The Way We Were Blu-ray Review

The video presentation of “The Way We Were” on Blu-ray represents an outstanding effort from Sony-Columbia, showcasing an AVC encoded 1080p transfer presented in a 2.40:1 aspect ratio. The film's palette is exquisitely reproduced, with vivid primary colors and cooler tones beautifully rendered on the screen, adding splendid depth to aerial shots and detailed location work. The fine detail is exemplary, particularly spotlighting the craftsmanship of costume designer Dorothy Jeakins. Moreover, the image boasts excellent clarity and contrast, complemented by a stable and damage-free presentation.

The transfer holds a natural-looking fine grain, adding to its filmic authenticity without becoming obtrusive. Harry Stradling Jr.'s cinematography is displayed in all its glory, honoring the film's period setting with a romantic, dream-like glow typical of Hollywood's golden age. The transfer is free from any nicks, marks, or scratches, ensuring the source material’s pristine condition. Digital enhancements are applied so subtly that they remain virtually undetectable, preserving the natural integrity of the film.

Black levels are rich and deep, providing vibrant contrast that enhances Redford’s white Navy uniform and Streisand's striking lipstick and nail polish. Verdant landscapes and crystal blue seas add further visual charm. Background elements and textures are solid and well-defined, while close-ups reveal intricate details, such as Streisand's creamy complexion and Redford's ruddy features. Overall, this Blu-ray presentation will likely exceed the expectations of even the most discerning fans, making it an unequivocal recommendation for upgrading their collection.

The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix of "The Way We Were" provides a notably immersive experience for a romantic drama, though it varies in its surround sound utilization. Scenes such as Katie's impassioned moment in front of a microphone are particularly well-executed, making excellent use of the side and rear channels to enhance crowd noises. Similarly, during the intense HUAC hearings, there is an effective sense of sonic claustrophobia that adds to the scene's tension. By the ocean, the mix captures a nice sense of spaciousness that enriches these sequences. While ambient effects might be somewhat muted in certain parts, the mix does ensure crisp interior accents and clean dialogue throughout.

The handling of Marvin Hamlisch's Oscar-winning score is a standout aspect of this audio presentation. Though sometimes mixed at a lower volume, the music effectively spills into the surround channels, enveloping the listener. Notably, Barbra Streisand's rendition of the iconic theme song benefits from a wide dynamic range, maintaining clarity and avoiding distortion even in its most passionate moments. Stereo separation is commendable, with distinct elements emanating from the left and right channels, broadening the soundscape and adding depth to scenes predominantly driven by dialogue.

Overall, while this isn't an overly showy surround mix, it offers a more immersive experience than many other films in the genre. Dialogue remains consistently clear and comprehensible, enhancing the narrative's emotional weight. An isolated music track is also available for those who wish to indulge in the film's romantic score exclusively.

The Blu-ray of "The Way We Were" is complemented by an exceptional selection of extras, enriching the viewer’s understanding and appreciation of the film. Notably, the disc features two expert commentaries. Director Sydney Pollack provides a reflective audio commentary, packed with detailed anecdotes and insights about the film's production, structure, and uncredited script revisions. Complementing this is the commentary by Julie Kirgo and Nick Redman, offering an engaging mix of film history and interesting tangential information. A standout is the comprehensive featurette "Looking Back," which includes interviews with key cast members, presenting an in-depth retrospective view despite Robert Redford's notable absence. The inclusion of Marvin Hamlisch's isolated score in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 allows fans to appreciate the Oscar-winning music separately. While some archival materials from previous releases were omitted, this collection profoundly enhances the home viewing experience.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary with Director Sydney Pollack: Insightful reflections and behind-the-scenes anecdotes.
• Audio Commentary with Julie Kirgo and Nick Redman: Engaging discussion on film history and tangential subjects.
• Looking Back: Detailed featurette with interviews and insights into the film's production.
• Original Theatrical Trailer: Preview focused on Streisand and Redford's pairing.
• Isolated Score: Marvin Hamlisch's score in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, including Barbra Streisand's theme song.

"The Way We Were" transports viewers through a nostalgic yet critically reflective lens on mid-20th century sociopolitical movements and relationships. The film juxtaposes the fervent activism of Katie Morosky (Barbra Streisand) against the easygoing charm of Hubbell Gardiner (Robert Redford), set against significant historical backdrops like the Spanish Civil War and McCarthyism. Arthur Laurents' screenplay weaves intricate character studies, particularly exploring Katie’s ideals and Hubbell's passive approach to life. Though this dichotomy between the protagonists sometimes feels overly orchestrated, it underlines broader ideological conflicts of the era. The film’s essence is succinctly encapsulated by its Academy Award-winning theme song by Marvin Hamlisch, which transcends the narrative to become an iconic cultural touchstone.

Director Sydney Pollack expertly balances a complex political subtext with a straightforward romantic narrative, producing a film that is both emotionally resonant and thematically rich. Despite the initial gutting of its political plotline post-preview, which some argue diluted the film’s substance, the decision evidently elevated the love story that fans continue to cherish. The casting of Streisand and Redford is impeccable, with both delivering performances that range from intensely personal to disarmingly charming. Streisand’s portrayal of Katie is especially striking, merging passion and vulnerability in a role that arguably defines her dramatic prowess. Redford’s understated yet compelling take on Hubbell complements Streisand's energy, resonating through their palpable on-screen chemistry.

"The Way We Were" remains an emblem of classic Hollywood romance, with Pollack’s nuanced direction and Hamlisch’s evocative score playing crucial roles in its enduring appeal. The film’s lush cinematography and carefully crafted production design provide a visual and emotional warmth, offsetting the turbulent societal changes depicted. While some critics note the film’s tendency to prioritize romantic elements at the expense of deeper ideological exploration, its ability to evoke powerful emotions and generate memorable moments cements its place as a beloved cinematic work.

Twilight Time's Blu-ray release of "The Way We Were" expertly captures the essence of this beloved romantic drama, despite some debates over its narrative execution. The film, featuring the star power of Barbra Streisand and Robert Redford, evokes strong emotional responses, enhanced by Marvin Hamlisch’s poignant score. Some viewers may feel that the characters are overly simplified—Katie’s relentless activism is one-dimensional, while Hubbell often appears lackluster in his willingness to conform. Nevertheless, the film’s emotional power is undeniable, and the performances from the leads are captivating.

The Blu-ray presentation is where this release truly excels. The video transfer is remarkably clear, preserving the film’s original aesthetic while offering a visual upgrade that brings new life to the decades-old footage. The audio quality is equally impressive, delivering a crisp and immersive experience that complements the film's evocative soundtrack. This edition also includes a couple of supplementary features that provide deeper insight into the film's production and legacy, making it an invaluable addition for any collector or fan.

In conclusion, "The Way We Were" may have certain narrative shortcomings, but its emotional impact and technical merits make the Blu-ray release a standout. Despite some dated elements in the storyline, the exceptional restoration and additional content ensure that this film remains a cherished piece of cinematic history. For these reasons, this Blu-ray edition comes highly recommended.