Daisy Kenyon Blu-ray Review
Score: 65
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Daisy Kenyon, a restrained Joan Crawford film, marred by some unnecessary courtroom drama but noteworthy for its honest performances; Kino’s Blu-ray, although flawed, is a worthwhile upgrade.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 58
The AVC encoded image in 1.33:1 aspect ratio presents wear and tear, with occasional scratches and fading leading to milkier black levels. Detail varies, with Crawford's glamour lighting softening frames, yet some shots retain texture. Overall, inconsistencies in density affect grayscale elements and sharpness.
Audio: 68
The DTS-HD MA 2.0 mono mix provides robust dialogue and immersive musical scoring while maintaining clear atmospheric effects, though it occasionally reveals mild hiss.
Extra: 71
The Blu-ray extras of 'Daisy Kenyon' feature an engaging commentary by film noir historian Foster Hirsch, insightful discussions on Otto Preminger’s tumultuous career and production anecdotes from 'Life in the Shadows,' along with a nostalgic animated image montage and theatrical trailer.
Movie: 71
"Daisy Kenyon" skillfully delves into a complex love triangle, with standout performances by Joan Crawford, Dana Andrews, and Henry Fonda. Otto Preminger's direction eschews typical melodrama for a more nuanced portrayal of human relationships, while David Hertz’s screenplay adeptly humanizes morally ambiguous characters.
Video: 58
The Blu-ray presentation of "Daisy Kenyon" utilizes an AVC encoded image at a 1.33:1 aspect ratio, maintaining the film's original theatrical dimensions in 1080p resolution. The transfer handles the source material well, though some wear and tear are visible, including scratches of varying intensity and occasional fade that contributes to milkier black levels.
Density inconsistencies are present, oscillating between sharp and strikingly monochrome scenes with excellent grayscale elements, to moments verging on washed out. The glamour close-ups of Joan Crawford are characteristically less crisp but intentionally softened to erase signs of aging, while certain shots preserve their texture particularly well. Male leads' details in facial expressions and elaborate costumes remain well-defined. Grain is consistently fine and filmic.
This amalgamation of the input reviews offers a thorough examination of the technical aspects of the video presentation, noting its strengths and areas where it falters.
Audio: 68
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono sound mix for "Daisy Kenyon" presents a commendable level of fidelity and immersion. Dialogue exchanges are front and center, with emotional nuances well-preserved, ensuring clarity in both intense and subdued scenes. The score by David Raksin is particularly noteworthy, brought to life with rich musicality that enhances the film’s melodramatic tones. Although the soundstage is relatively straightforward, ambient effects are utilized effectively to contextualize the action without overwhelming the primary audio elements.
Atmospherically, the mix maintains a basic but effective presence, providing support to the narrative without drawing undue attention. There is a minor presence of mild hiss, though it does not detract significantly from the overall listening experience. Notably, post-dubbing in outdoor scenes is expertly integrated, avoiding any jarring inconsistencies. The sound mix remains free of age-related artifacts such as crackle, pops, or flutter, indicating a well-preserved and skillfully transferred audio track.
Extras: 71
The Blu-ray release of "Daisy Kenyon" boasts a robust collection of extras that enrich the viewing experience, providing both historical context and in-depth analysis. The audio commentary by Otto Preminger expert Foster Hirsch is particularly commendable, offering detailed insights into the film’s strengths and weaknesses. "From Journeyman to Artist: Otto Preminger at Fox" gathers film historians who delve into Preminger’s complex career, highlighting his tumultuous relationship with Darryl F. Zanuck and celebrating his cinematic achievements. "Life in the Shadows: The Making of 'Daisy Kenyon'" provides a candid account of the film’s production challenges and behind-the-scenes dynamics involving Joan Crawford and the other leading actors. The Animated Image Montage and Theatrical Trailer complete a well-rounded supplementary package that appeals to both casual viewers and cinephiles.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Analysis by film historian Foster Hirsch.
- From Journeyman to Artist: Overview of Otto Preminger’s career.
- Life in the Shadows: Account of the film’s troubled production.
- Animated Image Montage: Publicity materials and BTS photos.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original theatrical trailer.
Movie: 71
"Daisy Kenyon," directed by Otto Preminger, represents a sophisticated departure from typical 1940s melodramas, bringing a nuanced take on complex relationship dynamics framed by a traditional love triangle. Based on Elizabeth Janeway's novel, the screenplay by David Hertz avoids excessive sentimentality, instead offering a candid exploration of marital and relationship difficulties with a notably authentic tone. The film's sharp cast is led by Joan Crawford, Dana Andrews, and Henry Fonda, each delivering multifaceted performances that add depth to their troubled characters. Fonda, in particular, excels as a war veteran grappling with his feelings toward Daisy, played by Crawford. Despite its melodramatic underpinnings, the film's authenticity in treating emotional chaos and characters' confessions shines through, giving it an engaging edge.
