Monte Walsh Blu-ray Review

Presented in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio with MPEG-4 AVC encoding, "Monte Walsh" on Blu-ray from Kino Lorber features a 1080p transfer that marks a notable improvement over its decade-old high-definition debut. Utilizing the same MGM-supplied master, this Special Edition rectifies previous gamma level issues by employing a dual-layer disc, enhancing both stability and quality of the presentation. This adjustment results in a discernible uptick in video fidelity, reflected in both indoor and outdoor scenes that exhibit improved clarity and detail.

Despite the improvements, potential viewers should note that the current master still carries minor imperfections, such as occasional nicks and marks. While these do not detract significantly from the viewing experience, a thorough 4K restoration could potentially bring forth a revitalized visual presentation, enriching highlight management and grain consistency, especially in darker sequences. Nevertheless, the color balance is convincingly accurate, with primary colors exhibiting commendable nuance, even though enhanced vibrancy in some areas could elevate the visuals further.

For those with large screens, this Blu-ray release presents a noticeably improved visual experience over the previous edition. The upscaling to 4K demonstrates significant visual strength, making this edition a worthwhile upgrade for dedicated collectors and cinephiles alike. However, be aware that this is a Region-A locked release necessitating a compatible player. The overall video quality received a favorable assessment, rated at 4.25 out of 5.

The Blu-ray release of "Monte Walsh" is equipped with an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, which delivers a commendable audio experience despite its mono nature. Subtitles in English SDH are available, appearing neatly within the image frame for accessibility. The audio exhibits a robust dynamic range, and its upper register maintains clarity without any evident age-related distortions, even when played at higher volumes. This suggests meticulous preservation of audio quality, though slight rebalancing could potentially enhance the current strength of the track without diminishing its effectiveness.

Despite being from an older transfer, the featured DTS-HD Master Audio (2.0 mono) remains quite adequate for this release. It effectively supports the visual elements of the film, providing a consistent auditory experience. The disc, encoded for Region A, includes optional English subtitles to accommodate diverse viewing preferences. While there might be minimal room for technical advancement, the current presentation succeeds in providing an engaging sonic backdrop to complement the movie's visuals, maintaining fidelity to the film's original atmosphere.

The reviews reveal that the Blu Ray extras of "Monte Walsh" provide an insightful dive into both the film's historical context and the legacy of its lead actor. Dwayne Epstein's audio commentary stands out as a significant highlight, offering an in-depth analysis of the film as part of a broader cinematic trend from the 1960s depicting the decline of the Old West. Epstein enriches the experience with intriguing anecdotes about Lee Marvin, including personal stories and professional challenges, as well as discussions about his collaborations with industry icons like Jack Palance. This commentary is deemed indispensable for enthusiasts wishing to gain a deeper understanding of Marvin’s impact on the film and his broader cinematic oeuvre. Additionally, the included vintage trailer offers a nostalgic glimpse into the film's original promotional strategies.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary: In-depth audio commentary by Lee Marvin biographer Dwayne Epstein.
• Trailer: Vintage trailer for "Monte Walsh".

The 1970 film "Monte Walsh," directed by William A. Fraker, is presented on Blu-ray by Kino Lorber. It offers an insightful commentary by Lee Marvin biographer Dwayne Epstein and a classic trailer as part of its supplemental features. The release is in English with optional English SDH subtitles and is Region-A locked. This Western unearths the sobering reality of the Old West, eschewing the glamorized portrayals often seen in period Hollywood productions.

Lee Marvin excels in the titular role, embodying a cowboy grappling with the obsolescence of his way of life. Monte Walsh's narrative centers around his struggle to adapt to changing times as he contemplates settling down amidst disappearing job opportunities. A poignant subplot unfolds through his interactions with Jeanne Moreau’s character, Martine, providing a nuanced exploration of love and companionship set against a backdrop of inevitable change. Jack Palance’s portrayal of Chet adds depth, accentuating themes of friendship and tragedy when betrayal and desperation lead to violence.

Cinematographer David M. Walsh captures striking visuals that enhance the film’s atmospheric drama, aligning perfectly with Fraker's directorial vision. The movie’s pace is deliberate, reflecting its poetic undertones, while engaging action sequences, particularly involving Marvin's attempt to tame a wild mustang, deliver intense thrills. Fraker, renowned for cinematography on films like "Bullitt" and "Rosemary’s Baby," deftly transitions into his directorial debut here, evoking a raw authenticity in this contemplative Western. With thoughtfully choreographed shootouts and textured performances by a top-tier cast, "Monte Walsh" serves as both a lament and a tribute to a vanishing era, succeeding as a uniquely subdued yet powerful example of the genre.

The Blu-ray release of "Monte Walsh," directed by William A. Fraker, provides viewers with a captivating glimpse into the waning days of the Old West, as realized by Lee Marvin’s profound performance. This release, labeled as a "special edition," includes an exclusive audio commentary track by Marvin's biographer, Dwayne Epstein, which adds a rich layer of historical context and insight into the film's production and narrative themes. The film, originally shot in 2.35:1 Panavision, offers a satisfactory visual experience. Despite the lack of remastering, which results in some visual imperfections such as speckling, the transfer holds up reasonably well.

The audio component is presented in DTS-HD Master Audio (2.0 mono), ensuring clear dialogue and sound effects though lacking more immersive qualities found in modern audio formats. The inclusion of optional English subtitles is a thoughtful addition for accessibility. However, it is important to note that the disc is Region "A" encoded, limiting its playability to specific geographic locations unless appropriate playback equipment is available.

As a film that poignantly captures the end of a storied era, "Monte Walsh" remains a compelling watch. The release could benefit from more encompassing extras and a fresh digital remaster to entice cinephiles who prefer pristine presentations. Nevertheless, Lee Marvin's portrayal and the thematic depth of the storyline resonate strongly, making this edition a worthwhile acquisition for fans of Westerns. If "Monte Walsh" has yet to become part of your collection, consider obtaining it alongside David Miller's "Lonely Are the Brave" for a coherent exploration of similar themes. This edition is strongly recommended, enhanced by the insightful commentary and solid presentation despite some technical limitations.