Love, Simon 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 74
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Love, Simon: Charming & heartfelt, with superb 4K upgrade, strong audio, and decent extras.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
Love, Simon's 4K UHD enhances detail and color vibrancy over its Blu-ray, with pleasing HDR nuances and richer, more natural hues, though improvements vary by scene.
Audio: 76
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 mixes are dynamic, clear, and immersive, with a balanced audio presentation, though more intricate use of surrounds could enhance the experience.
Extra: 58
Love, Simon's Blu-ray release includes a rich selection of extras, from behind-the-scenes featurettes to deleted scenes, all exploring its adaptation and production, mainly on the Blu-ray disc.
Movie: 81
Love, Simon" blends heart and humor in a coming-of-age journey, highlighting Simon Spier's struggle with his identity amidst high school drama, blackmail, and the quest for love, offering a fresh take on teen romance and self-discovery.
Video: 79
The 4K UHD presentation of "Love, Simon" offers a notable if not transformative enhancement over its Blu-ray counterpart. Though initial impressions suggest a modest uptick in sharpness and detail, the Ultra HD version, presented in a 2160p HEVC/H.265 encode with a 2.39:1 aspect ratio, indeed delivers a discernible improvement in image clarity and texture, particularly in close-up shots where finer details like facial features, clothing textures, and subtle environmental touches become more pronounced. Despite some scenes showing little difference in resolution, the overall image benefits from increased detail in backgrounds and objects, such as the intricate patterns on leaves and bricks in walls, which appear more refined on 4K.
Colors receive a substantial boost from the HDR10 wide color gamut grading, presenting a richer and more vibrant palette without succumbing to exaggeration or bleeding. Reds and greens are noticeably punchier, imbuing the film's visuals with a dynamic pop that enhances both the realism and the cinematic quality of the presentation. The application of HDR also adds depth to the image through bright specular highlights, improving the portrayal of nighttime scenes with a beautiful incandescent glow while maintaining deep blacks. Although some shots exhibit a darker tone that slightly muddles background details, these moments are few and do not detract significantly from the overall viewing experience.
The transition to 4K UHD is complemented by more natural skin tones and a cleaner presentation that's free from noise and artifacts. The increased resolution allows for a more tangible sense of depth and smoother transitions between foreground and background elements. Despite a minor increase in grain-like noise in certain scenes, "Love, Simon" on 4K UHD excels in delivering a clearer, more colorful, and thoroughly enjoyable viewing experience that surpasses its Blu-ray release and affirms its place in the higher resolution format.
Audio: 76
The audio presentation of "Love, Simon" on its 4K UHD Blu-ray edition is delivered via a 5.1 channel DTS-HD MA soundtrack, which ensures a full-bodied, articulate, and dynamically satisfying auditory experience. Notably, the soundtrack demonstrates excellent tonal balance and high-level detail, facilitating seamless pans across the soundstage. The bass reproduction is both taut and occasionally robust, contributing to the soundtrack's dynamic range and enveloping presence. This mix adeptly uses the surrounds to replicate discrete and ambient sounds, ensuring that key effects and ambient noises like classroom clatter and background conversations are spread out, enhancing the film's immersive quality. However, despite its strengths, some outdoor scenes, such as a football game, exhibit slightly thinner dialogue quality, likely due to recording conditions.
Dialogue in "Love, Simon" is consistently prioritized across various scenes, maintaining clarity and fidelity throughout the film. The surround channels are effectively engaged in high school scenes and during the Cabaret production, adding depth to the movie's soundscape. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix particularly shines with its musical elements, enhancing the film's emotional beats with excellent separation and range in its pop soundtrack. While overall immersive, the audio mix could benefit from slightly increased use of surrounds to elevate its atmospheric presence. The diversity in audible environments, from bustling school halls to a spirited house party, is well-captured, enhancing the narrative's realism.
Foregrounding vocals while balancing natural effects creates a compelling auditory experience appropriate for the film's scope. Despite lacking Dolby Atmos enhancement, the well-rounded 5.1 mix suffices, capturing accurate sound travel and leveraging bass from songs and score effectively. The blend of clear dialogue reproduction, alongside a solid low-frequency extension and sound dynamics, underlines a commitment to preserving vocal naturalness within varied environments. This dedication to audio quality ensures that "Love, Simon" remains engaging, offering an effective and lively complement to its visual storytelling.
