Himalaya Blu-ray Review
Score: 65
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Éric Valli's 'Himalaya' combines stunning cinematography, ethnological richness, and excellent Blu-ray quality, making it a captivating cultural time capsule.
Disc Release Date
Video: 70
Himalaya's new 1080p/AVC-encoded remaster, presented in 2.35:1, offers nearly perfect visuals that showcase the stunning 35mm Cinemascope work with exceptional clarity, fine grain, and balanced colors. The HD transfer maintains a filmic look without digital tampering, rendering a near IMAX-like experience.
Audio: 70
The Blu-Ray of 'Himalaya' boasts an immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, featuring a lush score by Bruno Coulais, rich environmental ambience, and crystal-clear, well-balanced dialogue. The mix excels in delivering cultural elements like chanting monks and nature sounds, ensuring a flawless audio experience.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray extras offer an insightful look into 'Himalaya' through engaging commentary with director Eric Valli, an in-depth making-of documentary detailing the challenges of on-location shooting, and a variety of behind-the-scenes promotional features and trailers.
Movie: 66
Himalaya is a visually stunning film set in the timeless Dolpa region of rural Tibet, offering an ethnographic glimpse into a vanishing culture through breathtaking cinematography and a simple, fable-like narrative centered around intergenerational conflict and tradition.
Video: 70
Kino-Lorber has outdone themselves with the Blu-ray video transfer of "Himalaya." Presented in 1080p/AVC-encoded format and retaining a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, the remastering work on this 35mm Cinemascope brings every detail to life with exceptional clarity. The natural grain patterns are intact, ensuring no excessive digital noise reduction, edge enhancement, or over-saturation mars the viewing experience. The transfer captures a vivid, almost three-dimensional quality reminiscent of 70mm IMAX, especially in the Tibet sections. The crispness reveals the intricate stitching of hand-sewn clothing and the weather-beaten faces of the actors, adding a remarkable layer of realism.
Colors are meticulously graded and balanced, with skies properly exposed despite the challenging full sun at high elevations, maintaining grounded black levels without appearing stylized. While there are a few fleeting softer shots, they are rare and do not detract from the overall sharpness and compelling depth of field in the mountainous landscapes. This finely tuned visual presentation allows viewers to fully appreciate the intricate details and natural textures, making it a phenomenal upgrade from any previous DVD versions. Fans of "Himalaya" will find this Blu-ray transfer an essential addition to their collection.
Audio: 70
The Blu-ray release of "Himalaya" features a superb Tibetan DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that truly elevates the cinematic experience. At the heart of this mix is a rich and immersive score by French composer Bruno Coulais, seamlessly blending Tibetan elements such as the atonal chanting of Buddhist monks with traditional orchestral arrangements. This results in a sweeping and forceful musical score that envelops the listener, especially when played at elevated volume settings. The intricate soundfield is further enhanced by authentic environmental ambiances, with buzzards cawing from rear speakers, herds of yaks stampeding, and the relentless whipping of wind, all contributing to a highly dynamic auditory landscape.
The dialogue throughout is consistently clear and well-balanced, predominantly occupying the center channel, which ensures intelligibility even amid the dense and active soundscape accompanied by optional English subtitles. The detailed ambient noises—from birds crowing to the subtle rustle of nature—emit frequently from the surround channels, producing an impressively immersive atmosphere. Additionally, the audio track is impeccably clean, devoid of any pops, cracks, or hissing, which underscores the exceptional quality of this release. Overall, the audio presentation of "Himalaya" is pristine and compelling, providing an engaging and enveloping experience that brings the film’s mesmerizing landscapes and cultural elements to life.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras for "Himalaya" provide a comprehensive and insightful look into the film's creation, combining professional commentary with behind-the-scenes footage. Notable is the Audio Commentary featuring director Eric Valli and journalist Debra Kellner, offering a Q&A format that delves into Valli's nine-month filming experience in Tibet and the real-life stories inspiring the script. The Making of Himalaya gives an in-depth 27-minute overview of the production's challenges and triumphs in the mountains. Additionally, the Electronic Press Kit compiles behind-the-scenes featurettes and promotional clips, while various short SD clips provide glimpses into specific moments and characters on set.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Discussion of film-making process and inspiration.
- The Making of Himalaya: Documentary exploring on-location challenges.
- Electronic Press Kit: Behind-the-scenes features and promotional materials.
- TV Promo Trailer: Brief TV spot.
- Yaks on a Cliff: Scene-specific featurette.
- Karma Leads A Caravan: On-set footage.
- Tinle and Norbou: Character-focused clip.
- Karma Wangiel On Set: Behind-the-scenes footage.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original movie trailer.
Movie: 66
Éric Valli's "Himalaya" is visually breathtaking, capturing the timeless essence of rural Tibet's Dolpa region. This narrative film, embedded in the tradition-rich lifestyle of villagers, doubles as a cultural documentarian piece, reflecting a way of life seemingly untouched for centuries. Dolpa's inhabitants mine salt, tend yak herds, and subsist on wheat, adhering to ancient rites and hand-sewn clothing. Valli, a seasoned National Geographic photographer and documentarian, brings an authentic touch by casting mainly local, non-professional actors and shooting in remote areas solely accessible by foot.
