The Stool Pigeon Blu-ray Review
綫人 Sin yan
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Stool Pigeon offers great performances, impressive visuals and audio, but is hindered by clunky scripting, making it a mostly entertaining yet flawed experience.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 67
The Stool Pigeon on Blu-ray features an impeccably sharp 1080p AVC encoded transfer in 2.35:1 with excellent depth, strong detail, and a stylized blue-grey color palette that highlights the gritty glamour of Hong Kong, deep black levels, and high contrast. Minor grain issues are present but don't detract significantly.
Audio: 67
The Cantonese DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks deliver brilliant lossless audio, with excellent surround activity, dynamic range, crisp dialogue, powerful LFE, and engaging directionality, ensuring an immersive experience during both subtle and action-packed scenes.
Extra: 31
Well Go USA Entertainment's Blu-ray extras for 'The Stool Pigeon' feature standard-definition behind-the-scenes footage and deleted scenes, with insightful but occasionally tedious material; a making-of segment with cast and crew interviews; and two international HD trailers, all delivered with Cantonese Dolby Digital 2.0 sound and English subtitles.
Movie: 61
The Stool Pigeon combines introspective character study with traditional action elements, featuring standout performances from Nick Cheung and Nicholas Tse, and directed with a keen eye by Dante Lam. While its emotional themes and some subplots can feel overdone, the film's gripping action sequences and nuanced exploration of a cop-informant relationship make it a notable, if flawed, Hong Kong thriller.
Video: 67
The Stool Pigeon is presented on Blu-ray courtesy of Well Go USA with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.35:1 aspect ratio, offering an impeccably sharp and well-detailed high-definition presentation. The director's intentional color palette favors a gritty blue-grey tone, which tastefully enhances the film's moody atmosphere. Despite this stylistic choice, fine detail remains consistently clear, allowing the intricate textures of the film's environment and characters to be vividly rendered. The depiction of Hong Kong's gritty glamour is spectacularly captured, with close-ups revealing remarkable detail, albeit sometimes distressingly so during intense scenes. Minor edge enhancement appears briefly in a few scenes but is negligible overall.
The transfer effectively maintains the film's intentionally gritty aesthetic, characterized by light to moderate grain that adds a rough texture fitting for the narrative. Detail levels are often quite strong, especially notable in the portrayal of the characters' often bruised and beaten faces. The movie's stylized cinematography highlights blue and yellow hues, contributing to a visual experience rich in depth and color pop. Black levels are impressively deep and inky, while contrast is high yet balanced, adding to the overall razor-sharp image quality. Despite a few minor technical issues like isolated grain resolution problems and occasional soft scenes, the transfer excels in preserving the film’s intended visual style, making it a thoroughly satisfying high-definition presentation.
Audio: 67
The audio presentation of "The Stool Pigeon" Blu-ray is exceptional and offers a thoroughly engaging experience. It provides multiple audio options, including Cantonese DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1, Cantonese Dolby Digital 2.0, English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 dub, and English Dolby Digital 2.0 dub. Notably, the Cantonese DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track stands out with its brilliant lossless audio quality, featuring fantastic surround activity, excellent fidelity, and wide dynamic range. Dialogue is consistently crisp and clear, with well-positioned and prioritized speech even during sonically busy sequences. The Cantonese track particularly shines during intense action scenes, where discrete channel utilization places the listener at the heart of the audio action.
Both the Cantonese and English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks provide a lively mix that enhances the film's many exciting moments. The audio design effectively uses directionality and surround sound to create a fully immersive soundscape. City ambiance envelopes the listener while action sequences—replete with whizzing bullets, crashing cars, blazing guns, and deep, resonant bass—rattle the floorboards with powerful effects. The dynamic range is impressively wide, featuring high fidelity and well-handled balance that prioritizes speech without sacrificing the mix’s overall range and impact.
In sum, “The Stool Pigeon” on Blu-ray is a masterful audio experience. Its mix of subtlety in quieter segments and exhilarating bombast during action scenes makes it an aural delight for crime thriller enthusiasts. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks, both in Cantonese and English, deliver highly satisfying performances, ensuring listeners are thoroughly drawn into the intricate soundscapes of this compelling film.
Extras: 31
Well Go USA Entertainment has produced a concise yet engaging set of extras for the Blu Ray of "The Stool Pigeon." Primarily in standard definition, these bonus features are presented with Cantonese Dolby Digital 2.0 sound and English subtitles, effectively complementing the main content. The "Behind the Scenes" feature provides a thorough look into the filming process, highlighting stunt work and challenging sequences, although some content might seem extraneous. The deleted scenes offer additional context, especially focusing on character backstories, though their exclusion from the final cut appears justified. The "Making Of" feature offers insightful interviews with cast and crew, touching on themes, inspirations, and casting choices. Additionally, two international trailers in high definition round out the offerings. Notably, the menu's automatic playback feature could either be a help or a hindrance depending on viewer preference.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind the Scenes: Raw behind-the-scenes footage with a focus on stunts and chase scenes.
- Deleted Scenes: Includes five scenes focusing on extended character backstories.
- Making Of: Interviews with cast and crew discussing themes, inspirations, and casting.
- International Trailer A: High-definition trailer.
- International Trailer B: Additional high-definition trailer.
