Captive State Blu-ray Review
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Captive State lacks full cinema depth but offers rich audiovisuals and a poignant, albeit flawed, reflection on resilience under oppression.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 75
Captive State's Blu-ray presentation showcases a clean, detailed image with vibrant early scenes but mostly favors bleak, muted colors and low light. High resolution and fine textures are evident, despite a desolate look and restrained contrast. Noise is minimal, ensuring quality viewing.
Audio: 75
Captive State's DTS-HD 5.1 soundtrack masterfully blends subtle ambience with intense action, detailed music, and clear dialogue, maintaining an immersive balance and atmospheric depth.
Extra: 36
Captive State's Blu-ray offers insightful extras: an in-depth audio commentary, two brief featurettes on its making and inspirations, and a digital copy, all enhanced by an embossed slipcover.
Movie: 66
Captive State critiques authoritarian rule and human resilience amidst alien occupation, focusing on resistance and societal issues over typical sci-fi action.
Video: 75
The Blu-ray presentation of "Captive State" showcases a digitally photographed visual feast that stands out for its clarity and detailed imagery, despite the film’s deliberately bleak and monochrome aesthetic. The video starts off bright and vibrant, particularly noticeable in the early sequences where colorful roadblocks demonstrate an impressive pop and depth. As the narrative progresses, the visual tone shifts to favor low light scenes, grays, and somewhat muted colors, including the notably subdued orange hoodies. However, this deliberate palette maintains a pleasing definition, with the movie's visual parameters ensuring that colors are reproduced faithfully. Details remain sharp under various lighting conditions, showcasing textures from human skin to the intricacies of urban outfits and interior environments with precision. Nighttime scenes are well-executed with solid black levels, contributing to the film's atmospheric depth without sacrificing clarity.
The color grading leans heavily on dry ambers, blues, and teals, contributing to a desolate and often monochromatic appearance that defines the movie's ambiance. This results in a muted saturation that is by design, aiming to enhance the film’s thematic elements rather than its visual appeal. Contrast is deliberately restrained, with dusty grays taking the place of true black to fill in shadows, creating a unique visual style that, while not traditionally attractive, adds depth and texture to the dystopian setting of Chicago. Despite these stylistic choices, resolution remains high, with only mild noise present, thanks to Universal’s adept encoding which ensures a clear presentation. The texture in both close-ups and wider shots of the cityscape is commendably high grade, maintaining consistent sharpness throughout. Overall, the Blu-ray video section of "Captive State" impresses with its technical proficiency and adherence to the movie’s artistic vision, offering a visually rich experience that complements its narrative depth.
Audio: 75
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack featured on "Captive State"'s Blu-Ray epitomizes a high-quality audio experience, finely balancing quiet, ambient moments with intense bursts of action and soundstage saturation. Specifically conceived to complement the film's narrative and visual elements, the soundtrack demonstrates an adept handling of diverse audio elements - from alien sounds and metal music to pulsating techno beats. Chapter-specific highlights, such as the eerie alien noises in Chapter 7, underscore the surround sound system's capacity for a deep, immersive experience. The careful integration of ambient effects, notably at a train depot, alongside more dynamic elements like the booming bass or sharply executed back channel balance, further showcases the soundtrack's versatility and technical prowess.
Dialogue remains crisp and anchored in the central channel, ensuring that plot exposition is never lost amidst the film's more sonically adventurous moments. This clarity is complemented by a front-heavy mix, where music engages with a natural clarity across the stereo field, enhancing the overall listening experience without overwhelming the nuanced sound design occupying the surround channels. The sound team's meticulous attention to ambient cues enriches the film’s atmospherics, crafting a palpable sense of place - whether it be the subtle lapping of waves at a beach setting or the echoing cheers in a packed stadium scene.
Action sequences receive particular care in this audio presentation, with alien drone chases and glass shattering impacts creating an all-encompassing soundfield that heightens tension and immersion. Furthermore, the otherworldly vocalizations and situational ambient sounds extend into the rear channels effectively, supported by a measured use of low-frequency effects (LFE) that adds weight to the aliens’ presence without overwhelming the mix. While not overly powerful, the LFE channels provide just enough depth to complement intense scenes, ensuring a balanced and engaging auditory experience from start to finish.