The story hinges on the power dynamics within the village, centering around Tinle (Thinien Lhondup), the aging chief whose succession plan is disrupted by his son Lhakpa's death. Tinle's suspicion of Lhakpa's best friend Karma (Gurgon Kyap) sets off a series of events highlighting generational clashes. With Karma poised to lead against astrological advice, Tinle embarks alongside his son's son Tsering and older tribe members on a perilous journey through the Demon's Path.
Despite its narrative simplicity, the film holds a fable-like allure, infused with a moral about the mirroring flaws of youthful rebelliousness and stubborn old age. This minimally dramatic approach allows the majestic Himalayan landscape to command attention. "Himalaya" stands out for its vivid cinematography in 2.35:1 Cinemascope ratio, which beautifully captures the rugged terrain and emphasizes the remote, inhospitable environment of Dolpa. The film excels as an immersive visual experience rather than an emotionally gripping story, making it a culturally enriching and visually stunning watch regardless of its straightforward plot.
Total: 65
Review of "Himalaya" Blu-ray
Éric Valli's "Himalaya" seamlessly melds a Tibetan fable with breathtaking National Geographic quality visuals, capturing a disappearing culture with unmatched authenticity. While the storyline may not captivate in terms of drama, the ethnological depth and stunning cinematography significantly compensate. The Blu-ray release by Kino-Lorber is technically impressive, boasting a remarkable high-definition transfer and an impeccable lossless audio track. This package is enhanced by a suite of informative special features that elevate the overall viewing experience.
The film's brilliance lies in its visual storytelling. The landscapes are not merely backdrops but crucial elements of the narrative, providing a vivid, immersive experience of a tough yet beautiful way of life. The video and audio presentations on this Blu-ray are outstanding, making every frame a visual feast. Additional materials include a decent making-of featurette and an informative commentary track that provide further insight into the film's production and cultural context.
In conclusion, "Himalaya" on Blu-ray is a must-have for those interested in unique cultures and exceptional filmmaking. Despite its serene narrative pace, the film's visual and technical excellence create a compelling viewing experience. This Blu-ray comes highly recommended for its cultural significance and stunning visual presentation.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 90
There are rare softish shots, but most of the time, clarity is exceptional, revealing the finest contours of the non-actors' legitimately weather-beaten, wind-creased faces and the intricate stitching...
Audio: 90
The soundfield is additionally filled out with all sorts of environmental ambience; buzzards caw in the rear speakers, herds of yaks stampede down a dusty pathway, wind whips mercilessly and rocks crumble...
Extras: 60
Electronic Press Kit: A collection of behind-the-scenes featurettes, clips from the film, and promotional materials....
Movie: 80
The film's greatest shortcoming is thataside from this high-stakes journey through the Demon's Paththe story often feels slight and inconsequential, as if the minimal drama is here only in the service...
Total: 80
Kino-Lorber's Blu-ray release is all-around excellent as well, with a striking new high definition transfer, a lossless audio track, and a selection of informative special features....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There are a couple of softer shots in the film, but not many, and it doesn't take away from the viewing experience....
Audio: 80
Extras: 40
The Making of 'Himalaya' (HD, 27 mins) - Kellner brings us through the mountains on this making of feature as we explore how they made the movie in some of the dangerous locations....
Movie: 60
Valli used all real villagers and chiefs in his movie with the exception of two characters, so this is as real as we can get, without actually journeying to this village ourselves....
Total: 60
While the narrative story line won't move you, the pure brilliance of the filmmaking and landscapes will....
Director: Eric Valli, Michel Debats
Actors: Thilen Lhondup, Gurgon Kyap, Lhakpa Tsamchoe
PlotIn a remote village in the Dolpo region of Nepal, an aging chief named Tinle grapples with the accidental death of his son during a trading expedition. Thrust into a leadership role he can no longer physically manage, Tinle stubbornly resolves to lead the next yak caravan himself, despite his tribe’s hesitations and the oncoming harsh winter. His determination is deepened by an internal conflict with Karma, a young and pragmatic village rival, who believes it's time for new leadership and more modern methods. Tinle's journey is as much about holding onto tradition as it is about seeking personal justice and ensuring his grandson's future as a leader.
As the snow-capped peaks loom, Tinle sets off with his loyal followers including his daughter-in-law Pema and her son. The group is faced with treacherous terrain, unpredictable weather, and the intense pressure between Tinle's adherence to age-old customs and Karma’s forward-thinking approach. Each step is fraught with physical danger and emotional strain, making survival not just a test of endurance against nature but a battle to reconcile the past with the future. The caravan’s arduous journey through the Himalayas becomes an epic story of resilience, tradition, and change, weaving the intricate human struggle with the majestic yet unforgiving backdrop of the mountains.
Writers: Nathalie Azoulai, Olivier Dazat, Louis Gardel
Release Date: 22 Jun 2001
Runtime: 108 min
Rating: N/A
Country: France, Switzerland, United Kingdom, Nepal
Language: Tibetan