Extras: 58
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Love, Simon" offers an enriching collection of extras, predominantly hosted on the included Blu-ray disc, save for the insightful audio commentary track also available on the 4K disc. The supplementary materials provide an in-depth look at the adaptation process from Becky Albertalli's celebrated novel to the big screen, casting decisions, and the vibrant squad dynamics among Simon’s friends. Notably, features like "The Adaptation" and "The Squad" offer behind-the-scenes insights and cast interviews, enriching the viewer's understanding of the film's creative journey. Additionally, the extras include deleted scenes, a unique fan contest winner's short film about first love, and detailed explorations of the movie's Georgian locations, presenting a comprehensive package for fans and newcomers alike. These materials extend the narrative experience beyond the main feature, showcasing the thoughtful consideration given to every aspect of production.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Greg Berlanti, producer Isaac Klausner, and co-screenwriter Isaac Aptaker provide insightful commentary.
- Deleted Scenes: Includes two cut scenes offering additional context to the story.
- The Adaptation: A featurette on converting the book into a film.
- The Squad: Insights into the casting and development of Simon’s friend group.
- #FirstLoveStoryContestWinner: Showcases a fan’s winning short film about first love.
- Dear Georgia: Focuses on the filming locations within Georgia.
- Dear Atlanta: Highlights why Atlanta was chosen as the primary filming location.
- Gallery: A collection of production stills and behind-the-scenes photos.
- Theatrical Trailers: Includes two trailers of the film.
Movie: 81
Love, Simon," presented in a stunning 4K UHD Blu-ray, captures the essence of adolescence, navigating through the complexities of identity, societal expectations, and the quest for acceptance. Seventeen-year-old Simon Spier, portrayed compellingly by Nick Robinson, lives a seemingly idyllic teenage life surrounded by a supportive cast of friends and family. Nonetheless, beneath the facade of normalcy, Simon harbors a secret that he fears could disrupt the harmony of his existence - he is gay and yet to come out.
The film's narrative weaves through Simon's internal conflicts and external challenges with a deft blend of humor, heart, and a light touch on the themes of love and self-discovery. Despite its potentially clichéd premise involving high school drama and blackmail, "Love, Simon" transcends the typical genre boundaries by offering a fresh perspective on the coming-of-age story through the lens of a gay protagonist. This is accentuated by strong performances from the ensemble cast, including noteworthy contributions from Jennifer Garner and Josh Duhamel as Simon's empathetic parents, adding depth to the storyline. The film ingeniously utilizes contemporary storytelling techniques such as emails and social media, which serves as a pivotal element in driving the plot forward.
Moreover, "Love, Simon" distinguishes itself with its earnest approach towards depicting Simon's journey towards embracing his identity. It strikes a fine balance between the comedic elements and the more poignant moments, avoiding overly dramatized portrayals of LGBTQ+ experiences. The inclusion of romantic intrigue and the quest to uncover the identity of Simon's anonymous correspondent, Blue, adds an engaging layer to the movie while adeptly handling themes of anonymity and connection in the digital age. Through its heartfelt narrative and relatable characters, "Love, Simon" not only celebrates the uniqueness of each individual's story but also underscores the universal desire for acceptance and love, making it a landmark film within the teen rom-com genre.
Total: 74
Love, Simon," Greg Berlanti’s refreshing take on the coming-of-age genre, receives a commendable 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray release from 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment. This Ultra HD Blu-ray Combo Pack not only elevates the film's visual experience with an appreciable enhancement in detail and color palette but also retains its charming narrative encompassing themes of love, acceptance, and the angst of coming out. The film itself is lauded for its light-hearted yet sincere approach to weighty subjects, buoyed by earnest performances and a warmth that reassures viewers of its optimistic outlook. Despite some perceived shortcomings in its story-telling mechanics, "Love, Simon" stands out for its heart and inclusivity, presenting an updated and universally appealing teen romance.
Technical aspects of this release are notable, with the HDR10 video transfer offering a significant upgrade over standard high definition, bringing out finer details and brighter highlights that add to the film's visual storytelling. The audio presentation matches the film's relatively modest requirements but does so excellently, ensuring dialogue and the soundtrack are delivered with clarity and impact. While the supplementary material might not be extensive, featuring a director’s commentary and a few behind-the-scenes featurettes, it provides valuable insights into the making of this beloved film.
In conclusion, the 4K UHD release of "Love, Simon" is highly recommended for aficionados of earnest storytelling as well as home cinema enthusiasts looking to enjoy an enhanced viewing experience. The upgrade from Blu-ray to 4K UHD is distinctly noticeable, rendering it the definitive version for fans and collectors alike. Notwithstanding a somewhat limited array of special features, the superior audiovisual presentation serves to illuminate the film's strengths, ensuring "Love, Simon" resonates as a milestone teen comedy for contemporary audiences.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
But there are all of the typical upticks in fine detail that 4K fans like to see, including increased resolution on things like facial features or the bricks in the bathroom stall where Simon finds refuge...
