A Hidden Life Blu-ray Review
Score: 67
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Visually stunning with effective performances and solid technical merits, 'A Hidden Life' offers a moving story that may feel emotionally distant for some.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 86
A Hidden Life's Blu-ray boasts a breathtaking 1080p AVC transfer in 2.39:1, captured digitally on Red Cameras up to 7K, with a 4K DI. Utilizing natural light and featuring stunning detail, the reserved chromatic palette and occasional fish-eye lens effects add to the film’s thematic tone and immersive visuals.
Audio: 82
The DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack of 'A Hidden Life' provides a highly immersive and sophisticated 7.1 surround experience, with excellent dynamic range, clear dialogue, and meticulously placed ambient effects, particularly in outdoor scenes and James Newton Howard's evocative score.
Extra: 6
No supplementary material is included on this release, unfortunately.
Movie: 66
"A Hidden Life," while showcasing Terrence Malick's lush visual style and distinctive narrative approach, offers a relatively clear and poignant portrayal of Franz Jägerstätter's moral stand against the Nazis. The film’s trance-like presentation and lack of traditional plot highlight Malick’s unique yet polarizing cinematic technique.
Video: 86
"A Hidden Life" is presented in an immaculate AVC encoded 1080p transfer, framed at 2.39:1, that radiates reference quality high-definition visuals. Utilizing a reserved chromatic palette true to its historical era, the film's colors—such as the deep reds, succulent blues, and rich earth tones—are breathtaking. The transfer effectively renders the film's intent; interior designs and clothing stay within the time frame's scope with browns, grays, greens, and blacks flawlessly integrated into the overall aesthetic.
The film, captured entirely with Red cameras at up to 7K resolutions and mastered with a 4K DI, often employs a distinct stylistic choice—warped imagery that suggests a fish-eye lens effect. This can be seen most prominently near the edges of the frame, giving an unsettling yet immersive feel. Though this technique can occasionally distract some viewers, it adds to the narrative’s unique atmosphere. While some interior scenes shot using natural light might appear slightly murky, outdoor scenes present remarkable detail and stunning depth of field, showcasing alpine vistas with exceptional clarity.
The finely detailed close-ups, particularly of Diehl's expressive appearances, are notable highlights. Additionally, grading shows subtle blue hues especially in outdoor scenes, enhancing thematic consistency. Brief archival materials, such as elements from "Triumph of the Will," interspersed with the primary footage illustrate historical context through effective visual juxtapositions.
Audio: 82
The Audio presentation of "A Hidden Life" on Blu-ray is encapsulated in an impressive lossless DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack that intensely utilizes the surround platform. This sophisticated design occasionally rewards listeners with intricately placed activity within the sound field, offering a feeling of total immersion. The audio presentation stands out for its highly detailed execution, marked by excellent dynamic range which transitions seamlessly from authoritative to nuanced. Dialog is definitive and lucid through the center channel, extending far into the room and positioning slightly ahead of the left/right speakers within the soundstage. Front channel separation is executed with precision, allowing both large and small sound elements to be directionally correlated based on onscreen events.
Additionally, "A Hidden Life" features a subtly immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track that dynamically situates ambient environmental effects, particularly in outdoor scenes, and seamlessly integrates James Newton Howard's evocative score, blending original compositions with classical source cues. The film's traditional dialogue is sparse, with a significant portion delivered as voiceovers, adding to the unique auditory experience. Some stylistic choices in the soundtrack, such as unexplained ventures into German without subtitles, are characteristic of a Malick film and add a unique auditory texture. Nonetheless, all elements—including dialogue, score, and effects—are rendered cleanly and clearly without any issues. While the rear channels and subwoofer are not perpetually active, their application is highly engaging when utilized.
Extras: 6
The Blu-ray edition of "A Hidden Life" is notably sparse in its supplemental offerings, with no additional material beyond the digital code. This lack of extras will disappoint enthusiasts seeking deeper insights into Terrence Malick's filmmaking process or behind-the-scenes content. The minimalist approach to additional content contrasts sharply with the film's rich narrative and visual depth, leaving viewers without the opportunity for further engagement or exploration.
Extras included in this disc:
Digital Code: Digital version for online streaming.
Movie: 66
A Hidden Life, directed by Terrence Malick, stands as a distinguished piece in his filmography, blending historical narrative with Malick’s signature visual poetry. Based on the true story of Franz Jägerstätter, an Austrian farmer who refused to pledge allegiance to Hitler during World War II, the movie draws heavily from actual letters between Jägerstätter (portrayed by August Diehl) and his wife Fani (Valerie Pachner). Combining lush, almost ethereal cinematography with a relatively clear and straightforward narrative, A Hidden Life navigates through Jägerstätter's moral dilemmas and personal sacrifices. The film effectively juxtaposes the natural beauty of the Austrian countryside with the grim progression of Jägerstätter’s resistance, continuously highlighting Malick’s capability to invoke profound emotion through visual splendor.