Extras: 36
The "Captive State" Blu-ray extras deliver an intimate look into the film's making, serving both fans and cinephiles alike with a mix of technical and narrative insights. The package includes an engaging audio commentary by the Director/Producer/Co-Writer Rupert Wyatt and Producer David Crockett, offering a deep dive into the film's creation, storyline, and thematic elements. Accompanying the commentary are two succinct featurettes: "Igniting a War" and "Building the World of Captive State," both presented in 1080p. These featurettes, though brief, efficiently touch upon the inspirations behind the movie, the direction, the constrained budget, innovative visual effects, and thoughtful design elements that collectively bring the dystopian world to life. The inclusion of a Movies Anywhere digital copy code, along with the Blu-ray's embossed slipcover, further complements the overall package, making for an essential purchase for enthusiasts keen on embracing all aspects of this cinematic endeavor.
Extras included in this disc:
-
Audio Commentary: An informative session with Director/Producer/Co-Writer Rupert Wyatt and Producer David Crockett discussing the film's production and narrative intricacies.
-
Igniting a War: A featurette exploring the film’s influences, direction, cast, and character performances.
-
Building the World of Captive State: A look into the creative process behind the world-building elements including budget considerations, visual effects, and design.
-
Movie: 66
"Captive State" emerges as a bleak, yet nuanced exploration of a world subjugated by alien overseers known as The Legislators, presenting an Earth much changed yet eerily familiar. Directed with a deliberate hand by Rupert Wyatt, the film eschews traditional science-fiction tropes of dazzling battles and overt human-alien conflicts, opting instead for a grounded narrative focused on the insidious effects of authoritarian rule, both alien and all too human. This is not the destructive spectacle of "Battle: Los Angeles" nor the intricate coexistence detailed in "District 9". Instead, Wyatt crafts a scenario where the grandest conflicts arise in the shadowy corners of resistance and the quiet despair of a populace caught between compliance and rebellion. The CGI aliens, revealed in brief but memorable detail, serve less as characters and more as the catalyst for a deeper examination of societal fractures and the human spirit under duress.
Set against the backdrop of a Chicago divided and oppressed, the story centers on the human side of this dystopia. It follows Gabriel, an everyman entangled in the web of resistance led by his brother Rafe, against a world that has seemingly accepted its fate under alien dominion. The city itself becomes a character, embodying the resilience and complexities of its inhabitants who navigate a new normal where freedom is a concept as alien as their rulers. The narrative attempts to weave together multiple perspectives - from the beleaguered citizens to the dogged police commander William Mulligan - each adding layers to the film’s depiction of resistance and complicity.
However, "Captive State" grapples with its ambition, struggling at times to maintain clarity and emotional resonance amidst its sprawling narrative. The film's portrayal of a subdued Earth, coping rather than conquering, presents an intriguing premise that begs for deeper exploration. The somber tone and political overtones promise a film ripe with allegory yet it often feels hindered by its own complexity and the constraints of its runtime. Rupert Wyatt’s vision is commendable for its originality and restraint in an era of blockbuster excess, positioning "Captive State" as a thought-provoking piece on oppression, resistance, and the grey areas of moral ambiguity that define them. Yet, its potential impact is muffled by narrative fog, leaving audiences yearning for the more expansive exploration that perhaps only a different medium could provide.
Total: 66
"Captive State" emerges on Blu-ray with a presentation that, while not breaking new cinematic ground, firmly plants its feet in a solid, if not entirely unique, cinematic territory. It straddles the line between wanting to be a high-concept science fiction film and grounding itself in a more tangible, relatable setting. This positioning might leave viewers seeking the bombastic action of films like "Battle: Los Angeles" somewhat underwhelmed, signaling an early exit for those hoping for non-stop extraterrestrial warfare. However, it potentially offers more substance to those who appreciated the nuanced socio-political commentary of "District 9" or "Alien Nation." The film pivots away from focusing solely on alien invaders to explore the resilience and adaptability of human spirit under duress. Despite its ambition, it somewhat misses the mark in delivering a fully coherent cinematic experience, struggling with pacing and the depth of its own metaphorical aspirations, which aim to mirror current political climates but may fall short in subtlety.