Audio: 90
Love, Simon is awash in source cues, and the musical elements tend to really buoy the disc's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix in a way that the more intimate dialogue scenes can't....
Extras: 90
For a list of supplements included on the 1080p Blu-ray that's part of this package, please see our Love, Simon Blu-ray review....
Movie: 80
Why Simon takes a while to get to where this film is obviously going is perhaps not sufficiently explained, but otherwise Love, Simon, while essaying much of the same "teen angst" territory as any number...
Total: 10
Love, Simon overcomes some of its own perhaps self inflicted deficits by offering really sincere performances and a rather breezy attitude toward inherently weighty subjects that may come off as a little...
High-Def Digest review by Steven CohenRead review here
Video: 90
Either way, the source material is being upscaled to some degree, but the resulting image still offers a solid gain in fine detail over the HD disc, providing a sharp image with a nice sense of fine texture...
Audio: 80
Key effects, like tussling sets and props during a rehearsal for a school play, hit the rears with emphasis, but the surrounds are mostly relegated to faint atmospherics....
Extras: 40
Deleted Scenes (HD, 8 min) – Two deleted scenes are presented here viewable separately or together, including a sequence where Simon lies to Abby about Nick's history with women, and a scene featuring...
Movie: 80
From its catchy soundtrack and peppy style to its amusing sense of humor and exceptionally likeable ensemble, the movie takes all the best aspects of John Hughes-era teen comedies and pushes them forward...
Total: 70
Though not packed with extras, the release includes a worthwhile commentary track and some featurettes....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 80
On occasion, discernible improvements in depth could be seen in wide angle shots but, in most respects, I saw little difference in apparent resolution when checking select scenes from the UHD and Blu-ray....
Audio: 88
I enjoyed the blend between the track's dynamic range and enveloping presence which resulted in a solid surround sound presentation....
Extras: 50
“Dear Georgia” – Join the filmmakers as they show you the iconic filming locations in Atlanta....
Movie: 80
But when an email falls into the wrong hands, his secret is at risk of being thrust into the spotlight....
Total: 75
is a light, charming and well-spun coming of age story about first love, family, friendships and the pressures associated with the fear of acceptance when coming out....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
Its a pretty crisp image and one that really is an improvement of the standard Blu-ray counterpart.Depth: Some good spacing between foreground and background here with good free movements in all environments...
Audio: 80
The film is dialogue heavy and so the track is more focused on the vocals, with all of them always feeling natural within any environment....
Extras: 60
Aside from the commentary, all bonus materials are found on the standard Blu-ray disc.4K UHDAudio CommentaryBy Greg Berlanti, Isaac Klausner and Isaac AptakerBlu-ray DiscDeleted Scenes (HD, 7:48)The Adaptation...
Movie: 90
No matter, there are also universal messages about a person’s self in the youthful search for identity, discovering that you’re perfectly normal and not at all alone in the world despite what a community...
Total: 80
Love, Simon is a terrific coming of age comedy that offers something for all ages and one of the very best films of the year....
Director: Greg Berlanti
Actors: Nick Robinson, Jennifer Garner, Josh Duhamel
PlotSimon Spier is a high school student with a loving family and close-knit group of friends. However, he harbors a secret: he's gay and hasn't come out to anyone, feeling uncertain about how his friends, family, and classmates might react. Simon's life takes a complex turn when he discovers an anonymous confession from a fellow student under the pseudonym "Blue" on a local message board, revealing that he is also in the closet. Piqued by their shared circumstance, Simon begins an email correspondence with Blue, and the two form a deep connection, providing each other with support and understanding, even though Simon is frustrated by his inability to identify Blue’s true identity.
As Simon navigates the typical trials and tribulations of high school life, his secret is put at risk after a classmate, Martin, stumbles upon Simon's email exchange with Blue. Martin, infatuated with Simon's friend, Abby, manipulates Simon by threatening to expose his secret unless Simon helps him win Abby's affection. Torn between his desire for privacy and fear of being outed, Simon tries to manage Martin's demands while keeping his friendships intact and pondering how coming out will affect those relationships. Amidst the tumult, Simon continues to communicate with Blue, whose identity increasingly dominates his thoughts as Simon becomes ever more curious, invested, and eager to meet the person behind the emails.
Writers: Becky Albertalli, Elizabeth Berger, Isaac Aptaker
Release Date: 16 Mar 2018
Runtime: 110 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, German, French