Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children Blu-ray Review
Score: 72
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
While 'Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children' visually impresses with strong technical merits, its underdeveloped storyline leaves much to be desired.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
"Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children" boasts an exceptionally beautiful 1080p AVC MPEG-4 encode with vibrant colors and sharp details, though CGI is occasionally softer. The film's varied tonal changes and precise cinematography are well-preserved, making it a visual delight in 1.85:1 aspect ratio.
Audio: 83
Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children delivers an immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track with engaging directional effects, precise mid-range detail, and a hearty low-end punch. Despite missing the Dolby Atmos track from the theatrical release, the sound design excels in environmental ambiance and action sequences, providing a clear and distortion-free experience.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray extras for 'Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children' include comprehensive features on character profiles, time loops, and villain adaptations, enriched by extensive interviews with Ransom Riggs and the cast. The package is complemented by a Florence + The Machine music video, galleries, and trailers.
Movie: 46
Tim Burton's 'Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children' offers entertaining yet emotionally distant storytelling, with visually whimsical but curiously disconnected scenes that struggle to marry Burton's style with intricate plot mechanics, resulting in a film that feels overstuffed and mildly disappointing despite its potential.
Video: 83
The Blu-ray of "Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children," presented by 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment, boasts an exemplary AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. Captured using the Arri Alexa XT at a 2.8K source resolution and finished with a 4K digital intermediate (DI), this presentation exhibits masterful visual fidelity. Tim Burton's typically vibrant and grotesque aesthetic is slightly more restrained here, but cinematographer Bruno Delbonnel’s (notable for "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince," "Dark Shadows," and "Big Eyes") expertise shines through, ensuring a rich, visual experience throughout the film.
Various environmental and temporal settings—from the sunny vibrancy of Florida to the dreary, teal-tinted Cairnholm, and the warm, nostalgic 1943 time loop—are portrayed with high detail levels, although some dimly lit interiors and underwater sequences transpire with softer focus. A slight instance of banding occurs during these underwater scenes but remains minimal and fleeting. CGI elements tend to appear softer compared to practical effects, a minor detraction from an otherwise superb visual presentation.
The Blu-ray showcases stunning color reproduction, particularly with the vibrant greens of Miss Peregrine's garden and the striking blue skies intensified during a lightning storm amidst a Luftwaffe raid. Black levels are impressively deep, providing excellent depth without sacrificing detail in shadows. The clarity extends to the finest details, such as the intricacies in Victorian-era clothing, foliage texture, and character facial features, contributing to an overall reference-quality visual experience notwithstanding occasional softness in CGI sequences.
Audio: 83
The DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track in "Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children" delivers a highly immersive experience, boasting excellent surround utilization that enhances both the movie's action-packed sequences and atmospheric ambience. Early scenes, such as the harrowing appearance of a Hollow at Jake's grandfather's death, feature robust low-end effects and dynamic sonic bursts from gunfire. Ambient sounds, like the gentle ruffling of breezes during Jake's tour with Miss Peregrine, add to the immersion. Despite some anticlimactic moments in the supposed climax, the overall clarity and fidelity of dialogue and the musical score remain impeccable.
While the absence of the Dolby Atmos track from the theatrical release is regrettable, the DTS-HD MA 7.1 soundtrack compensates with a broad, engaging soundstage enriched by Mike Higham and Matthew Margeson's whimsical score. The mid-range reproduction is precise and detailed, ensuring each musical element stands out distinctly. Action-packed scenes involving the Hollowgasts benefit from a complex and powerful audio mix; tentacle stomps and roars resonate through the low-end, while explosions and lightning add impactful rumbles. Moisture sounds on the Welsh island and vintage surroundings during 1943 time-loop scenes provide vivid audio textures.
Additionally, the surround speakers are constantly active, delivering delightfully directional effects across the soundfield. Scenes on Cairnholm Island and within Miss Peregrine's residence are filled with natural environmental sounds, giving an authentic sense of space. The battle with the Hollowgasts, especially on the pier in Blackpool, is enhanced by flawless panning effects and layered sounds, creating a superbly immersive experience. Combat sequences during Luftwaffe raids stand out as prime demo scenes due to their impressive auditory detail and dynamic range, making this Blu-ray audio presentation both engaging and technically proficient.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras for "Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children" are comprehensive and insightful, providing both casual viewers and enthusiasts substantial content. With high-definition interviews, featurettes, and interactive elements, these extras delve deeply into the film's creation. Noteworthy is "The Peculiar Story," offering an enriching narrative behind Ransom Riggs' original series. "The Peculiars" stands out with its extensive profiles and background insights on the unique characters, combining cast and crew interviews with film snippets to enhance understanding. Each extra elaborates on different aspects of the movie, from the mystical time loops in "Map of Days" to the dark antagonists in "Hollows and Ex-Hollows." The array of multimedia content includes a captivating Florence + The Machine music video, enriching the viewer's experience beyond the main feature.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Peculiar Story: Interviews with Ransom Riggs on the series’ origins.
- The Peculiars: Character profiles and background details.
- Hollows and Ex-Hollows: Exploration of the film's villains.
- Map of Days: Insights into the film’s time loops.
- Wish That You Were Here Music Video: Performance by Florence + The Machine.
- Gallery: Comparison of vintage photos from the book and film sketches by Tim Burton.
- Theatrical Trailers: Promotional trailers of the film.
Movie: 46
"Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children," directed by Tim Burton and based on Ransom Riggs's novel, promises a combination of fantastical whimsy and dark intrigue but ultimately delivers a mixed cinematic experience. The film starts strong with teenager Jake Portman (Asa Butterfield) discovering his grandfather's cryptic past involving a mysterious home for peculiar children. The narrative's initial phase, filled with suspense and eerie visuals, sets a compelling stage. Unfortunately, as the plot unfolds, it struggles to maintain emotional resonance despite overt attempts to create heartfelt connections.