Despite its nearly three-hour runtime, which allows for languorous development and extended sequences often devoid of dialogue, the film maintains a trance-like quality that invites viewers into its contemplative space. The use of epistolary dialogue from actual letters further enhances the authenticity and emotional depth. However, the sparse traditional plot and Malick’s distinctive style may polarize audiences. Some may appreciate the intimate portrayal of a man standing against overwhelming odds, while others might find the film’s stylistic choices and deliberate pacing less engaging.
The narrative succinctly captures Jägerstätter's steadfast faith and growing unease with the Nazi regime, leading to his ultimate imprisonment and execution. The portrayal of his family’s struggle back home, particularly Fani’s efforts to maintain their farm and navigate the bureaucratic hurdles to visit her husband, lends an additional layer of emotional gravity. Malick’s use of skewed perspectives and the mysterious, almost hallucinogenic climactic sequence reflect the unsettling reality of Jägerstätter’s ordeal but may leave some viewers yearning for a more traditional cathartic resolution. Nevertheless, A Hidden Life remains a compelling testament to individual resistance and moral integrity, making it a fascinating addition to Malick’s oeuvre.
Total: 67
Terrence Malick’s "A Hidden Life" emerges as a stylistic masterpiece, showcasing the director’s visionary prowess. This film can be both compelling and enigmatic, reflecting Malick's characteristic approach to storytelling that may either captivate or distance viewers. The narrative of conscientious objector Franz Jägerstätter is inherently powerful, yet some may find it emotionally restrained. However, the consistently impressive visuals and nuanced sound design compensate for any perceived emotional gaps, ensuring a memorable viewing experience.
The Blu-ray release of "A Hidden Life" demonstrates commendable technical achievements. The 1080p transfer delivers stunning clarity and detail, capturing the lush landscapes of rural Austria with remarkable fidelity. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack delivers an immersive auditory experience, effectively balancing dialogue, natural sounds, and James Newton Howard’s evocative score. The performances of August Diehl and Valerie Pachner are crucial in bringing the story’s emotional depth to the forefront, enhancing the overall impact.
In conclusion, "A Hidden Life" is recommended for its compelling visual and auditory presence, particularly for fans of Malick’s unique directorial vision. While it may not resonate emotionally with all viewers, its technical proficiency and artistic merit are undeniable, making it a significant addition to any Blu-ray collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Detail levels, even with the bizarre warping, tend to be excellent throughout the presentation, and depth of field in some of the alpine vistas is typically great as well....
Audio: 90
As alluded to above, there isn't a ton of traditional dialogue in the film, and in fact much of the spoken material is delivered as voice over, specifically with regard to some of the epistolary material....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 70
The through line of A Hidden Life isn't complex by any means: J�gerst�tter is a devout Christian who sees Hitler's advances as at the very least troubling and at the worst a devastating commentary on what's...
Total: 70
Stylistically, this is another tour de force for Malick, a director whose visionary tendencies can both fascinate but also alienate, and there is in fact a kind of weird distancing factor to A Hidden Life...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 100
The nature defined colors look terrific as the deep, vivid, reds, succulent blues, and resplendent earth toned hues leap from the 2.39:1 framed video....
Audio: 92
Front channel separation is excellent which draws out both large and small sound elements allowing their directional correlation based upon the onscreen events to be definable....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 70
From visionary writer-director Terrence Malick comes this timeless story based on real events about an unsung hero, Franz Jägerstätter (played by August Diehl), who refused to fight for the Nazis during...
Total: 68
Dual SVS PC4000 Cylinder Subwoofers Niles Audio In-Ceiling/In-Wall Series Speakers Panamax M5400-PM Power Conditioner/Surge Protector Wireworld, Better Cables (Silver Serpent) - Audio/Video/Speaker Cabling...
Director: Terrence Malick
Actors: August Diehl, Valerie Pachner, Maria Simon
PlotIn a serene village in the Austrian Alps, Franz Jägerstätter, a devout farmer, leads a peaceful life with his wife, Fani, and their three daughters. As the Nazi regime strengthens its grip over Europe during World War II, Franz is faced with a moral dilemma when he is called up to fight for the Third Reich. Conflicted by his religious beliefs and personal convictions against the war, Franz grapples with the potential repercussions his refusal could have on his family and community. His unwavering stance begins to isolate him from neighbors and friends, while Fani endures increasing pressure and hostility from their once close-knit village.
Franz's internal conflict intensifies as he seeks guidance from spiritual leaders and contemplates the impact of his defiance. Despite mounting external pressures and the looming threat of severe consequences, he clings to his principles. The tension between his ethical resolve and the dire ramifications of his choices reverberates through his family, testing the bonds of love and loyalty. While Franz and Fani navigate this turbulent period, their resilience is continuously challenged, showcasing the profound struggle between conscience and conformity in the face of overwhelming adversity.
Writers: Terrence Malick
Release Date: 17 Jan 2020
Runtime: 174 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom, Germany, United States
Language: English, German, Italian