From a technical standpoint, Universal's Blu-ray release of "Captive State" is commendable. It boasts high-quality video and audio presentations that are likely to satisfy even the most discerning viewers. The Blu-ray is equipped with a modest selection of extras, including several featurettes and an engaging audio commentary track, providing additional insight into the film’s production and thematic intentions. Though it might not be packed with extensive behind-the-scenes material or an array of special features, what is provided adds value to the overall package.
In conclusion, "Captive State" on Blu-ray offers a mixed bag that mirrors the film’s own uneven execution. While it attempts to delve into substantial themes and presents itself with technically proficient audio-visual quality, it doesn't fully realize its ambitious premise. The extras, although limited, are thoughtful additions that bolster the package, making it a worthwhile consideration for fans of the genre looking beyond mere spectacle. Despite its flaws, "Captive State" and its Blu-ray presentation encapsulate a flawed yet intriguing examination of resistance and resilience.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
It's bright and vibrant in its early opening sequence, revealing colorful roadblocks and other elements with impressive pop and depth....
Audio: 90
The track offers some intense surround integration at several points, such as in chapter seven when creepy alien sounds spill from all channels in a chaotic release of various alien tentacle-type visual...
Extras: 40
Igniting a War (1080p, 5:20): A discussion of influences and inspirations, Rupert Wyatt's direction and love of the genre, the film's structure, cast and characters, performances, and more....
Movie: 60
The story might have worked far better as a television miniseries in the tradition of V (the original from the 80s, not necessarily the linked remake which this reviewer has admittedly not seen) where...
Total: 70
It's unquestionably grounded in a solid, approachable, perhaps even compelling foundation, but there's just not enough time or balance to create a complete cinema experience....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
A mixture of dry ambers, blues, and teals, Captive State maintains a desolate and often monochrome appearance....
Audio: 80
...
Extras: 40
For an additional 25 Captive State screenshots, early access to all screens (plus the 30,000+ already in our library), 75+ exclusive 4K UHD reviews, and more, support us on Patreon....
Movie: 80
In cinematic terms, Captive State is the antithesis of genre expectations, but coming away as a smart – if muddy – statement piece bound to resonate with distance....
Total: 70
A damning indictment of current political circumstance, Captive State whiffs on subtle metaphors, but still depicts a terrifying truth....
Director: Rupert Wyatt
Actors: John Goodman, Ashton Sanders, Jonathan Majors
PlotSet in Chicago nearly a decade after an extraterrestrial force has occupied Earth, the narrative explores the lives of the citizens who live under the strict control of an alien-led government known as "The Legislature." Society is divided sharply between those who collaborate with the occupiers, benefiting from their advanced technology and governance, and the resistors, who are viewed as insurgents fighting for the freedom of humanity. The city has become a tightly monitored landscape, with all forms of rebellion harshly suppressed by the extraterrestrial authorities and their human collaborators. Amidst this setting, the population endures under the watchful eyes of drones and patrol units, attempting to navigate a life of compliance or resistance under the alien rule.
The story focuses on a young man, Gabriel, who becomes entangled in the burgeoning resistance movement against the alien overseers. Struggling with the memory of his parents, who were leaders in the early days of opposition before their disappearance, Gabriel is drawn into the conflict between the insurgents and the collaborating government forces. The narrative juxtaposes Gabriel's personal journey with the broader societal impacts of alien occupation, examining themes of freedom, collaboration, and resistance. As Gabriel becomes more involved, he uncovers a deeper web of intrigue, alliances, and secrets that challenge his understanding of the world around him, pushing him towards a critical decision that could alter the course of the resistance and the future of humanity under alien rule.
Writers: Erica Beeney, Rupert Wyatt
Release Date: 15 Mar 2019
Runtime: 109 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English