The visual storytelling, underscored by Burton's signature aesthetic, is captivating, especially in the portrayal of the peculiar children with their distinct abilities. Characters include Emma Bloom (Ella Purnell), who must wear lead boots to avoid floating away, and Enoch (Finlay MacMillan), capable of reanimating the dead. Despite their intriguing capabilities, the children's peculiarities serve more as whimsical diversions rather than integral elements driving the plot forward. This oversight muddles the narrative, leading to disjointed storytelling that lacks the tight cohesion necessary for a truly engaging fantasy world.
One of the most glaring issues is the screenplay's effort to cram extensive lore into a concise 127-minute runtime. Central plot mechanics, such as the concept of time-loops and the threat posed by shapeshifting antagonist Barron (Samuel L. Jackson), are introduced with insufficient exposition, leaving audiences to play catch-up. This rushed approach dilutes potential emotional depth and renders critical scenes anti-climactic. Furthermore, although Eva Green shines as the enigmatic Miss Peregrine, her character — like many others — is not given room to fully develop amidst the overstuffed cast and scattered plot points.
In conclusion, while "Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children" contains elements of charm and visual appeal typical of Burton's oeuvre, it ultimately falters due to its fragmented story structure and overly ambitious world-building efforts.
Total: 72
"Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children," directed by Tim Burton, lands on Blu-ray with a substantial offering in the technical department, demonstrating high-caliber visual and auditory precision. The film itself, however, struggles to capture the full potential of Ransom Riggs' beloved novel. While Burton's distinct visual style is evident in the striking topiary gardens and imaginative settings, the narrative suffers from a lack of depth in character and story development. The peculiar children, who are visually compelling, unfortunately lack substantial backstories that could have provided richer engagement with the audience.
The Blu-ray presentation excels with its demo-worthy video and reference quality audio. The sharpness of the visuals and the clarity of the sound design are outstanding, allowing viewers to fully immerse themselves in Burton's world. However, this impressive technical execution can't wholly compensate for the underwhelming execution of the film's plot and character arcs. The supplemental materials included could be more robust but still offer some additional insights for fans of the film.
In conclusion, though the film falls short in leveraging its fascinating premise to its fullest potential, the Blu-ray release showcases exceptional technical quality. Offering a mixed viewing experience, "Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children" comes recommended for those who can appreciate Burton's visual artistry and are seeking a bit of enchantment, despite some narrative shortcomings. Fans of Burton's aesthetic will find enough to enjoy here, making it worth adding to their collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
There are a number of "looks" throughout the film, from the initial bright sunniness of Florida which suddenly turns both figuratively and literally dark and deep blue, to the kind of slate gray or (dare...
Audio: 90
The first appearance of a Hollow at what seems to be the death of Jake's grandfather has good low end as well as bursts of sonic energy when a gun is repeatedly fired....
Extras: 60
"Wish That You Were Here" Florence + The Machine Music Video (1080p; 2:18) Gallery Photographs (1080p; 1:13) is a fun side by side comparison of the vintage photos from Riggs' book and those created for...
Movie: 60
Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children would seem to be a fitting substitute, at least on a surface level, since it involves a gaggle of "gifted" youths whose special powers have made them protectorates...
Total: 60
There's a lot to like in this film, but much of it is severely underdeveloped to the point that my hunch is some viewers will end up giving the whole a decided "meh", when perhaps a little more time detailing...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
In fact, for a Tim Burton feature, the film is delightfully picturesque with lots of warm, clean-rendered secondary hues, revealing a slight rosiness in the palest cheeks of the odd children and their...
Audio: 100
Whether it's the nature noises of Cairnholm Island or the kids running through the house, the design is filled with exceptional directionality as background sounds convincingly move off-screen, maintaining...
Extras: 40
The Peculiars (HD, 65 min) — A somewhat exhaustive piece detailing each of the peculiar children and their unique abilities as explained through cast & crew interviews....
Movie: 40
There is little of that classic Burtonesque quality or sense of wonderment to be found anywhere, and it's somewhat frustrating watching a house full of endearingly strange children draw a mild curiosity...
Total: 60
It's unfortunate that in a house full of endearingly strange children, the best the film can barely muster a mild curiosity and disappointingly dull....
Director: Tim Burton
Actors: Eva Green, Asa Butterfield, Samuel L. Jackson
PlotThe story follows a teenager named Jacob Portman, who is left reeling after a horrific family tragedy that appears to be linked to his grandfather's mysterious past. Haunted by his grandfather's tales of a magical place sheltering children with extraordinary abilities, and by his last cryptic words hinting at a hidden truth, Jacob decides to travel to Wales in search of answers. There, he stumbles upon the ruins of what was once Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children. As he explores the abandoned bedrooms and hallways, he realizes that the children, considered peculiar by the outside world, were more than just unique; they possessed powers that defied reason and time itself.
Through a turn of events, Jacob discovers that these children are not just stories from the past; they live in a time loop, reliving the same day in the 1940s under the protective care of Miss Peregrine, who, like her charges, has her own peculiar abilities. As he gets to know the residents—among them Emma, a girl who can manipulate fire, and Millard, an invisible boy—Jacob learns of the danger that threatens their very existence. Sinister creatures led by a malevolent force are hunting the peculiars, prompting Jacob to realize that he too may have his own place in this unusual world. His life takes on a new purpose: to help protect the children and uncover the depth of his own grandfather's legacy.
Writers: Ransom Riggs, Jane Goldman
Release Date: 30 Sep 2016
Runtime: 127 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, United Kingdom, Belgium, Canada
Language: English