Movie: 61
Director Dante Lam blends gritty noir sensibilities with kinetic action in the 2010 Hong Kong thriller, "The Stool Pigeon." The narrative meticulously explores the complex relationship between police officers and their informants, centering on Detective Don Lee (Nick Cheung) and Ghost Jr. (Nicholas Tse), an illegal street racer turned informant. The movie opens with a botched drug bust that leaves Lee's informant, Jabber (Liu Kai-Chi), brutalized, setting a dark tone. The plot follows Lee as he recruits Ghost Jr., who has personal motives tied to his sister's plight, to infiltrate a criminal gang led by Barbarian (Yi Lu). The film continuously shifts its focus between Lee’s guilt-ridden by-the-book demeanor and Ghost Jr.'s perilous dual life, allowing for deep character exploration amid the action.
Lam’s directorial prowess shines through the film’s visceral action sequences. Key highlights include a car chase paired with "White Christmas," showcasing his ability to juxtapose violence with serenity, creating memorable cinematic moments. Cheung and Tse exhibit palpable chemistry, bringing nuance to their respective roles, while Liu Kai-Chi delivers a heart-wrenching performance as the beleaguered Jabber. Despite these strengths, the film stumbles with overindulgent subplots, particularly those related to Lee’s haunted past, which strain the narrative flow and feel somewhat gratuitous. Additionally, stylistic flourishes sometimes come off as superficial, undermining the otherwise tightly wound script.
"The Stool Pigeon" attempts a daring blend of action and introspective drama. While it occasionally falters in maintaining balance—particularly in scenes delving into Lee's personal turmoils—it succeeds in delivering an engaging exploration of guilt, loyalty, and redemption. Its intricate character studies and impactful action sequences are marred only slightly by its less cohesive elements. For audiences appreciative of both character-driven narratives and high-octane action, especially fans of films like "The Departed" and "Heat," this movie proves to be an intriguing, if imperfect, endeavor.
Total: 59
'The Stool Pigeon' is a dynamic film that showcases a balanced blend of action and psychological depth. Director Dante Lam demonstrates a confident hand, deftly merging visceral sequences with introspective character development. The film excels in delivering high-tension moments, bolstered by strong performances from the cast. Although some narrative elements may come across as overambitious or heavy-handed, these minor critiques do not overshadow the overall impact and entertainment value.
The Blu-ray technical specifications are impressive. The video quality is exceptional, bringing out the gritty vibrancy of Hong Kong's streets with remarkable clarity. The audio presentation is equally strong, providing an immersive experience that enhances the tension and emotional weight of the film. The supplemental features, while not extensive, offer solid additional content that complements the main feature well.
In conclusion, 'The Stool Pigeon' may not be completely flawless, but it largely succeeds in its ambitious dual approach. With great performances and Lam's assured direction, it stands apart from the usual fare. The effective use of psychological elements entwined with traditional action tropes adds substantial depth. The Blu-ray presentation is top-notch, making this release highly recommended for those seeking a fresh twist on the genre.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
There is some very minor (almost negligible) edge enhancement which crops up in a couple of scenes, but it's fleeting and shouldn't bother most....
Audio: 90
But many of the action sequences, including the brutal smackdown that caps the film, are filled with great discrete channel utilization that really puts the listener squarely in the center of very involving...
Extras: 50
Behind the Scenes (SD; 46:38) is the usual assortment of scenes being shot interspersed with setups and other preparations....
Movie: 70
Unfortunately, The Stool Pigeon lacks Beast Stalker's immediacy and in fact seems to slather on the emotional turmoil a bit too much for its own good, especially with regard to at least a couple of subplots...
Total: 70
The Stool Pigeon may not in fact be completely successful, but it's largely successful, and that, coupled with great performances and a sure directorial hand by Lam, make this a really interesting "combo"...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Though there are a few very small technical hiccups and an occasional soft scene or two, the movie's intentional look is preserved well and shines through nicely on Blu-ray....
Audio: 80
Directionality and surround use are very strong, creating a full and immersive soundscape full of whizzing bullets and crashing cars....
Extras: 20
Making of (SD, 15 min) - This is a more traditional promotional piece about the making of the film that features cast and crew interviews with some behind-the-scenes footage....
Movie: 60
The character's scenes are also home to most of the film's action and suspense, and the script features some effectively tense moments, including one particularly nail-biting sequence that sees one of...
Total: 60
'The Stool Pigeon' offers some exciting action and occasional thrills, but unfortunately, it suffers from some clunky scripting and over-the-top choices....
Director: Dante Lam
Actors: Nick Cheung, Nicholas Tse, Gwei Lun-Mei
PlotDon Lee is a deeply troubled police detective who has experienced numerous professional and personal setbacks. Haunted by a botched operation that left an informant dead and his own marriage in shambles, Don is driven by guilt and a relentless desire for redemption. He becomes fixated on bringing down the notorious gang leader Barbarian. In order to accomplish this, Don recruits Ghost, a skilled but emotionally scarred street racer, as his latest informant. Ghost, desperate for money to secure a better future for his sister and himself, reluctantly agrees to infiltrate Barbarian's gang, despite the immense danger involved.
As Ghost delves deeper into the criminal underworld, he faces constant threats and tests of loyalty that put his life at risk. Don, struggling with his own internal demons, tries to guide and protect Ghost from the sidelines but finds it increasingly difficult to keep the young man safe. Tension mounts as both men grapple with their own moral dilemmas and the cost of their choices. The situation intensifies when Barbarian's plans grow more ruthless, pushing Ghost to the brink. The film reaches a gripping climax, exploring themes of trust, sacrifice, and the heavy burden of guilt.
Writers: Man-Lung Ho, Dante Lam, Wai-Lun Ng
Release Date: 26 Aug 2010
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: R
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Cantonese