Red Dawn Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Red Dawn remake: all action, no depth. Fans will be disappointed; great A/V, no extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
Red Dawn's Blu-ray presents stunning, detailed visuals with natural colors and precise textures, despite minor black level inconsistencies, embodying modern action film aesthetics.
Audio: 84
'Red Dawn' Blu-ray boasts a reference-quality DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack, with explosive, immersive audio that enhances every action-packed moment and maintains clarity in dialogue and ambience, despite the movie's mediocrity.
Extra: 0
Despite the film's poor quality and expectations for new releases, the package surprisingly includes only a DVD along with iTunes and UV digital copies, completely devoid of any extra content or featurettes.
Movie: 36
The 'Red Dawn' remake, criticized for lackluster action and emotional depth, transforms a cult classic into a superficial, action-heavy movie, disappointing with its implausible North Korean antagonist and failing to capture the original's heartfelt, anti-war narrative.
Video: 74
The Blu-ray release of "Red Dawn" showcases an impressive video presentation that aligns with the expectations for high-definition modern cinema. The 1080p transfer exudes clarity with images that are consistently sharp and crystal clear, ensuring details like skin textures, clothing, and the environment are presented with remarkable precision. Viewers can appreciate the distinctness of elements in both bustling city scenes and the serene woodland hideouts, where every leaf and blade of grass holds its own identity, free from any digital compression artifacts. Colors are rendered with natural accuracy across a variety of settings, from urban grays to the vibrant greens of forests, maintaining fidelity irrespective of lighting conditions. The slight warmth to the image adds a subtle richness without compromising the overall balance.
However, despite these virtues, the video presentation is not without minor faults. There are occasional moments where black levels falter slightly, predominantly noticeable in a specific dialogue scene where they appear somewhat flat. This inconsistency is brief and does not detract significantly from the overall quality of the presentation, but it's an area where the visual execution shows room for improvement. Nonetheless, these are rare disruptions in what is otherwise a visually stunning presentation.
Fox's transfer of "Red Dawn" manages to capture the film's action-packed essence while also preserving the cinematic beauty of its diverse landscapes. From dynamic action sequences to quieter moments of introspection in dimly lit interiors, the video quality remains unfalteringly high. Despite incorporating modern cinematic techniques such as cyan filters and lens flares, the transfer remains faithful to delivering a polished and slick visual experience. Overall, this Blu-ray rendition stands as a commendable effort, balancing artistic intention with technical prowess to deliver a viewing experience that both respects and enhances the source material.
Audio: 84
Red Dawn" boasts an exemplary DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack on Blu-ray, setting a high bar for home theater experiences. Its superior audio design showcases intense action sequences with remarkable clarity and depth. The soundscape of gunfire and explosions is meticulously crafted, providing a robust and enveloping experience. Every bullet and blast is rendered with such precision that the auditory sensation alone is enough to keep viewers on the edge of their seats. This audio presentation doesn't just excel in action-packed moments; it also captures subtler sounds, from the atmospheric noises of nature to the bustling ambience of a football game, with exceptional detail and fidelity.
The mix balances intensity with nuance, ensuring that the more explosive scenes do not overshadow quieter moments or dialogue, which is consistently crisp and clear throughout. This careful engineering ensures that even amid the film's most chaotic scenes, dialogue remains perfectly intelligible. The soundtrack's dynamic range is impressive, with low-end frequencies providing a solid foundation that enhances the realism and impact of every explosion, without ever feeling overmixed or overwhelming the senses.
Furthermore, the soundtrack distinguishes itself with its handling of music and ambient effects, seamlessly integrating them into the overall soundscape. This creates an immersive audio experience that complements the visual spectacle of "Red Dawn," solidifying its position as a must-hear for audiophiles and action aficionados alike. The audio mix does an admirable job of balancing sheer power with intricate details, making every scene, whether intense or subdued, an auditory delight.
Extras:
The Blu-ray release of "Red Dawn" astonishingly falls short in terms of providing any value-added content, leaving enthusiasts and collectors equally perplexed and disappointed. Despite the film's own merits or lack thereof, it is unusually barren of the customary extras one might anticipate, such as behind-the-scenes featurettes, director’s commentaries, or even simple cast interviews. Instead, the package solely offers a DVD version and includes both iTunes and UV digital copies, which, while somewhat compensatory, hardly makes up for the complete absence of supplementary video materials that are typically expected to enrich the viewing experience. This lack of effort in exploiting the potential of the Blu-ray format to enhance the film's universe is a missed opportunity and significantly detracts from its overall appeal to its potential audience.
Extras included in this disc:
- No additional extras
Movie: 36
The latest incarnation of "Red Dawn" on Blu-ray wades into the murky waters of remake territory, bringing with it a flurry of technical polish and high-octane sequences, yet it ultimately falls short of capturing the essence that made the original a revered classic. The very fabric of the movie, much like its antagonist shift from China to North Korea— a decision born not out of narrative ingenuity but rather a last-minute capitulation to external pressure—symbolizes a fundamental misunderstanding of what gave the original its lasting appeal. In an era where 'Call of Duty'-style spectacles dominate, this Red Dawn iteration leans heavily into the action genre's most bombastic traits, offering a succession of gunfights and explosions that, while technically impressive, leave little room for the depth of character or thematic gravitas present in its predecessor.
