Special ID Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Engaging yet familiar, 'Special ID' delivers impressive technical quality in its Blu-ray release but falls short in originality and dynamic storytelling.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
Special ID's Blu-ray presentation, leveraging an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.34:1, delivers stellar clarity and detail with natural colors and solid contrast. Despite a slightly boosted cool palette, dynamic range remains high with vibrant colors, well-detailed black levels, and minimal compression artifacts.
Audio: 74
The Chinese DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix for 'Special ID' provides clear, well-articulated dialogue with notable dynamic energy in sound effects and music. While front-channel emphasis is prominent, the surround elements deliver immersive atmospherics and LFE during action sequences, making it a strong yet occasionally overwhelming mix.
Extra: 13
Special ID Blu-ray extras include a brief, standard 'Making of' featurette (HD, 4 min.), which abruptly ends, and a high-definition theatrical trailer (HD, 1:35).
Movie: 46
"Special ID" impresses with Donnie Yen's action-packed performance and engaging martial arts sequences, yet falls short in delivering a coherent narrative, suffering from convoluted plot elements and occasionally lackluster fight choreography. Still, it's an entertaining experience for Yen fans and those seeking thrilling set pieces.
Video: 79
The Blu-ray presentation of "Special ID" offered by Well Go USA delivers an exemplary video transfer that showcases the film’s intricacies and diverse visual settings. Presented in 1080p resolution with an AVC MPEG-4 encoding, the transfer boasts a stable 2.34:1 aspect ratio. The native high-definition elements from the Red One camera are rendered with remarkable sharpness and crystalline clarity. This high bitrate encoding ensures pristine quality and avoids any noticeable compression-related anomalies or artifacts.
While the film often leans towards a cool color palette with an array of teal blues and almond yellows, colors appear natural and vibrant, seamlessly enhancing various scenes. Flesh tones, though slightly variable, generally maintain a warm and lifelike appearance. Contrast is consistently high, providing robust blacks that enrich nighttime sequences without losing detail, and ensuring daytime elements remain clear and vibrant without appearing washed out. Depth is well-maintained throughout, with cityscapes and other locations exhibiting striking dimensionality that stands out vividly in both daylight and night-time settings.
Detail clarity is persistent across the film, contributing significantly to the impact of action sequences and finer visual elements such as clothing textures and environmental details. The high contrast adds an effulgent quality to certain scenes without looking overly processed, allowing for a balanced representation of brightness and shadow. The overall stellar image quality heightens the visceral excitement of the film, placing it a cut above many other entries in the martial arts genre.
Audio: 74
The audio presentation of "Special ID" on Blu-ray offers both Chinese and English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks alongside Dolby Digital 2.0 options. The DTS-HD Master Audio soundtracks are particularly notable for their clear and well-articulated dialogue, ensuring that every syllable is perfectly centered and discernible. The mix achieves a commendable balance between dialogue, sound effects, and the musical score, though it tends to emphasize the front channels more than might be expected for an action-centric film. Nevertheless, the fidelity remains excellent throughout, maintaining clarity and detail even amidst the most chaotic scenes.
The surround sound capabilities are effectively utilized, creating an immersive atmosphere that adds depth and nuance to various sequences, particularly in busy scenes such as restaurant battles and the climactic freeway chase. While the rear channels effectively enhance the sensation of being enveloped in the action, providing a solid atmospheric element, some may find the mix occasionally restrained. The low-frequency effects add substantial weight to specific sound effects and the score, contributing to a full-bodied audio experience that will satisfy action enthusiasts. However, in some instances, this emphasis on LFE and score might overwhelm other audio elements but generally serves the dynamic energy of the film well.
Overall, "Special ID" delivers an engaging auditory experience that faithfully represents the high-octane action on screen. Despite some minor imbalances favoring the front channels, the Blu-ray’s audio presentation remains near-reference quality, enhancing the immersive quality of the action sequences while maintaining coherent and crystal-clear dialogue.
Extras: 13
The "Special ID" Blu-ray's extras offer minimal but engaging content. The primary feature is a standard making-of featurette, offering behind-the-scenes footage and brief interviews with the cast and crew, though it abruptly concludes around the four-minute mark. Additionally, the disc includes the final theatrical trailer, providing a concise overview of the film. Both extras are presented in high definition.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making Of: Standard behind-the-scenes featurette with interviews (HD, 4:06)
- Trailer: Final theatrical trailer for the film (HD, 1:35)
Movie: 46
"Special ID" stars Donnie Yen as Detective Chen Zilong, also known in the underworld as "Dragon" Chen. Embedded deeply into the criminal syndicate, Chen's life becomes perilous when old enemies resurface and internal Triad executions accelerate. As he navigates a volatile undercover operation alongside his new partner, Fang Jing (portrayed by Jing Tian), the film dives into a familiar but engaging narrative of an undercover cop teetering between his false criminal persona and his law enforcement duties.
As with many Donnie Yen films, "Special ID" is heavy on action, delivering meticulously choreographed fight scenes and high-octane sequences that thrill martial arts fans. However, it suffers from a convoluted plot that occasionally disrupts the narrative flow, making the storyline appear disjointed. The film attempts to inject a sense of personal growth and introspection in Chen’s character, but these efforts do not compensate for the lack of originality when compared to similar genre classics like "Infernal Affairs."
