation. The bass, though not overwhelmingly powerful, adds an appreciable level of depth, particularly in sequences involving gunfire. Composer David Buckley's score is delivered with a smooth and airy quality, providing a room-filling sound that complements the on-screen action.

The 5.1 surround mix showcases an adept use of directional audio and imaging, with rear speakers actively contributing to the immersive soundfield. From the murmurs during Lincoln's second inaugural address to the ambience of a seaport and the cheers of theatergoers, the environment is meticulously crafted with a good sense of presence and clarity. Gunshots and other sound effects maintain a balanced presence without overshadowing the dialogue, ensuring that spoken words from the front channels are always clear and intelligible. Tom Hanks' narration is similarly well-handled, offering a stately presence that ties the audio together seamlessly.

Overall, the DTS-HD Master Audio track is impressive for a made-for-television production, delivering a mix that is both satisfying and engaging. Optional English SDH, Spanish, and French subtitles are provided, ensuring broad accessibility. The absence of audio defects or drop-outs further enhances the consistency and quality of this soundtrack.

The Blu-ray extras for "Killing Lincoln" are exceptionally informative and provide a rich, immersive experience into the film's production and historical accuracy. The audio commentary by executive producer and screenwriter Erik Jendresen stands out for its meticulous detail, elaborating on the depth of research undertaken to ensure historical fidelity. This dedication is similarly evidenced in the behind-the-scenes featurettes, which cover various aspects of the film's creation and the actors' immersion into their roles. An interview with author Bill O'Reilly gives insight into his motivations and historical anecdotes not covered in the film. Overall, these extras enhance the viewer's appreciation of both the filmmaking process and the historical context.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary with Executive Producer/Screenwriter Erik Jendresen: In-depth discussion on historical accuracy.
• Interview with Author Bill O'Reilly: Insight into motivations behind the book and film.
• Uncovering the Truth: The Making of Killing Lincoln: Comprehensive making-of featurette.
• Lincoln in Virginia: Promotional ad for Virginia tourism.
• Promotional Features: Brief behind-the-scenes segments.
• Preview for Killing Lincoln: Teaser for the film.
• Ultraviolet Digital Copy: Digital version for portable viewing.

"Killing Lincoln," based on the non-fiction book by Bill O'Reilly and Martin Dugard, delivers a historically accurate yet somewhat lackluster portrayal of the events surrounding President Abraham Lincoln's assassination. Produced by Ridley Scott and narrated by Tom Hanks, the National Geographic Channel docudrama meticulously lays out the conspiracy led by John Wilkes Booth. While it excels in factual accuracy, presenting nuanced historical contexts and detailed commentaries from writer/producer Erik Jendresen, it often feels dry and documentary-like, failing to delve deeply into the personal complexities or deeper motivations of its primary figures.

One of the standout features is Tom Hanks' narration, which intersperses the dramatic sequences with direct-to-camera exposition, offering an engaging personalized history lesson. Despite strong performances, Jesse Johnson’s depiction of Booth and Billy Campbell's portrayal of Lincoln lack depth, leaving viewers with a flat impression of these historical figures. The film emphasizes the broader conspiracy beyond Booth’s actions, detailing the attack on Secretary of State William Seward and the failed attempt on Vice President Andrew Johnson. However, it avoids dramatizing the personal lives of characters like Booth, reducing its potential emotional impact.

Technically, "Killing Lincoln" strives for precision, presenting various conflicting historical accounts and engaging with meticulous accuracy. The Blu-ray release supports this commitment to detail, offering high definition with added historical commentary. Ultimately, the film serves as a comprehensive educational tool rather than a deeply captivating drama, fitting neatly within the niche of factual entertainment while struggling to achieve theatrical dynamism or emotional engagement.

"Killing Lincoln," initially airing on the National Geographic Channel, aims to delve deeper into the events surrounding President Lincoln's assassination. Despite its ambitions, it offers a somewhat dry and uninspired retelling. The portrayal of John Wilkes Booth, in particular, fails to provide fresh insight into his psyche or motivations, leaving the historical figure as two-dimensional as before. Though the program might serve as a handy resource for middle school history classes, it seems less suited for engaging home-viewing experiences.

That said, the production still holds notable merits. It sidesteps potential political bias that might deter viewers wary of Bill O'Reilly's involvement and stands a respectable distance from comparisons to Steven Spielberg's "Lincoln." The technical execution of the Blu-ray presentation deserves commendation: the visual clarity and audio quality meet high standards, making the viewing experience smooth and engaging. Special bonus features add a layer of depth that enthusiasts might appreciate, but they may not be compelling enough to justify purchasing the disc over streaming options.

In conclusion, while "Killing Lincoln" may not captivate all audiences, it serves its purpose as an informational piece. Its competent technical presentation and significant historical context can appeal particularly to those interested in this pivotal chapter of American history. However, for more casual viewers, waiting for its availability on streaming platforms like Netflix or Amazon Prime could be a more prudent choice.