At its core, the remake swaps the grim, introspective look at guerilla warfare for a sleeker, more superficial exploration of resistance, erasing the nuanced portrayal of loss, camaraderie, and moral ambiguity that characterized the Wolverines of the 1980s. The tight-knit group of resistors, once a gritty ensemble hardened by the realities of war, has been replaced by a cast that feels more at home in a CW drama, their development sacrificed on the altar of action. Jed Eckert (Chris Hemsworth) and his band of survivors are thrust into a visually stunning but emotionally hollow battle against North Korean invaders, a premise that strains credibility even with the film's concerted effort to frame it within a contemporary geopolitical context.
This reimagined "Red Dawn" demonstrates a meticulous attention to technical filmmaking and an ambition to modernize its story for a new audience. However, in its pursuit of spectacle and adherence to modern action mores, it loses sight of the heart and soul of its source material. Plagued by changes that seem driven more by fearful compliance than creative vision—evidenced by the controversial switch in antagonists—the film's narrative and emotional impact is significantly diluted. Instead of presenting a harrowing tale of survival and resistance punctuated by poignant moments of personal struggle, it opts for relentless action and shallow sentimentality, resulting in a portrayal that is as glossy as it is unmemorable.
Total: 59
The recent Blu-ray release of "Red Dawn" provides fans with a visually and audibly impressive experience, though it falls significantly short of capturing the nuanced spirit of the original 1984 film. This remake is marked by its emphasis on high-octane action sequences, relentless gunfire, and explosive set pieces, prioritizing a sleek presentation over the depth and reflective anti-war commentary that distinguished its predecessor. The technical brilliance of the Blu-ray, with its killer video quality and reference audio, stands in stark contrast to the movie's substantive deficiencies. Fans of the original will likely find this update jarring, as it diverges from the thought-provoking, uneasy atmosphere of the original, opting instead for a more superficial approach that focuses on the thrill of combat rather than conveying a broader message.
True to form, the Blu-ray edition of this remake boasts no additional content or special features, an omission that may disappoint enthusiasts hoping for a deeper dive into the film's production or insights from its creators. This lack of supplemental material reinforces the perception that this release prioritizes form over function, delivering a technically flawless viewing experience that lacks in narrative depth. The stellar audiovisual presentation, no doubt, makes it a worthwhile consideration for those purely interested in the sensory aspects of cinema, or for newcomers seeking an action-packed adventure unburdened by the weight of its origins.
To conclude, while the Blu-ray release of "Red Dawn" is a testament to modern filmmaking’s technical prowess, it serves as a reminder that dazzling visuals and resonant audio are but components of what makes a film truly memorable. The remake's deviation from the thematic essence of the original has resulted in a product that, although spectacular in sensory quality, might leave fans of the original yearning for the depth and complexity that once defined this story. As such, this Blu-ray stands as a mixed bag: a marvel of technical achievement housing a film that could have benefited from a more thoughtful approach to its source material.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The image is remarkably sharp and crystal clear, revealing film-perfect skin textures, clothing details, and structural city elements both intact and war-torn....
Audio: 100
The thump-thump of automatic weapons fire practically shreds the stage, heavy machine guns tear straight through, and explosions rock the listening area to its core....
Extras: 0
The package does, however, contain a DVD and both iTunes and UV digital copies of the film....
Movie: 40
Millius did write the story for the video game Homefront about a North Korean invasion of the United States, but that's beside the point and an entirely different project for an entirely different medium;...
Total: 60
Casual fans of the original might like it well enough, and newcomers craving some action will find a slick, well-made movie with endless gunfire....
High-Def Digest review by Aaron PeckRead review here
Video: 90
The image on screen is pristinely presented with refined edges, well-delineated shadows, and great contrast....
Audio: 100
At the beginning, when a plane explodes during the invasion and crashes into a house, the roar is pleasantly deafening....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 40
The movie fails in many areas, but the most egregious is when it tries to get sentimental and patriotic....
Total: 50
This one is all about the guns and how fun it is to be a kid with a gun with a reason to use it excessively....
Director: Dan Bradley
Actors: Chris Hemsworth, Isabel Lucas, Josh Hutcherson
PlotIn a quiet Washington state town, life is disrupted when paratroopers descend from the sky, heralding the beginning of a surprise invasion by North Korean forces. With their town captured and the United States under siege, recently returned Marine Jed Eckert and his brother Matt find themselves trapped behind enemy lines. As the invaders solidify their grip on the town, imposing martial law and taking over central points like the local police station, the brothers narrowly escape to their father's cabin in the woods.
Struggling to come to terms with the chaos, Jed, Matt, and a group of their friends and fellow students decide to fight back. They form a guerrilla resistance group, dubbing themselves the Wolverines after their high school mascot. The fledgling fighters embark on daring attacks against the occupying forces, using hit-and-run tactics to disrupt communications and supply lines, and inspire hope in the beleaguered townspeople. As they grow bolder, the Wolverines attract the attention of the occupation's commanders, who become intent on crushing the rising insurgency.
Writers: Carl Ellsworth, Jeremy Passmore, Kevin Reynolds
Release Date: 21 Nov 2012
Runtime: 93 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, Korean