The choreography, aiming for a gritty MMA-inspired style, often feels lackluster and anti-climactic, failing to deliver the visceral impact expected of a Yen film. Surprisingly, non-combat scenes—such as tense car chases and inventive stunts—provide more consistent thrills. While Yen's performance maintains his trademark intensity and Jing Tian brings a spirited dynamic to the screen, these elements do little to elevate the film's overall execution. Despite its shortcomings, "Special ID" offers enough adrenaline-fueled moments to satisfy hardcore fans, even if it doesn't quite live up to its potential.
Total: 61
"Special ID" on Blu-ray delivers an exhilarating yet uneven experience for fans of Donnie Yen and action cinema. While the film showcases Yen's formidable martial arts skills and charisma, its basic storyline is a familiar trope, revisited without significant innovation. The breathless pacing and well-staged action sequences manage to engage, but they might not elevate the film beyond Yen's more exceptional works. Despite mixed feelings about the narrative and character depth, the Blu-ray's technical aspects shine.
The video quality is impressive, capturing high-definition action and scenic views with remarkable clarity. The audio presentation is also very good, adding to the visceral enjoyment of the fight scenes and explosive set pieces. Regrettably, the lack of substantial special features feels like a missed opportunity, somewhat detracting from the overall package. However, the high-caliber visual and sound performance compensates for this shortfall, rendering the film a must-watch for action enthusiasts and Blu-ray collectors.
In conclusion, "Special ID" may not be top-tier Donnie Yen, but it offers enough excitement for his devoted followers. The Blu-ray's strong technical merits make it a worthwhile addition to any collection, even though the film's predictability and lack of dynamic characters might temper some viewers' expectations.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
This is a really fantastically sharp and almost crystalline looking high definition transfer of native high definition elements from the Red One camera....
Audio: 90
While fidelity is excellent on the 5.1 tracks, there's a somewhat surprising emphasis on the front channels that tends to work against the film's action elements....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 50
Films as varied (and at times as iconic) as Infernal Affairs (the inspiration for Martin Scorsese's The Departed) and New World have already proven what a potent storyline this basic setup can be, but...
Total: 60
The basic storyline has been told many times before, and at least some of those times, better....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
The image is richly detailed from start to finish, delivering equally stunning views in a wide variety of settings, from the fluorescent-lighted dinginess of an illegal gambling establishment, to the rain-soaked...
Audio: 80
Still, several other scenes manage to use the immersive qualities of the sound to good effect, too, but, like the freeway sequence that ends the film, they can sometimes become overwhelmed with the emphasis...
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 60
That is certainly true of the new Donnie Yen actioner 'Special ID,' which runs like a well-oiled machine in terms of finding ways to put its star in the mix of some fantastically choreographed and viscerally...
Total: 60
Although the film could have had more well rounded characters, the fact that it even tried to add something more diverse to the typical undercover cop routine is enough to give the lack of truly dynamic...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 86
Colors were natural looking with a pleasing and reserved quality that capably handled the somewhat limited palette used to represent the various settings and clothing featured in the film....
Audio: 86
When engaged it renders the recordings elements well delivering proper atmosphere, clarity detail....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 40
Undercover and under attack, he has no choice but to rely on a new partner (Jing Tian) and his knowledge of the streets to get out alive....
Total: 56
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SVS PB-13...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
The city and locations are also one of the main stars of Special ID and I could tell that they spent a fortune on a good second unit team, because the cityscapes look phenomenal and really pop out....
Audio: 90
Dialogue Presentation: Dialogue levels are clean and clear and every syllable is perfectly placed in the center sound field....
Extras: 10
Special ID has only two extras and they are a short making of featurette and the theatrical trailer....
Movie: 40
He must navigate his way through the gang life, which calls for killings, extortion, robbery, etc.All goes well until the head of the most powerful gang in the city starts to kill other undercover agents,...
Total: 60
The Blu-ray from Well Go USA is pretty spot-on in terms of technical specs but the obviously edited extras drag the overall score down....
Director: Clarence Fok
Actors: Donnie Yen, Tian Jing, Andy On
PlotA dedicated undercover cop fights to uphold justice within a treacherous world dominated by ruthless gangs. He balances his dual identity, carefully maneuvering between his duties as a police officer and his criminal persona. This delicate tightrope walk becomes increasingly dangerous as he delves deeper into the criminal underworld, targeting an ambitious and menacing gang leader who poses a significant threat. His goal is to collect critical evidence that will dismantle the organization from within, all while maintaining the trust of both the gang and his police superiors.
As the stakes escalate, tensions rise between the cop and his fellow gang members, testing his loyalty and resolve. Amidst these challenges, he forms an uneasy alliance with a determined female colleague, working together to bring the criminals to justice. The pressure mounts as he battles both physical confrontations and psychological warfare, racing against time to achieve his mission before his cover is blown. The unyielding pursuit of his goal pushes him to his limits, blurring the lines of trust and betrayal in a high-stakes game of cat and mouse.
Writers: Tai-Lee Chan, Kam-Yuen Szeto
Release Date: 18 Oct 2013
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: R
Country: China
Language: Cantonese, Mandarin, English