Enhanced by Preminger's directorial decisions, "Daisy Kenyon" challenges gender clichés and delves into the psychological motivations of its characters. Preminger's preference for long takes and minimal cutting ensures that interactions unfold naturally within the frame, fostering organic character developments and audience connections. Although the studio's grandiose production design may seem excessive—especially evident in the sprawling New York loft and other lavish sets—it somehow contrasts effectively with the film's intimate human interest narrative. The movie maintains suspense and unpredictability right up to its final moments, underscoring the uncertainty inherent in the characters' entangled lives.
Joan Crawford delivers a notably restrained performance for this phase of her career, despite being miscast due to her age. Dana Andrews' charismatic portrayal of a conflicted lawyer and Henry Fonda's understated depiction of a PTSD-afflicted veteran add layers of complexity to the story. Other supporting roles, including Ruth Warrick as a nearly hysterical wife and mother, consolidate the movie’s emotional palette while reflecting the era's subtler handling of contentious issues like child abuse. This convergence of talent—combined with an adept script and Preminger’s precise direction—results in a captivating film that transcends its melodramatic roots, presenting an impactful study of love and infidelity.
Total: 65
"Daisy Kenyon" is a noteworthy film from the mid-to-late 1940s that showcases one of Joan Crawford's most controlled performances during her career renaissance. Directed by Otto Preminger, the film navigates through a complex narrative of romantic entanglements and emotional turbulence. The story, while leisurely paced, maintains engagement through its intricate exploration of human relationships and nuanced character portrayals. The Blu-ray release by Kino provides a notable opportunity to appreciate these elements, although some video quality issues are present.
The transfer quality of the Blu-ray is a mixed bag, with certain scenes demonstrating a clear enhancement over previous DVD versions, yet some persistent problems detract from the overall experience. Despite that, the film's production values remain first-rate, offering a visually compelling 1940s period piece. The performances of the lead actors stand out, significantly elevating the material and providing a certain modernity to the otherwise melodramatic sequences. The courtroom detour in the third act, while potentially stalling the narrative flow, brings a unique tension and unexpected depth to the character arcs.
In conclusion, while "Daisy Kenyon" may falter slightly due to pacing issues and minor technical shortcomings in its Blu-ray rendition, it remains a film of substantial merit due to its robust performances and sophisticated direction. Fans of Joan Crawford and classic cinema will find this an essential addition to their collection. Otto Preminger’s deft handling ensures that a balance between audience expectations and genuine artistic expression is maintained, resulting in an enduring work that transcends its era.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 70
Still, certain shots keep their texture, and the male leads are more open for inspection, including facial responses and thick costuming....
Audio: 70
The DTS-HD MA sound mix is limited, but it finds a comfortable level of engagement, leading with dialogue exchanges that always keep emotional surges in control, while hushed encounters aren't lost....
Extras: 80
"Life in the Shadows: The Making of 'Daisy Kenyon'" (16:12, SD) recounts the troubled production, which went through casting difficulties before settling on Crawford, who brought with her a list of demands,...
Movie: 70
"Daisy Kenyon" is not a subtle feature, but it does have candor and a few eye-raising scenes of confession, with the production working to keep maudlin interests on the sidelines long enough to help generate...
Total: 70
It's an unnecessary detour, but performances keep the material alert, riding the line between sudsy declarations of need and more realistic expectations of others....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 70
Density inconsistencies are the primary problems here with some scenes looking smashingly sharp and gorgeously monochrome with excellent grayscale elements and others appearing on the verge of being washed...
Audio: 90
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono sound mix offers a strong track featuring very nicely recorded dialogue (post dubbing in outdoor scenes has been skillfully blended to not be that noticeable) combined...
Extras: 70
Life in the Shadows – The Making of Daisy Kenyon (16:12, SD): the story of the film’s production is told by Victoria Preminger, Dana Andrews’ children Susan and Stephen, and film experts Foster Hirsch,...
Movie: 80
Before that happens, however, we’re treated to a lengthy courtroom scene during the divorce proceedings which gives Joan Crawford her requisite chance to emote theatrically (elsewhere, Preminger restrains...
Total: 70
One of the best and most controlled of the movies which Joan Crawford made during her career renaissance in the mid-to-late 1940s, Daisy Kenyon reads quite modern today with a definite lack of histrionics...
Director: Otto Preminger
Actors: Joan Crawford, Dana Andrews, Henry Fonda
PlotDaisy is a successful commercial artist in New York who finds herself entangled in a complicated love affair. She is romantically involved with Dan, a married but influential lawyer, whose promises of leaving his wife for Daisy seem increasingly hollow. Daisy's emotional turmoil intensifies when she meets Peter, a World War II veteran grappling with his own past traumas and seeking solace in her company. Torn between Dan’s manipulative charm and Peter’s earnest affection, Daisy must navigate her own desires and moral dilemmas.
As Daisy contemplates her future, societal expectations and personal fulfillment loom large over her decisions. Dan's wife becomes suspicious, complicating matters further, while Peter’s unpredictable behavior leaves Daisy questioning the stability he could offer. Each character's choices lead to shifting dynamics and heightened emotional stakes, drawing Daisy into a crescendo of decisive moments that will ultimately determine her path forward.
Writers: David Hertz, Elizabeth Janeway
Release Date: 25 Dec 1947
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English